


Ask the community...
Has anyone here dealt with making an S corp election for an existing LLC? My situation sounds similar to the OP's. I've been operating as a single-member LLC and thinking about the S corp election for 2025, but I'm confused about what happens to my LLC's EIN and bank accounts.
When you elect S corp status for an existing LLC, you keep the same EIN and bank accounts - nothing changes there. It's just a tax election, not a new legal entity. Your LLC legally remains the same entity, but it's just taxed differently. This is actually one of the benefits of the LLC with S corp election route versus forming an actual S corporation - you don't have to change your bank accounts, contracts, etc. You'll just start running payroll for yourself and separating distributions from salary once the election is effective.
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now! My CPA told me the same thing about waiting until March 2026, but after reading all these responses, I'm pretty sure there's been a miscommunication. It sounds like your CPA might be confusing the S corp tax filing deadline (March 15, 2026 for 2025 taxes) with the actual election deadline (March 15, 2025 for 2025 tax year). I'd definitely recommend getting clarification on this ASAP. The difference between filing the election in March 2025 vs March 2026 is huge - it's literally the difference between getting S corp tax treatment for 2025 or having to wait until 2026. That could mean thousands of dollars in tax savings lost if you miss the deadline. Also, from what I understand, you absolutely need the S corp election in place before you start taking distributions. Operating as an S corp without having filed the election could create some serious tax complications down the road.
5 Has anyone actually compared standard mileage vs MACRS over a 5 year period? I'm curious what the total deduction difference would be over the typical ownership period of a vehicle.
16 I did the math for my landscaping business with a $38K truck driven about 28,000 business miles annually. Over 5 years: - Standard mileage: roughly $83,000 in total deductions - Actual expenses w/MACRS: about $79,000 in total deductions Standard mileage won, but just barely. The big difference was maintenance - my truck needs minimal repairs in the first 5 years. If you have higher maintenance or insurance costs, actual expenses might win.
This is really helpful analysis! I'm in a similar situation with high business mileage and was leaning toward MACRS thinking it would automatically be better. Your 5-year comparison is eye-opening - I never thought to calculate the total deductions over the full ownership period. One thing I'm still confused about though - if I choose standard mileage this year, am I locked into that method for the life of the vehicle? Or can I switch to actual expenses with MACRS in future years if my situation changes (like if maintenance costs spike or I start driving fewer business miles)? Also, does the standard mileage rate typically increase each year with inflation? I'm wondering if that factors into the long-term calculation at all.
I'm in the same boat with Lyft too! I just use the annual summary from the driver portal for my taxes. My tax guy said it's totally fine to use that instead of an official 1099. Just make sure you're tracking your mileage with an app throughout the year cause that's where the big deductions are!
TurboTax has an import feature that can pull info directly from Uber and Lyft even without a 1099. Made it really easy for me last year. Way better than manually entering everything!
This is such a frustrating situation that so many gig workers are dealing with! I had the same issue with Uber last year - made about $8,500 and got absolutely nothing from them while other platforms sent forms for much smaller amounts. After reading through all these comments, I think the key takeaway is that while it's annoying, we're not actually missing out on anything tax-wise. The IRS cares about accurate income reporting, not whether you have a piece of paper. I ended up using my Uber annual summary along with my bank deposit records to file my taxes. What really helped me was setting up a separate checking account just for gig work deposits. That way I had a clean paper trail of all my earnings throughout the year, regardless of which companies sent forms and which didn't. Makes tax time way less stressful when you're not scrambling to piece together income from different apps with different reporting methods. For anyone still dealing with this - don't waste hours on the phone with Uber support like I did. Just download your annual summary, track your mileage religiously, and move on with filing your taxes!
That's really smart advice about the separate checking account! I wish I had thought of that earlier. I'm dealing with this exact situation right now and it's been such a headache trying to reconcile all my different gig income sources. One thing I learned from calling the IRS (through that Claimyr service someone mentioned) is that they actually prefer when taxpayers keep detailed records like you're describing, even more than just having the 1099 forms. The agent told me that having bank records, mileage logs, and expense receipts is way more valuable for an audit than just having the basic 1099 info. I'm definitely setting up that separate account for this year. Thanks for sharing what worked for you!
One thing nobody has mentioned that helped me with my cattery taxes: Track your mileage for ANYTHING business related - vet visits, supply runs, cat shows, picking up new breeding stock, etc. This ends up being a surprisingly large deduction! Also, if you're using part of your home exclusively for the cattery business (like a dedicated cat room or nursery space), you can take the home office deduction. Make sure to measure the square footage accurately. And definitely keep photos of all your cats with their names, registration papers, and purchase prices organized. The one year I got audited, having detailed records with photos for each animal saved me thousands.
The mileage tracking is a great tip! Do you use any particular app to track it, or just keep a manual log? And for the home office deduction - my cattery actually takes up about 40% of my home (dedicated breeding rooms, nursery, etc.). Is there a limit to how much of your home you can claim for business use?
I use MileIQ app for tracking - it automatically logs all my drives and I just swipe right for business trips. Super easy and worth the subscription fee since it saves me hours of manual logging. For home office space, there's no specific percentage limit, but larger percentages might increase audit risk. The key is that the space must be used EXCLUSIVELY for your business. If your cattery truly uses 40% of your home exclusively for the business, you can claim it, but make sure you have good documentation - take photos of the spaces, have a floor plan with measurements, and keep records of business activities that happen in those areas. If you ever get audited, you'll need to prove that those spaces are used solely for the cattery.
Another cattery owner here! Just wanted to add that how you handle your breeding cats can have big implications for years to come. If you treat them as capital assets and depreciate them, you'll need to report gain/loss when you "retire" them from breeding. I learned this the hard way when I rehomed some of my retired breeders. Had to report the difference between their depreciated value and what I got for them. My accountant said I should have been tracking each cat's "adjusted basis" all along! Also, consider Section 179 expensing for some of your larger equipment purchases (like specialty cages, air purification systems, etc.) instead of depreciating them - might give you a bigger deduction upfront.
This is really important! I've been breeding Maine Coons for 6 years and the tax implications of retiring breeding stock can be significant. Do you need to track the depreciation individually for each cat, or can you group them together as a single asset class?
You typically need to track depreciation individually for each breeding cat since they're separate assets with different acquisition dates and costs. Each cat should have its own depreciation schedule based on when you acquired it and its cost basis. When you retire a breeding cat, you'll need to know that specific cat's adjusted basis (original cost minus accumulated depreciation) to calculate any gain or loss on disposal. If you group them together, it becomes much harder to track this accurately for tax purposes. I'd recommend setting up a simple spreadsheet with columns for each cat's name/ID, acquisition date, original cost, annual depreciation, and accumulated depreciation. This makes it easy to calculate the adjusted basis when you need to retire or rehome any of them. Your accountant will thank you for having these records organized!
Monique Byrd
Just to be super clear here - there are TWO separate tax issues that might be getting confused: 1. SALES TAX - This is collected by sellers from buyers and remitted to state tax authorities. Individual casual sellers typically don't need to collect this unless they're running a business. 2. INCOME TAX - This is what the seller pays on their earnings. PayPal now reports transactions to the IRS on Form 1099-K if you receive more than $600 in a year, and the seller might need to pay income tax on their earnings. It sounds like your seller is confused and is trying to make you pay for their potential income tax obligations, which is NOT how it works! They can't pass their income tax burden onto you by calling it "sales tax.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
ā¢This makes so much sense! I think the seller is definitely confused about which type of tax they're responsible for. Thank you for breaking it down so clearly.
0 coins
StarSurfer
This is a classic case of seller confusion about tax obligations. Based on what you've described, you should NOT pay any additional money. Here's why: The seller is mixing up income tax reporting with sales tax collection. When PayPal reports transactions to the IRS via Form 1099-K (for sellers who receive over $600/year), that's for INCOME tax purposes - meaning the seller might owe income tax on their earnings. This is completely separate from sales tax. For sales tax, individual sellers doing occasional transactions typically don't need to collect it unless they're operating as a registered business. Even if sales tax were required, it should have been included in the original invoice - not requested after payment. The seller's tax obligations (whether income tax or sales tax) are their responsibility, not yours. You paid the agreed-upon amount on a properly processed invoice. If they made an error in their invoice calculation or are now worried about their tax reporting requirements, that's their problem to solve, not yours to fund. I'd politely decline their request for additional payment and explain that any tax obligations they have are separate from the transaction you already completed in full.
0 coins