


Ask the community...
Quick tip from someone who's dealt with Form 2210 multiple times: check if you qualify for any of the penalty waivers! The IRS can waive the penalty if: 1. You had a casualty, disaster, or other unusual circumstance 2. You retired after age 62 or became disabled during the tax year or previous year AND the underpayment was due to reasonable cause 3. There was an uneven income distribution during the year and using the standard method would be unfair Given your land sale and layoff, you might qualify under #1 or #3. Worth exploring!
Adding to this great advice - you can attach a statement explaining your situation if you're requesting a waiver. Make sure to be specific about why you had a "reasonable cause" for not making the estimated payments. Especially emphasize if you didn't realize capital gains required immediate estimated tax payments and that you made good faith efforts to correct the situation with your January payment.
I've been through a similar situation and want to add some clarity on why your software might be showing no penalty despite the large capital gain. One thing that often gets overlooked is the "de minimis" rule - if your total tax owed (after withholding) is less than $1,000, there's no underpayment penalty at all. But with your $15,500 tax liability and $9,200 withholding, that's clearly not your situation. What's more likely happening is that your software is applying the penalty calculation correctly but benefiting from how withholding is treated. Since you had steady employment through October, your $9,200 in withholding gets spread evenly across all four quarters for penalty purposes. This means each quarter is credited with about $2,300 in payments. For the capital gains portion specifically, the penalty would only apply to the amount that exceeds what your "deemed" quarterly withholding covers. Given that you made a large payment in January 2024 that created a refund situation, it's possible the actual penalty amount is quite small or even zero when calculated properly. However, I'd strongly recommend double-checking this by either downloading the actual Form 2210 from your software or consulting with a tax professional. The IRS will definitely scrutinize large capital gains transactions, and you want to make sure you're not missing anything that could trigger penalties or interest later.
This explanation really helps clarify what might be happening! I'm starting to understand how the withholding gets spread across quarters even though mine stopped in October. One thing I'm still confused about - if my withholding of $9,200 gets treated as $2,300 per quarter, and let's say I needed to pay $3,875 per quarter (25% of my $15,500 total tax), wouldn't I still owe penalties on the $1,575 shortfall each quarter? Even if it's a small amount per quarter, over four quarters that could add up. Or does the January 2024 payment somehow get applied retroactively to reduce those quarterly shortfalls? I thought estimated payments were supposed to be made by the quarterly due dates to avoid penalties entirely. I definitely plan to download the actual Form 2210 to see exactly what calculations were used. Better safe than sorry with the IRS!
Has anyone here tried using one of the online tax prep services for their S-Corp returns instead of a CPA? I'm wondering if that could be a cheaper alternative that still gets the job done right.
I tried TaxAct for my S-Corp last year after getting quoted $6k from a CPA. Only paid about $170 for the software, but honestly it was a nightmare. Spent over 40 hours figuring everything out and still wasn't 100% confident. This year I found a smaller local CPA who charges $2,900 and it was worth every penny for the time saved and peace of mind.
I'm dealing with a similar situation as an S-Corp owner myself. That $10,500 quote is absolutely ridiculous for your business size and complexity. I paid $3,800 last year for similar revenue and services. Here's what I'd suggest: Get at least 3 quotes from different firms and make sure you're comparing identical services. Ask each firm to break down exactly what's included - tax prep, quarterly planning, audit protection, etc. Also, don't be afraid to negotiate. When I got my first quote of $7,200 this year, I showed them quotes from competitors and they came down to $4,100 for the same services. Some firms will quote high initially to see if you'll pay it. The key is finding someone experienced with S-Corps who can explain their value proposition clearly. If they can't justify the price difference with specific additional services or expertise, they're probably overcharging.
This is really helpful advice about negotiating! I never thought about showing competing quotes to get them to lower their price. When you negotiated from $7,200 down to $4,100, did they reduce the services included or keep everything the same? I want to make sure I'm not sacrificing quality just to save money, especially since this is my first year dealing with S-Corp taxes and I'm still learning the ropes.
Quick tip from someone who's done this for years - if you mess up printing, you can order replacement W-2 forms overnight from most office supply stores or Amazon. No need to panic if you waste a few forms getting the alignment right!
Does it matter if the replacement forms are from a different company/brand than my original ones? I bought mine from Office Depot but the closest store to me is Staples.
No, it doesn't matter at all! All W-2 forms sold by office supply stores are standardized to IRS specifications, so the box sizes and spacing are identical whether they're from Office Depot, Staples, Amazon, or anywhere else. The only thing that might vary slightly is paper thickness or quality, but that won't affect your printing alignment. I've mixed forms from different suppliers over the years and never had any issues.
I went through this same headache last year! Here's what worked for me after trying several approaches: The IRS fillable PDF is definitely your best bet for accuracy and professional appearance. But here's the key trick nobody mentions - before you print on your actual W-2 forms, create a "test template" by placing a blank piece of paper over your W-2 form and tracing the box outlines with a pencil. Then print the IRS PDF on that traced paper first to check alignment. Also, make sure to set your printer to "actual size" (not "fit to page") and use the highest quality print setting. I learned the hard way that draft mode can shift things just enough to throw off the alignment. One more tip - if you have a local small business association or SCORE chapter, many of them offer free tax prep workshops in January that include hands-on help with W-2 preparation. Might be worth checking out for next year so you're not scrambling at the deadline!
This is such helpful advice! The test template idea with tracing the boxes is genius - I never would have thought of that. I'm definitely going to try this approach since I'm terrified of wasting my forms. Quick question though - when you say "highest quality print setting," do you mean something specific in the printer settings? I have a basic HP inkjet and I'm not sure what setting would be best for this kind of precise alignment work. Also, the SCORE workshop idea is great for next year. Do you know if they typically cover state-specific requirements too, or is it mainly federal forms?
For HP inkjet printers, you'll want to look for "Best" or "Maximum DPI" in your print quality settings - usually found under Print Properties or Preferences when you go to print. This ensures the sharpest, most precise printing which is crucial for alignment. Also make sure "Borderless" is turned OFF since you want exact margins. Regarding SCORE workshops, they typically cover both federal and state requirements, but it varies by location. When I attended one in Ohio, they had separate sessions for different states since we had people from Ohio, Kentucky, and Pennsylvania. I'd recommend calling your local SCORE chapter to ask specifically what they cover - they're usually very helpful about explaining what their workshops include. The workshops fill up fast though, so sign up early if you decide to go that route next year!
As someone who's been preparing financial statements for construction companies for over 8 years, I can tell you that your quotes are actually reasonable for the scope of work involved. Construction accounting adds significant complexity that many general practice CPAs aren't equipped to handle properly. The $2,800-$5,500 range you're seeing likely reflects different levels of service and the accountant's experience with construction-specific issues. Here's what should be included in a proper construction company financial statement preparation: 1. Proper revenue recognition using percentage of completion method for long-term contracts 2. Work-in-progress schedules showing costs incurred vs. billings 3. Proper classification of retention receivables and payables 4. Equipment and depreciation schedules 5. Job cost analysis and gross profit by project 6. Cash flow considerations for construction cycles Before choosing an accountant, ask them specifically about their experience with ASC 606 revenue recognition standards and how they handle over/under billings. A good construction accountant will immediately know what you're talking about and can explain how it affects your specific situation. Also, definitely get clarification from your bank about whether they'll accept compiled statements versus reviewed statements. For a $840K construction company, compiled statements with proper disclosures are often sufficient, which could save you $1,500-$2,000. Your current tax accountant's quote of $3,200 isn't unreasonable if they truly understand construction accounting. Sometimes the familiarity with your business is worth the slightly higher cost.
This is incredibly helpful - thank you for breaking down exactly what should be included! I'm definitely going to use this as a checklist when interviewing potential accountants. Quick question about the ASC 606 standards you mentioned - is this something that affects all construction companies or just larger ones? I'm wondering if my size ($840K revenue) means I might be exempt from some of these more complex requirements. Also, when you mention "proper disclosures" for compiled statements, what specific disclosures are typically required for construction companies that banks look for? I want to make sure I'm asking the right questions when I call my bank back.
ASC 606 applies to all construction companies regardless of size - it's been required since 2019 for private companies. However, the complexity of implementation depends on your contract types. For smaller contractors like yourself doing mostly short-term projects (under 12 months), the impact might be minimal since you can often recognize revenue when work is completed rather than over time. For compiled statements, banks typically want to see specific construction-related disclosures including: revenue recognition methods used, significant accounting policies for long-term contracts, details about retention practices, and any material contracts or change orders that could affect financial position. They also want to see work-in-progress presented correctly on the balance sheet. When you call your bank, specifically ask if they require "industry-specific disclosures for construction companies" and whether they need supplementary schedules showing contract details. Some banks are satisfied with basic compiled statements plus a simple WIP schedule, while others want more detailed project-level reporting. The good news is that at your revenue level, you're likely not subject to some of the more complex requirements that larger contractors face, but proper percentage of completion accounting is still essential if you have any multi-month projects.
I've been through this process twice now with my electrical contracting business, and I learned some hard lessons that might help you avoid costly mistakes. First, definitely confirm with your bank whether they'll accept compiled vs reviewed statements. Like others mentioned, many banks will accept compiled statements for businesses under $1M, but you need this in writing. I made the mistake of assuming and ended up paying for a review when compilation would have been fine. Second, since you're in construction, make absolutely sure your accountant understands job costing and percentage of completion accounting. I hired someone who claimed construction experience but didn't properly handle my work-in-progress, and the bank rejected the statements. Had to start over with a specialist. The $3,200 quote from your current tax accountant isn't bad if they truly know construction accounting. Ask them specifically about how they'll handle your ongoing projects and retention receivables. If they can't give you clear answers about WIP schedules and over/under billings, find someone else. One tip that saved me money: get your QuickBooks completely cleaned up first. Make sure all job costs are properly allocated, your accounts are reconciled, and you have backup documentation for any large transactions. This prep work can cut 3-4 hours off your accountant's time, which translates to real savings. Also, ask about payment terms. Some firms will let you pay in installments, especially if you're establishing an ongoing relationship for future years.
This is all really great advice! I'm new to this whole financial statement process and feeling pretty overwhelmed by all the different requirements and terminology. As someone just starting to navigate this, I'm curious - how do you typically find accountants who specialize in construction? Is there a certification or credential I should be looking for, or is it more about asking the right questions during interviews? Also, when you mention getting QuickBooks "completely cleaned up," could you give some specific examples of what that looks like? I think my books are in decent shape, but I want to make sure I'm not missing something obvious that could end up costing me more later. Thanks for sharing your experience - it's really helpful to hear from someone who's been through this process multiple times!
Gemma Andrews
I totally understand the confusion! I went through the exact same thing when I first started dealing with tax paperwork. The good news is that for most people like yourself, your TIN (Taxpayer Identification Number) is simply your Social Security Number (SSN) - they're the same thing! You can find your SSN on: - Your Social Security card (if you still have it) - Any previous tax returns you've filed - W-2 forms from current or past employers - Bank statements or financial documents (though some only show partial numbers for security) The reason this is confusing is that "TIN" is just the IRS's umbrella term for different types of tax identification numbers. For regular U.S. citizens and permanent residents filing individual taxes, that's your 9-digit SSN. You only need different types like an EIN (for businesses) or ITIN (for non-residents) in special circumstances. So for your financial paperwork, just enter your SSN wherever it asks for your TIN. You don't need to apply for anything new - you already have what you need! Don't feel bad about asking - this trips up a lot of people because the government loves using different terminology for the same thing.
0 coins
Manny Lark
ā¢This is such a great explanation, Gemma! I'm actually a newcomer to this community and was lurking through this thread because I had the exact same question as Fatima. It's so reassuring to see how helpful and patient everyone has been with what might seem like a basic question to some people. I've been putting off filling out some investment paperwork for weeks because I kept seeing "TIN" and didn't understand what it meant. Now I realize I've been overthinking it completely - I can just use my SSN that I've had since I was a kid! Sometimes the simplest answers are the right ones. Really appreciate how welcoming this community is to newcomers asking questions. Makes me feel much more confident about tackling my own tax-related paperwork now!
0 coins
Zara Mirza
Hey Fatima! Welcome to the community and don't worry at all about asking this question - it's actually one of the most common sources of confusion when dealing with tax documents. For most US citizens and permanent residents like yourself, your TIN (Taxpayer Identification Number) is simply your Social Security Number (SSN). They're exactly the same thing! The IRS just uses "TIN" as an umbrella term to cover different types of tax identification numbers, but for individual taxpayers, it's your 9-digit SSN. You can find your SSN on your Social Security card, previous tax returns (it's at the top of Form 1040), W-2 forms from any jobs you've had, or bank statements. So when your financial paperwork asks for your TIN, just enter your SSN in the XXX-XX-XXXX format. The only people who need different types of TINs are businesses (who use EINs) or non-residents who can't get an SSN (who use ITINs). Since you're filling out regular financial paperwork, your SSN is definitely what you need. You don't need to apply for anything new - you already have your TIN! Hope this helps clear things up for you.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
ā¢Thanks so much for this clear explanation, Zara! As someone who just joined this community, I'm really impressed by how helpful everyone has been in answering what could seem like a basic question. I actually had the exact same confusion when I first moved to the US a few years ago. The terminology can be really overwhelming when you're dealing with government forms for the first time - seeing "TIN" everywhere made me think I was missing some crucial document I needed to obtain separately. It's such a relief to understand that for most of us regular folks, TIN and SSN are just two different names for the same number. The government really could make this clearer by just saying "SSN" instead of throwing around acronyms like "TIN" that sound so official and scary! Fatima, you're definitely not alone in this confusion, and I'm glad you asked because I'm sure there are lots of other people reading this who had the same question but were too nervous to ask.
0 coins