Can I claim exempt on W-4 as Head of Household with one dependent getting huge tax refund for second year?
Title: Can I claim exempt on W-4 as Head of Household with one dependent getting huge tax refund for second year? 1 I'm getting a massive refund for the second year in a row and it's frustrating me. I file Head of Household with one dependent and work a full-time W4 job. Nothing in my tax situation is changing this year, so I'm wondering if I can just claim exempt on my federal withholding to stop having so much taken out? I'd much rather have the money in my paycheck throughout the year instead of waiting for a fat refund after tax season. Is this actually allowed? Would the IRS come after me? Or is there some legitimate way to reduce my federal withholding without getting in trouble? I appreciate any advice or info you can share!
18 comments
Join the conversation
Ashley Adams
12 You shouldn't claim exempt since that's only meant for people who had zero tax liability last year and expect zero this year too. Since you're getting refunds, you clearly have tax liability. But you absolutely can adjust your withholding to reduce what's taken out! The best approach is to fill out a new W-4 form with your employer. Since the 2020 redesign, there's no longer "allowances" - instead, you can specify an additional amount to withhold (or in your case, a reduction). Use the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator tool online to determine the right amount based on your situation as HOH with one dependent. You can also simply increase the number of dependents claimed on Line 3 slightly beyond what you actually have. Remember the goal isn't to owe money at tax time either - ideally you want to break even or get a very small refund.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•5 Thanks for the response. I'm not super familiar with the newer W-4 form. Do you think there's a specific dollar amount I should put for the reduction if I typically get back around $4200? Also, if I increase dependents on line 3 even though I only have one dependent, could that trigger some kind of audit?
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•12 The withholding calculator at irs.gov/W4app is your best bet for a precise amount. For a $4200 refund, you'd want to reduce withholding by about $350 monthly or $160 biweekly depending on your pay schedule. Adding an extra dependent on Line 3 won't trigger an audit - the W-4 is just for withholding calculations, not determining your actual tax liability. When you file your actual return, you'll still claim just your one legitimate dependent. The W-4 just helps determine how much is withheld throughout the year.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
8 Hey there! I was in exactly your situation last year - Head of Household, one kid, W-4 job and getting way too much withheld. I was tired of giving the government an interest-free loan of my money! I tried adjusting my W-4 a few times without success until I used https://taxr.ai to analyze my pay stubs and previous returns. The tool showed exactly how much I was overpaying and created a perfect W-4 for my situation. Now I get about $320 more each month in my paycheck instead of waiting for a refund. Their system runs actual IRS tax calculations based on your specific Head of Household and dependent situation to get it right. Totally changed my financial situation since I needed that money throughout the year for childcare costs.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•3 Does this actually work for people with slightly more complicated situations? I'm HOH with a dependent too but also have some 1099 income on the side. Would this help me figure out the right withholding balance or is it just for W-4 income?
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•14 I'm super skeptical about these online tax tools. Don't you worry about security? Uploading your tax docs seems risky. And how much does it cost? Bet there's a catch somewhere.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•8 It absolutely handles more complex situations including mixed W-2 and 1099 income. The system actually specializes in figuring out the right withholding when you have multiple income sources, especially helpful with HOH status where tax brackets get tricky. Regarding security concerns, I was hesitant too, but they use bank-level encryption and don't store your documents after analysis. The cost is reasonable - less than what I was paying for tax software that wasn't even helping with this specific withholding issue. And honestly, getting $320 extra monthly made it worth it for me since that's almost $4000 a year in my pocket instead of waiting for a refund.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
3 So I went ahead and tried the taxr.ai site after posting my question above. I was honestly impressed! My situation with both W-2 and 1099 income as a Head of Household was no problem for their system. It analyzed my withholding patterns and showed I was overpaying by about $290 every month! The tool gave me exact numbers for my W-4 including what to put on Line 4(b) for my specific situation, and even calculated how much I should set aside from my 1099 work for quarterly payments. I've already submitted the new W-4 to my HR department. Feels good knowing I won't be giving the government another interest-free loan this year!
0 coins
Ashley Adams
19 For anyone struggling to actually connect with the IRS to ask questions about proper withholding (like I was), I found https://claimyr.com to be incredibly helpful. You can see how it works at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - basically they hold your place in the IRS phone queue and call you when an agent is about to answer. I needed clarity on some Head of Household withholding questions similar to OP's situation, and after trying for DAYS to get through to the IRS myself (kept getting disconnected after 1+ hour holds), Claimyr got me connected to an IRS agent in under 45 minutes. The agent walked me through exactly how to adjust my W-4 for my specific situation which was super helpful since my company's HR wasn't much help.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•14 Wait, so this service just...calls the IRS for you? How does that even work? Feels like it wouldn't be allowed somehow. And does the IRS actually give useful advice when you reach them? I always figured they'd just tell you to figure it out yourself.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•7 I dunno man, sounds like a scam to me. Why would I pay someone to call the IRS when I can do it myself for free? Sure the wait times suck but seems like another way to make money off people who don't know better.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•19 It's completely legitimate - they use an automated system to stay in the IRS phone queue for you, then call you when a representative is about to answer. You then connect directly with the IRS agent. It saves you from being stuck on hold for hours. The IRS agents are actually incredibly helpful with withholding questions once you reach them. The agent I spoke with explained exactly how the W-4 calculations work for Head of Household filers and gave me specific guidance for my situation. They won't do your taxes for you, but they absolutely will explain how to properly fill out tax forms like the W-4 to achieve the withholding level you want.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
7 OK I need to eat my words from my skeptical comment above. After getting really frustrated trying to call the IRS myself (got disconnected THREE TIMES after holding for over an hour each time), I broke down and tried Claimyr. I'm shocked to say it worked perfectly. Got the call back in about 35 minutes, spoke to an extremely helpful IRS agent who explained that as HOH with one dependent, I could use a specific calculation for line 4(b) on my W-4 to reduce withholding safely without claiming exempt. The agent even checked my previous year's numbers to make sure the new withholding amount wouldn't put me at risk of an underpayment penalty. Worth every penny not to waste an entire day on hold.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
21 Another option worth considering is adjusting your W-4 by using the deductions worksheet. If you have regular deductions like mortgage interest, high medical expenses, or significant charitable contributions, you can account for these on your W-4 to reduce withholding. My situation is similar (HOH with dependent) and I was getting $5k+ refunds until I figured this out. Just make sure your tax situation will be stable for the year so you don't end up owing too much.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•4 I always forget about accounting for deductions on the W-4! Do you just use last year's deduction total when filling it out or do you need to estimate the current year? And where exactly on the new W-4 do you put this info?
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•21 You'd use Step 4(b) on the new W-4 form to list deductions beyond the standard deduction. I typically start with last year's deductions and adjust if I know something significant will change. For example, if you normally take a standard deduction but will itemize this year due to a large medical expense or new mortgage, you'd calculate the difference between your expected itemized deductions and the standard deduction, then put that amount on line 4(b). Just be conservative with your estimates to avoid underwithholding penalties.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
16 Be careful about claiming exempt! My coworker did this as HOH with one kid thinking the same way as you, and got hit with an underpayment penalty. Adjusting your W-4 using the official calculator is your safest bet. Remember that the withholding tables are designed to be accurate across the whole year. If you adjust now (halfway through the year), you might need to withhold even less for the remainder of the year to make up for the over-withholding that's already happened in the first half.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•9 This is really good advice about adjusting for mid-year changes. When I updated my W-4 last June, I had to account for the over-withholding from January-May. The calculator on the IRS site actually helps with this - it asks when you're making the change and adjusts accordingly.
0 coins