


Ask the community...
You might want to try checking your tax topic code on WMR instead. The 'as of' date seems to be somewhat relevant, but it's not necessarily definitive. I've had some success looking at the cycle code on my transcript - it's usually in format YYYYCCDD. If your cycle code ends in 01-05, you're likely on a weekly update schedule. If it ends in 05, specifically, many people report updates on Fridays with deposits the following Wednesday. This seems to be more reliable than the 'as of' date, though I can't guarantee it's foolproof.
Just wanted to share a win! I was obsessing over my 'as of' date too, watching it change from Feb 26 to Mar 12 to Mar 5 (yes, it went BACKWARDS š¤£). But then I just randomly checked my bank account this morning and boom! š° Full refund deposited! Never even saw an update on WMR or any 846 code on my transcript. Sometimes the system works in mysterious ways! Hope you all get your refunds soon too!
That's so encouraging to hear! š I've been checking my transcript obsessively and seeing those dates jump around like yours did. It's reassuring to know that sometimes the money just shows up without any warning signs. Gives me hope that I might wake up to a surprise deposit too! Thanks for sharing your success story - definitely needed that positivity today.
Anyone here actually used a CRT for crypto specifically? I'm looking at doing this with some Ethereum that's way up from my cost basis, but my attorney seems hesitant about using crypto in a trust like this. Said something about valuation issues.
I set up a CRUT (not a CRAT) with Bitcoin last year. The key challenge was getting proper valuation documentation for the IRS. We used the average of three exchanges at exactly the same time to establish FMV. Also, the trustee immediately converted to a diversified portfolio to avoid exactly the scenario OP is worried about. No regrets so far - saved a ton on capital gains and the income stream is stable now that we're not at the mercy of crypto volatility.
This is exactly why I always recommend consulting with both a tax attorney AND a financial advisor who specializes in charitable trusts before setting up any CRT with volatile assets. The interplay between the 10% remainder rule, payment obligations, and asset volatility can create serious cash flow issues even when you're technically compliant with IRS requirements. One strategy I've seen work well is setting up what's called a "flip CRUT" - it starts as a net income makeup trust (NIMCRUT) that only pays out actual income earned, then "flips" to a standard unitrust once a triggering event occurs (like diversification of the original volatile assets). This provides protection during periods when the trust assets might not generate enough income to support full payments. The key takeaway from your crypto example is that while the 10% rule won't be violated by market crashes after establishment, you could end up with a trust that gets completely depleted paying the fixed annuity amounts, leaving nothing for the charitable remainder. That defeats the whole purpose of the structure.
This is incredibly helpful information! I hadn't heard of a "flip CRUT" before but it sounds like exactly what I need for my situation. The idea of starting with income-only payments until the assets can be diversified makes so much sense for volatile investments like crypto. Could you explain a bit more about what typically serves as the "triggering event" for the flip? Is it usually just the sale and diversification of the original assets, or are there other common triggers people use? And does setting up this type of structure significantly complicate the trust documents or make it more expensive to establish? I'm wondering if this approach would work for my crypto situation where I want to avoid immediate capital gains but also don't want to risk depleting the trust if the market crashes again.
Check if any of your dividend income is from foreign sources. If so, you might be able to claim the foreign tax credit, which while it doesn't reduce your investment income, could help offset some of the tax impact from losing the EITC. Also worth checking if any of your investments made return of capital distributions that might have been misclassified as dividends on your statements.
I'm in a similar situation with investment income pushing me over the EITC threshold. One thing that might help is reviewing your 1099s very carefully - sometimes brokerages misclassify certain distributions. Also, if you have any investments in REITs or master limited partnerships (MLPs), some of their distributions might be considered return of capital rather than dividend income, which wouldn't count toward the $11,000 limit. Another angle to consider: if you have any investments showing unrealized losses, you could sell them before year-end to generate capital losses that offset some of your gains or other investment income. Just make sure you don't run afoul of wash sale rules if you plan to repurchase. Unfortunately, there's no way to "undo" interest and dividends that have already been distributed to you this year, but these strategies might help reduce your reportable investment income for EITC purposes.
Random tip from someone who's been through this - make sure your husband is taking before and after pictures of everything he fixes up! Not only is this good for sales listings, but if you ever get audited, having visual proof of the improvements made can help justify the expenses. The IRS can be picky about hobby vs business classification for flipping activities.
This is actually brilliant advice. I got audited last year for my restoration business and the before/after photos saved me. I also keep a simple project log with dates and hours worked on each item which proved I was treating it as a business.
Great question! I went through this exact same confusion when I started my furniture flipping side business. Here's what I learned works best in TurboTax: The initial purchase price of the motorcycles/tools should definitely go under "Cost of Goods Sold" - these are your inventory items that you're buying specifically to resell. For the repair parts and materials he's purchasing to fix them up, those go under "Materials and supplies" in the expense section. This includes things like replacement parts, paint, cleaning supplies, etc. One thing that really helped me was keeping a simple spreadsheet for each item - purchase price, repair costs, selling price, and profit. This makes it super easy when you're entering everything into TurboTax and gives you great records if you ever need them. Also don't forget about other deductible expenses like gas/mileage for picking up items, any selling fees (eBay, Facebook Marketplace, etc.), and even a portion of your phone bill if he uses it for business calls. These little things add up! The key is treating this as a legitimate business from day one with good record keeping. That way there's no question about hobby vs business classification with the IRS.
This is super helpful, thank you! The spreadsheet idea is brilliant - I've been keeping receipts but not organizing them by project. One quick question: when you say "portion of phone bill" - how do you calculate what percentage is business use? Do you need to track every business call or is there a simpler way to estimate it?
CosmicCowboy
This is such a frustrating situation, and I feel for you! The marketplace rep really put you in a tough spot by changing that answer without fully explaining the consequences. From what I've learned dealing with similar issues, you'll need to determine if CVS's health insurance offer met the IRS "affordability" standard. For 2024, employer coverage is considered affordable if your share of the premium for self-only coverage is less than 9.12% of your household income. Here's a quick way to check: Take your 2024 annual household income, multiply by 0.0912, then divide by 12. If CVS's monthly premium for just you would have been less than that amount, their offer was technically "affordable" and you'll likely need to repay some of your Premium Tax Credits. The good news is there are income-based repayment caps. If your household income is under 400% of the federal poverty level (around $58,320 for single filers), you won't have to repay more than $325-$2,825 depending on your specific income bracket, even if you received much more than that in credits. When you file your taxes, you'll use Form 8962 to reconcile everything. This form is incredibly complex, so I'd strongly recommend getting help from a tax professional who specializes in Premium Tax Credit issues. They can also help you identify any deductions that might lower your adjusted gross income and potentially reduce your repayment. Don't panic - while this isn't ideal, the repayment caps exist specifically to protect people in situations like yours. Just make sure you handle it properly on your return.
0 coins
Arnav Bengali
ā¢This is really solid advice! I'm in a similar boat and have been dreading tax season. One question though - when you say "tax professional who specializes in Premium Tax Credit issues," how do you actually find someone like that? Most tax preparers I've called seem confused when I mention PTC reconciliation. Is there a specific certification or credential I should be looking for? I don't want to end up with someone who's just as lost as I am on Form 8962.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
ā¢Great question @Arnav Bengali! Finding the right tax professional for PTC issues can be tricky. Here are some tips: Look for Enrolled Agents (EAs) or CPAs who specifically mention ACA/Premium Tax Credit experience on their websites or advertising. The IRS has a "Find a Tax Professional" tool where you can search by specialty. You can also contact your local VITA (Volunteer Income Tax Assistance) program - they're trained specifically on ACA tax issues and it's free for people earning under $60K. Many have specialists who deal with Form 8962 regularly. When calling tax preparers, ask specifically: "How many Form 8962s did you complete last year?" and "Are you familiar with Premium Tax Credit reconciliation and repayment caps?" If they seem unsure or say they'll "figure it out," keep looking. The National Association of Tax Professionals and National Association of Enrolled Agents both have member directories where you can search for practitioners with ACA experience. Don't be afraid to interview 2-3 tax pros before deciding. A good one should be able to explain the affordability test and repayment caps clearly in your initial consultation. @CosmicCowboy gave excellent advice about the income calculations - any qualified preparer should immediately understand what you're dealing with when you mention employer coverage vs marketplace PTC.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
This is definitely a stressful situation, but you're not alone - this happens to thousands of people every year who get caught between employer coverage and marketplace plans. The key issue is whether CVS's insurance offer met the IRS "affordability" test. For 2024, employer coverage is considered affordable if your portion of the premium for employee-only coverage costs less than 9.12% of your household income. If it was "affordable" by this standard, you'll likely need to repay some of your Premium Tax Credits when you file. However, there are important protections in place. If your household income is under 400% of the federal poverty level (about $58,320 for single filers in 2024), your repayment is capped based on your income bracket - ranging from $325 to $2,825 maximum, regardless of how much you actually received in credits. Here's what I'd recommend: 1. Calculate the affordability test using your actual 2024 income 2. Gather all your tax documents (1095-A from the marketplace, 1095-C from CVS, W-2s) 3. Find a tax professional experienced with Form 8962 - this form is complex and mistakes can be costly 4. Consider any legitimate deductions that could lower your adjusted gross income and potentially reduce repayment The marketplace rep shouldn't have changed your answer without explaining the tax implications, but what's done is done. The good news is the repayment caps exist specifically to protect people in situations like yours. Focus on handling this correctly on your tax return rather than panicking about worst-case scenarios.
0 coins
Scarlett Forster
ā¢This is really helpful advice! I'm curious about one thing though - when calculating that 9.12% affordability test, do you use your gross income or your adjusted gross income? And what if your income varied throughout 2024 - like if you got a raise partway through the year? Do you use your total annual income or try to calculate month by month based on what you were earning when you made the marketplace application? Also, I noticed a few people mentioned services like TaxR.ai and Claimyr - has anyone actually used these successfully for PTC reconciliation issues? I'm hesitant to use online tools for something this complex, but if they actually work it might be worth considering before paying for a tax professional.
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
ā¢Great questions @Scarlett Forster! For the affordability test, you use your household income for the entire tax year - so your total annual income including any raises or changes throughout 2024. The IRS doesn't do month-by-month calculations for this purpose. Regarding gross vs. adjusted gross income - this is where it gets a bit confusing. The affordability test itself uses your household income (which is closer to gross), but the repayment caps are based on your adjusted gross income (AGI). So income changes can affect both calculations differently. As for the online tools mentioned - I haven't personally used TaxR.ai, but I have heard mixed reviews. Some people find the calculations helpful for getting a ballpark estimate, while others say it's not sophisticated enough for complex situations. The challenge with any online tool is that PTC reconciliation involves a lot of nuanced rules that automated systems might miss. Claimyr is different - it's not a tax calculation tool, it's a service that helps you get through to the IRS. I actually did try it last year when I couldn't reach anyone at the IRS after weeks of trying. It worked as advertised - got me connected to an actual IRS representative who could answer my specific questions. Cost about $50 but saved me probably 20+ hours of trying to get through on my own. For something as complex as your situation, I'd still lean toward finding an experienced tax professional. The peace of mind of having someone who really knows Form 8962 handle it properly is usually worth the cost.
0 coins