Back to California Unemployment

Connor Rupert

What to do if unemployment paid money I wasn't eligible for - California EDD situation

So I'm in a kind of nightmare situation right now. I was collecting UI benefits for about two months earlier this year, and I recently got a letter from California EDD saying they've determined I wasn't eligible for some of those weeks. The letter mentions an overpayment amount of around $1,840 and says I need to repay it. Here's the thing though - I genuinely didn't think I was doing anything wrong when I certified. I answered the questions the way I understood them, but apparently EDD sees it differently. I don't even fully understand WHY they say I wasn't eligible. The notice doesn't explain it super clearly to me. Has anyone dealt with an overpayment notice like this? Do I have to pay it all back immediately? Can I fight it if I think their decision was wrong? I'm freaking out because that's money I already spent on rent and groceries while I was unemployed. I really need to know what my options are here.

Overpayment notice hit me earlier this year on a week where my part-time earnings got recorded wrong in the system. The DE 1080CZ - that's the Notice of Determination that comes with the overpayment decision - had an Appeal Form stapled to the back, the DE 1000M. What I did first was use Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD's phone line; there's a video they put out about reaching a live person at EDD if you want to see what that's about: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent I spoke to pulled up my claim and confirmed exactly which week the overpayment was tied to and whether EDD had flagged it as fraud or non-fraud - those two categories get treated very differently. For me it was non-fraud, which meant no penalty on top of the amount owed, and the agent told me I could request a waiver using the DE 1446UI if repaying would be a real hardship. I ended up appealing anyway because I believed I'd reported my earnings correctly, and the Appeal Form goes back to the address printed on that notice, postmarked within 30 days of the mailing date on it.

0 coins

The 30-day window on that appeal - does it start from when I received the letter or the date printed on the notice itself?

0 coins

Mailing date on the notice is what EDD goes by, not when it showed up in your mailbox. So if the letter is dated a week before you got it, those days already count.

0 coins

That's cutting it close for me then. The date on mine is about 18 days ago and I just found it in a pile of mail yesterday. Need to move fast.

0 coins

If the deadline already passed when you file, write a note explaining why the appeal was late - EDD will consider it. Don't just skip appealing because you think you missed the window.

0 coins

What exactly did the overpayment notice say about whether it was fraud or not? The reason I ask is that matters a lot for what comes next. A non-fraud overpayment is bad enough - you owe the money back - but there's no extra 30 percent penalty tacked on. A fraud finding means EDD is saying you intentionally gave false information or hid something, which is a totally different situation with real consequences beyond just the money.

0 coins

Mine says 'non-fraud overpayment' which I think is the better of the two bad options? But I still don't understand why they ruled I wasn't eligible those weeks.

0 coins

Non-fraud is definitely the better situation. It still means EDD wants the money back, but you're not looking at the fraud penalty on top of it. The Notice of Determination should list the specific weeks and the reason code - even if the explanation feels vague, there's usually a reason cited. Worth calling EDD to get them to explain what triggered it.

0 coins

My non-fraud one last year took about four months to resolve through appeal. Just setting expectations - this isn't a quick process.

0 coins

Does anyone know if you have to pay the whole amount right away or can you set up payments? I'm in a similar situation and there's no way I can come up with over a thousand dollars all at once.

0 coins

EDD can collect overpayments from future UI benefits, state tax refunds, lottery winnings, and other state payments - basically they have a lot of ways to eventually collect. But whether you can arrange a payment plan is something to ask EDD directly about your own situation. The notice usually has information on repayment options.

0 coins

Also worth knowing - if the overpayment wasn't your fault and paying it back would be a genuine financial hardship, you can apply for a waiver using the DE 1446UI form. It's not guaranteed but it's a real option EDD offers for non-fraud cases. You'd want to still appeal if you disagree with the underlying decision though.

0 coins

The waiver form - is that something I can find through EDD's site or do I have to call to request it?

0 coins

EDD mails it in some situations, but you can also ask for it by calling EDD or sending a message through your UI Online account. Ask EDD on their website is another way to request forms.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact scenario about eight months ago. The thing that helped me most was understanding that an overpayment decision and an appeal are two separate tracks - you can appeal the decision itself AND separately ask about the waiver. You don't have to choose one or the other. I appealed because I genuinely thought I'd certified correctly, and while that was going on I also submitted the waiver application because I honestly couldn't afford to repay $2,100 on a part-time income.

0 coins

Can you do both simultaneously - appeal the overpayment amount and also apply for the waiver just in case?

0 coins

Yes, that's exactly what I did. The appeal goes through the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board process if EDD doesn't reverse its decision first, and the waiver is a separate form EDD evaluates on its own. Having both in motion is not inconsistent.

0 coins

Important to keep certifying through all this too if your benefit year is still open. If EDD eventually decides in your favor on some weeks, they can only pay those weeks if you certified for them.

0 coins

The way EDD explains these notices is honestly terrible. I got one last spring and read it four times and still couldn't figure out what I supposedly did wrong. Had to request my claim file to even understand what information EDD had on record versus what I reported.

0 coins

How did you request your claim file? I didn't know that was something you could do.

0 coins

You can send a message through UI Online or contact EDD and ask for the records related to your claim and the specific determination. It takes a while but it shows you exactly what employer-reported wages they had, what you certified, and where the discrepancy was flagged.

0 coins

This is actually really useful when you're preparing an appeal. The administrative law judge at the CUIAB hearing is going to look at the same records, so knowing what's in there beforehand helps you explain your side.

0 coins

Something I learned the hard way - whatever happens with the overpayment, don't stop certifying if you're still in your benefit year. I made that mistake. When my appeal eventually came through partially in my favor, EDD could only back-pay the weeks I'd actually certified for. The weeks I'd skipped were just gone.

0 coins

Even during the appeal process, I should keep certifying?

0 coins

Especially during the appeal. EDD can only pay retroactively for weeks you certified. If you stop and later win the appeal, those uncertified weeks won't be paid.

0 coins

This is one of the most important things in this whole thread. Keep certifying regardless of whatever notice you received.

0 coins

Is there any chance they'll just garnish wages or come after your bank account for the overpayment? That's what I'm scared about with mine.

0 coins

EDD's recovery methods from what they publish are things like deducting from future unemployment payments, taking state tax refunds, state lottery winnings, and other state-owed money - they can also get a court judgment or record a lien. But wage garnishment specifically isn't something EDD lists as a method they use.

0 coins

That's somewhat reassuring I guess. Still a lot of money to figure out how to handle.

0 coins

If you haven't already, appeal the determination and also request the DE 1446UI waiver. Those are your two main tools while EDD is figuring out collection.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused about something - is a phone interview the same thing as an appeal hearing? My sister got an overpayment letter and she's been talking about her 'hearing' but I think she means she got a call scheduled with EDD?

0 coins

Those are very different things. A phone interview is EDD gathering information before they make a decision - it's scheduled, the date and time come on a notice called the DE 4800, and the interviewer phones at that time. An appeal hearing happens after EDD has already made a decision, through the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, with an administrative law judge. If your sister got an overpayment notice and hasn't filed an appeal yet, she should figure out which stage she's at.

0 coins

Okay that makes a lot more sense. She got the overpayment letter so the decision is already made - she needs to file the actual appeal then, not wait for a call?

0 coins

If she disagrees with the decision, yes - she needs to file the written appeal with the DE 1000M form or a letter, within 30 days of the mailing date on the notice. The hearing comes later after she files.

0 coins

Sending her this thread right now. She thought she was already in an appeal just because a phone interview was mentioned somewhere.

0 coins

For anyone reading this who's newer to how overpayments work - the waiver and the appeal are genuinely different tools and both are worth understanding. The appeal says 'I disagree with EDD's underlying determination that I wasn't eligible.' The waiver says 'Even if I do owe this money, I can't repay it without serious hardship and it wasn't fraud.' You can pursue both. Neither is an admission that the other path is wrong.

0 coins

The waiver form - what does EDD actually look at to decide if someone qualifies for it?

0 coins

EDD weighs whether the overpayment was not your fault and whether repaying it would cause extraordinary hardship. They look at your financial situation - income, expenses, assets. It's not just 'I don't want to pay it.' There's a real financial hardship standard. And it's only available for non-fraud overpayments.

0 coins

Worth mentioning that a waiver is never guaranteed. EDD evaluates each one. But submitting the DE 1446UI at least gets your situation in front of them formally.

0 coins

Just got through reading this whole thread. Filed my own overpayment appeal two weeks ago and I'm waiting to hear when my CUIAB hearing will be scheduled. The notice of hearing is supposed to come by mail at least 10 days before it happens. Anyone know roughly how backed up those hearings are right now?

0 coins

Scheduling varies a lot and nobody can give you a reliable number. My appeal took months from the filing date to actually having the hearing. Plan for it to take time and keep certifying in the meantime if your benefit year is open.

0 coins

Yeah I figured it wouldn't be quick. At least I know from this thread that I should stay on top of certifying while I wait.

0 coins

Paycheck from a temp gig in mid-October overlapped with two weeks I'd already certified for, and EDD sent me a DE 1080CZ saying I owed $390 for those weeks. Spent three days redialing the EDD phone line and kept getting the high-volume message. Eventually I tried Claimyr and got an actual EDD agent on the line. The agent looked at my claim record and confirmed the overpayment was flagged non-fraud, that the two specific weeks were the ones in question, and that my appeal window was still open. Filed the appeal that same afternoon to the address on the notice.

0 coins

The appeals address - is that always the same EDD address or does it vary by notice?

0 coins

Use the address printed on your specific notice. That's what the agent told me too - don't assume it's a universal address.

0 coins

Did using that service take long before you actually reached someone? Just wondering if it's worth trying for my situation.

0 coins

My situation was resolved in terms of what I needed to know from that call - the agent had my claim pulled up and answered the questions I had. I still had to do the actual appeal filing myself after.

0 coins

Can EDD come after you for an overpayment from a benefit year that's already closed? Like if the claim year ended but they just now found the problem?

0 coins

An overpayment doesn't disappear when the benefit year closes. EDD can still issue an overpayment notice and pursue collection after the claim year has ended - the year closing just means you can't collect new benefits on that claim, not that any debts tied to it are forgiven.

0 coins

That's what I was afraid of. Got a letter about a claim from over a year ago.

0 coins

Still appeal it within 30 days of the mailing date if you disagree. The process is the same regardless of when the original claim was active.

0 coins

My situation was a little different - I got hit with an overpayment because EDD said I should have been disqualified from the first week due to severance pay from my employer. I had no idea severance was something I needed to report. Ended up being almost $900.

0 coins

Severance pay is on EDD's list of things to report when you certify - same with vacation pay, holiday pay, bonuses. EDD decides how those affect your payment. Even though severance under a company plan or policy isn't counted the same way as regular wages for UI purposes, it still needs to be reported when the certification asks about it. If you didn't report it and that's what triggered the overpayment, the appeal would need to explain the circumstances around why.

0 coins

I genuinely didn't know I was supposed to report it. Does that factor in at all when they classify it as fraud vs non-fraud?

0 coins

Whether something was intentional or a genuine mistake is part of what EDD considers when they classify fraud versus non-fraud. If you honestly didn't know you were supposed to report it and there was no intent to deceive, that's relevant to the non-fraud classification. Your appeal is the place to explain that clearly.

0 coins

This actually came up in my appeal too - the judge asked whether I had read the instructions on the certification questions. Worth being honest about what you knew and when.

0 coins

Does submitting the waiver form stop EDD from trying to collect while they evaluate it? Or are they still going to deduct from future payments in the meantime?

0 coins

Ask EDD directly about what happens to collection during a waiver review - that's not something to guess at because it can affect your situation practically. Send a message through UI Online or call them to ask what the status is while the DE 1446UI is pending.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'll send a message through UI Online today.

0 coins

The appeal hearing itself - does anyone know if you can represent yourself or do you need a lawyer? Mine is coming up in about six weeks and I really can't afford an attorney.

0 coins

You can absolutely represent yourself. The appeal rules allow you to represent yourself, have a union official help if that applies to you, or have an attorney - but nothing requires an attorney. The administrative law judge conducts the hearing, testimony is under oath, and you get to explain your side. A lot of people go through it without legal representation.

0 coins

That's a relief. I was worried I'd be at a huge disadvantage without a lawyer.

0 coins

Bring whatever documentation you have - your certifications, any pay stubs for the weeks in question, the original determination notice. The more organized you are, the clearer your explanation will be.

0 coins

Good point. I've been saving everything since I got the notice.

0 coins

Something nobody's mentioned yet - what does the EDD do if you win the appeal but they already collected some of the overpayment from a tax refund or something? Do they refund it?

0 coins

If EDD collected money that the appeal decision later says you didn't owe, that's worth asking EDD directly about - it touches on accounting within your claim that only they can tell you the status of. Send a message through UI Online with the specific details of your situation.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. I'll follow up on that since my appeal is still pending.

0 coins

DE 1080CZ showed up at my door last month for $720 - EDD said I wasn't eligible during three weeks when I was doing some contract work and apparently didn't report all of it correctly. I tried calling EDD for two weeks straight and never got past the busy message. Used Claimyr to reach an actual agent who told me those weeks were showing non-fraud in their system and that the 30-day appeal window from the mailing date on the notice was still open. Mailed the DE 1000M that week to the address on the bottom of my notice.

0 coins

The contract work reporting thing is what got you? I'm worried about something similar on my end - I did a few days of freelance during my UI period and I'm not sure I reported the exact amounts right.

0 coins

Yeah, the certification asks about work and earnings for the week they were earned. If you think you reported something incorrectly on a past week, the right move is to contact EDD - either a message through UI Online or by phone - because there's no way to fix a week you already certified through the Report Wages screen. That's only for looking things up before you certify, not correcting after.

0 coins

This is exactly right. Report Wages in UI Online lets you see what's on record before certifying, it doesn't fix past certifications. For already-submitted weeks with errors, it's EDD contact or the appeal process.

0 coins

Reading back through this thread - the person who said you have to prove your quit had a good reason but EDD has to prove misconduct for a firing, that's accurate for those two situations. But I want to flag that for a layoff there's no misconduct question at all, so nobody needs to prove anything about that. Misconduct only comes up in a firing. Just wanted to clear that up since I've seen people get confused and think any termination situation involves the employer proving something.

0 coins

Good clarification. Layoffs and firings get treated completely differently and mixing those up can really confuse someone going through an overpayment appeal where the reason for separation is being questioned.

0 coins

Exactly - and in overpayment cases the question is usually about whether you were eligible during specific certified weeks, not necessarily why you separated. But the separation reason can come up if EDD is revisiting the original eligibility decision, so knowing which category you're in matters.

0 coins

For anyone who gets to the CUIAB hearing stage - the Notice of Hearing comes by mail and it arrives at least 10 days before the hearing date. If your address has changed since you filed your claim or your appeal, make sure EDD and the appeals board have the right address. Missing a hearing notice because it went to an old address is a problem you really don't want.

0 coins

How do you update your address with EDD? Just through UI Online account settings?

0 coins

Update it in your myEDD account, and it's also worth contacting EDD directly to confirm the update went through, especially if a hearing is coming up. Don't assume a system update automatically reaches every office.

0 coins

Moved last year and completely forgot about this. Going to update mine right now.

0 coins

Has anyone had the actual appeal reversed by EDD before it even went to a CUIAB hearing? Or does it always end up going all the way to the judge?

0 coins

EDD does an internal review before forwarding to the Office of Appeals. If they reverse the determination on their own, it doesn't need to go to a hearing. It doesn't happen in most cases from what I've seen people share, but it does happen - usually when there's a clear documentation issue EDD can resolve on their end.

0 coins

Okay so it's worth filing the appeal even if you're not sure you'll win, because EDD might catch it on review first.

0 coins

Filing the appeal is almost always worth doing if you disagree with the determination. Not filing means EDD's decision stands automatically.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure