


Ask the community...
Have you considered the Medicare surtax implications? At your income level, you'll be subject to the additional 0.9% Medicare surtax on earned income above $250k (married). By taking $325k as salary and the rest as distributions, you're minimizing the income subject to this surtax. Also worth noting that all your income (both salary and distributions) will still be subject to the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax for income above $250k married. So while you're saving on the FICA taxes for distributions, you're not escaping all the medicare-related surtaxes completely.
I thought S Corp distributions weren't subject to the 3.8% NIIT since they're business income, not investment income? My CPA told me only my investment portfolio gets hit with NIIT, not my S Corp distributions.
You're absolutely correct! S Corp distributions are generally NOT subject to the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) because they're considered ordinary business income from active participation, not passive investment income. The NIIT typically applies to things like dividends, capital gains, rental income (if you're not a real estate professional), and other investment-type income. So for Holly's situation, only the salary portion ($325k) would be subject to Medicare taxes (including the 0.9% surtax on amounts over $250k), while the distributions would avoid both regular Medicare tax AND the NIIT. This makes the S Corp structure even more advantageous than James suggested. The key is that you need to be actively involved in the business generating the income. Since Holly is actively working as a physician generating this income through her contracts, the distributions should qualify as exempt from NIIT.
As someone who went through a similar decision process, I'd strongly recommend sticking with your S Corp setup. At your income level ($1.1M), the employment tax savings alone make it worthwhile. Here's a quick breakdown: With your proposed $325K salary, you'll pay Medicare/Social Security taxes on that amount. The remaining ~$613K in distributions (after your $32K expenses and $130K retirement contributions) will avoid the 15.3% self-employment tax that you'd pay if you were a sole proprietor, or the Medicare taxes you'd face on a W2. The employment tax savings on that $613K distribution should be around $9,400 (1.45% Medicare tax) plus the 0.9% additional Medicare surtax on amounts over $250K, which works out to roughly $12,700 in total Medicare tax savings. That's over $22K annually in tax savings, which easily covers your S Corp compliance costs and then some. Your $325K salary seems reasonable for a physician at your income level - not so low as to trigger IRS scrutiny, but not unnecessarily high either. Just make sure to document how you arrived at that figure using industry compensation data for your specialty and location. The key advantage isn't necessarily a lower overall effective tax rate, but rather avoiding employment taxes on a significant portion of your income while maintaining the same ordinary income tax treatment.
This is exactly the kind of analysis I was looking for! The $22K in annual employment tax savings really puts it into perspective. I'm curious though - have you found that the IRS has become more aggressive about auditing S Corp reasonable compensation in recent years? I keep hearing conflicting stories about whether they're cracking down more on medical professionals specifically. Also, do you know if there are any safe harbors or guidelines for what percentage of total S Corp income should be taken as salary versus distributions?
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now - filed early in February, then had to amend in March for a corrected 1099-R, and just last week had to file ANOTHER amendment for a late K-1 from a partnership. The stress is real! What's helped me cope with the uncertainty is setting up a simple tracking spreadsheet with dates for when I filed each return/amendment, when documents arrived, and payment amounts. It gives me something concrete to reference instead of just worrying. I took everyone's advice here and made a manual payment for my second amendment through IRS Direct Pay yesterday. The system was pretty straightforward - I selected "Form 1040" for tax year 2023 and added "Payment for 2023 1040X filed [date]" in the additional info field. The hardest part for me has been the complete lack of visibility into what's happening. The "Where's My Amended Return" tool is basically useless when you have multiple amendments. But reading everyone's experiences here makes me feel much better about the long processing times being normal rather than a sign something went wrong. Thanks to everyone who shared their timelines and advice - it's incredibly helpful to know other people have successfully navigated this exact situation!
The tracking spreadsheet idea is brilliant! I wish I had thought of that when I was going through my amendment situation. Having all those dates and amounts in one place would have saved me so much stress and confusion when trying to remember what I filed when. It's really reassuring to see so many people sharing similar experiences here. When you're in the middle of it, you feel like you must have done something wrong or unusual, but clearly multiple amendments in one season is more common than I thought - especially with how late some investment documents arrive. Good call on making that manual payment right away. The interest and penalties can really add up if you wait for them to process everything, and at least this way you know you've done everything you can on your end. The waiting game is still brutal, but at least the financial part is handled. Thanks for sharing your experience too - it really helps to know we're not alone in dealing with this IRS processing nightmare!
I'm going through this exact nightmare right now! Filed in January, amended in February for a corrected 1099-B, and just had to file a THIRD amendment last week for a surprise K-1 that showed up from an investment I honestly forgot I even had. The stress of wondering if I'm handling this correctly has been keeping me up at night. Reading through everyone's experiences here is such a relief - I had no idea that multiple amendments in one season was actually common. My tax preparer made it sound like I was some kind of outlier, but clearly late investment documents are a real problem lots of people deal with. I'm definitely going to make a manual payment for my latest amendment today after reading all the advice here. The idea of interest continuing to accrue while waiting 4-5 months for processing is terrifying. And I love the spreadsheet idea someone mentioned - I'm going to set that up to track all my filing dates and payments so I have a clear record of everything. Has anyone had experience with what happens if you get yet ANOTHER late document after filing multiple amendments? At this point I'm paranoid that some other form is going to show up in my mailbox, and I'm not sure my sanity can handle filing a fourth amendment!
Don't overlook the option of specializing in tax technology! I started in sales tax compliance but moved into implementing tax engines (Vertex, Avalara, etc.) and it's been the best career move I ever made. The demand for tax technology specialists is growing like crazy because so many companies are automating their sales tax processes. You get to combine your tax knowledge with technical skills, which commands a premium in the market. Most people in sales tax stay on the compliance or consulting track, but the technology integration path is less crowded and often better compensated. Just my two cents!
This is really interesting! What kind of technical skills would I need to develop to go down this path? I have basic SQL knowledge but haven't done much beyond that. Is there a particular certification or training program you'd recommend?
You don't need to be a programmer, but understanding how ERP systems work is essential. Focus on learning the basics of major platforms like SAP, Oracle, or NetSuite. SQL is definitely useful for data manipulation and reporting. Avalara and Vertex both offer certification programs for their solutions, which are a good place to start. Try to get involved in any tax technology projects at your current company, even if it's just helping with requirements gathering or testing. The key is to demonstrate that you understand both the tax implications and how they translate to system requirements. Most of the specific technical skills can be learned on the job, but showing interest and basic aptitude will get your foot in the door.
This is such a timely question! I've been in sales and use tax for about 10 years now and have seen the field evolve dramatically. One path that's often overlooked is specializing in audit defense and voluntary disclosure agreements (VDAs). Companies are constantly discovering they have nexus in states they didn't realize, and the penalties can be substantial. If you can develop expertise in negotiating with state auditors and structuring VDAs to minimize penalties, you become incredibly valuable. I've seen specialists in this area command $150-200+ per hour as consultants. Another emerging area is economic nexus compliance post-Wayfair. Many companies are still struggling to understand their obligations, especially smaller businesses that suddenly found themselves with filing requirements in dozens of states. The intersection of e-commerce and sales tax is creating tons of opportunities. My advice: get really good at one specific area first (like nexus determination or exemption management), then gradually expand. The breadth of knowledge will come naturally as you gain experience. And definitely join your local IPT chapter - the networking opportunities are invaluable for career advancement!
As someone who works with disability clients (though in Canada, not Australia), I'd recommend also checking if receiving this inheritance might affect your disability benefits in Australia. Many disability programs have asset limits, and while an inheritance might be exempt, you sometimes need to report it or set up a specific type of trust.
This is such important advice! My cousin lost her disability payments for 6 months because she didn't properly report a much smaller inheritance. Different country, but same concept - many disability programs have strict asset reporting requirements.
I'm so sorry you're dealing with this stress on top of your health challenges. The good news is that your situation is very manageable, and you're definitely not going to be in "serious trouble" with the IRS. A few key points that might ease your worry: 1. **Inheritance isn't taxable income to you** - The US doesn't tax inheritance recipients. Your grandmother's estate would have handled any estate taxes before distributing to you. 2. **You likely won't owe much (if anything)** - As an Australian resident, you can exclude foreign earned income up to about $120,000 USD annually, and Australia has a tax treaty with the US to prevent double taxation. 3. **The Streamlined program is designed for people exactly like you** - It's specifically for those who didn't know they had filing obligations. Since this was clearly non-willful, penalties are typically waived. 4. **Your disability status may qualify you for additional assistance** - The IRS has programs to help taxpayers with disabilities, including extended deadlines and simplified procedures in some cases. Don't let this overwhelm you. Start by gathering your financial documents from the past few years, and consider whether the tools others mentioned (like AI tax assistance) or speaking directly with the IRS might help you understand your specific situation. You've got time to sort this out properly, and it's really not as scary as it seems right now.
Liam Duke
I saw one where it shows the IRS as Michael Scott from The Office saying "I am not superstitious, but I am a little stitious" with the caption "The IRS requiring receipts for exactly $599 but not $600" and I think about it every time I do my self-employment taxes.
0 coins
Manny Lark
ā¢Wait is that actually true? I thought the threshold was $600 for 1099s? I've been tracking all my freelance income but now I'm confused...
0 coins
Isabella Russo
The "calculating if I can claim my plants as dependents" one absolutely sent me! š My personal favorite is the one with someone frantically digging through a mountain of papers captioned "Me looking for that ONE receipt from 8 months ago that might save me $3 in taxes." There's also this classic with Drake pointing - "Doing taxes myself" (disapproving Drake) vs "Paying someone else to do them and pretending I understand what they did" (approving Drake). Hits way too close to home! Anyone else relate to the meme where it's like "January: I'm going to be so organized with my receipts this year" followed by "April: *shoebox full of crumpled receipts*"? That's literally my life story every single year.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
ā¢The shoebox full of crumpled receipts is SO relatable! š I start every year swearing I'll use an app to track expenses and by March I'm literally photographing gas station receipts with my phone at 11 PM trying to remember what they were for. That Drake meme is spot on too - there's something oddly comforting about paying someone else to deal with the chaos and just nodding along when they explain deductions like I totally knew that already. The plant dependents one still makes me chuckle every time I look at my houseplants though!
0 coins