Back to California Unemployment

Liam O'Donnell

What does letter earnings excess of 40 times weekly benefit amount mean for California EDD?

Got a letter in the mail from EDD last week and I'm completely lost on what it's saying. The part that's confusing me is where it talks about 'earnings in excess of 40 times your weekly benefit amount' and I genuinely have no idea what that means or what I'm supposed to do about it. For context - I was laid off from my warehouse job back in the spring and my weekly benefit amount on my DE 429Z was $310. I've been certifying every two weeks like clockwork and I did pick up a few shifts at a temp agency over the summer while still on claim. I reported everything when I certified, every single dollar. So now getting this letter is making me really anxious because I don't know if it means my benefits are ending, if they're saying I owe money back, or what. The letter doesn't really explain itself in plain English. Has anyone gotten something like this and can explain what it actually means?

Maximum benefit amount is basically a cap on the total your whole claim can pay out, and there are two ways EDD calculates it - either 26 times your weekly amount, or half of everything you earned during your base period, whichever one comes out lower. The '40 times' language is EDD's way of saying your earnings on record were enough to set a certain ceiling on the claim. With a $310 weekly benefit amount, your max would be around $8,060 if you get the full 26 weeks. The letter might just be a notice about where your claim balance stands, not necessarily that you owe anything back.

0 coins

Does that mean the letter is just informational and I don't need to do anything? Or is there some kind of response required?

0 coins

Usually those letters are status notices, not demands. But if there's any action required it'll say so somewhere on the letter, sometimes in a small box or at the very bottom.

0 coins

Found it - there's a line at the bottom that says I have the right to appeal within 30 days if I disagree. So I guess it IS some kind of determination?

0 coins

DE 429Z on my claim showed $285 as my weekly amount and I couldn't figure out why the total looked so low compared to what I thought I'd earned. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with a live EDD agent after I'd spent two days getting nowhere with the phone line on my own - I ended up talking to someone who pulled up my actual base period quarters and walked me through the math. The agent explained that the max payout is whichever is smaller: 26 times my weekly amount, or half my total base period wages. Mine hit the half-wages ceiling, not the 26-week one, which is why the number looked odd. Here's the video if you want to see how reaching a live person at EDD actually works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. I asked the agent about reporting my part-time shifts and she confirmed I had to report earnings in the week I did the work, not when the check landed in my account.

0 coins

The base period quarters thing is what's really confusing me - does that mean EDD only looks at certain months of your work history, not everything?

0 coins

EDD looks at a specific window of time called the base period, which is usually the first four of your last five full calendar quarters before you filed. So if you filed in September, they're looking at wages from about a year and a half ago up through June, not your most recent few months.

0 coins

That explains so much actually - my highest earning quarter was right before the base period window so it wasn't counted, which is probably why my weekly amount felt lower than I expected.

0 coins

My certification had a week where I earned $180 doing some freelance work and I panicked thinking I'd lose all my benefits for that week. What actually happens is EDD takes the first $25 or 25 percent of what you earned (whichever is bigger) and doesn't count it, then subtracts the rest from your weekly amount. So on a $310 weekly benefit with $180 earned, the 25 percent exemption is $45, the remaining $135 gets subtracted, and you'd still get $175 that week. The '40 times' language in the letter is a different calculation - it's about the total claim ceiling, not week-to-week earnings.

0 coins

Wait so the formula is 25 percent of gross earnings comes off first and THEN the rest reduces my benefit? Not the other way around?

0 coins

Exactly right. The bigger of $25 or 25% of your gross for that week is excluded, and what's left over is what actually reduces your weekly benefit dollar for dollar.

0 coins

Had no idea the exemption worked this way. I thought any earnings just got deducted straight from the weekly amount. No wonder some of my payments came out looking weird when I checked UI Online.

0 coins

The way I read letters like this after going through my own claim mess - if EDD is telling you about the 40x number it usually means you've hit or are approaching the total maximum benefit amount for the claim. It's not an overpayment notice, it's more of a heads-up that there's a limit to how long this claim can keep paying. Check your Claim History in UI Online and look at your remaining balance.

0 coins

Checked Claim History and it shows a remaining balance still, so it doesn't look like I've exhausted it yet. Maybe the letter was triggered by the temp work earnings I reported?

0 coins

Possibly. When you report earnings during certification EDD has to recalculate how that affects your overall balance, so a notice can go out as part of that process.

0 coins

After earnings get reported and EDD adjusts the balance, sometimes the payments tab in UI Online updates within a day or two. Worth checking there too.

0 coins

Missed my first certification date because I didn't realize the two-week window, and EDD sent me a notice that looked alarming - I thought it meant my whole claim was cancelled. Turns out it was just a notice that those weeks had lapsed and I needed to contact EDD about reopening them. Point being: scary-sounding official letters from EDD often mean something much more mundane than they appear. Read every line carefully and look for the specific action item if there is one.

0 coins

Were you able to get those lapsed weeks paid eventually, or were they just gone?

0 coins

Had to contact EDD to explain the situation and they were able to process the late certification for those weeks. It took about three extra weeks to sort out but I did eventually get paid for them.

0 coins

EDD's letters really should come with a plain English translation section. Half the people I know who filed panicked over routine notices.

0 coins

Something I wish I'd known earlier - the base period thing the person above mentioned, there's actually a backup calculation called the alternate base period. EDD is supposed to automatically check if the alternate base period (your four most recent completed quarters) would give you a valid claim when the standard one doesn't. But it doesn't swap to the alternate base period just to get you a higher weekly amount if your standard claim is already valid - it's only there as a fallback when the standard base period doesn't have enough wages.

0 coins

Mine was already valid under the standard base period, so I guess the alternate doesn't apply to me in this case?

0 coins

Correct. If your claim was valid from the start, EDD used the standard base period and that's what set your weekly amount. The alternate is only triggered automatically when standard wages aren't enough.

0 coins

Got tripped up by this exact thing - my highest wages were in the most recent quarter which wasn't in the standard base period, and I kept wondering why my weekly amount felt off. The alternate base period would have given me a valid claim if the standard hadn't, but since my standard was valid already, nothing changed.

0 coins

Filing a few months ago my DE 429Z showed up about two weeks after I applied and I didn't understand half of what it said. The 'maximum benefit amount' line is really the key number - it tells you the total cap for the entire claim. The weekly benefit amount times 26 equals one possible ceiling, and half your total base period wages equals the other. EDD uses whichever is smaller. So if your base period wages were on the lower side, the half-wages ceiling kicks in before you hit 26 weeks.

0 coins

Mine said $310 weekly and the max benefit amount was listed as around $5,900 on the DE 429Z. By the 26-week math that should be $8,060, so I guess the half-wages cap is what's limiting mine.

0 coins

That tracks. If your max is $5,900 it means half your total base period wages came out to around that number, which is less than 26 times $310. Perfectly normal, just means your base period earnings set the ceiling rather than the 26-week rule.

0 coins

NOBODY explains these letters in plain English and it's infuriating!! I got a similar notice earlier this year and spent an entire week convinced I was being accused of fraud or something. The language EDD uses sounds like legal documents written by people who have never tried to actually be unemployed. Just say 'your claim has a maximum total payout and here's the number' and be done with it.

0 coins

The frustration is real. EDD's written communications feel designed for people who already understand the system inside out.

0 coins

And then when you try to call to ask a question you're on hold forever or the line just disconnects. I finally got through after calling right at 8am on a Monday but it took three separate tries even then.

0 coins

The 8am Monday thing is real but even then it's hit or miss. I've had better luck mid-week around 8am than on Mondays when everyone has the same idea.

0 coins

Severance from my last job was what triggered the letter I got - I reported it when I certified because EDD's list says to report severance, and then a notice came explaining how it was being treated. Spent a couple hours trying to get someone on the phone about it. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to an EDD agent who told me my specific severance was under a company policy plan and EDD wasn't counting it as wages that would affect my weekly payments - but I still had to report it, which I'd done correctly. The agent looked at the weeks in question and confirmed the payments for those weeks were processed fine.

0 coins

How did you know to report severance if you weren't sure how EDD would count it?

0 coins

EDD's own list of things to report when you certify includes severance, so I reported it even though I wasn't sure what it would do. Better to report and let EDD sort it out than to not report and have it come back as an overpayment issue later.

0 coins

Severance handling is one of those things where you just have to report it and let EDD make the call. The certification question asks about all pay, so the answer is always yes if you got anything.

0 coins

Part-time work I picked up between jobs taught me how the earnings deduction actually works in practice. My weekly benefit amount was $265 and one week I earned $190 at a temp gig. The 25 percent of $190 is $47.50, which is bigger than $25, so $47.50 was excluded. The remaining $142.50 was subtracted from $265, and I got about $122.50 for that week. What I didn't know was that you report earnings for the week you worked them, not when the paycheck came. Got that wrong on my first certification and had to contact EDD to fix it.

0 coins

Reporting wages in the week earned vs. when paid - this is exactly the kind of thing that trips people up and causes overpayment notices later.

0 coins

EDD has a Report Wages section in UI Online that lets you work out the math before you certify, which I didn't discover until three weeks in. Really useful for figuring out how a week's earnings will affect the payment.

0 coins

The Report Wages tool - does it actually change anything you've already submitted, or is it just for calculating future weeks?

0 coins

Just for figuring out what a week looks like before you certify it. If you already certified a week wrong you have to contact EDD through UI Online or by phone to correct it - Report Wages doesn't fix past certifications.

0 coins

DE 4800 came in the mail after I reported a large week of earnings and I thought it was about the earnings, but it turned out EDD had opened a question about my availability for work during some of those weeks. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD without spending a day on hold, and talked to an agent who confirmed the interview was scheduled about the availability question, not the earnings amount itself. The notice had the date and time I needed to keep my phone ready. Agent said to have my work schedule details from those weeks handy for the interview.

0 coins

So the DE 4800 is specifically the interview notice? I want to make sure I'm reading my letter correctly to see if I have one of those coming.

0 coins

Yes, DE 4800 is the phone interview notice from EDD. It has the scheduled date, time, and a list of what topics the interviewer will likely ask about. The time is also shown on your UI Online homepage so you can double-check it there.

0 coins

Missing that interview is a big deal - if you don't answer at the scheduled time you're supposed to phone EDD the same day, otherwise they can make a decision on the question without hearing your side.

0 coins

Appealing a determination was something I had to do and the process was less intimidating than I expected once I understood the steps. EDD mails a Notice of Determination with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) attached. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date to appeal in writing - either use that form or write a letter, and send it to the address on the notice. After that it goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board and an administrative law judge holds the hearing. You can represent yourself.

0 coins

If the letter I got has 'you have the right to appeal within 30 days' on it, does that mean this IS a Notice of Determination even if it doesn't say those words anywhere?

0 coins

If it has the appeal rights language and a mailing date, treat it like a Notice of Determination and start counting the 30 days from that date. Don't wait to figure out what it's called - the deadline runs from the mailing date no matter what.

0 coins

The mailing date vs. the date you actually received it matters a lot here. 30 days starts from when EDD mailed it, not when it landed in your mailbox.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration caught me off guard - nobody told me I had to do it and then my payments stopped for two weeks while EDD sorted it out. The Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) came in the mail and I missed it. EDD gives 21 days from that notice date to register in CalJOBS and post a resume, and if you miss it your payments can be paused. Got it fixed by registering right away once I realized what happened.

0 coins

Haven't gotten a DE 8405 - does that mean I might not be required to register, or should I check somewhere to find out?

0 coins

EDD's paperwork tells you if you're required. If you haven't gotten the DE 8405 it might mean EDD determined you're exempt, but you could also check your UI Online messages to be sure.

0 coins

Worth verifying either way. CalJOBS registration issues are one of the more common reasons payments stop unexpectedly on an otherwise active claim.

0 coins

Work search is something a lot of people on this forum stress about but EDD's requirement is basically that you're actively looking for work every week you certify. Keeping notes on where you applied and when is a good habit even though EDD doesn't specify a set number of contacts you have to make each week. If EDD ever asks about your work search you want to be able to describe what you were doing.

0 coins

The 'no specific number required' thing surprised me. I'd heard you need exactly three contacts a week from multiple people, but EDD's actual rule doesn't state a fixed number.

0 coins

That's a common thing people say but it's not in EDD's official rules - no one should be turning down legitimate work search activities because they hit some number they heard about. The requirement is that you're genuinely looking.

0 coins

The confusion might come from mixing up work search requirements that existed during some earlier periods with current rules. Right now EDD just asks if you looked for work, not how many contacts you made.

0 coins

Overpayment notice I got last year was from a week where I reported wages in the wrong week - I earned the money on a Thursday and Friday but got paid the following Monday, and I reported it in the week I got paid instead of the week I earned it. Ended up needing to talk to EDD about it. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone and confirmed the week in question - the agent told me which form to submit to explain the correction and said the overpayment could potentially be waived since it wasn't intentional. I sent in the Application for Overpayment Waiver (DE 1446UI) the same week.

0 coins

If EDD decides to waive an overpayment does that mean the amount just disappears, or does it get deferred or something?

0 coins

A waiver means EDD forgives the amount - you don't have to pay it back. But EDD has to decide you weren't at fault and that repaying it would cause real financial hardship. It's not automatic, they weigh the circumstances.

0 coins

The DE 1446UI is the form for the waiver request. You can appeal an overpayment determination too, separately from the waiver - both options can run at the same time within the 30-day window from the notice date.

0 coins

Pension income is on EDD's list of things that can reduce your benefits, which is different from Social Security - Social Security payments don't get deducted and you don't even report them. If the letter about excess earnings involves a pension payout from the last job, that's worth asking EDD about specifically since the amount of reduction depends on the details of the pension.

0 coins

No pension involved in my situation, just the temp work wages. But good to know Social Security is handled differently than other income types.

0 coins

The Social Security rule trips people up because it's an exception to the general 'report everything' instinct. Everything else in the certifications, yes report it. Social Security, no.

0 coins

Had a coworker convinced her Social Security was going to wipe out her UI benefits entirely. She was relieved to find out it doesn't work that way - Social Security and unemployment run independently of each other.

0 coins

Letter wording on EDD notices is notoriously dense and I went through something similar when my claim hit its maximum benefit amount. EDD sent a notice and all it said was my claim had reached the limit of benefits payable, with the total amount listed. I thought it was an audit or accusation. It just meant I'd used up everything the claim could pay. At that point there's no extension available unless EDD announces Extended Benefits under a specific program, which requires unemployment rates to hit certain thresholds.

0 coins

Mine still has a balance though - does that mean I can keep certifying normally and just ignore the letter for now?

0 coins

If there's still a balance and no action required on the letter, keep certifying as normal. The 30-day appeal window is what matters if you disagree with something specific on the notice.

0 coins

Worth keeping the letter anyway in case questions come up later. EDD correspondence has dates and reference information that can be useful if you ever need to contact them about that specific claim period.

0 coins

Money Network debit card vs. direct deposit - when I first filed I didn't know I could switch to direct deposit through myEDD and ended up waiting for a card in the mail that added days to getting my first payment. For anyone reading this mid-claim, you can update your payment method in myEDD, and either way payments often post within 24 hours of certifying online.

0 coins

The card mailing delay on a first claim is real. Setting up direct deposit before that first payment hits is worth doing as soon as your claim processes.

0 coins

The UI Online Payments tab updates daily too, so you can check there or call 1-866-333-4606 anytime since that line runs 24 hours if you just want payment status without waiting to reach a person.

0 coins

Form 1099G at tax time is something to keep in mind if you're on a claim right now. UI benefits count as federal taxable income even though California doesn't tax them. At each certification you have the option to have 10 percent withheld for federal taxes. The 1099G shows up in UI Online under Payments each January and EDD also mails it unless you went paperless.

0 coins

Can you change the withholding election partway through a claim or is it locked in once you set it at the start?

0 coins

You can change it at any certification - it's not locked in. If your situation changes and you'd rather handle federal taxes yourself at the end of the year, you can turn withholding off, and vice versa.

0 coins

The temp agency situation described in the original post is worth unpacking a bit - temp agencies are employers and their wages count exactly like any other job for both base period purposes and for in-claim reporting. I worked temp assignments while on claim and reported every shift. The key was making sure I reported for the week I actually did the work, not when the temp agency's payroll cut the check.

0 coins

Mine was definitely reported in the right weeks - I was really careful about that. So I'm hoping this letter is just a notice about my claim balance math and not anything about my reporting.

0 coins

If you reported correctly and the letter just references the 40x earnings ceiling language, that's most likely a notice explaining how your maximum benefit amount was calculated rather than an accusation of anything.

0 coins

EDD sends these explanatory notices as part of regular claim processing. The scary official envelope doesn't always mean something is wrong - sometimes it's just EDD documenting the numbers on your account.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure