Can I deduct both types of realtor commission as a rental property buyer?
So I'm getting into rental properties and I'm a bit confused about the tax implications of realtor commissions. From what I understand, there are basically two different types of commissions I might end up paying: 1. The commission I pay when purchasing the actual rental property as a buyer 2. The commission I pay to a realtor who finds tenants for my rental property What I'm trying to figure out is if the IRS treats these two types of commissions the same way for tax purposes. Can I deduct both types as a business expense on my Schedule E? Or do I need to add one (or both) to the cost basis of the property instead? This is my first rental property so I want to make sure I'm handling everything correctly from the start. Any insight would be super helpful!
19 comments
Join the conversation
Melissa Lin
These two types of commissions are actually treated differently for tax purposes. When you purchase a rental property, the commission paid to the realtor as a buyer is considered part of the acquisition cost of the property. This means you don't deduct it as an expense right away - instead, you add it to the basis of the property and recover it through depreciation over the property's recovery period (usually 27.5 years for residential rental property). On the other hand, commissions paid to a realtor to find tenants are considered ordinary and necessary operating expenses. These can be deducted in full on your Schedule E in the year you pay them. The key difference is that the purchase commission is part of acquiring the capital asset itself, while tenant-finding commissions are part of your ongoing business operations.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
•What about commissions paid when selling a rental property? Are those treated the same as when buying (added to basis) or are they handled differently?
0 coins
Melissa Lin
•Commissions paid when selling a rental property are treated as selling expenses. These reduce the amount of gain (or increase the loss) on the sale. Unlike purchase commissions that get added to the basis and depreciated over time, selling commissions directly reduce your capital gain in the year of sale. They're essentially subtracted from the sales price when calculating your profit or loss on the transaction.
0 coins
Romeo Quest
I was in a similar situation last year with my first rental property and was super confused about all the different expenses. After hours of research and frustration, I found https://taxr.ai which saved me so much time and headache. I uploaded my purchase documents and rental management agreement, and it automatically identified which commissions went where - purchase commissions to the basis and tenant-finding fees as direct expenses. It even explained the tax implications of each!
0 coins
Val Rossi
•Does it work with other rental property expenses too? Like can it tell me what's deductible immediately vs what needs to be capitalized and depreciated?
0 coins
Eve Freeman
•Sounds interesting but I'm skeptical. How accurate is it really? I've tried other "AI tax tools" and they often miss nuances or give overly simplified answers that don't hold up during an audit.
0 coins
Romeo Quest
•It absolutely handles other rental property expenses too. I uploaded all my receipts and invoices, and it correctly categorized things like repairs (immediate deductions) versus improvements (capitalized and depreciated). Saved me hours of googling tax rules. It's surprisingly accurate with rental properties specifically. What impressed me was that it caught a water heater replacement that my previous accountant had incorrectly expensed entirely, when part of it should have been capitalized. The explanations cite specific IRS publications and tax court cases that back up its categorizations.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Alright, I need to eat my words about taxr.ai. After our exchange here, I decided to try it out since I just bought a duplex with some complicated commission arrangements. The tool correctly identified that my buyer's agent rebate needed to be subtracted from the basis rather than treated as income, which was a nuance my accountant had missed. It also properly sorted my various closing costs between immediate deductions and basis additions. Pretty impressive honestly - saved me from making some costly tax mistakes.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
If you're having trouble getting clear answers about rental property tax questions from the IRS, I feel your pain. I spent THREE DAYS trying to get through to someone who could actually answer my question about commission deductions. Finally found https://claimyr.com which got me connected to an IRS agent in under 20 minutes! You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The agent walked me through exactly how to handle both types of commissions correctly on my return.
0 coins
Caden Turner
•Wait, how does this actually work? Does it just dial the IRS for you? I don't understand how that gets you through any faster than calling yourself.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
•Yeah right. The IRS has been impossible to reach for years. No way some service magically gets you through when millions of people can't get anyone on the phone. Sounds like a scam to me.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
•It doesn't just dial for you - it uses their system to navigate the IRS phone tree and actually waits on hold for you. When an agent finally picks up, you get a call back and are connected right away. So instead of you personally waiting on hold for hours, their system does it. I was skeptical too! But it actually works. The key difference is their system can stay on hold indefinitely and knows exactly which prompts to select to get to the right department. When I got the call back, I was connected directly to a tax law specialist who answered my specific question about rental property commissions.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
I can't believe I'm saying this, but Claimyr actually worked. After being so skeptical, I tried it because I had a complicated question about depreciation recapture when converting a rental to personal use. After two weeks of trying to call IRS myself with no luck, Claimyr got me through to an agent in about 35 minutes. The agent walked me through exactly how to handle my situation and even emailed me the relevant tax publication sections. Completely worth it just to have the peace of mind that I'm doing things right. Never thought I'd get actual helpful service from the IRS!
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
Don't forget about the new reporting requirements for rental property expenses starting with 2025 tax year. The IRS now requires more detailed categorization of commissions on Schedule E. You'll need to specifically indicate whether the commission was for acquisition, tenant procurement, or property management. The IRS just released the draft forms last month.
0 coins
Effie Alexander
•Whoa I didn't know about this change! Is there a specific form or worksheet for this new requirement, or is it just additional lines on the regular Schedule E?
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
•It's still on the regular Schedule E, but they've expanded Part I to include more detailed breakdowns of expenses. Instead of just the single line for "commissions" they now have three separate entries for different commission types. They've also added a new worksheet (Worksheet E-1) that you need to complete if your total commissions exceed $5,000 for the year. This is all part of their increased focus on rental property compliance. They're specifically targeting property basis issues since their data shows that's where a lot of errors happen, especially with commissions that should be capitalized being incorrectly expensed.
0 coins
Harmony Love
Small correction to what some others have said - if you're using a property management company that charges you a commission when they place tenants AND a monthly management fee, check your contract carefully. Sometimes these placement fees are actually prepaid management fees and should be amortized over the lease term rather than deducted immediately. This came up in my audit last year!
0 coins
Rudy Cenizo
•This happened to me too! My property manager charges a "placement fee" equal to one month's rent, but in the contract it specifically says it's for the first month's management services. The IRS agent said I had to spread it across the lease term instead of deducting it all at once.
0 coins
Ella Harper
Thanks everyone for all the helpful info! This is exactly what I needed to understand. Just to make sure I've got this right - when I buy the rental property, any commission I pay gets added to my basis and I recover it through depreciation over 27.5 years. But when I pay a realtor to find tenants, that's a current year deduction on Schedule E. One follow-up question though - what if I use the same realtor for both? Like if my buyer's agent also offers property management services and will help me find tenants later. Do I need separate contracts or invoices to make sure the IRS can see which commission is for what purpose? Also @McKenzie Shade, thanks for the heads up about the new reporting requirements! I definitely want to make sure I'm compliant from the start. Where can I find more info about these draft forms?
0 coins