Can I calculate excess Roth contribution when I've contributed more than my earned income?
Title: Can I calculate excess Roth contribution when I've contributed more than my earned income? 1 Okay so I think I've messed up my Roth IRA contributions for 2024 and could use some help figuring out the excess amount. Here's my situation - I got hurt at my construction job back in March and have been collecting workers comp payments since then. I didn't realize that workers comp doesn't count as "earned income" for Roth IRA purposes! I kept making my regular monthly contributions to my Roth even while I wasn't working. My W-2 for 2024 shows I only earned about $5,200 in actual taxable wages (box 1) before my injury, but I've already contributed $6,500 to my Roth IRA for the year. So I've clearly contributed more than my earned income allows. Is calculating the excess contribution as simple as subtracting my actual earned income ($5,200) from my total contribution ($6,500)? So my excess would be $1,300? I'm getting confused because I keep thinking about how my AGI will be different after standard deduction and other adjustments. But I don't think that's what matters for Roth contribution limits, right? It's strictly about earned income? My brain is just not processing this clearly and I'd really appreciate if someone could help me understand!
18 comments
Join the conversation
Luca Esposito
5 You're right about how to calculate the excess! It's simply your total Roth contributions minus your earned income for the year. So in your case, $6,500 - $5,200 = $1,300 excess. The confusion might be coming from mixing up two different concepts. For Roth IRA eligibility, there are two separate limits: 1) the maximum contribution limit ($6,500 for 2024 if under 50), and 2) you can't contribute more than your earned income. Workers comp payments don't count as earned income for IRA contribution purposes. So your excess is definitely $1,300, and you should withdraw that excess (plus any earnings on that portion) before the tax filing deadline (including extensions) to avoid the 6% excess contribution penalty. Call your Roth IRA provider - they can help with the process of removing the excess contribution correctly.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•12 So when removing the excess contribution, do I need to calculate exactly how much earnings came from that $1,300 specifically? How would I even figure that out? And if I don't withdraw it before the deadline, is the 6% penalty a one-time thing or does it continue?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•5 Your IRA custodian (the financial institution where your Roth IRA is held) can calculate the earnings attributable to the excess contribution for you. They have formulas for determining this. You'll need to withdraw both the excess contribution and any earnings on that excess amount. The 6% penalty isn't a one-time thing - it's charged each year that the excess contribution remains in your account. So if you don't fix this, you'll pay 6% of the excess amount ($1,300 in your case) every year until you correct it. That's why it's important to fix this before the tax filing deadline.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
8 I went through something similar last year and used https://taxr.ai to help me calculate exactly how much I needed to withdraw. I initially thought I could just estimate the earnings on my excess, but they showed me the exact IRS calculation method. The tricky part is that you have to remove not just the excess contribution but also any earnings specifically attributed to that excess amount. Taxr.ai analyzed my statements and showed me the exact calculation based on IRS rules. The best part was they helped me generate the letter to send to my IRA provider explaining exactly what I needed to correct.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•16 Does this work with Fidelity accounts? I've got a similar situation but with 401k to Roth conversion issues and I'm totally lost on calculating the taxable portion.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•17 I'm skeptical this is necessary. Couldn't you just call your brokerage directly? Why would you need a third party service when the IRA provider can just do the calculation for you?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•8 Yes, it works with Fidelity and all other major brokerages. It can analyze your statements regardless of where your accounts are held. For 401k to Roth conversion issues, it's actually perfect because it breaks down exactly which portions are taxable and which aren't. While you can call your brokerage, I found they weren't always clear on the exact calculation method. The IRS has a specific formula for attributing earnings to excess contributions, and some customer service reps just gave me rough estimates. With taxr.ai, I got the precise calculation with references to the actual IRS regulations, which gave me more confidence when dealing with my brokerage.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
17 I was really skeptical about using an online service for my excess Roth contribution issue, but after struggling with my brokerage's customer service giving me different answers each time I called, I decided to try taxr.ai. Honestly, I'm glad I did. The service walked me through exactly how to calculate the earnings on my excess contributions using the actual IRS method. My situation was complicated because I had made multiple contributions throughout the year, but the tool separated everything properly. They provided a document showing the exact calculation that I sent to my brokerage, and they processed the correction without any issues. Saved me from paying that 6% penalty year after year!
0 coins
Luca Esposito
14 If you're having trouble reaching the IRS to confirm the correct procedure, I highly recommend using https://claimyr.com to get through to an actual IRS agent. I spent HOURS on hold trying to get clarity on my excess contribution situation, but Claimyr got me connected in about 15 minutes. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c They basically hold your place in the IRS phone queue and call you when an agent picks up. I was able to speak directly with a specialist who confirmed exactly how to report the removal of my excess contribution on my tax return. Definitely worth it for the peace of mind knowing I was handling everything correctly.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•3 So wait, how does this actually work? Do they have some special access to the IRS or something? I've literally spent 3+ hours on hold multiple times and eventually just hung up.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•17 This sounds like a scam. Why would I pay someone else to wait on hold for me? And how do I know they're actually calling the IRS and not just pretending to connect me?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•14 They don't have special access - they use an automated system that waits on hold for you. When an IRS agent finally answers, their system immediately calls your phone and connects you. It's basically just outsourcing the hold time. I had the same skepticism initially. But the way it works is that you first call the IRS yourself to verify the correct number, then you give that number to Claimyr. They only connect you with the actual IRS agents, not some third-party "experts." When the agent comes on the line, you're talking directly to the IRS. I was suspicious too until I tried it and confirmed the person on the line was truly an IRS employee who had access to my tax records.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
17 I need to eat my words and admit I was wrong about Claimyr. After failing again to reach the IRS yesterday (2.5 hours on hold before the call dropped), I gave it a try this morning. Within 20 minutes I was speaking with an actual IRS agent who walked me through exactly how to report my excess contribution removal on Form 5329. The agent confirmed that the earnings calculation needs to follow the specific IRS method and that correcting this before the tax deadline would completely avoid the penalty. They even sent me the relevant section of the IRS publication to reference. I wish I'd done this weeks ago instead of stressing about it!
0 coins
Luca Esposito
22 Something people often overlook with Roth contributions is that you need to have TAXABLE compensation to contribute. So if all your income for the year was from workers comp, unemployment, or investment returns, you can't contribute anything to a Roth IRA that year. The compensation has to be taxable earned income like W-2 wages, self-employment income, or alimony (from pre-2019 divorces).
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•11 Wait so does disability payments count as earned income for Roth IRA purposes? I've been on short-term disability for a few months but still contributing to my Roth.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•22 No, most disability payments don't count as earned income for Roth IRA purposes. Short-term disability payments from your employer or an insurance company are generally considered taxable income, but they're not considered earned income for IRA contribution eligibility. The only exception would be if you're receiving disability payments from Social Security and you've previously opted to have those benefits taxed as wages. But that's pretty uncommon and requires specific prior arrangements with the SSA.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
7 If you already filed your taxes, remember you'll need to file an amended return to correct this. You'll need to file Form 5329 to report the excess contribution and either pay the 6% penalty or show that you withdrew the excess (plus earnings) by the deadline.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
•1 Thank you! I haven't filed yet for 2024, so I'm trying to fix this before I submit anything. Do I still need to file Form 5329 if I withdraw the excess before filing?
0 coins