


Ask the community...
Thank you all for this incredibly helpful discussion! As someone new to navigating grad school finances, this has been so educational. I really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences and tools. A couple follow-up questions based on what I've learned here: 1. Since my son will be getting a W-2 for his research assistant position, should we expect any federal or state taxes to already be withheld from his stipend payments, or will he need to make quarterly estimated payments? 2. For the record-keeping that several people mentioned - what specific documents should we be sure to save beyond the W-2? Should we request something in writing from the university specifically documenting the tuition waiver amount and its tax-free status? 3. His program is 5 years, so we want to make sure we're setting him up for success long-term. Are there any common mistakes grad students make in years 2-5 that we should be aware of now? This community has been amazing - I feel so much more confident about helping him navigate this properly now. The tools mentioned (taxr.ai and Claimyr) sound like great backup options if we run into complications down the road.
Welcome to the community! Great questions - let me help with those follow-ups: 1. For the W-2 situation, most universities do withhold federal and state taxes from stipend payments, but often not enough. Grad student stipends are treated as regular wages, so they'll withhold based on standard tax tables, but they might not account for things like the standard deduction properly. I'd recommend having your son check his first few paystubs to see what's being withheld and compare it to what his actual tax liability might be. If it looks low, he can submit a new W-4 to increase withholding or make quarterly payments. 2. For record-keeping, definitely save: the W-2, any documentation about the tuition waiver (sometimes called a "tuition remission letter"), the 1098-T if the university sends one, and any official correspondence about his funding package. I'd also recommend taking screenshots of any online portals that show the funding breakdown, since these can disappear when systems change. 3. Common mistakes in later years include: not updating tax withholding when stipend amounts change, forgetting to report any summer funding that might be processed differently, and not keeping track of education-related expenses that could qualify for deductions. Also, if he switches from RA to TA or vice versa, the paperwork might change. You're being such a supportive parent by helping him get organized early!
One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet is the importance of understanding how summer funding might be handled differently. Many grad programs have different funding structures for summer months - sometimes it's research assistant wages (W-2), sometimes it's fellowship money (1099 or no form at all), and sometimes students are on their own to find funding. I learned this the hard way when my summer research stipend was processed as a fellowship rather than wages, which meant no taxes were withheld at all. I ended up with a surprise tax bill the following year because I wasn't prepared for the different treatment. If your son's program has summer funding, I'd recommend asking the graduate program coordinator or financial aid office specifically how summer stipends are classified and reported. This way you can plan ahead for any potential tax differences rather than being caught off guard later. Some students end up needing to make quarterly estimated payments during summer months if taxes aren't being withheld from fellowship-type funding. Also, international students have completely different tax rules that can be even more complex, but I'm assuming your son is a US citizen/resident based on your post. Just wanted to mention it in case it's relevant for anyone else reading this thread!
This is such an important point about summer funding! I wish I had known this when my daughter started her program. Her first summer she got what she thought was just a continuation of her regular stipend, but it turned out to be classified as a fellowship with zero tax withholding. We ended up scrambling to make estimated payments in the fall when we realized what had happened. One thing I'd add is to also ask about how conference travel funding and research expense reimbursements are handled. My daughter's program sometimes gives students money upfront for conferences (which might be taxable) versus reimbursing expenses after the fact (usually not taxable). The timing and classification can make a big difference come tax time. @185bf088fa41 For your son's 5-year program, I'd definitely recommend having him check with the graduate coordinator each year about any changes to funding structure, especially as he transitions from coursework to dissertation phases. Some programs change how they classify students once they advance to candidacy, which can affect the tax treatment of their funding.
Does anyone know if the IRS is still doing that first-time penalty abatement I've heard about? I'm in almost the identical situation (unfiled 2022-2023, self-employed) and wondering if that could help me?
Yes, First-Time Penalty Abatement (FTA) is still available! To qualify, you need to have: 1) No penalties for the 3 tax years prior to the year you're requesting abatement 2) Filed all currently required returns or filed extensions 3) Paid, or arranged to pay, any tax due The IRS doesn't advertise this program widely, but you should definitely request it after you file your past-due returns. It can wipe out the failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties for one tax year, which could save you thousands depending on how much you owe.
Victoria, I completely understand that crushing anxiety - I was in your exact shoes 18 months ago with unfiled returns from my freelance graphic design work. The panic attacks were real, but I promise you this is absolutely manageable. Here's your immediate action plan: **STEP 1:** Contact your bank ASAP and request detailed statements for 2022-2023. Most banks can provide up to 7 years of records. Also check any business banking apps, PayPal, Venmo, or Zelle for transaction histories. **STEP 2:** Reach out to clients you worked with during those years. Many will still have records of payments made to you, and some might even have copies of invoices you sent them. **STEP 3:** Check your email for ANY business-related correspondence - contract confirmations, payment notifications, expense receipts, travel bookings, etc. This can help reconstruct your business activities. **STEP 4:** File those returns IMMEDIATELY, even if incomplete. The failure-to-file penalty is much worse than failure-to-pay, and it stops accruing once you file. For penalties: You're likely looking at 5% per month (max 25%) for failure-to-file, plus 0.5% per month for failure-to-pay, plus interest. But if you qualify for first-time penalty abatement, you can get one year's penalties completely waived. The IRS has payment plan options if you can't pay everything at once. Don't let fear paralyze you - every day you wait, the penalties grow. You've got this!
Just to add some perspective - I work at an accounting firm and see this ALL THE TIME. Adjustments can go either way, but most commonly it's because: 1. You made a math error 2. You claimed a credit incorrectly 3. You reported withholding differently than what your employer reported 4. They applied an offset from another debt 5. They found additional income reported to them that wasn't on your return The good news is they're processing your return and you're getting at least some refund. The explanation letter will arrive eventually, but their system is crazy backed up so don't be surprised if it comes after your deposit.
From ur experience, are the adjustments usually in favor of the taxpayer or the state lol
Honestly? About 70% of the time it favors the state. But that's because people make mistakes that benefit themselves more often than mistakes that benefit the state. But I've seen plenty of adjustments where people get MORE money back too.
Don't stress too much about this! I've been through NYS tax adjustments multiple times and they're honestly pretty routine. The fact that you already have a deposit date scheduled is actually a good sign - it means they've finished reviewing your return and determined you're still getting money back. The most important thing is that you'll get that explanation letter before or around the time your refund hits. In my experience, common adjustments include simple math corrections, differences in reported income vs what employers submitted, or credits that needed verification. Sometimes the adjustment is even in your favor! Since you mentioned you're really anxious about it, you could try calling them directly if waiting for the letter is too stressful. But honestly, March 7th isn't that far away, and you'll likely have your answer soon. Try not to assume the worst - plenty of us have been in your shoes and it usually works out fine. Keep us posted on what the adjustment was once you find out! Good luck! π€
Thanks for the reassuring perspective! As someone new to dealing with tax adjustments, it's really helpful to hear from people who've been through this before. The waiting and not knowing is definitely the worst part. I'm trying to stay optimistic that it might even be good news, but my anxiety brain keeps assuming the worst case scenario. I'll definitely update everyone once I get that letter or the deposit comes through. This community has been so helpful in calming my nerves about the whole situation! π
Has anyone actually been audited over 1099-K stuff for selling personal items? I'm in a similar boat with some sports memorabilia I sold last year. My understanding is that personal items sold at a loss aren't even supposed to be reported - like if you sell your old laptop for less than you paid, that's not income or a deductible loss.
That's mostly correct, but the problem is the 1099-K makes it look like income to the IRS. If you don't report it at all, they'll send you a letter asking why the amount on your 1099-K isn't on your return. Better to report it on Schedule D showing zero gain or a loss (even though personal losses aren't deductible) than to ignore it completely.
I'm dealing with a very similar situation with Pokemon cards I sold last year! Got a 1099-K for about $8K but definitely sold at a loss overall. One thing that helped me was creating a spreadsheet breaking down my collection by era and card type - I used a combination of PSA population reports and old price guides from when I originally bought the cards (many from the late 90s/early 2000s). For cards I couldn't find specific historical data on, I used the "replacement cost method" - basically what it would have cost to buy similar condition cards at the time I purchased them. I kept screenshots and printed documentation of everything I used as sources. The key thing my tax preparer told me was that the IRS expects "reasonable effort" not perfection, especially for collectibles purchased over many years. As long as you can show you made a good faith attempt to establish your basis using available data, you should be fine. Don't let the 1099-K stress you out too much - it's just a reporting document, not a tax bill!
This is really reassuring to hear from someone who went through the same process! The "replacement cost method" sounds like a smart approach - I never thought about using PSA population reports as documentation. Did your tax preparer give you any specific guidance on how detailed the spreadsheet needed to be? I'm wondering if I should break things down by individual sets or if broader categories would be sufficient. Also, when you say "reasonable effort," do you have a sense of what that actually means in practice? Like is there a minimum amount of documentation the IRS would expect to see? I'm definitely feeling less stressed about this after reading everyone's responses. It's good to know I'm not the only one dealing with this 1099-K situation!
Emma Davis
Don't forget to call the IRS after sending important faxes to confirm they received them! I learned this the hard way when I faxed my offer in compromise docs and assumed they got them, only to find out 2 months later they had no record of receiving anything. Now I always follow up with a call about a week after sending anything critical.
0 coins
Tasia Synder
Great advice from everyone here! I'd also add that if you're sending time-sensitive documents like amended returns or payment agreements, consider sending them through multiple channels (fax AND certified mail) for extra security. I've had situations where the IRS received one but not the other, and having both methods gave me backup proof of timely filing. Also, always keep your fax confirmation receipts - I scan mine and save them digitally with my tax files. The IRS can be slow to update their systems, so even if they received your fax, it might not show up in their records for several weeks when you call to check. One more tip: if you're faxing forms that require signatures, make sure your signatures are dark and clear on the scanned document. Light or blurry signatures can cause processing delays.
0 coins
StarStrider
β’This is excellent advice! I'm dealing with my first amended return and was planning to just fax it, but sending through both channels makes so much sense for peace of mind. Quick question - when you send through both methods, do you need to include any special notation on the documents to indicate you're submitting via multiple channels? I don't want to accidentally create duplicate processing issues with the IRS.
0 coins