Will I have to pay back unemployment if I quit my job? California EDD situation
So I put in my two weeks at my retail job last month because I genuinely couldn't take the conditions anymore - my manager had been cutting my hours down to almost nothing and then when I did come in, the environment was just hostile and I was constantly being written up for stuff that made no sense. I ended up quitting instead of waiting to see if they'd eventually just fire me. Now I'm realizing I actually need money because finding a new job is taking way longer than I expected. I filed a California EDD unemployment claim about two weeks ago and I'm sitting here wondering if I even had any right to do that in the first place. My biggest fear is getting approved, spending those benefits, and then having EDD come back later and say I owe it all back. Does quitting mean EDD will automatically deny me? Or if they do pay me and then decide later I shouldn't have gotten it, will I have to pay back unemployment if I quit my job and they change their mind? I'm scared to even certify again because what if that makes the overpayment worse. Someone please help me understand how this actually works.
93 comments

Axel Far
Retail hours getting slashed and then a hostile write-up situation - my layoff looked cleaner on paper but EDD still put a hold on three weeks while they sorted out some question about my separation. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live person at EDD on the phone after messages through UI Online kept going unanswered. The agent pulled up my claim, told me exactly which weeks were showing pending and that the hold was tied to a document EDD hadn't processed yet - I mailed it in the same day and the weeks cleared about a week later. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what that looks like before you try it.
0 coins
Jasmine Hernandez
Which document did EDD say was missing? I'm dealing with something similar and I don't even know what I'm supposed to send them.
0 coins
Axel Far
The agent said it was an identity document - the DE 1326C. If your pending weeks are from a different issue, your document might be something else entirely. That's why talking to a live person matters, they can actually see what your specific hold is.
0 coins
Luis Johnson
Pending weeks are so stressful because UI Online gives you nothing to go on. Just says Pending and you're left guessing.
0 coins
Ellie Kim
Quitting doesn't automatically disqualify you in California - that's the thing most people don't realize until they're already in a panic about it. EDD's rule is that if you quit, you have to show you had a good reason tied to the job. The hostile write-ups and the manager cutting your hours are exactly the kinds of things EDD looks at. Neither of those means you'll automatically get paid, but it's not an automatic no either.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorBut what actually counts as a good reason to them? Like how does EDD decide that?
0 coins
Ellie Kim
They schedule a phone interview and hear from both you and your former employer. The notice EDD sends you - it's called the DE 4800 - has the date and time the interviewer phones. You answer, you tell your side, your employer tells theirs, and EDD makes the call after that. No one can promise you an outcome ahead of that.
0 coins
Fiona Sand
What happens if you miss that interview though? I'm always at work during business hours now and terrified I'll miss it.
0 coins
Ellie Kim
Miss it and you should phone EDD at 1-800-300-5616 that same day - seriously, same day matters. If you just let it slide, EDD will decide from whatever they already have, and that usually isn't good for the claimant side of things.
0 coins
Mohammad Khaled
Had the same spiral of terror when I quit my last job. What finally clicked for me was understanding the difference between getting denied upfront versus getting paid and then getting an overpayment notice later. If EDD decides you didn't have good cause to quit, they send you a Notice of Determination - that's the DE 1080CZ - and it comes with an Appeal Form. That's the denial. At that point nothing has been paid out yet that you'd owe back. The overpayment situation is different and scarier, but it usually comes up when someone got paid, then EDD goes back and finds something that was misreported.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorSo if I get the denial notice before they ever pay me, I wouldn't owe anything yet?
0 coins
Mohammad Khaled
Right. The Notice of Determination is EDD's eligibility decision. If they say no before cutting you any checks, there's nothing paid to pay back. The appeal window on that notice is 30 days from the mailing date, so read the date on the envelope.
0 coins
Alina Rosenthal
This is a really important distinction that gets lost in a lot of posts about quitting. The overpayment fear is real but it's usually about misreporting wages or fraud, not about EDD reconsidering a quit case out of nowhere after they already paid.
0 coins
Finnegan Gunn
Keep certifying while everything is pending - stopping is one of the worst moves you can make right now. Even if the interview hasn't happened yet, certified weeks create a record of what you're owed if EDD eventually decides in your favor. Stopped certifying during my own adjudication because I thought I was going to get denied anyway, and when they came back with an approval I had a gap of uncertified weeks that just couldn't be recovered. Those weeks were gone.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorEven during the phone interview adjudication period I should keep certifying?
0 coins
Finnegan Gunn
Especially then. EDD can only pay weeks that have been certified - they can't go back and pay weeks you never submitted. File them, keep your work search going, and wait for the determination.
0 coins
Miguel Harvey
This is news to me. I thought you weren't supposed to certify until EDD said you were eligible. Where does it say to keep certifying during this?
0 coins
Finnegan Gunn
EDD's own guidance says to keep certifying. The payments just stay pending while the eligibility question is open. Once it's resolved in your favor, those certified weeks get paid. If you stop, there's no record for them to pay even if they decide you qualified.
0 coins
Ashley Simian
My hours also got cut before I finally left my last job, and I went through the same question spiral you're going through. What I didn't understand at first was that EDD is not just looking at whether you quit - they look at whether staying was reasonable. Hours cut to almost nothing while still being written up for things that don't make sense? That's the kind of situation worth explaining in detail during the phone interview. Write down everything you remember, dates, what was said, what your hours were before and after. The interviewer is going to ask specifics.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorShould I have any kind of documentation ready or is just my word going to be enough?
0 coins
Ashley Simian
Any pay stubs showing the hour reduction are helpful. Texts or emails if you kept any. It's not a court case but concrete things help your account hold up better when your employer gives their version.
0 coins
Oliver Cheng
The employer's side matters too - EDD will contact them. If your employer claims the write-ups were legitimate performance issues they can make a case for misconduct on your end, so being detailed and factual about what actually happened matters a lot.
0 coins
Taylor To
Can I ask a dumb question here - is an overpayment the same thing as getting penalized for fraud? Because I keep seeing those two things in the same conversations and I honestly can't tell if overpayment automatically means EDD thinks you lied.
0 coins
Mohammad Khaled
Not the same at all. An overpayment just means EDD paid more than they think you were entitled to - it can happen without any fraud at all, like a miscalculated wage report or a retroactive decision. Non-fraud overpayments still have to be paid back but there's no penalty on top. Fraud is when EDD finds you gave false information or deliberately hid something - that gets a 30 percent penalty added to whatever you owe.
0 coins
Taylor To
Okay so quitting and getting paid before EDD makes a decision wouldn't automatically be fraud, even if they then deny me after the fact?
0 coins
Mohammad Khaled
Correct. If you answered the certification questions honestly about being available for work and looking for work, and EDD later decides you didn't have good cause to quit, that's a determination issue - not fraud. The fraud territory is when someone lies on their certification or conceals something deliberately.
0 coins
Fiona Sand
This thread is clarifying things I've been confused about for weeks. The word fraud gets thrown around so casually by people who don't know the difference.
0 coins
Ella Cofer
DE 429Z came in the mail about two weeks after I filed, which is the notice that shows what my weekly benefit amount would be if EDD decides I qualify. At the time I thought receiving that meant I was approved - I actually told my roommate I got approved. Someone on another forum corrected me and explained that document just shows the potential payment amount, not an eligibility decision. Getting that notice doesn't mean EDD has decided anything about your quit situation yet. The interview still happens after that.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorWait, so the DE 429Z isn't an approval letter?
0 coins
Ella Cofer
Not at all. It's the award calculation - what your weekly amount would be based on your earnings. The eligibility decision for why you left comes separately after the phone interview. I genuinely confused the two and spent a week thinking I was fine.
0 coins
Kevin Bell
This exact confusion tripped me up too. The form shows up and looks official and it's easy to assume it means something it doesn't. The adjudication of the quit reason is a whole separate process from calculating what you'd receive if you qualify.
0 coins
Savannah Glover
Severance and quit situations both held my claim up at the same time, which made everything twice as confusing. EDD's rules around severance were something I genuinely needed clarified by an actual agent, so I ended up reaching EDD through Claimyr and asking directly. The agent confirmed that my severance was paid under my company's standard separation policy, looked at the notes on my file, and told me EDD had it documented - what was still open was the quit reason interview, which had its own separate queue. Knowing those were two different issues helped me stop panicking that the severance was making things worse.
0 coins
Taylor To
Severance added into the mix sounds incredibly stressful. Did the agent say anything about how the severance would affect what you'd actually get paid weekly?
0 coins
Savannah Glover
They said it was on my file and that EDD had it, but the actual decision on how it affects payment was something EDD determines - the agent wouldn't give a number or a prediction, just confirmed they had the documentation. The interview for the quit reason was still what was driving the pending status at that point.
0 coins
Jasmine Hernandez
How long did your pending weeks end up sitting there before the interview happened?
0 coins
Felix Grigori
Just want to flag something I've seen get people into trouble in this exact situation - if EDD pays you during the pending period and then denies you after the interview, yes, you would likely have to pay those weeks back. That's a real overpayment scenario. The way to protect yourself is to certify honestly, report any work or wages accurately every period, and understand that the pending payments before a determination are essentially conditional. I know that sounds scary but it's better to know than to assume approved is approved.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorSo payments that come in before the final determination are kind of provisional?
0 coins
Felix Grigori
In a way, yes. If EDD sends a payment before the phone interview is done and before they've issued a Notice of Determination, and then the determination comes back as a denial, they'll send an overpayment notice for those paid weeks. It doesn't happen to everyone but it's a real possibility with quit cases specifically.
0 coins
Felicity Bud
This is the part that scares me most about the whole system. How is a regular person supposed to know the difference between getting paid because you're approved and getting paid while still pending?
0 coins
Felix Grigori
UI Online Claim History is the place to watch. If your weeks still show as Pending in Claim History, the determination hasn't been made yet - regardless of whether money has moved.
0 coins
Alina Rosenthal
Something about the original question that I think is worth addressing directly: the scenario where EDD approves you, pays you for weeks, and then comes back way later and reverses itself is much less common than people assume. What's more typical is that they hold payment entirely until after the interview and determination. The overpayment fear is valid but the more immediate question is usually whether you get paid at all, not whether they'll claw back money they already gave you.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorThat actually makes me feel a little better. I've been picturing getting a bill for thousands of dollars after all this.
0 coins
Alina Rosenthal
That can happen but it's usually tied to fraud findings or significant wage misreporting - not to EDD doing a routine reversal of a quit decision. Report everything accurately each certification and keep records.
0 coins
Max Reyes
Agreed. The catastrophic overpayment stories are real but they're the outliers, not the standard experience for someone who answered the certifications honestly.
0 coins
Mikayla Davison
Has anyone actually appealed after a quit denial? I got denied after my interview about two months ago and I haven't done anything with the Appeal Form yet. Reading this thread made me realize the 30 day window might have passed.
0 coins
Ellie Kim
The 30 days runs from the mailing date on the Notice of Determination itself, not from when you received it. If that date has passed, you can still file a late appeal but you'll need to include an explanation for why you missed the deadline. It's worth submitting anyway rather than just letting it go.
0 coins
Mikayla Davison
The mailing date on mine was about 36 days ago. So I'd need to explain the delay?
0 coins
Ellie Kim
Yes, include your reason in writing with the Appeal Form DE 1000M and mail it to the address printed on your notice. The California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board will look at whether the reason justifies the late filing. Don't sit on it longer while deciding whether to try.
0 coins
Oliver Cheng
Even filing a late appeal is better than not filing at all. The worst outcome is they say the deadline isn't excused, which is the same position you're in now.
0 coins
Adrian Connor
Availability for work question keeps coming up in quit cases and I want to make sure people understand it. Every single week you certify, you're saying you were able to work, available for work, and looking for work. If the reason you quit had anything to do with not being able to work - a medical issue, a situation that limits your availability - that's a separate eligibility question from the quit reason itself. Both have to be satisfied.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorMy reason was the work environment and hour cuts, not a health issue. Does that change the availability question for me?
0 coins
Adrian Connor
If you're genuinely able and available to work any new job and you're actively searching, you answer yes to those certification questions and you're in the clear on that part. The quit reason interview deals with why you left the specific job, not whether you're available for new work now.
0 coins
Miguel Harvey
This is where the certification questions got confusing for me - I didn't realize 'available for work' meant available for any job, not just your old type of job.
0 coins
Aisha Jackson
My employer actually tried to tell me I couldn't collect because I quit voluntarily, like they had any say in that. EDD decides, not the employer - that's the part I wish someone had told me sooner. Your employer can respond to EDD's inquiry and tell their side, and EDD absolutely weighs it, but an employer can't deny or block your claim on their own. EDD makes the call.
0 coins
Fiona Sand
Mine said the same thing - basically implied I was wasting my time filing. I filed anyway.
0 coins
Aisha Jackson
Good. Former employers sometimes push back or argue misconduct to try to protect their account, but that's their side of the story, not an EDD decision. File, do the interview, and let EDD actually determine it.
0 coins
Felicity Bud
Wait, does it hurt you if your employer responds aggressively to EDD?
0 coins
Aisha Jackson
Their response is considered but it's not automatically taken at face value either. That's what the interview process is for - EDD hears both sides. What you say, documented and consistent, matters.
0 coins
Ryder Everingham
What's the CalJOBS thing about - I see it mentioned in every EDD thread and I genuinely don't know what it is or whether I need to do it.
0 coins
Kevin Bell
CalJOBS is the state's job search and registration site. EDD sends most claimants a notice - the DE 8405 - telling them they need to register on CalJOBS and post a resume within 21 days of that notice's date. If you don't do it in time, EDD can stop your payments. The site is caljobs.ca.gov.
0 coins
Ryder Everingham
And how do I know if EDD sent me that notice? I've gotten a bunch of mail and I'm not sure I'm tracking all of it.
0 coins
Kevin Bell
Look through any EDD mail for the DE 8405. If EDD said you don't need to register, they'll tell you that too. When in doubt, registering doesn't hurt you.
0 coins
Ashley Simian
CalJOBS also has job listings and resume help resources which are actually useful while you're searching, beyond just the EDD registration requirement.
0 coins
Lilly Curtis
Unemployment benefits are federal taxable income even though California doesn't tax them at the state level. Something I did not know going into my own claim and it hit me at tax time. If you end up getting paid, you can elect to have 10 percent withheld for federal taxes each time you certify. Way easier than owing a lump sum later.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorCan you change that withholding election later if you forget to set it up at first?
0 coins
Lilly Curtis
You can update it at certification time - each period you have the option to change whether you want federal withholding. EDD also sends a 1099G in January showing what you received, and it's available in UI Online under Payments.
0 coins
Luis Johnson
I had no idea California didn't tax it. I was mentally budgeting for both state and federal taxes on my payments.
0 coins
Oliver Cheng
Misconduct is a word that gets misused constantly in quit discussions. EDD uses that term specifically in the context of being fired - the employer has to show there was misconduct to defend a fired employee's claim. For a quit, the standard is different: you have to show you had a good reason to leave. Those aren't the same thing and confusing them can make you feel worse about your situation than you should.
0 coins
Taylor To
So misconduct is only relevant if you were fired, not if you quit?
0 coins
Oliver Cheng
Exactly. EDD's own language is that if you're fired, the employer must prove misconduct. If you quit, you have to show good cause. Two different standards, two different burdens. Someone who quit and had real reasons for leaving shouldn't be applying the fired-misconduct framework to their case.
0 coins
Mohammad Khaled
This was me in my first EDD claim - I kept reading about misconduct and applying it to my quit case and confusing myself completely. The frameworks are genuinely different.
0 coins
Jasmine Hernandez
Phone interview scheduling is something I didn't understand at all. My DE 4800 notice came and I didn't realize the date and time printed on it was when the interviewer phones - I thought I had to call in at that time. Sat there the whole window waiting for the call and then spent an hour trying to get through to EDD to reschedule.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorSo you just keep your phone with you at the time printed on the DE 4800 and they call you?
0 coins
Jasmine Hernandez
That's exactly it. The interviewer phones at the scheduled time. You don't dial in. The time is also on your UI Online homepage. If you need to change the time, contact EDD at least one day before - but only if there's an open slot available.
0 coins
Max Reyes
This is such an easy thing to get wrong and EDD doesn't make it obvious. The phrasing on the notice makes it sound like you're supposed to do something at that time, not just be ready to receive a call.
0 coins
Ella Cofer
Filing date timing matters more than people think. My claim started on the Sunday of the week I actually applied, not on my last day of work. Lost about a week of potential benefits because I waited a few days before filing. If you haven't filed yet or just did, the first certified period usually covers the waiting week and then one paid week - EDD has an unpaid waiting week built into every new claim.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorI already filed so I can't change that, but good to know for the future. The waiting week thing - does that reduce the total I can eventually get from the claim?
0 coins
Ella Cofer
The waiting week doesn't reduce your maximum benefit amount - the total stays the same. It's just a one-week gap at the start that isn't paid. It shifts when you start seeing money but doesn't change the overall ceiling on what the claim can pay.
0 coins
Miguel Harvey
Had no idea about the waiting week when I filed my first claim. Got confused when the first certification only resulted in one week of payment instead of two.
0 coins
Kevin Bell
Can I ask what happens if EDD decides your quit had good cause but only partially? Like what if they agree some conditions were bad but not all of them? Does that mean partial payment or a full denial?
0 coins
Ellie Kim
EDD's determination is usually an up or down decision on whether you qualified - good cause existed or it didn't. The specifics of your situation as a whole inform that decision. It's not really structured as partial credit for some reasons and not others. What you want is to present all the conditions together as your complete account of why you left.
0 coins
Kevin Bell
That's helpful - I was picturing some kind of pro-rated outcome which sounds like isn't how it works.
0 coins
Felix Grigori
The interview is your chance to tell the full picture - the hour cuts, the write-ups, the environment, everything together. EDD considers all of it and then makes one determination.
0 coins
Felicity Bud
My employer is telling coworkers I'm going to have to pay it all back because I quit without notice. Is the two-week notice thing actually an EDD rule? Because I gave mine but someone who didn't is now worried.
0 coins
Oliver Cheng
Giving or not giving two weeks notice is not an EDD rule that determines eligibility. Whether you had good cause to quit is what EDD looks at. How you exited - two weeks notice, same day, whatever - doesn't automatically make a quit ineligible. Your former employer is not an authority on how EDD decides your claim.
0 coins
Felicity Bud
That's genuinely reassuring. My old manager has been telling everyone they can get people's benefits denied by just saying they quit without warning.
0 coins
Oliver Cheng
The employer's response to EDD matters but it's their account of events, not a veto. EDD considers both sides. How you gave notice doesn't determine the outcome by itself.
0 coins
Aisha Jackson
Employers sometimes say things like this to discourage people from filing. File, do the interview honestly, and let EDD actually decide.
0 coins
Max Reyes
Something I figured out the hard way: checking payment status every hour on UI Online does not make it update faster and it also drives you completely insane. Payment info updates daily, and the phone line 1-866-333-4606 has updated payment info 24 hours a day. Set a time to check once a day and step away from refreshing UI Online constantly.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
AuthorThis is surprisingly practical advice that I need to hear. I've been checking UI Online every few hours.
0 coins
Max Reyes
The pending status sitting there is brutal psychologically. Daily check, write down what you see, close the tab. The determination happens on EDD's timeline regardless of how often you look.
0 coins
Luis Johnson
1-866-333-4606 is the payment line right? I always mix it up with the main EDD number.
0 coins
Max Reyes
Yes - 1-866-333-4606 is specifically for payment info and certifying by phone. The main EDD line for agents and claim questions is 1-800-300-5616. Different numbers for different things.
0 coins