
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I'm trying to wrap my head around Form 1095-A and how the Premium Tax Credit works with Obamacare. I've seen some really weird situations that don't make sense to me. I know a few people who only pay like $7 a month for their ACA health insurance with incomes around $65-75K, and somehow they end up getting HUGE tax refunds at the end of the year. Like thousands of dollars back! But then I've helped some friends with their taxes who make about $50K and pay $13 monthly for their marketplace plans, and they got totally screwed - ended up owing the IRS like $1400! They were devastated since they weren't expecting to owe anything. How does this make any sense? Why do some people with similar situations get big refunds while others owe a ton? Is there some trick to how the Form 1095-A information gets entered? Or is it about estimating income correctly when signing up? Can someone explain in simple terms how the ACA premium tax credit reconciliation actually works? It seems so inconsistent and I want to understand before I do my own taxes this year.
Hey everyone! I'm trying to start investing in stocks and one of the questions on the application is asking if I'm a US resident for tax purposes. I honestly have no clue how to answer this. From what I understand, I need to meet something called the "substantial presence test" to qualify. I've been living in the US continuously since September 2019 (going on my 6th year now), but here's where it gets complicated: I was on an F-2 visa until May 2024 when I switched to an F-1 visa. Does the time on my F-2 visa count toward the substantial presence test? Or does only my F-1 time count? I'm really confused about how this works for tax residency purposes. Any advice would be greatly appreciated! I don't want to answer incorrectly and get in trouble later.
Just to add some practical advice - when investment platforms ask if you're a US resident for tax purposes, they're usually trying to determine if they need to collect a W-9 (for US residents) or W-8BEN (for nonresidents). If you're a nonresident alien for tax purposes based on the substantial presence test, you'll generally need to fill out a W-8BEN form for your investment account. This tells the broker to apply the appropriate tax withholding to any investment income.
This is such a common confusion for international students! Based on what you've described, you're likely still considered a nonresident alien for tax purposes. Here's the key thing about F-2 to F-1 transitions: F-2 visa holders are "exempt individuals" for their first 5 calendar years, and F-1 students have their own separate 5-year exemption period. Since you were on F-2 from 2019-2024 (about 5+ years) and just switched to F-1 in May 2024, you're now in your first year of F-1 status. For the substantial presence test, your F-2 days likely don't count because of the exempt individual rules. Your F-1 days starting in May 2024 also don't count since you're in the beginning of that 5-year exempt period. When filling out investment applications, you'll probably need to indicate you're a nonresident for tax purposes and complete a W-8BEN form instead of a W-9. But definitely verify this with a tax professional or the IRS directly since visa timing and transitions can have nuances that affect the calculation. Don't forget you'll also need to file Form 8843 each year to document your exempt status!
This is really helpful, thank you! Just to make sure I understand correctly - so even though I've been in the US for almost 6 years total, because I was on F-2 status for most of that time and just switched to F-1, I'm basically starting fresh with the F-1 exemption period? And when you mention verifying with the IRS directly, would something like that Claimyr service people mentioned above actually be useful for this type of question? I'm a bit nervous about making the wrong choice on my investment application.
Yes, you've got it exactly right! Each visa type has its own 5-year exemption period, so switching from F-2 to F-1 essentially gives you a fresh start with the F-1 exemption. Your nearly 6 years of total US presence doesn't automatically make you a tax resident because most of that time was in exempt status. Regarding Claimyr for this type of question - it could definitely be worth it for peace of mind! The IRS agents can look at your specific situation and confirm your tax residency status based on your exact visa timeline and entry/exit dates. Since investment account setup depends on getting this right (W-8BEN vs W-9 forms, different tax withholding rates, etc.), having official confirmation from the IRS could save you from potential complications later. Just make sure you have all your visa dates and any travel history ready when you call. The IRS agent will need those details to properly apply the substantial presence test rules to your situation.
Been trying to file my Kentucky state taxes through TurboTax for the past week and keep getting errors. The system wont let me submit. Starting to get worried since the deadline is coming up. Anyone else experiencing this or found a workaround?
Just wanted to add that I called the Kentucky Department of Revenue directly yesterday and they confirmed the TurboTax integration issues. They said it should be resolved by end of week. In the meantime, they recommended filing directly through their website at revenue.ky.gov if you need to get it done ASAP. The rep was super helpful and walked me through the process!
I'm trying to decide between Free Tax USA's free version and their Deluxe edition which costs $6.99. My tax situation is pretty basic - just a W-2, some bank interest, and standard deduction. Nothing fancy like investments, rental property, or business stuff. Has anyone used their Deluxe package? I'm wondering if those extra features are actually worth the money for someone with a straightforward tax return. The audit assistance sounds nice, but realistically, how often do simple returns get audited? Just trying to save a few bucks if the free version will do everything I need! Would appreciate hearing about your experiences either way.
Switched from TurboTax to Free Tax USA this year and I'll NEVER go back! Even with the state filing fee and Deluxe upgrade, I paid $22 total instead of the $120+ TurboTax wanted. The interface isn't as polished but it got the job done perfectly. I actually went with Deluxe because it was my first time using the software and I was nervous about making mistakes. The priority support came in handy when I had questions about entering some stock sales. For $7, the peace of mind was worth it for me as a first-timer, but I'll probably just use the free version next year now that I'm familiar with how everything works.
For someone with just W-2 income, bank interest, and standard deduction like you described, the free version will absolutely handle everything you need. I've been using Free Tax USA's free version for years with a similar tax situation and never felt like I was missing anything important. The audit assistance in Deluxe sounds nice in theory, but with your straightforward return, the audit risk is practically zero. The IRS typically flags returns with unusual deductions, unreported income, or business expenses - none of which apply to you. I'd save the $6.99 and put it toward something else! One thing to keep in mind is that you'll still need to pay around $15 for state filing regardless of which federal version you choose, so your total cost would be either $15 (free federal + state) or about $22 (deluxe federal + state). For most people in your situation, that extra $7 just isn't worth it.
I made approximately 950 trades during 2022. I'm completely overwhelmed trying to figure out how to report these properly for my 2024 filing. I understand that trades can be reported in aggregate on Schedule D, but I've got around 80-90 wash sales mixed in there and I'm confused about how to handle those specifically. Do I need to exclude all the wash sales from the aggregate totals on Schedule D and instead report each one individually on Form 8949? Or do they still get included in Schedule D somehow? The other thing I'm confused about - if I do need to use Form 8949 for the wash sales, do I seriously have to list every single one of those trades line by line? Or can I just include the total and reference my 1099-B? It seems ridiculous to manually enter 80+ trades when all the exact same information is already on the 1099-B from my broker. I'm using tax software but it's not clear on this specific situation with so many trades and wash sales. Any advice would be really appreciated!
Random question: Does anyone know if there's a maximum number of pages allowed for Form 8949? I have about 120 wash sales to report individually, and I'm wondering if there's a limit to how many continuation sheets I can attach.
There's no maximum page limit for Form 8949. You can attach as many continuation sheets as needed to report all your transactions. Just make sure to number each page and include your name and social security number on each continuation sheet. I had over 200 pages one year and it processed fine. Just make sure you're transferring the totals correctly to Schedule D.
I went through this exact same nightmare last year with about 800 trades and numerous wash sales. Here's what I learned after making several mistakes: The key thing to understand is that wash sales MUST be reported individually on Form 8949 - there's no way around this. You cannot include them in summary reporting. However, for your regular trades without adjustments, you can absolutely use the summary method. What worked for me was organizing everything in Excel first. I separated my trades into two categories: those with wash sale adjustments and those without. For the clean trades, I created a single line on Form 8949 that said "Various stocks - see attached statement" and attached a spreadsheet with the totals. For the wash sales, I had to list each one individually. Pro tip: Make sure you're tracking the disallowed loss amounts correctly. The wash sale rule doesn't just defer the loss - it adjusts your basis in the replacement shares. This gets complex when you have multiple wash sales in the same security. TurboTax Premier should handle most of this automatically once you resolve the import issues. The software is actually pretty good at identifying wash sales, but you need to review each flagged transaction to make sure the adjustments are correct. Don't just accept everything blindly. One more thing - keep detailed records of everything. With that many trades, the IRS might want to see supporting documentation if they have questions.
StellarSurfer
Don't forget that income changes aren't the only thing that affects your premium tax credit! My big mistake was not updating my application when my daughter moved out mid-year. My premium tax credit was calculated based on a household of 3, but at tax time, I could only claim a household of 2. This completely changed my calculations even though my income was exactly what I had estimated. I ended up owing $1,700 because the smaller household size meant I was eligible for less subsidy. The 1095-A doesn't know about your household changes - it just shows what premium assistance was paid on your behalf. It's your responsibility to update the marketplace when ANYTHING changes - income, household size, address, etc.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
This is such an important point that so many people miss! Same thing happened to me but with adding a dependent mid-year (had a baby). I didn't update marketplace and missed out on higher subsidies for months.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
This is such a helpful thread! I'm dealing with my first year of ACA coverage and was completely lost on Form 1095-A until reading these explanations. One thing I'd add based on my experience - timing of when you report income changes really matters. I got a raise in July but didn't report it to the marketplace until October. Even though I updated it before the year ended, those three months of receiving too much advance credit still created a balance due situation. The marketplace customer service rep told me that ideally you should report changes within 30 days, but honestly their system makes it pretty confusing to navigate. I had to call three times before someone could actually help me update my projected annual income correctly. For anyone in a similar situation - definitely keep documentation of when you made changes and what your income projections were, because the 1095-A reconciliation process at tax time can get really complex if you had multiple income changes throughout the year.
0 coins