


Ask the community...
Has anyone considered the flipside? If the tenant pays utilities directly, does that mean the TENANT can deduct those utilities somehow? Like as a home office deduction if they work from home? Just curious if there's any benefit to the tenant for paying utilities directly vs having them included in rent.
Tenants generally can't deduct regular household utilities, even if they work from home. The home office deduction works differently - they could potentially deduct a PORTION of utilities based on the percentage of the home used exclusively for business. But that's true regardless of whether they pay utilities directly or if utilities are bundled into rent. The tenant doesn't get any special tax treatment just because they pay utilities directly vs having them included in rent. The only real difference is that with direct payment, they have more control over usage and can potentially save money by being more energy-conscious.
I went through this exact same situation with my duplex rental last year. The bottom line is definitely no - you cannot deduct utilities that your tenant pays directly to the utility companies. The IRS is very clear that you can only deduct expenses that you actually paid out of pocket. However, don't let this discourage you from the tenant-pays-utilities arrangement! There are actually some advantages to this setup. You don't have to worry about tenants leaving lights on or cranking up the heat since they're paying the bill. Plus, you avoid the hassle of having to collect utility reimbursements or dealing with seasonal fluctuations in your cash flow. Just make sure you're capturing all the deductions you ARE entitled to - property management fees, repairs, maintenance, insurance, property taxes, depreciation, etc. Those can add up to significant savings even without the utility deductions.
That's a great point about the advantages of having tenants pay utilities directly! I never thought about it from the cash flow perspective. I'm actually considering switching my rental arrangement to have tenants pay utilities directly for exactly those reasons - no more worrying about them blasting the AC all summer on my dime. Quick question though - when you made that switch, did you adjust the rent at all to account for the tenant now being responsible for utilities? I'm trying to figure out if I should lower the rent slightly since they're taking on that additional expense, or if the market rent should stay the same regardless of the utility arrangement.
I went through a nearly identical situation with Jackson Hewitt in 2022 - they botched my education credits and completely missed my student loan interest deduction, costing me almost $1,200 in additional tax liability. Here's what actually worked for me: 1. **Document everything with dates and reference numbers** - I created a spreadsheet tracking every phone call, email, and document exchange 2. **Request their internal complaint escalation process** - Most people don't know that Jackson Hewitt has a formal Quality Review Department separate from local management 3. **File Form 14157 immediately** - Don't wait. I filed mine while simultaneously working with their corporate office, which actually strengthened my position 4. **Contact your state's Board of Accountancy** - If your preparer was a CPA or EA, this adds serious pressure The breakthrough came when I sent a certified letter to their corporate Quality Review Department (not just customer service) citing IRC Β§6694 and mentioning I had already filed Form 14157. Within 5 business days, I had a call from their regional compliance manager who arranged for a senior EA to completely redo my return at no cost. They also reimbursed the $89 I paid for professional review of their errors. Total timeline: 3 weeks from escalation to resolution. The key is being persistent and showing you understand the regulations better than their seasonal preparers do.
This is incredibly helpful! I'm dealing with a Jackson Hewitt error right now and your step-by-step approach gives me a clear roadmap. Quick question - do you happen to have the specific mailing address for their corporate Quality Review Department? I've been trying to find it but keep getting routed to general customer service addresses. Also, when you mentioned filing Form 14157 while working with their corporate office, did that create any complications or did it actually help move things along faster? I'm worried about seeming too aggressive but also don't want to waste more time with their local office runaround.
Based on my experience dealing with tax preparer errors, I'd recommend taking a multi-pronged approach while the filing deadline is still fresh. First, send a demand letter via certified mail to both the local office manager AND Jackson Hewitt's corporate compliance department, specifically referencing IRC Β§6694 and Circular 230 violations. Include calculated damages from their errors and request full remediation within 10 business days. Simultaneously, file Form 14157 with the IRS - don't wait on this. The form creates an official record and often motivates preparers to resolve issues quickly. Also consider contacting your state's consumer protection agency if Jackson Hewitt is licensed there. Document the specific financial impact: if their education credit error cost you $1,000 in additional tax, plus any penalties or interest, they should cover those costs under their accuracy guarantee. Most major chains will settle rather than face regulatory scrutiny, especially when you demonstrate knowledge of the specific tax code sections they violated. Keep pushing up their corporate ladder - local managers often lack authority to authorize full remediation, but regional compliance departments usually do. The key is showing you won't accept partial fixes or excuses.
One important thing no one's mentioned yet - if your parents receive Medicaid, SSI, or certain other benefits, being claimed as dependents on your taxes could potentially affect their eligibility or benefit amounts. Some means-tested government programs have specific rules about this. I found this out the hard way when I claimed my grandmother and it caused issues with her benefits. Might be worth checking with your state's Medicaid office or your parents' benefits administrators before making any changes to your tax situation.
This is really helpful information everyone! I'm dealing with a similar situation but with one additional wrinkle - my parents also receive some help from my brother who lives across the country. He sends them about $300/month to help with their medications and other expenses. Does anyone know how this affects the "more than half support" calculation? I'm definitely paying the majority of their living expenses (housing, utilities, food), but I want to make sure I'm calculating this correctly. Do I need to include what my brother contributes when determining if I'm providing more than half their total support? Also, has anyone dealt with the IRS asking for documentation of the support you provide? I've been keeping receipts like Molly mentioned, but wondering what specific records I should focus on maintaining.
I'm dealing with a very similar situation with my grandmother who moved in with us last year. She's married to my grandfather and they want to file jointly, but I'm covering most of their living expenses since they're on a fixed income from Social Security. After reading through all these responses, it sounds like the key is whether they would have zero tax liability if filing separately. In my case, their combined Social Security is about $16,000 annually, so they likely wouldn't owe any taxes filing separately either. One thing I'm wondering about - do I need to calculate the support test for each parent individually, or can I look at their combined expenses? For example, if I'm paying $1,200/month for their housing costs, do I split that between them when calculating whether I provide more than 50% support for each one? Also, has anyone had experience with the IRS accepting utility bills and grocery receipts as documentation? I've been keeping everything, but I want to make sure I'm tracking the right types of expenses in case I get audited.
Great question about the support calculation! You need to calculate the support test individually for each person you want to claim as a dependent. So if you're claiming both your grandmother and grandfather, you'd need to show that you provide more than 50% of support for each one separately. For shared expenses like housing, you would typically divide them equally between the people benefiting from that expense. So your $1,200/month housing cost would be $600 attributed to your grandmother and $600 to your grandfather when calculating their individual support tests. Regarding documentation, the IRS generally accepts utility bills, grocery receipts, medical bills, and other reasonable proof of expenses. I'd recommend keeping a simple spreadsheet that tracks monthly expenses by category (housing, utilities, food, medical, etc.) and then splits shared costs appropriately between each person. Take photos of receipts and keep digital copies - it makes everything much easier to organize if you ever need to provide documentation. The key is being able to show that for each person individually, your contributions exceed 50% of their total support for the year. Since their Social Security income is relatively low, you should be able to meet this threshold for both of them if you're covering housing, utilities, and most other living expenses.
I've been through this exact scenario with my parents who moved in with me two years ago. The good news is that you can absolutely claim your mother as a dependent while your parents file jointly, as long as they meet that joint filing exception everyone mentioned. One piece of advice I wish I'd gotten earlier - start documenting your support contributions NOW if you haven't already. I learned this the hard way when the IRS requested documentation. Create a simple monthly expense tracker that includes: - Housing costs (use fair rental value for the space they occupy - I calculated what a 2-bedroom apartment would rent for in my area and divided by the bedrooms in my house) - Utilities (divide by number of household members) - Food expenses (keep grocery receipts and estimate what portion goes to them) - Medical expenses you pay on their behalf - Transportation costs if you drive them places - Any other support like clothing, personal care items, etc. The 50% support test can be tricky to calculate, but with your parents' income at $13,500 combined, you're likely well over the threshold. Just make sure you're calculating it correctly - their total support includes what YOU provide plus what THEY provide for themselves from their own income. Also, don't forget that claiming them as dependents might make you eligible for additional tax benefits beyond just the dependency exemption. If you're paying medical expenses for them, that could potentially push you into itemizing territory depending on your other deductions. Good luck with your tax situation!
This is incredibly helpful advice, thank you! I wish I had started tracking expenses from day one when my parents moved in. I'm definitely going to set up a monthly tracker like you suggested. Quick question about the fair rental value calculation - did you use current market rates for your area, or did you get an official appraisal? I'm in a pretty expensive housing market, so I want to make sure I'm calculating this correctly and not overestimating the housing support I'm providing. Also, you mentioned additional tax benefits beyond the dependency exemption - could you elaborate on what other benefits I might be eligible for? I hadn't considered that there might be other deductions or credits available.
Ryder Ross
dont forget to check if your state has its own supplemental subsidy too! i live in california and we get extra help on top of the federal subsidies, but you have to pay those back separately. its confusing because some states have different rules for repayment than the federal system
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
β’This is a really good point - I'm in Massachusetts and we have ConnectorCare which has its own subsidy structure that works alongside the federal ACA subsidies. When I had an income change, I had to update both systems and the reconciliation process was different for each. What's the California program called?
0 coins
Ryan Kim
Great question about ACA subsidy reconciliation! I went through something similar last year as a self-employed consultant. One key thing to remember is that you should definitely update your income estimate on the Marketplace as soon as you realize it's going to be higher - don't wait until tax time. This will reduce your monthly subsidy going forward and minimize the repayment shock at tax time. Also, keep in mind that the self-employed health insurance deduction (which goes on Schedule 1) is actually more valuable than just writing off premiums as a business expense, because it reduces your adjusted gross income. This can help lower your overall tax bracket and potentially affect other income-based calculations. If you're close to the 400% Federal Poverty Line threshold that Kyle mentioned, you might want to consider some year-end tax planning strategies to keep your income under that cap if possible - like maxing out retirement contributions or other deductible expenses.
0 coins