


Ask the community...
One thing nobody has mentioned yet - if you have any retirement accounts, filing MFS severely limits your ability to contribute to Roth IRAs. The income limit for MFS is only $10,000 before you're completely phased out! Also, if you're doing backdoor Roth conversions, these become much more complicated with MFS status. At your income level, this could actually be a significant long-term financial hit that might offset the student loan savings.
Hadn't even considered the retirement account implications. Do you know if this affects 401k contributions as well? My employer matches up to 6% and I wouldn't want to lose that benefit.
Your 401k contribution limits actually aren't affected by filing status - you can still contribute the full amount ($23,000 for 2025, plus catch-up contributions if you're eligible) and get your employer match regardless of whether you file jointly or separately. The issue is specifically with IRAs, particularly Roth IRAs where the income limits are drastically lower for MFS. If you're currently doing backdoor Roth IRA conversions, which many high-income professionals do, you'll face additional complexities with MFS status due to the pro-rata rule calculations being done separately, but it's still doable with proper planning.
Has anyone mentioned how this affects your mortgage interest deduction? Since you said that's a big part of your itemized deductions. When my husband and I filed MFS, we had to split that deduction and it got messy real fast.
FWIW, I've been investing internationally for 7 years now. For small amounts like yours, I just take the credit directly on Schedule 3 without Form 1116. But I always keep track of the total in my records so that once it gets significant (like over $100) I start filing Form 1116. Another option - if you use a cheaper tax software like FreeTaxUSA, they include Form 1116 in their basic package which is much less expensive than TurboTax's premium tier.
Thanks for the suggestion about FreeTaxUSA! Do they handle everything else TurboTax does? I'm already halfway through my return on TurboTax but maybe I should switch for next year. And is there any downside to skipping Form 1116 when the amount is under the threshold?
FreeTaxUSA handles all the same forms as TurboTax for federal filing at a fraction of the cost. Their interface isn't quite as polished but it gets the job done. Their deluxe version is only about $7 and includes priority support and audit assistance. State returns are extra though. There's no real downside to skipping Form 1116 when you're under the threshold. The only limitation is you can't carry forward unused foreign tax credits, but with just $3, that's not an issue for you. If your foreign investments grow significantly in future years, then you'll want to start using Form 1116.
Just to add another perspective - I wouldn't pay $89 for a $3 credit, that's just throwing money away. But don't just "ignore" the foreign tax either. Enter it directly on Schedule 3 like others have said. Also, look at Credit Karma Tax (now Cash App Taxes) - it's completely free and supports Form 1116 if you need it in the future.
Is Cash App Taxes actually reliable? I've heard mixed things. Anyone used it for investment stuff? Seems sketchy to trust a free app with complicated tax situations...
One thing to watch for with NOLs is that there have been some changes in how they work over the past few years. Currently, you can only carry NOLs forward (not backward like you could in the past), and they're limited to 80% of your taxable income in future years. So if you have a $28,000 NOL from 2023, and in 2024 you have $50,000 in taxable income, you can only use $40,000 of your NOL (80% of your income) to offset your 2024 taxes. The remaining $12,000 would carry forward to 2025. Make sure you keep really good records of your NOL so you can properly apply it in future years!
Thank you for pointing this out! I had no idea about the 80% limitation. Does this mean I need to file any special forms for my 2024 taxes next year when I use the NOL? And should I be keeping copies of anything specific from my 2023 return as proof?
Yes, when you apply your NOL to your 2024 taxes next year, you'll need to file Form 1045 Schedule B to show how you're applying the carryforward. It's a good idea to keep a complete copy of your entire 2023 tax return, especially Schedule A of Form 1045 where you calculated the original NOL. Also keep any supporting documentation for the business losses that created the NOL - receipts, invoices, mileage logs, etc. The IRS tends to look more closely at returns with NOLs, so being able to substantiate everything is important. I recommend creating a dedicated "NOL documentation" folder with copies of everything, since you might be carrying this forward for several years.
One more thing to consider - if you're filing in a state with income tax, the NOL rules may be different than federal. Some states don't recognize NOLs at all, some have different carryforward periods, and others follow federal rules. For example, in California, NOL rules are different from federal with their own forms and calculations. Worth checking your state's department of revenue website for specifics before filing your state return.
Good point about state taxes! I've also seen some states limit the amount of NOL you can claim in a single year, regardless of the federal 80% rule. My state (Illinois) has its own NOL worksheet that's completely different from the federal one.
Be extremely careful with ERC claims. I work at a CPA firm, and we're seeing massive audits on these. The IRS announced increased enforcement specifically targeting ERC claims. If you're filing in 2025 for 2021 credits, make sure you have ROCK SOLID documentation showing: 1. Your exact revenue decline with supporting financial statements 2. That the decline was related to COVID and not other factors 3. That each employee you're claiming was actually performing services during the claim period 4. That you didn't double-dip with PPP funds for the same wages The IRS has extended the statute of limitations to 5 years for ERC claims, so they have plenty of time to come after improper claims. Be extremely careful!
This is exactly what I'm worried about. How detailed does the documentation need to be for proving the revenue decline was COVID-related? We definitely had a 32% drop, but how do I PROVE it was because of COVID vs other market factors? We're in manufacturing and there were supply chain issues, reduced orders, etc.
For proving COVID causation, you'll want to create a narrative document that connects specific COVID factors to your business decline. Include things like: emails from customers canceling or reducing orders citing COVID concerns, documentation of supply chain disruptions with vendor communications, any relevant COVID restrictions that affected your operations, contemporaneous business records showing canceled projects or reduced capacity. The key is showing a clear cause-and-effect relationship. Also maintain detailed quarterly revenue reports that clearly show the percentage decline from 2019 to 2021 for the same quarters. The more specific documentation you have linking COVID factors directly to your revenue decline, the stronger your position will be if audited.
Has anyone here actually been audited for an ERC claim? I filed mine last year and got about $82k back, but now I'm paranoid with all this talk about increased audits. What happens if they decide you shouldn't have received it?
My brother's construction business got audited for their ERC claim last month. They claimed about $135k total. The auditor mainly focused on two things: documentation of their revenue decline and making sure they didn't count wages that were paid with PPP funds. They had good records and passed, but the agent mentioned they're specifically targeting claims filed by third-party "ERC specialists" since they've found a lot of fraud there.
JaylinCharles
Don't forget that business meal deductions changed in recent years! For 2025, business meals are still 50% deductible in most cases, but there was that temporary 100% deduction for restaurant meals during 2021-2022 that went away. Also, make sure you're tracking mileage if you drive to these business meals! That's another deduction many sole props forget about. I use an app to track all my business drives automatically.
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
ā¢Thanks for mentioning the mileage deduction! Do you know if I should be tracking mileage for all business-related driving? And what app do you use to track it?
0 coins
JaylinCharles
ā¢Yes, you should absolutely track mileage for all business-related driving - going to client meetings, picking up supplies, driving to business meals, etc. Just remember that commuting to a regular workplace isn't deductible. I use MileIQ for tracking, but there are several good options like Everlance and Hurdlr too. Most of these apps automatically detect when you're driving and let you swipe to categorize trips as business or personal. Super simple and creates the documentation you need for tax time.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
For business meals, my accountant told me to always write on the back of the receipt WHO i met with and WHAT business we discussed. Been doing this for 10 years and never had an audit problem. Also, don't try to claim every meal as "business" - that's asking for trouble. The IRS knows that not every lunch is a business expense lol.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
ā¢That receipt tip is gold! Do you just write directly on the physical receipt or do you scan it first and add notes digitally?
0 coins