


Ask the community...
has anyone actually had an audit after filing as a resident alien with treaty benefits? im nervous about claiming the treaty exemption and then getting flagged for an audit. is there anything specific i should document just in case?
I went through this exact same situation two years ago and it was incredibly stressful! One thing that really helped me was keeping detailed records of everything - not just for potential audits, but to make sure I was filing correctly. Since you mentioned you're in your 6th year on F-1, you're definitely correct about being a resident alien. Just make sure you have documentation showing your entry dates and status changes. I kept copies of all my I-94 records, passport stamps, and previous tax returns. For the 1042-S treaty benefits, the key is making sure you report the income AND claim the exemption properly. Don't try to hide the income - that's what gets people in trouble. Report it all transparently and let the treaty exemption do its job. One last tip: if you're still nervous about getting it right, consider having a tax professional review your return before filing, especially for your first year as a resident alien. It's a small cost for big peace of mind!
Has anyone else had weird issues with FreeTaxUSA this year? I used them for the first time and noticed some glitches in their system. My state payment went through instantly but the federal one took almost 2 weeks to hit my bank account, and the IRS website showed no record of my return for about 10 days.
I completely understand your panic - I went through the exact same thing last year! The key thing to remember is that "accepted" and "processed" are two different steps. When FreeTaxUSA says your return was accepted, it means the IRS received it and it passed their initial validation checks. The full processing (which updates your account balance and payment obligations) can take up to 21 days during busy season. For your immediate concerns: 1) Check your FreeTaxUSA account dashboard - it should show confirmation numbers for both your federal and state filings, 2) Your state payment delay is normal - ACH transfers can take 3-5 business days to appear, and 3) Don't worry about penalties since you filed before the deadline. If you're still anxious after a week and want to verify everything is in order, you can request your tax transcript from the IRS website (irs.gov/individuals/get-transcript) - this will show if your return is actually in their system even before it appears on the regular "Where's My Refund" tool. You did everything right by filing on time. The system is just slow during peak season!
This is really helpful advice! I'm in a similar situation as the original poster and was starting to worry something went wrong with my filing. The distinction between "accepted" and "processed" makes so much sense now - I was wondering why the IRS website wasn't showing my balance yet even though I got confirmation emails. Quick question about the tax transcript - is that something I can access immediately after filing, or do I need to wait for processing to complete? I'd love to have that extra peace of mind that my return is actually in their system. Thanks for breaking this down so clearly!
You can actually access your tax transcript pretty quickly after filing! In most cases, it shows up within 1-2 weeks of the IRS accepting your return, which is much faster than the full processing timeline. To get it, go to irs.gov/individuals/get-transcript and choose "Get Transcript Online." You'll need to verify your identity, but once you're in, look for your "Record of Account Transcript" for the current tax year. This will show all the transaction codes and dates related to your return, even if it hasn't fully processed yet. The transcript is actually more detailed than the regular "Where's My Refund" tool and will give you a much clearer picture of exactly where your return stands in the system. If your return was truly accepted, you should see entries showing when it was received and initial processing steps, even before your balance appears on the main IRS website.
22 Can someone explain what happens with the depreciation you've taken when you sell at a loss? I know if you sell at a gain, there's depreciation recapture, but what if you're already taking a loss?
This is a really comprehensive discussion about converted rental properties! I'm dealing with a similar situation where I converted my primary residence to a rental in 2021. One thing I'd add is that you should also keep detailed records of any improvements you made to the property both before and after conversion. Capital improvements made while it was your primary residence get added to your original basis, while improvements made after conversion to rental property are treated differently - they create separate depreciable assets with their own recovery periods. This can actually help reduce your taxable loss or increase your deductible loss depending on the timing. Also, don't forget about the home office deduction if you used part of your primary residence for business before converting it - that creates yet another layer of complexity in the basis calculations. I learned this the hard way when preparing my taxes last year!
Great point about keeping detailed improvement records! I hadn't thought about the timing difference between improvements made as a primary residence versus as a rental. Do you know if there's a specific form or worksheet that helps track all these different basis adjustments? Also, regarding the home office deduction - does that mean if I had a home office while living there, I would have already been depreciating part of the house, which would complicate the conversion basis calculation even more?
I used to be a bartender and now I do tax prep, and I see this issue from both sides. From the venue perspective, we had several "social media influencers" who would come in and drink while filming. The IRS would definitely consider this a legitimate business expense IF (big if) you're actually generating revenue from these streams. The test is: would a reasonable businessperson in your industry consider this an ordinary and necessary expense? For nightlife content? Absolutely yes.
What about the fact that he's personally consuming the alcohol though? Doesn't that make it partially personal by definition? Like if I buy a camera for my photography business but also use it for family photos, I have to allocate the expense.
That's a great point about the personal consumption aspect. However, I think the key difference here is that @Jabari-Jo explicitly stated they NEVER go to bars for personal reasons and only consume alcohol when actively working on streams. This creates a much cleaner business-only use case than your camera example. If you can demonstrate that 100% of the alcohol consumption is for business content creation (which seems to be the case based on their description), then there's no personal use allocation needed. It's more like an actor drinking prop alcohol during a scene - the consumption is part of the business activity, not personal enjoyment. The documentation will be crucial though. Each purchase should clearly tie to a specific stream/content piece to prove the business purpose.
This is a fascinating tax situation that highlights how modern content creation businesses push the boundaries of traditional tax categories. Based on what you've described, I believe you have a strong case for deducting these expenses. The critical factor here is that the alcohol serves a legitimate business purpose - it's essentially a required element of your content, similar to how a food blogger needs to purchase ingredients or a makeup artist needs cosmetics. Since you've stated that you never visit these establishments for personal reasons and only consume alcohol while creating content, you've established clear business purpose. I'd recommend treating these as "production costs" or "content creation materials" rather than meals & entertainment to avoid the 50% limitation. However, be prepared with rock-solid documentation: detailed receipts, stream links, business purpose notes, and ideally separate business payment methods. One thing to consider - since this represents $8,000 annually, you might want to consult with a tax professional who has experience with content creator businesses before filing. The unique nature of your business model means you want to ensure you're categorizing everything correctly to minimize audit risk while maximizing legitimate deductions. The fact that you've been conservative for 3 years actually works in your favor - it shows you're not trying to push questionable deductions, just properly claiming legitimate business expenses as you've learned more about tax law.
This is really helpful analysis! I'm curious though - when you mention consulting with a tax professional who has experience with content creators, how do you find someone like that? Most CPAs I've talked to seem confused by the unique aspects of livestreaming/content creation businesses. Are there specific credentials or specializations to look for? Also, regarding the separate business payment methods - would using a dedicated business credit card for all stream-related expenses be sufficient, or should I be doing something more formal like setting up an LLC?
Victoria Stark
Has anybody used QuickBooks Self-Employed for tracking business vs personal expenses? I'm a sole proprietor too and get confused about what counts as business vs personal. Last year I just guessed and probably left money on the table.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
β’I've been using QB Self-Employed for about 3 years now. It's pretty decent for the basics - you can swipe left/right to categorize transactions as business or personal, and it automatically calculates your estimated quarterly tax payments. The receipt scanner is handy for keeping track of business expenses too. It won't help with the entity selection question though - for that you really need a tax pro or something like that taxr.ai service others mentioned. But for day-to-day tracking as a sole prop, it works well.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
β’Thanks for the recommendation! That sounds exactly like what I need right now. I'm spending way too much time trying to separate all my expenses manually, and I'm sure I'm missing deductions. I'll definitely check it out.
0 coins
Ingrid Larsson
Just wanted to chime in as someone who went through this exact decision process last year with my consulting business. The key thing that helped me decide was getting clear on my actual numbers and goals. As others mentioned, you're right at that threshold where an S-corp election might make sense financially. But beyond just the tax savings, consider the administrative overhead - you'll need to run payroll (even for yourself), file additional returns, and maintain more formal records. One thing I didn't see mentioned is that you can actually elect S-corp status for an LLC, which gives you the tax benefits without some of the corporate formalities. This might be a middle ground worth exploring. For your furniture business specifically, also consider liability protection. As a sole prop, your personal assets are at risk if something goes wrong with your products. An LLC (even without S-corp election) would give you that protection layer. My recommendation would be to run the actual numbers for your situation - either with a tax pro or using one of the tools mentioned here - before making any changes. The "right" answer really depends on your specific income level, expenses, and business goals.
0 coins
GalacticGuardian
β’This is really helpful advice, especially the point about LLC with S-corp election - I hadn't heard of that option before! The liability protection aspect is something I definitely need to consider more seriously. I've been so focused on the tax implications that I kind of overlooked the fact that if someone gets hurt by one of my custom furniture pieces, I could be personally liable for everything I own. That's honestly pretty scary when I think about it. Do you happen to know if the LLC with S-corp election is significantly more complicated than just a regular LLC? And roughly what kind of additional costs should I budget for if I go that route?
0 coins