Back to California Unemployment

Ezra Bates

Unemployment overpayment letter missing repayment information form 1099g taxes - what do I do?

Got an overpayment notice from EDD last week and I'm honestly more confused than when I started reading it. The letter says I owe them back for some weeks from earlier this year but there's literally no instructions on how to actually pay it back. No payment portal, no address to send a check, no form, nothing. Then on top of that I got my Form 1099G and the number on it includes those overpaid weeks. So now I'm looking at a tax situation where I'm supposed to report income I apparently wasn't entitled to in the first place? Like do I still have to pay federal taxes on money EDD now says I owe back? I did report all my work and wages when I certified every two weeks, never hid anything. The overpayment letter doesn't say fraud anywhere on it so I assume it's the non-fraud kind but I'm still freaking out. Anyone dealt with this before - specifically the part where the repayment instructions are just... missing from the letter? And the 1099G issue on top of it?

Overpayment from EDD with no repayment info on the letter - that one caught me off guard too. My situation was a DE 1099Z mailing that showed more than what hit my Money Network card, and I genuinely could not figure out what EDD wanted me to do about the balance. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with a live EDD agent after I'd spent two days getting the busy signal. The video showing how to reach a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see it first. What I actually needed to ask was whether the overpayment amount would affect my remaining balance on the claim, and the agent pulled up my account and confirmed the weeks in question and told me EDD would mail a separate notice with the repayment instructions within about two weeks of the overpayment notice. The 1099G I'd already received showed the gross amount paid, not what I'd be required to repay, so the agent said to report what's on the form and sort the tax adjustment through IRS guidance for repaid benefits.

0 coins

Did the separate repayment notice ever actually come? I got my overpayment letter over three weeks ago and nothing else has shown up yet.

0 coins

Mine came about 11 days after the original notice. If it's been three weeks I'd phone EDD at 1-800-300-5616 the same day you can get through - could be a mail delay or the account still being reviewed.

0 coins

The 1099G reporting piece is what's stressing me out most. So you just report what the form says even though part of it was overpaid? That feels wrong.

0 coins

The 1099G thing trips a lot of people up - EDD issued it for every dollar they paid you, full stop. The IRS has a rule called the claim of right doctrine that covers repaid benefits. Basically if you repay an amount that you already reported as income in a prior year, you can either deduct it or take a tax credit in the year you actually repay it, depending on how much it is. But you don't just subtract it from the 1099G before filing - you report the form as-is and handle the repayment on the return for the year you paid it back. Talk to a tax person if the amount is significant.

0 coins

So if I repay EDD this year I'd handle the tax credit on this year's federal return, not amend last year's? Just want to make sure I understand that right.

0 coins

Exactly. You report the 1099G on the year it was received. Then when you repay, you deal with it on the year of repayment. The IRS has a worksheet for it - worth looking up 'repaid benefits claim of right' on irs.gov.

0 coins

Wait does California also tax unemployment? I thought I read somewhere it doesn't.

0 coins

California does not tax unemployment benefits at the state level, so the 1099G only matters for federal taxes. The state income tax piece doesn't apply here.

0 coins

Can you check whether the letter says anything about an Appeal Form DE 1000M? Because sometimes EDD sends the overpayment notice and wants you to reply within 30 days if you disagree. If you think the determination is wrong you have that 30-day window from the mailing date on the notice. Missing it makes things way harder to fix later.

0 coins

The letter did come with an appeal form actually. I reported everything correctly when I certified so I'm wondering if I should appeal or just wait to see what the repayment notice says.

0 coins

If you genuinely reported everything right, filing the appeal protects you while EDD sorts it out. Keep certifying in the meantime if your claim is still open - you need certified weeks on record in case any are owed to you after the appeal.

0 coins

What counts as the mailing date though, the postmark or when I actually got it? I always assumed it was when I received it but that could eat into the 30 days pretty fast.

0 coins

It's the date printed on the notice itself, not when you got it in the mail. So if it sat in transit for a week that week is already gone from your 30 days. Act sooner rather than later.

0 coins

The repayment instructions missing from the initial notice is actually pretty common from what I've seen on here. EDD typically sends the overpayment determination letter first and then follows up with the repayment booklet separately. But if more than two weeks pass without it, calling EDD directly is the move - they can tell you whether a repayment plan is set up or whether the account is still pending something.

0 coins

How long did others usually wait before the follow-up notice came? Trying to figure out if I should start calling now or give it more time.

0 coins

Two weeks from the overpayment notice date seems to be the typical window. After that I wouldn't wait any longer.

0 coins

Got mine in about 10 days. Had a whole payment coupon book included with the second mailing which I genuinely did not expect - thought it would be an online portal.

0 coins

Something that helped me when I was in this situation was going into UI Online under Claim History and checking whether the overpaid weeks were listed there separately. Not that it shows you how to pay, but it confirmed for me exactly which weeks EDD flagged so I could match them against my own records before deciding whether to appeal or accept the overpayment.

0 coins

Just checked Claim History and I can see which weeks are listed as the issue. They match a period where I had some part-time hours - I reported those wages when I certified but I wonder if the numbers got entered wrong somewhere.

0 coins

If you reported them and you have your pay stubs to prove it, that's exactly the kind of thing worth appealing. Document the gross wages for each week and what you reported when you certified and lay it out in the appeal.

0 coins

Does UI Online actually show overpayment amounts or just which weeks? Mine just shows Pending for a few weeks and I can't tell what that means in dollar terms.

0 coins

For me it showed the weeks flagged but not a dollar breakdown - the actual amount was only in the letter. Pending weeks usually mean EDD is still deciding something, which could or could not be related to an overpayment question.

0 coins

The waiver option is worth knowing about too. If the overpayment wasn't your fault and EDD agrees it wasn't fraud, you can request a waiver by filing the DE 1446UI. EDD looks at whether repaying would cause extraordinary financial hardship. No guarantee they approve it, but it's an option that exists and doesn't cost you anything to ask for.

0 coins

I had no idea there was a waiver form. Would filing for a waiver stop the repayment clock while they decide?

0 coins

I honestly don't know the answer to that one - it's worth asking EDD directly when you get through to them. Don't assume repayment is on pause just because you filed the waiver form.

0 coins

What's the DE 1446UI? Is that something you have to request or does EDD send it automatically with the overpayment notice?

0 coins

Usually you have to ask for it - EDD doesn't always include it automatically. You can request it by calling EDD or through a message in your UI Online account.

0 coins

ARE WE ALL JUST GOING TO IGNORE HOW BROKEN THIS IS?? Getting an overpayment notice with no repayment instructions and then also getting a 1099G for money you have to give back is insane. I went through almost this exact thing - got a determination that some of my weeks were overpaid because my employer apparently reported my final paycheck differently than I did. EDD couldn't explain it over chat, the phone line was impossible to get through, and the repayment booklet took FOUR WEEKS to show up. Meanwhile taxes were due. The whole system is designed to confuse people.

0 coins

Final paycheck on the employer's end being reported differently - same exact thing happened to me and my hours for those weeks. My case was about two weeks in January where EDD got a different wage number from my old job than what I'd reported. Got the overpayment notice for $412 and I had no idea what the difference even was. Used Claimyr to get to an EDD agent and she actually pulled up both numbers side by side on my account, told me the employer had reported my vacation payout for those weeks as wages even though I'd already noted those were termination wages. Filed the DE 1000M that same day.

0 coins

See, that's what I mean - there's no way to even know what the discrepancy is until you get a person on the phone. The online systems don't show you enough detail to understand what happened.

0 coins

Quick reality check on the 1099G: the amount on it is whatever EDD actually paid you during that calendar year. If the overpayment determination came this year for weeks from last year, your last year's 1099G already reflects those payments and you have to report them. The IRS provision for repaid amounts handles the other end of it - but that's a tax question, not an EDD question. EDD issued the 1099G correctly by their own rules.

0 coins

So EDD isn't going to issue a corrected 1099G even if I end up repaying everything?

0 coins

Correct - they won't. The 1099G shows what was paid. The repayment is handled on your end through your federal return in the year you repay. EDD's job on the 1099G is done from their perspective.

0 coins

This is really helpful to understand. I was expecting EDD to fix the 1099G number but it sounds like that's just not how it works.

0 coins

Appealing while also requesting the waiver is something people don't realize they can do at the same time. If you disagree with the determination, appeal it within 30 days using the DE 1000M. If you agree you were overpaid but it wasn't your fault and repaying would be a hardship, request the DE 1446UI waiver. Those are two separate paths that aren't mutually exclusive. Doing both hedges your situation if the appeal doesn't go your way.

0 coins

Can you actually do both simultaneously? I was afraid submitting a waiver request would look like I was admitting the overpayment was legitimate.

0 coins

You're not wrong that it could read that way, honestly. If you're confident you reported correctly and have documentation, the appeal is probably your strongest position. The waiver is more for situations where you know the overpayment happened and you just can't pay it back. Worth talking to EDD or even a legal aid office about your specific situation before deciding.

0 coins

Are legal aid offices actually useful for EDD appeal stuff? I always assumed they only handle bigger things.

0 coins

Many California legal aid offices have workers' rights programs that do handle unemployment appeals. It varies by county but it's worth looking up your local one - representation at a CUIAB hearing is allowed and sometimes really matters.

0 coins

How did the original notice get to you - was it in myEDD or just physical mail? Mine keep showing up in the mailbox days after they're dated and I always wonder if people whose paperwork went paperless are getting earlier notice.

0 coins

Physical mail only for me. I don't think overpayment determinations go through UI Online messages the same way regular claim updates do.

0 coins

That's frustrating. Mail adds so much uncertainty when you're counting days toward a 30-day appeal window.

0 coins

Physical mail is how EDD sends these official determination notices - the date on the letter is what counts for the 30-day window, not when you open it. No way around it currently.

0 coins

Repayment plan is something you can specifically ask EDD about - you don't have to pay the whole overpayment in one shot. I had a $680 non-fraud overpayment from earlier this year and when I finally got an agent on the phone through Claimyr, I asked whether I could set up installments. The agent confirmed a payment plan was possible and told me to request it in writing through my UI Online account. The $680 was from a week where my hours were misreported and I was going to appeal it, but the plan gave me breathing room while I decided.

0 coins

Payment plan option - I really needed to hear this. The lump sum would genuinely wreck me right now. Did you request it through the message center in UI Online or through the repayment booklet?

0 coins

I sent a message through the UI Online account first to get it in writing, then followed up by phone to confirm they received it. The agent had noted my account from the first call, which helped.

0 coins

Does a payment plan affect whether you can still appeal the overpayment? Or does starting a plan mean you're accepting it?

0 coins

Genuinely a good question and not one I know the answer to for sure. I was in a situation where I accepted the overpayment and was just managing repayment, not disputing it. If you're planning to appeal, ask EDD directly before starting a payment plan.

0 coins

Waiting week question because I never understood this - if you get an overpayment notice does that affect the waiting week on your original claim? Or is that totally separate?

0 coins

Completely separate. The waiting week is just the first week of a new claim that goes unpaid - it's always been there regardless of what happens later with any overpayment. An overpayment determination doesn't change how the waiting week worked at the start.

0 coins

Got it, I was confusing myself. I thought maybe EDD could retroactively apply the waiting week to a different point to create an overpayment or something. That doesn't make sense now that I think about it.

0 coins

Does filing the appeal stop EDD from collecting on the overpayment while it's pending? I appealed one of mine and kept getting notices about the balance while waiting for the hearing date.

0 coins

An appeal filed with the CUIAB doesn't automatically pause collection - EDD can still pursue it. The important thing is that you appealed before the 30 days ran out. At the hearing, if the administrative law judge rules in your favor, the overpayment gets reversed.

0 coins

That's what I figured but it was stressing me out getting balance notices while knowing the appeal was in. Good to know the hearing can fully reverse it if I win.

0 coins

Keep copies of everything you send to CUIAB and everything they send back. The Notice of Hearing will come by mail at least 10 days before - don't miss it.

0 coins

Does the 1099G in UI Online show the same number as the one EDD mailed? Just wondering if there's ever a mismatch between the two.

0 coins

They should match - the one in UI Online under Payments and then Form 1099G is the same document EDD mailed. If yours shows a different number between the two, that would be unusual and worth flagging to EDD directly.

0 coins

Mine matched when I checked. I was just being paranoid honestly.

0 coins

My employer reported wages for a week I called in sick and EDD flagged it as an overpayment because the wage amount looked like I'd worked a full week. Took me three weeks to get through on the phone and when I finally talked to someone they said the employer submitted a correction but it was still pending on EDD's end. These discrepancies between what you report and what an employer reports can sit in limbo for a long time.

0 coins

That's exactly what I'm worried happened to me - wages I reported accurately but the employer's numbers don't match. Did your situation eventually get resolved in your favor?

0 coins

It did but it took about six weeks after the employer correction went through. I checked Claim History repeatedly and eventually the pending weeks updated. Never fun to wait but it did work out.

0 coins

Employer wage reporting mismatches seem like they happen way more often than EDD acknowledges. I had a similar situation with a final pay period that crossed a month boundary.

0 coins

Can someone clarify - the person who posted mentioned they 'certified every two weeks' and I want to make sure I'm doing this right. Is it every two weeks or is there some option to do it weekly? I've been reading conflicting things.

0 coins

California unemployment is certified every two weeks, not weekly. That's how EDD structures it. Wherever you read that it was weekly might have been about a different state or an old pandemic-era program - in California right now it's every two weeks through UI Online, by phone on EDD Tele-Cert, or by mail.

0 coins

Thank you! I was so confused. I've been certifying every two weeks and started second-guessing myself.

0 coins

Every two weeks is correct. The first certification usually covers your waiting week plus one paid week. After that it continues on that same two-week cycle.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for people worried about the tax piece - EDD benefits are not taxed at the California state level, so whatever is on your 1099G is only relevant for federal purposes. I didn't realize this for two years and was overpaying my state return because I thought I had to report it both places.

0 coins

Wait really? I definitely added mine to my California state return last year. That was a mistake?

0 coins

Yes - unemployment benefits are exempt from California state income tax. If you included it on your state return in prior years you may want to look into amended returns. A tax preparer can confirm but EDD's own materials say state income tax doesn't apply to UI benefits.

0 coins

Confirmed - EDD is clear on this. Federal taxable, California state exempt. The 1099G goes on the federal return only.

0 coins

DE 1080CZ in my mailbox about six weeks ago was not how I wanted to start a Tuesday. The overpayment amount was $340 for three weeks where EDD said my part-time wages reduced my benefit more than I'd calculated. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr after getting nowhere with the message center. The agent walked me through the earnings formula - turns out the first $25 or 25 percent of gross weekly earnings, whichever is larger, isn't counted against your weekly benefit amount, and the rest comes out dollar for dollar. I'd been calculating it on net pay, not gross, which was the source of the discrepancy.

0 coins

The gross versus net piece - that might actually be what happened with me too. I was definitely thinking about my take-home pay when I was mentally checking my numbers, not gross.

0 coins

Worth going back and running the math on gross wages for each week in question. If the formula works out differently it could be the basis of an appeal.

0 coins

So if someone earns $200 gross in a week and their weekly benefit amount is $400, what do they actually get paid for that week?

0 coins

Using those numbers: 25 percent of $200 gross is $50, which is larger than $25, so $50 is excluded. The remaining $150 gets subtracted from the $400 weekly benefit amount, leaving a payment of $250 for that week.

0 coins

The appeal hearing itself is way less intimidating than it sounds. Had mine with a CUIAB administrative law judge over the phone last spring. You give testimony under oath, explain your side with whatever documentation you have, and the judge asks questions. I had my pay stubs and my certification records printed out and that was it. Decision came in the mail a few weeks later.

0 coins

Testimony under oath - does that mean if I make any mistake in what I say it could hurt me?

0 coins

Honestly just be accurate and stick to what you actually know and have records for. The judge isn't trying to trap you, they're trying to understand what happened. If you're not sure about something, say so.

0 coins

You're allowed to represent yourself at a CUIAB hearing or bring representation - a union rep, attorney, whoever you want. Especially if the amount is significant, having someone familiar with unemployment appeals in your corner helps.

0 coins

The fact that you have to go through an entire formal hearing process just to fix what might be EDD's own bookkeeping error is what gets me. But at least the process exists.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD try to collect on an overpayment by taking it from future benefits? I read somewhere they can do that.

0 coins

EDD can collect unpaid overpayments from future unemployment benefits, disability benefits, Paid Family Leave, state tax refunds, lottery winnings and other money the state owes you. It's not an immediate garnishment of your paycheck but future state payments can be intercepted. That's why getting the repayment or waiver situation sorted is worth doing quickly.

0 coins

So if I file for DI later and still have an unpaid overpayment balance, they could take from that? Good to know, definitely filing the appeal before the 30 days are up.

0 coins

The tax refund interception is what caught someone I know off guard - they forgot about an old overpayment balance and found out when their state refund disappeared.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure