Back to California Unemployment

Chloe Robinson

What separation reason to choose on unemployment when quitting for health reasons

Filed my California EDD unemployment application online yesterday and I got completely stuck on the separation reason dropdown. I left my job two months ago because my doctor told me I needed to stop working due to a chronic condition that was getting worse from the job stress and physical demands. So technically I quit, but it wasn't like I just decided I didn't want to work anymore - it was a medical situation. The options in the dropdown were confusing and I didn't know if I should pick something like 'quit for personal reasons' or if there's a more specific option for health. I ended up just picking the most general quit option and submitting but now I'm second-guessing whether that was the right call. Has anyone gone through this? My weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z came out to $390 so I really can't afford to get disqualified over a dropdown selection.

Chronic pain from a warehouse job was what I was dealing with when I filed last spring - two bulging discs and my doctor had been telling me for months to get out of that environment. The separation dropdown stumped me too so I called EDD, and I got through using Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it handles the hold so you end up speaking with a live EDD agent. Here's their video on reaching a live person at EDD: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and walked me through what happens after you pick a quit reason: EDD schedules a phone interview regardless of which option you chose, and that interview is where you actually explain the medical situation. She said the dropdown category matters less than what you tell the interviewer and what documentation you bring. I asked if I needed a doctor's note and she said to have something from my physician ready for the interview date shown on my DE 4800. Got the interview, explained everything, and payments came through a few weeks later.

0 coins

DE 4800 in my mailbox right now and the interview date is showing on the UI Online homepage too - good to know the dropdown isn't the whole story. Did the agent say anything about what happens if the medical condition is related to the job itself versus just being made worse by it?

0 coins

The agent on my call said EDD looks at the whole picture during the interview - whether the condition pre-existed or developed on the job didn't come up as a separate category. She just said to explain the timeline honestly and bring whatever my doctor put in writing.

0 coins

Warehouse jobs do real damage, I went through something similar with a rotator cuff. The interview being the real decision point makes a lot of sense, the application is just to get the process started.

0 coins

My DE 4800 came yesterday actually, the interview is scheduled for next week. So I need to get documentation from my doctor before then - is a letter enough or does it need to be on a specific form?

0 coins

Spent three days reading through EDD's site when I quit for a heart condition last year and here's what I pieced together: EDD's own language is that if you quit, you have to show you had a good reason. Health is explicitly in that category when you can back it up. The dropdown selection on the initial application doesn't lock anything in - it just routes your claim to the right queue for the phone interview. What actually counts is what comes out in that call, so being ready to explain the medical timeline clearly matters a lot more than which dropdown you clicked.

0 coins

That's a relief to hear about the dropdown. My condition is documented - I have three specialist visits in the last four months and a letter my doctor wrote when I resigned. I just want to make sure I'm not walking into the interview blind.

0 coins

The documentation point is huge. My claim got approved after a quit for anxiety disorder and the doctor's letter was the first thing the interviewer asked about. Without something in writing from a physician I think it gets much harder to establish the medical reason was genuine.

0 coins

Exactly - the letter from your doctor plus the visit records gives EDD something concrete. The interviewer is basically weighing whether the medical situation left you a reasonable choice other than quitting, and paperwork makes that case for you.

0 coins

Wait, does it matter which specific quit reason you pick if EDD is going to call you anyway? Like is there a 'quit for medical' option or is it all lumped under personal reasons on the California EDD application?

0 coins

The options vary a bit but quitting for health or medical reasons is usually its own category separate from general personal reasons - it's worth checking if you can amend the application before the interview. If you already submitted, the interview is where you correct the record anyway.

0 coins

My application is already submitted too so I guess the interview is what matters. I picked 'other personal reasons' because I panicked. Hoping I can just explain the full situation on the call.

0 coins

The UI Online Claim History showed my claim as Pending for about two weeks after I submitted with a vague quit reason, then the DE 4800 arrived. The interviewer didn't seem bothered by the initial category I chose - she just asked me to describe what happened in my own words.

0 coins

Something people get wrong about quitting for health reasons: you don't necessarily have to be unable to work entirely to qualify. EDD's question is whether you had a good reason to leave that specific job - if the job itself was damaging your health and you couldn't get a reasonable accommodation, that's the argument. I quit a nursing job due to severe back issues from patient lifting and was approved. I was still able to do other kinds of work, just not that physical demand level.

0 coins

This is actually my situation almost exactly - I can do other work, just not the physical requirements of that specific job. I was worried EDD would say I should have just switched roles but my employer didn't offer any alternatives when I asked.

0 coins

Requesting accommodation and being denied or given nothing is exactly the kind of thing to bring up in the interview. Keep anything in writing if you have it - even a text or email where you asked about lighter duty and got no response.

0 coins

The accommodation angle is a good point. I had a respiratory issue and my employer wouldn't move me away from the chemicals even with a doctor's note. EDD asked about that specifically during my interview.

0 coins

Severance package timing confused me when I quit for a pinched nerve - my HR said severance might affect my claim start date and I wasn't sure if I should wait to file. Actually used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the phone before I did anything, because I'd heard the phone lines were impossible. The agent told me EDD's policy is that severance paid under a company plan isn't counted as wages against your benefits, but to still report it when certifying and EDD sorts out the impact. She also confirmed my claim start date and said to file right away rather than wait. Ended up with a weekly benefit amount of $340 on my DE 429Z.

0 coins

The severance thing was confusing me too - I have two weeks of severance coming and I didn't know if I needed to wait until it ran out. So I should just file now and report the severance when I certify?

0 coins

That's what the agent told me for my situation - file immediately, then report it honestly during certification and EDD handles the calculation. Waiting to file could push your claim start date back and cost you weeks.

0 coins

DE 429Z arrived about two weeks after I filed and mine didn't mention severance at all - it's separate from the award calculation from what I understand. Report it, let EDD decide.

0 coins

Filing today then. I had no idea the claim starts from the week you apply, not when you first get paid. That waiting week thing already costs one week, didn't want to lose more by waiting to file.

0 coins

Can I ask something - does EDD require you to still do work search activities every week even if you quit for health reasons and you're waiting for the interview? I've been logging applications but I'm worried my condition makes it hard to meet whatever the requirement is.

0 coins

Every week you certify, EDD asks whether you were able to work and available for work - quitting for health reasons doesn't exempt you from that. If your condition makes you genuinely unable to work, unemployment may not be the right program and Disability Insurance through SDI Online might apply. But if you can work in some capacity just not your old job, you certify that you're able and available and do your work search.

0 coins

I can do lighter work, just not the physical labor of my old job. So I certify that I'm able and available for appropriate work and keep applying. That makes sense, I was confusing myself thinking I had to be fully able-bodied to certify.

0 coins

Exactly right. The question is whether you're available for some kind of work, not whether you can go back and do the exact job you left.

0 coins

My claim got denied after quitting for stress-related health reasons and I'm now in the appeal process. Just want to flag for anyone reading this that the interview outcome isn't guaranteed - EDD denied me saying I didn't establish the medical condition was serious enough to compel the quit. I'm appealing with my therapist's records now. File the Appeal Form DE 1000M within 30 days of the date on your Notice of Determination, and keep certifying the whole time you're appealing so EDD can pay back weeks if you win.

0 coins

Sorry to hear about the denial, that's really stressful. The keep certifying during the appeal part is important, I wouldn't have thought of that. How detailed does the appeal letter need to be?

0 coins

My appeal letter basically walked through the timeline of my health issues, what I told my employer, and why I had no reasonable option other than quitting. I attached everything from my therapist. The Office of Appeals is a separate process from EDD - an administrative law judge handles the hearing.

0 coins

The 30-day window on the DE 1080CZ is strict. If you miss it you have to explain why in writing and hope they accept the late appeal. Don't sit on that form.

0 coins

EDD's phone lines were killing me after my claim for a quit due to hypertension went into adjudication - kept getting disconnected after 45 minutes of hold music. Eventually tried Claimyr and got to an actual EDD agent the same afternoon. The agent found that my claim was pending because my CalJOBS registration hadn't been completed within the 21-day window on my DE 8405. I had no idea that was sitting there. Got into CalJOBS that night and posted my resume, and payments released shortly after.

0 coins

DE 8405 - I don't think I've checked for that in my mail. So most people quitting for health reasons still have to register in CalJOBS even during the interview wait period?

0 coins

The agent said EDD sends the DE 8405 to most claimants - if you get it, you have 21 days from the date on the notice to register and post your resume at caljobs.ca.gov or payments can stop. Health-related quit doesn't automatically waive it.

0 coins

Missed mine for two weeks because it was buried in a stack of mail. Got it resolved but had two weeks of Pending in Claim History while I sorted it out. Check the mail carefully around weeks two and three after filing.

0 coins

Does a doctor's note have to say you CAN'T work at all or just that the job was harmful? Because my doctor wrote that my condition was 'aggravated by working conditions' but didn't say I was disabled from working entirely.

0 coins

Aggravated by working' conditions is actually useful language for a California EDD quit-for-health claim -'EDD s question is whether the job was making you sick and you had no other reasonable option, not whether'you re totally disabled. Totally disabled would be more of a Disability Insurance situation throughSDI.

0 coins

That's really clarifying. I was about to go back to my doctor and ask for stronger wording but maybe what I have is already useful.

0 coins

Bring what you have to the interview and let the interviewer ask if they need more. Getting documentation amended before the interview just to make it sound worse could come across odd if your doctor then has questions about what you asked them to write.

0 coins

My situation is a little different - I didn't quit, my employer technically terminated me after I requested a leave of absence for a surgery. I keep seeing people say they 'quit for health reasons' and I'm wondering if I should have selected a different category since it was actually a firing after a medical leave request.

0 coins

That's a pretty different situation from a voluntary quit. If your employer ended your employment, that's a termination - EDD's rule is that for a firing, the employer has to prove misconduct, not you. How you were told your job was ending matters.

0 coins

They sent me an email saying my position was 'eliminated while I was on leave.' My paperwork says terminated, not resigned. I think I may have selected the wrong reason on my application.

0 coins

Contact EDD through the message option in your UI Online account and explain the discrepancy - 'position eliminated' while on medical leave is probably a layoff situation, not a voluntary quit. That changes what EDD has to decide.

0 coins

Quick correction to something that came up earlier about work search - someone said the number of applications you need to track each week. EDD's site doesn't actually publish a specific number of contacts required per week. The requirement is that you're able, available and actively looking, and that you keep a record. No official count is stated anywhere in EDD's rules.

0 coins

Wait, I read somewhere that it was 3 contacts a week - that was wrong? I've been tracking exactly 3 every week thinking that was the rule.

0 coins

No specific number is in EDD's published rules. Keeping your records is smart, but there's no official '3 per week' requirement stated on EDD's site. If an interviewer or auditor ever asks, you show your records and explain your search.

0 coins

I had an EDD staffer at an America's Job Center tell me to 'aim for three' but she also said it wasn't a hard rule. The habit of keeping records is the actual thing you want to protect yourself.

0 coins

Pending status in my Claim History for over three weeks now after a quit for migraines - had my phone interview already, thought it would clear up after. Is it normal for it to stay Pending this long after the interview is done?

0 coins

My claim stayed Pending for about two and a half weeks after the interview before the Notice of Determination arrived. The interview being done doesn't flip it to paid right away - EDD still has to make its decision and you need to have certified too.

0 coins

I've been certifying every two weeks so that part is covered. I'll give it another week before I try reaching EDD directly. The waiting is the hardest part.

0 coins

UI Online updates daily so keep checking Payments under Claim History. Mine flipped overnight when it finally moved.

0 coins

For anyone confused about the actual interview: the interviewer phones at the time listed on your DE 4800, it's not something you call in for. Keep your phone available and don't miss it. If you do miss it, phone EDD that same day - 1-800-300-5616 - because if you don't, EDD makes its determination from whatever information it already has and that usually doesn't go in your favor.

0 coins

Mine is Thursday morning according to my DE 4800 and the UI Online homepage shows the same time. I'll have my doctor's letter, my specialist visit records, and my notes about requesting accommodation all in front of me.

0 coins

That prep sounds solid. The interviewer will likely ask you to walk through the timeline of when the health issue started, what you tried before quitting, and whether your employer could have done anything differently. Having the timeline written out beforehand helps.

0 coins

Lumbar herniation was my reason for quitting, and my employer's HR department had been slow responding to my accommodation request for weeks before I finally left. Used Claimyr to reach EDD after my interview because my claim status still hadn't updated and I wanted to know if EDD had received the medical records I'd faxed over. The agent confirmed EDD had the records on file and that my case was still in the decision queue - told me a Notice of Determination would come by mail and to appeal within 30 days if I disagreed with whatever it said.

0 coins

A friend told me if you quit for health reasons EDD automatically approves you no questions asked. That doesn't sound right to me but wanted to check.

0 coins

Not accurate - nothing about quitting is automatic. EDD schedules a phone interview and decides based on what you and your employer say. Health is a category that can support a good-cause quit, but approval requires going through the process and demonstrating the medical situation.

0 coins

Yeah I figured that was too simple. My friend had a quick experience with it but that doesn't mean it's guaranteed for everyone.

0 coins

EDD notifies your former employer too when you file - they have a window to respond. For a health-related quit the employer may push back and say accommodation was available, which is exactly why having documentation of what you asked for matters.

0 coins

My condition was diagnosed after I quit - my doctor confirmed in writing that the symptoms I'd been having during my last months of work were consistent with the diagnosis I got later. EDD accepted that as documentation even though the actual diagnosis came after the separation date. Just sharing in case anyone is in a similar timeline situation.

0 coins

That's actually my situation almost exactly - my formal specialist diagnosis came about three weeks after I stopped working, but the symptoms and urgent care visits go back five months into my employment. Good to know the timeline doesn't have to be perfect.

0 coins

The urgent care visits during employment are probably your strongest documentation - they show the timeline predates your quit. Bring those records to the interview.

0 coins

The retrospective diagnosis thing came up in my appeal too. The administrative law judge accepted my therapist's written statement that my symptoms had been present and work-related for months before the official diagnosis, even though the records from that period were notes rather than a formal diagnosis letter.

0 coins

Something nobody's mentioned: whether you should file for Disability Insurance through SDI if your condition is still ongoing. Unemployment requires you to certify that you're able and available to work each week. If your health situation means you genuinely can't work right now, filing for DI might be the right call and you can't be on both programs for the same days.

0 coins

My doctor cleared me for light work and said I should avoid the specific physical demands of my old job. So I think I'm able and available for other kinds of work - is that enough to certify honestly?

0 coins

If your doctor has cleared you for light or modified work and you're genuinely available for that category of jobs, then certifying that you're able and available is accurate. The key is that it has to be honest - if you have a week where your health genuinely prevents you from working at all, you stop certifying for unemployment that week and look into DI for that period.

0 coins

SDI Online is where you file for DI if it comes to that. You can't be on both programs at the same time but you can transition between them if your situation changes.

0 coins

DE 429Z shows $390 weekly for the opening poster - worth noting that number comes from wages in the base period, not anything about why you quit. The separation reason affects eligibility, not the weekly amount. So the amount on that form doesn't change regardless of how the quit interview goes.

0 coins

I actually didn't understand that - I thought EDD might reduce the amount if the quit reason was questionable. So it's either I get the $390 or nothing, not a reduced amount?

0 coins

Exactly. EDD either decides you're eligible and pays the weekly benefit amount, or they issue a Notice of Determination saying you're not, with the appeal form included. There's no reduced-amount middle ground based on quit reason.

0 coins

That's clarifying. I thought there were partial approvals for certain quit categories too. Good to know it's a yes or no on eligibility.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure