


Ask the community...
Has anyone actually gotten this to work in practice? I tried claiming the medical exemption on my 401k withdrawal last year and still got hit with the penalty. The IRS sent me a letter saying I didn't qualify because I wasn't permanently disabled. I'm wondering if I filled out the Form 5329 incorrectly or something.
You probably used the wrong exception code on Form 5329. There are different codes for different types of exceptions. For medical expenses, you'd use code "02" on line 2. If you accidentally used code "03" (for disability), that would explain why they rejected it, since that requires permanent disability.
I went through this exact situation two years ago and want to share what I learned the hard way. The key thing that tripped me up initially was understanding that you can only exempt the portion of your 401k withdrawal that corresponds to the medical expenses ABOVE 7.5% of your AGI - not your entire withdrawal amount. Here's the calculation: If your AGI was $50,000, then 7.5% is $3,750. If you had $15,000 in unreimbursed medical expenses, only $11,250 ($15,000 - $3,750) of your 401k withdrawal can be exempt from the 10% penalty. So if you withdrew $27,000 like you did, you'd still pay the penalty on $15,750 of it. Also, make sure your tax software is asking about Form 5329. In TurboTax, I had to specifically search for "early withdrawal penalty" in their forms section - it wasn't part of the main interview process. The software should walk you through entering exception code "02" for unreimbursed medical expenses. Don't let the software just automatically apply the 10% penalty to your entire withdrawal without checking for this exemption first!
This is really helpful, thank you! I'm dealing with a similar situation and was confused about the calculation. So just to make sure I understand - if my AGI was $60,000 and I had $20,000 in medical expenses, then 7.5% of my AGI would be $4,500. That means only $15,500 ($20,000 - $4,500) of my 401k withdrawal would be exempt from the penalty? And I need to specifically look for Form 5329 in my tax software since it might not automatically prompt me about it?
Has anyone used the primary residence exclusion in this type of situation? If he lived there 2 out of 5 years before the "buyout," could he exclude his portion of gain under the $250k exclusion?
Yes, this is an important consideration! If he met the ownership and use tests (owned and lived in the home as his main residence for at least 2 out of the 5 years before the interest was disposed of), he could potentially exclude up to $250,000 of gain. In this case, it sounds like he might have taken a loss rather than a gain, but the timeline matters. The 5-year lookback period would start from when he effectively "sold" his interest (the buyout), not the final sale date of the house. So if he lived there for at least 2 years before accepting the buyout payment, he would qualify for the exclusion if there had been a gain.
This is a tricky situation but definitely manageable with proper documentation. Since your brother's name remained on the deed, he'll need to report this on his return even though he didn't receive proceeds from the 2024 sale. The key is treating the buyout as his actual "sale date" rather than the 2024 transaction. On Schedule D, report his cost basis as his original investment in the property, and his proceeds as the $15,000 he received during the buyout. Include a statement explaining that he disposed of his interest in [year of buyout] and received full compensation at that time. Make sure to keep all documentation from the original buyout agreement - this will be crucial if the IRS has questions. You'll also want to get the sale details from his ex (sale price, date, etc.) to properly complete the forms, even though his "sale" technically happened years earlier. The good news is that if he lived in the home as his primary residence for 2+ years before the buyout, he may qualify for the primary residence exclusion on any gain (though it sounds like he likely has a loss anyway). Consider consulting with a tax professional if the numbers are significant, as this type of split ownership situation can have nuances that are worth getting right the first time.
Has anyone dealt with partial reimbursement? My company only reimburses 80% of meals while traveling, meaning I'm covering the other 20%. Can I deduct that 20% portion?
Unfortunately, probably not. Since the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act went into effect (2018-2025), unreimbursed employee business expenses are no longer deductible for most employees on federal taxes. This includes that 20% of meal costs your company doesn't cover.
This is a common misconception that trips up a lot of business travelers! The key principle here is that you can only deduct expenses that you actually bear the cost of. Since you were fully reimbursed by the client, you have no net out-of-pocket expense to deduct. Think of it this way - if you could deduct the $3,700 AND keep the $3,700 reimbursement, you'd essentially be getting paid to take a business trip, which isn't how the tax code works. The timing of when you fronted the money versus when you got reimbursed doesn't matter for tax purposes. What matters is that by the end of the tax year, you were made whole. Make sure to keep all your receipts and documentation of the reimbursement though - the IRS likes to see the paper trail showing these were legitimate business expenses that were properly reimbursed, especially when the amounts are significant like yours.
Hey Max! I totally get the panic - been there myself. The good news is that for just 1-2 days late, you're looking at a really minimal penalty. The IRS charges 0.5% per month (calculated daily), so for a couple days you're talking pennies to maybe a few dollars depending on what you owe. But here's the thing - don't stress too much about it. If you do get hit with a penalty, the First Time Penalty Abatement that others mentioned is basically a get-out-of-jail-free card if you've been compliant for the past 3 years. I used it myself about 2 years ago when I had a similar situation (also due to a family emergency, ironically). The IRS approved it without any questions - didn't even need to provide documentation about the emergency. Just called and said "I'd like to request First Time Penalty Abatement for this penalty" and they took care of it on the spot. Your family emergency is totally understandable and these things happen. Don't beat yourself up over it - you'll get it sorted out!
Thanks Lucas, this is really reassuring! I was literally losing sleep over this thinking I'd ruined my perfect payment record. It's good to know that even if there is a penalty, it won't be some massive amount that destroys my finances. The family emergency angle is exactly what happened to me too - my dad had to go to the ER unexpectedly and between hospital visits and coordinating with family, taxes were the last thing on my mind until it was too late. I'm definitely going to try the First Time Penalty Abatement route if needed. Did you call right away after getting the penalty notice, or is there a specific timeframe you have to request it within?
Don't panic! I was in almost the exact same situation last year - payment was 2 days late due to a banking issue. The penalty was literally $3.47 on a $2,800 tax bill, so we're talking pocket change here. What really helped me was calling the IRS practitioner priority line (if you have a tax pro help you) or the regular taxpayer line early in the morning. I got through around 7:15 AM and the agent was actually really understanding. Just mention you've never been late before and ask about First Time Penalty Abatement - they pulled up my record, saw I had clean history for 3+ years, and removed it immediately. The key is being proactive. Even if you don't get a penalty notice (which you might not for such a small amount), you can still call preemptively if you're worried about it. The IRS agents deal with way worse situations daily, so a responsible taxpayer who's 1-2 days late with a good explanation isn't going to raise any red flags. Hope this helps ease your stress! Family emergencies definitely count as reasonable cause if you need to go that route.
This is such helpful advice, Lauren! I'm actually dealing with a very similar situation right now - my payment was about 2 days late due to a bank transfer delay. Reading all these responses has been a huge relief because I was convinced I was going to face some massive penalty. The $3.47 penalty on a $2,800 bill really puts things in perspective. I was imagining hundreds of dollars in fines! And it's good to know that calling proactively is an option even before getting a notice. I've been putting off calling because I wasn't sure if I should wait to see if they even charge me anything first. One quick question - when you called and mentioned it was due to a banking issue, did they ask for any documentation to prove that, or did they just take your word for it when processing the First Time Penalty Abatement?
Ethan Anderson
One important thing no one has mentioned: if you go to a TAC office, you MUST call ahead for an appointment specifically for ITIN services. You can't just walk in for this service. Also, if your spouse entered the US on any kind of visa that allowed work (even if she's not working), she might actually qualify for an SSN instead of an ITIN. Worth checking that angle first since an SSN is way more useful long-term.
0 coins
Layla Mendes
ā¢Thanks for mentioning this! Does anyone know how far in advance you need to schedule TAC appointments? Are they booking weeks out or can you usually get something within a few days?
0 coins
Ethan Anderson
ā¢In my experience, TAC appointment availability varies dramatically by location. In major cities, you might need to book 3-4 weeks out, especially during tax season (January-April). In smaller offices, you might get an appointment within a week. If you're flexible with timing and location, check multiple nearby TAC offices if possible. Sometimes one office will be booked solid while another 30 minutes away has openings. The online appointment system doesn't always show all available slots, so calling can sometimes yield better results than booking online.
0 coins
Avery Davis
I went through this exact situation with my husband from Germany two years ago, and I completely understand your stress about the passport! Here's what we learned: The key is definitely using a Taxpayer Assistance Center (TAC) appointment. You can get an ITIN without any US income - we did it specifically for future joint filing benefits even though my husband wasn't working yet. A few practical tips from our experience: - Book your TAC appointment as early as possible (we had to wait 3 weeks in our area) - Bring your completed tax return, the W-7 form, passport, marriage certificate, and maybe a utility bill showing both names - The appointment took about 45 minutes total, and they made certified copies of everything right there - We got the ITIN about 6-7 weeks later One thing that really helped us was calling the IRS beforehand to confirm exactly what we needed to bring. The agent was super helpful and walked us through the process step by step. Don't stress too much - thousands of people go through this process successfully every year. The TAC route is definitely the safest way to handle original documents, and the agents there are experienced with ITIN applications for spouses.
0 coins
Isabella Oliveira
ā¢This is really helpful! I'm curious about the call you made to the IRS beforehand - how long did it take to get through to someone? I've been dreading having to call them because I've heard the wait times are terrible. Also, when you brought the utility bill with both names, was that something they specifically asked for or just something you brought as extra documentation?
0 coins
Mei Liu
ā¢The IRS call actually wasn't as bad as I expected - I got through in about 45 minutes, which seemed reasonable compared to horror stories I'd heard. I called early in the morning (around 8 AM) which might have helped with wait times. The utility bill was something we brought as extra documentation, not specifically requested. The IRS agent at the TAC didn't actually need it, but they appreciated that we were thorough. The main documents they cared about were the passport for identity verification and the marriage certificate to establish the spousal relationship. One tip - when you call the IRS, ask them specifically about what supporting documents to bring for your situation. They can give you a personalized checklist based on your circumstances, which really helped us feel prepared for the appointment.
0 coins