


Ask the community...
Friendly reminder that you can actually have an HSA without an employer! I opened my own after leaving a job with a high-deductible health plan. Fidelity offers HSAs with zero fees and no minimum balance. As long as you're currently enrolled in a qualifying high-deductible health plan (HDHP), you can contribute to an HSA, with or without an employer. And if you're not eligible to contribute new funds, you can still open an HSA just to receive rollovers from previous accounts.
But don't you lose the advantage of pre-tax contributions if your employer isn't handling it? That's a significant benefit of HSAs.
Actually, you don't lose the pre-tax advantage completely! You can still deduct HSA contributions on your tax return even if you're making them with after-tax dollars from your paycheck. It's just not as convenient as having your employer handle it through payroll deduction, but the tax benefit is still there when you file your return. The bigger loss is that you miss out on the FICA tax savings (Social Security and Medicare taxes) that you get when contributions are made through employer payroll. That's about 7.65% in additional tax savings that you can't get back through deductions. But for someone in Ethan's situation with just $95 to roll over, the convenience of having an individual HSA definitely outweighs those considerations.
Just want to emphasize how time-sensitive this is! That 60-day clock started ticking the moment Health Equity issued your check, not when you received it. So if there was any delay in mail delivery, you might have even less time than you think. I'd recommend calling whatever HSA provider you're considering (Fidelity, your bank, etc.) TODAY and explaining that you need to do an emergency rollover. Many can expedite the account opening process when they understand the time crunch. Some even allow you to deposit the rollover funds before all the paperwork is finalized. Also, make sure to deposit the exact amount of the check - don't subtract any fees the new provider might charge for opening the account, as that could complicate the rollover documentation. You can pay those separately. The good news is $95 isn't a huge tax hit if you do miss the deadline, but it's still worth saving if you can act quickly!
Just wanted to point out that the IRS sometimes offers penalty relief through their First Time Abatement program if you've had a clean tax record for the past 3 years. Might be worth asking about if this is your first time missing a deadline.
I've been through this exact situation and want to add some practical advice. First, file your return IMMEDIATELY even if you can't pay - the failure-to-file penalty (5% per month) is much worse than the failure-to-pay penalty (0.5% per month). When you do file, make sure to pay whatever you can, even if it's not the full amount. This reduces the balance that penalties and interest accrue on. The IRS also looks more favorably on taxpayers who make good faith efforts to comply. Also, consider requesting penalty abatement when you call. Besides first-time abatement, the IRS can waive penalties for "reasonable cause" - things like serious illness, death in family, natural disasters, or other circumstances beyond your control. Even financial hardship can sometimes qualify. One last tip: if you end up owing a lot in penalties, you can request an installment agreement that includes the penalties and interest in your monthly payment plan. This makes it much more manageable than trying to pay everything at once.
This is really helpful advice, especially about filing immediately even if you can't pay the full amount. I'm curious though - when you mention "reasonable cause" for penalty abatement, how specific do you need to be with documentation? Like if someone had a medical issue or family emergency, what kind of proof does the IRS typically want to see?
My husband and I were in a similar situation but with accounts in Europe totaling about ā¬60k. We filed both FBAR and 8938 for years because our accountant said it was "better safe than sorry." This year we switched accountants and they told us we never needed the 8938! We asked about amending previous returns to remove the unnecessary forms but were advised it wasn't worth the effort since there's no penalty for over-reporting. Apparently the IRS doesn't issue refunds for the extra accounting fees we paid all those years š
Did your new accountant charge less since they didn't have to file the 8938? I'm curious because I'm paying my accountant about $400 extra for "international reporting" and now I'm wondering if I actually need all the forms they're filing.
Yes, our new accountant charges about $150 less per year since they don't prepare the unnecessary Form 8938. They explained that the FBAR filing is actually free (it's filed directly with FinCEN), so we were essentially paying extra for a form we didn't need. I'd suggest asking your accountant to break down exactly what forms they're filing for your "international reporting" fee. If your foreign assets are under the thresholds, you might only need the FBAR, which shouldn't add much to your tax prep costs since it's a relatively simple form.
Based on everyone's experiences here, it sounds like you're in good shape! I went through something very similar last year - had about $65k in foreign accounts and my accountant filed both FBAR and Form 8938 even though I was below the 8938 threshold. I was worried about the same things you mentioned, but after reading through IRS publications and speaking with a tax attorney, I learned that over-reporting foreign assets is actually quite common and not problematic at all. The IRS sees it frequently, especially from cautious preparers who want to ensure full compliance. The key thing is that your information is consistent across both forms, which creates a clean paper trail. Your voluntary late FBAR filings before any IRS contact also puts you in the best possible position penalty-wise. One thing I'd suggest is asking your accountant for next year - now that you understand the thresholds better, you can discuss whether Form 8938 is truly necessary going forward. This could save you some money on preparation fees while still maintaining full compliance with the FBAR requirements.
This is really helpful to hear from someone who went through the exact same situation! I'm curious - when you spoke with the tax attorney, did they mention anything about how long the IRS typically takes to process late FBAR filings? I'm wondering if there's a timeframe after which I can stop worrying about potential penalties. Also, you mentioned asking my accountant about dropping Form 8938 for next year - should I be concerned that this might look inconsistent to the IRS if I suddenly stop filing a form I've been including? Or do they not really track that kind of pattern?
As someone who switched from paper to e-filing last year, I can't stress enough how much easier it makes the whole process. The biggest game-changer for me wasn't even the faster processing time (though getting my refund in 3 weeks instead of 6+ months was amazing) - it was the error checking. When I paper filed, I'd spend hours double and triple-checking my math, worried I'd made a mistake somewhere. With e-filing, the software catches basic errors automatically before you even submit. It'll flag things like mismatched social security numbers, math errors, or missing required forms. Also, if you're worried about security, e-filing is actually safer than mailing sensitive documents. I used to worry about my tax return sitting in a mailbox or getting lost in transit. Electronic transmission is encrypted and you get immediate confirmation that the IRS received it. For someone with a straightforward return like yours (W-2, some interest income, standard deduction), the transition should be really smooth. Most tax software will walk you through everything step by step, and many have free versions for simple returns.
This is really helpful! I'm actually in a similar situation to the original poster - been paper filing for years but starting to think it's time to make the switch. One question though - do you remember roughly how much you paid for the e-filing software? I've been using the free fillable forms from the IRS website for paper filing, so I'm trying to figure out if the convenience is worth the extra cost. Also, when you say the software walks you through everything step by step, does it actually explain WHY certain deductions apply or don't apply? I've always liked understanding my taxes rather than just plugging numbers into boxes.
Great question! I actually started with the same free fillable forms approach, so I totally get the cost concern. For a basic return like yours, you can probably still file for free through the IRS Free File program - it covers most taxpayers with AGI under $73,000 and includes e-filing at no cost. If you don't qualify for Free File, most basic e-filing software runs around $30-60 depending on the provider. I personally think it's worth it for the time savings alone - what used to take me 3-4 hours of careful manual calculation now takes maybe 45 minutes. And yes, the better software definitely explains the "why" behind deductions! It'll ask you interview-style questions and then explain what each deduction means and whether you qualify. For example, instead of just asking for a dollar amount, it might say "Did you pay student loan interest in 2024? This deduction can reduce your taxable income by up to $2,500 if you meet the income requirements." Much more educational than just filling out forms blindly. The software also flags potential deductions you might have missed - I actually got a bigger refund than expected my first year e-filing because it caught a few things I'd been overlooking on paper returns.
I made the switch from paper to e-filing three years ago and honestly wish I'd done it sooner. The processing time difference alone is worth it - I used to wait until September or October to get my refund, now I have it in my account by mid-February. One thing that really convinced me was the audit protection. Most e-filing software includes some level of audit support, and the built-in error checking actually reduces your audit risk compared to paper filing. When you paper file, simple math errors or forgotten signatures can trigger correspondence that looks suspicious to the IRS system. E-filing eliminates most of those issues before submission. For your situation with just W-2 and 1099-INT, you'd probably qualify for free e-filing through the IRS Free File program. Even if you don't, the cost is usually under $50 for basic returns, which pays for itself in the time you save and faster refund processing. The environmental impact was another factor for me - no more printing dozens of pages and mailing thick envelopes. Plus I can access my returns from anywhere if I need them for loan applications or other financial paperwork.
That's a great point about the audit protection - I hadn't really thought about how manual errors could actually increase audit risk. I've been doing my own paper returns for about 8 years now and always stress about making mistakes, especially with the math calculations. The environmental aspect is actually something that matters to me too. I hate how much paper I go through every tax season between printing forms, making copies, and mailing everything. Going digital would definitely align better with trying to reduce my paper waste. One more question - when you mention accessing returns from anywhere for loan applications, how does that work exactly? Do you just log into the software and download PDFs, or is there some other way lenders can verify your tax information electronically?
Diego Chavez
pro tip: take a picture of the letter before you do anything with it. trust me on this one
0 coins
Emma Wilson
ā¢good idea! doing that rn
0 coins
Elijah Knight
I've been through this exact same thing! Got my letter last month and was terrified to open it too. Turned out to be just a routine verification request. The key is to respond quickly - don't let it sit around. If you need help understanding what they're asking for, there are plenty of people here who can walk you through it step by step.
0 coins
Miguel Alvarez
ā¢This is so reassuring to hear! I'm new to dealing with IRS stuff and seeing everyone's experiences here really helps calm the nerves. Quick question - when you say respond quickly, what's the typical timeframe they give you? I want to make sure I don't miss any deadlines if I get something similar.
0 coins