


Ask the community...
One thing no one has mentioned yet - make sure you're calculating your mom's cost basis correctly! The original purchase price is just the starting point. You can add the cost of capital improvements made over the years she owned the home (new roof, remodeling, additions, etc.). This can significantly reduce the taxable gain even before applying the $250k exclusion. My parents kept receipts for major improvements and it added about $85k to their basis when they sold their home last year. Unfortunately, normal repairs and maintenance don't count - has to be improvements that add value.
That's really helpful! I know she did a kitchen renovation about 10 years ago and replaced all the windows. I'll have to see if she kept the receipts. Does TurboTax have a specific section for entering these improvements or do you just add them to the original purchase price?
Yes, TurboTax does have a specific section for this. After you enter the original purchase price, it should ask if you made any improvements to the home. There will be a place to itemize and enter each major improvement separately. If she doesn't have all the receipts, reasonable estimates are generally acceptable - just be prepared to justify them if ever questioned. Make sure to only include capital improvements (things that add value, prolong the home's useful life, or adapt it to new uses) - not repairs or maintenance. So the kitchen renovation and window replacement definitely count, but something like painting or fixing a leaky faucet wouldn't.
We went through this exact situation with my mother-in-law last year. Don't forget to consider state taxes too! The federal $250k exclusion is great, but some states have different rules for capital gains on real estate. What state does your mom live in? That could make a significant difference in the total tax bill.
If you're hiring from India specifically, make sure you understand their local labor laws too. My brother runs a software company and hired developers in India thinking it would be simpler, but there were unexpected complications with India's PF (Provident Fund) requirements and GST (their sales tax). Depending on how you structure it, you might need to register a business entity in India too. Sometimes it's easier to work with an EOR (Employer of Record) service that handles all the local compliance stuff for you.
What's an EOR service? Is that like a PEO? And do you have any recommendations for ones that work well with very small businesses? I'm only looking to hire one person to start.
An EOR (Employer of Record) is similar to a PEO but specifically designed for international hiring. They essentially become the legal employer in the foreign country while you maintain day-to-day management. For small businesses hiring just one or two people, services like Deel, Remote.com, or Ontop tend to be more cost-effective than traditional global PEOs which usually cater to larger companies. They handle everything from compliant contracts to local tax withholding and benefits requirements. The fees usually range from 5-8% of the employee's salary, which might seem high but is typically cheaper than setting up your own foreign entity. For just one employee in India, this approach could save you significant headaches with compliance.
Has anyone actually looked into the tax treaty between US and India for this situation? The issue might be simpler than it seems. Also wondering if an LLC is the best structure if international hiring is your main focus? Maybe an S-Corp would be better for tax purposes?
The US-India tax treaty definitely applies here. Article 15 covers dependent personal services (employment), while Article 14 covers independent personal services (contractors). Generally, if your Indian worker never comes to the US to perform services, their income is only taxable in India. As for LLC vs S-Corp, it really depends on your overall business situation. An LLC with S-Corp election could give you some employment tax advantages if you're also taking a salary, but for purely hiring overseas workers, the structure is less important than properly documenting the relationship. What matters more is whether you classify them correctly as employees vs contractors, and whether you follow the reporting requirements for foreign persons.
The other thing nobody's mentioned yet is that LLC and corporation status also gives you liability protection. If your business gets sued, they can't come after your personal assets (in most cases). So there are non-tax benefits too. But yeah, the tax situation is tricky. My accountant actually advised AGAINST S-Corp election for my LLC this year because I'm only projecting about $65k in profit, and the payroll costs and extra tax filings would eat up any SE tax savings. She said once I hit about $80k consistently, we'll make the switch.
Is the liability protection really that valuable though? I've heard you need good insurance anyway since people can still try to pierce the corporate veil if you don't keep business and personal completely separate?
The liability protection is valuable but not perfect. You're right that you still need good insurance, and yes, "piercing the corporate veil" is a real concern. If you don't maintain separate business bank accounts, mix personal and business expenses, or don't follow corporate formalities, the courts can potentially hold you personally liable. LLC protection works best for legitimate business debts and certain types of lawsuits. It's one layer of protection that works alongside proper insurance. So it's not an either/or situation - smart business owners have both the legal structure AND insurance coverage.
I think everyone's missing a key point here. The tax savings of an S-Corp setup mostly come from avoiding self-employment tax (15.3%) on a portion of your income. But remember Biden signed that bill that increased Medicare tax for higher incomes to fund some of those IRA climate thingys. So make sure your calculations are using the current tax rates not old advice from a few years ago!
I wanted to add something about that $4,500 fee your friend's fiancรฉ mentioned. I'm a former tax preparer (not giving official advice), but that fee is WAY too high for what's likely needed in this case. A typical OiC application might cost $1,500-2,500 from a reputable tax professional, including preparing the unfiled returns. I'm concerned that: 1. The fiancรฉ might be getting kickbacks from whoever he's referring her to 2. The professional is overcharging by promising "guaranteed" results 3. They might file a boilerplate OiC that has little chance of acceptance Remember that ANYONE can request an installment agreement or apply for an OiC - these aren't secret programs. The value in professional help is proper preparation and documentation, not access to "secret" programs. Also, I'd be concerned about the fiancรฉ who promised to file her taxes and didn't. That's a major breach of trust, especially since it's causing penalties and interest to accumulate.
Thank you for this perspective! I've been really concerned about the high fee and the relationship dynamics. The fiancรฉ has been handling her finances for a while and I'm definitely worried he's not acting in her best interest. Do you think she should separate the tax issue completely from him at this point?
Based on what you've shared, I would absolutely recommend she handle this separately from her fiancรฉ. His track record isn't good - he failed to file her taxes for two years despite promising to do so, and now he's steering her toward an expensive service with unrealistic promises. This is a situation where she needs to take control of her own financial situation. She should consider getting a free consultation with a licensed EA (Enrolled Agent) or CPA who specializes in tax resolution to understand her real options. Many offer free initial consultations. She should go alone, without the fiancรฉ, to ensure she gets unbiased advice.
Just want to add one thing about bankruptcy and taxes - timing is SUPER important here. For income taxes to be dischargeable in bankruptcy: 1. The taxes must be income taxes 2. The due date for filing the tax return was at least 3 years ago 3. The tax return was filed at least 2 years before filing for bankruptcy 4. The tax assessment was made at least 240 days before filing bankruptcy 5. There was no fraud or willful evasion Since her taxes for 2022 and 2023 haven't even been filed yet, they almost certainly won't be dischargeable in bankruptcy. This means she'll still owe them after bankruptcy unless she uses OiC or another resolution method.
Donna Cline
The same thing happened to me when I worked at Domino's! The franchise was sold mid-year to a completely different owner. Check your husband's pay stubs throughout the year - you might notice the company name changed slightly at some point. Also, double-check that the combined income from both W2s matches what you'd expect for the full year's earnings. Sometimes during ownership transitions, there can be accounting issues where a week or two of pay gets missed.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
โขI never thought to check his paystubs! I'll have him dig those up tonight. Do you remember if your tax withholding was affected when the ownership changed? That's the part that seems strange to me - one W2 has withholding and one doesn't.
0 coins
Donna Cline
โขYes, the withholding situation definitely changed when ownership switched. The first owner withheld taxes properly, but the new owner classified me as an independent contractor for the first month before fixing it. That meant one W2 had normal withholding while the other had almost none. The paystubs should show exactly when the change happened. If you notice one of the employers wasn't withholding properly, you might owe more at tax time than you expected. It's better to find out now rather than get surprised with a tax bill!
0 coins
Harper Collins
Make sure you also check if one of the W2s shows any tips! Sometimes when delivery places change ownership, they handle tip reporting differently. One might include reported tips in Box 1 while the other might have them broken out separately in Box 8.
0 coins
Kelsey Hawkins
โขThis is super important! When I delivered for Pizza Hut, one owner reported credit card tips on the W2 while the next owner made us report our own cash AND credit tips. Made my tax situation confusing.
0 coins