


Ask the community...
I just want to point out that just because you're reinvesting profits back into the business doesn't mean you're not making a taxable profit. The IRS doesn't see "reinvestment" as an expense category that reduces your tax liability (with some exceptions like qualified retirement plans). For example, if you make $100K in revenue and have $60K in deductible expenses, you have $40K in taxable profit - even if you use that entire $40K to buy more inventory or equipment for next year. Some of those reinvestments might be immediately deductible, others might have to be depreciated over time.
This is what confused me at first too! I thought if I never "took money out" of my business I wouldn't owe taxes. Learned the hard way that the IRS doesn't care if the money stays in your business account - they care about the difference between income and deductible expenses.
Thanks everyone for all the amazing advice! I think I understand better now. So even if I physically keep all the money in my business account, I'll still owe taxes on the profit (revenue minus deductible expenses). And not all "reinvestments" count as immediate deductions - some have to be depreciated over years. I'm going to look more carefully at what types of business expenses I'm planning and see which ones are fully deductible now versus depreciated. Sounds like I should probably keep tracking my 30% savings based on profit rather than revenue, which will free up more cash for growth. And I definitely need to get those quarterly payments set up correctly!
Great thread! One thing I'd add that really helped me as a new LLC owner is to track your effective tax rate quarterly. Once you have a few quarters of data, you'll get a much better sense of your actual tax burden rather than relying on generic percentages. I use a simple spreadsheet where I track quarterly profit, estimated taxes owed (including self-employment tax), and my effective rate. This has been super helpful for cash flow planning because I can see seasonal patterns in my business and adjust my savings accordingly. Also, consider opening a separate savings account specifically for tax withholding. I automatically transfer my estimated tax percentage there every time I get paid, so I'm never tempted to spend that money. When quarterly payments are due, the money is already set aside and earning a bit of interest while it waits.
Has anyone ever successfully fought a fringe benefit tax? My company is taxing us for the free lunches they provide in the office which seems ridiculous since I'm basically working through lunch anyway.
You probably can't "fight" it because the IRS is clear that meals provided for the "convenience of the employer" are taxable unless they meet specific criteria. However, your company could potentially reclassify the meals if they're truly for business purposes. If your workplace doesn't have sufficient eating facilities nearby, or if you're genuinely required to stay on premises for work reasons during meals, they might qualify as non-taxable. Worth asking your HR to review the policy.
I see a lot of great explanations here, but I wanted to add one more possibility that might help explain your situation. Sometimes employers will have a "true-up" or catch-up process for fringe benefits that happens at year-end or after annual enrollment periods. For example, if you enrolled in benefits mid-year, or if there was an error in how your benefits were being calculated throughout the year, your employer might need to correct the tax withholding with a one-time adjustment. This could explain why you're seeing it as a single deduction rather than ongoing monthly taxes. I'd definitely recommend checking with your HR department about the specific benefit this relates to, and ask them to provide documentation showing how the taxable amount was calculated. They should be able to give you a clear breakdown - it's not something you should have to guess about on your paycheck. Also worth noting that if this is related to a significant fringe benefit (like a large life insurance policy or company car), make sure you're prepared for it to potentially show up on your W-2 as additional income when tax season comes around.
This is really helpful context! I hadn't considered that it might be a year-end adjustment. Now that I think about it, I did start this job in August, so maybe they're catching up on something from when I enrolled mid-year. The timing makes sense too - it's January and they might be doing their annual reconciliation of benefits before issuing W-2s. I'll definitely reach out to HR for that breakdown you mentioned. Thanks for pointing out that this could show up on my W-2 as additional income - I want to make sure I'm prepared for that when I file my taxes. Do you happen to know if there's a deadline for when employers have to correct these kinds of benefit tax calculations? I'm wondering if other companies I worked for just handled it differently or if this is something new.
Just want to echo what others have said - you're definitely not alone in this situation! I made the same mistake for 3 years before realizing Form 8606 was required for non-deductible contributions. One thing I learned the hard way is to double-check that your IRA custodian has accurate records of which contributions were deductible vs. non-deductible. When I was preparing my backdated 8606 forms, I discovered that my investment company's records weren't clear about the deductible status of some contributions, which could have caused problems down the road. I'd recommend calling your husband's IRA provider and asking them to clearly mark in their system which contributions were non-deductible for each year. This will make future distributions much smoother and help avoid any confusion about your basis. Also, once you get all the forms filed, keep copies somewhere safe along with documentation of the contributions. When retirement time comes, you'll be grateful to have everything organized!
This is such great advice about checking with the IRA custodian! I never thought about making sure their records match what we're reporting on the 8606 forms. That could definitely cause headaches later when it comes time for distributions. One question - when you called your investment company, did they update their records immediately or did you need to send them copies of the filed 8606 forms as proof? I'm wondering if we should wait until after we file the forms with the IRS before contacting our husband's IRA provider, or if we can get them to update their records now based on what we're about to file. Also, did your provider charge any fees for updating the records or was it just a matter of calling customer service?
I just went through this exact same situation last month! Had 4 years of missing 8606 forms for my wife's non-deductible IRA contributions. Here's what I learned from the process: **The filing approach everyone mentioned is correct** - you need separate 8606 forms for each year. I initially tried to combine them and it would have been a disaster for tracking basis properly. **One tip I haven't seen mentioned yet:** When you're filling out the forms, pay special attention to Part I, Line 14 on each form. This is where you report your total basis, and it should increase cumulatively each year. So if you contributed $6,000 in 2019, that's your basis for 2019. Then if you contributed another $6,000 in 2020, your basis on the 2020 form should show $12,000, and so on. **The IRS was actually pretty reasonable** - I included a cover letter explaining the oversight and requesting penalty waiver for "reasonable cause." Got no pushback and no penalties assessed. **Pro tip:** I created a simple spreadsheet tracking each year's contribution and cumulative basis before filling out the forms. Made the whole process much less stressful and helped me catch a calculation error before sending everything in. You're doing the right thing by fixing this proactively. The peace of mind is worth the effort!
This spreadsheet idea is brilliant! I'm actually dealing with this exact situation right now and was getting overwhelmed trying to keep track of all the numbers across multiple years. Creating a simple tracker with each year's contribution and running basis total would definitely help me avoid mistakes. Quick question about the cumulative basis calculation - when you say Line 14 should show the total basis increasing each year, does that mean if I had $6,000 in 2019, $6,000 in 2020, and $6,000 in 2021, then my 2021 Form 8606 Line 14 would show $18,000? I want to make sure I understand this correctly before I start filling out the forms. Also, did you send all the forms at once or file them separately? I'm torn between getting it all done in one mailing versus spacing them out to avoid overwhelming whoever processes them at the IRS.
Has anyone used an electric vehicle for business? I'm considering getting a Chevy Bolt for my business, and I'm wondering if there are additional tax benefits beyond the regular vehicle deductions. From what I understand, there's still the $7,500 tax credit for some EVs, but I'm not sure how that interacts with business use deductions.
Yes! EVs have some great tax advantages. The $7,500 EV credit applies regardless of whether it's for business or personal use. For business use, you can still claim either standard mileage or actual expenses deductions on top of the credit. One significant advantage of EVs for business: lower operating costs. If you use the actual expense method, your "fuel" costs will be much lower, but you'll still get to deduct the business percentage of higher depreciation, insurance, and the interest on any loan. Just remember if you claim the EV credit, your depreciation basis is reduced by the amount of the credit if using actual expenses.
Great thread everyone! As someone who just went through this process with my marketing consultancy, I wanted to add a few practical tips that helped me maximize my deduction for my Subaru Outback (definitely under 6,000 lbs). First, start tracking your mileage NOW if you haven't already - even if you're still shopping for the vehicle. Use a smartphone app or simple logbook to record business trips. The IRS expects contemporaneous records, not reconstructed logs. Second, consider your long-term business plans. If you expect your business mileage to increase significantly, the standard mileage rate might be better. If your mileage will stay consistent but you're buying a more expensive vehicle, actual expenses could work better. Finally, don't overlook the home office deduction connection. If you have a qualifying home office, trips from your home office to client meetings are fully deductible business miles. This can really add up over the year and make either deduction method more valuable. The key is running the numbers for YOUR specific situation rather than following general rules. Every business is different!
Sean Kelly
Just a quick warning - be careful with daycares that shut down suddenly like this. We had a similar situation and it turned out the owner was being investigated for tax fraud. Make sure you keep ALL your receipts and documentation showing you paid them. If they weren't reporting income or paying taxes, there's a small chance this could come back to haunt you if there's ever an investigation.
0 coins
Zara Malik
ā¢Oh no, that sounds scary. Did you end up having any issues with your own taxes after that happened? I'm in a similar boat with a daycare that just vanished overnight.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now! My son's daycare also disappeared suddenly in the middle of the year, and I was panicking about Form 2441. After reading through all these comments, I feel much more confident about how to handle it. A few things I learned from my research that might help others: 1. The IRS Publication 503 specifically mentions situations where providers refuse to give tax information or can't be contacted. You're not penalized for their non-compliance. 2. I found that some states maintain databases of licensed childcare providers that include tax ID information. It's worth checking your state's Department of Human Services or similar agency website. 3. If you paid by check or credit card, those records can serve as additional documentation of legitimate childcare expenses, especially if the provider's bank information is visible. The most important thing I learned is that the IRS cares more about whether you actually had legitimate childcare expenses than tracking down every provider's tax information. As long as you document your reasonable efforts to obtain the information and report what you have, you should be fine. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences - it really helped reduce my stress about this whole situation!
0 coins