Back to California Unemployment

Zane Gray

Unemployment fraud suspension file new claim prompt - how to certify with California EDD?

Got hit with what EDD is calling a fraud suspension on my account about six weeks ago and I'm completely lost on what to do next. Here's the situation: I filed a new claim after getting laid off from my warehouse job in September, went through the whole ID.me verification process, and then out of nowhere UI Online started prompting me to 'file a new claim' every time I tried to certify. No Notice of Determination in the mail yet, no explanation on the screen, nothing in my Claim History except weeks showing as Pending. I've heard from people at my old job that this sometimes happens when EDD flags something as potential fraud even if you didn't do anything wrong. My benefits were coming in fine for about three weeks after I filed, then everything just stopped and now I can't get past that new claim prompt screen. I still need to certify for the weeks I missed but clicking through that prompt takes me in circles. Does anyone know what this new claim prompt actually means when you're in a fraud suspension situation? Can I even certify for back weeks once this gets resolved? I really need to understand the process because I have no idea if I should be filing a brand new claim or waiting for whatever EDD is doing to finish.

DE 1080CZ notices about a false statement disqualification sat in my mailbox for two weeks before I even opened them because I thought it was junk mail - two of them, same issue, different weeks flagged. Filed in early October, same warehouse sector. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent after the hold music cut me off three times in a row; there's a video on reaching a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. When I actually got someone on the phone I asked straight up whether I could certify for weeks that happened before the disqualification notice date, and the agent pulled up my account and confirmed which weeks were still certifiable and which had been frozen. She also told me my Claim History would stay in Pending until the adjudication on the false statement question was resolved, one way or the other. I went ahead and filed my appeal using the DE 1000M that came with the second notice, mailed it to the address on the form, and kept certifying for every week that wasn't frozen.

0 coins

Eighth week of this same loop on my claim - the new claim prompt appears, I back out, try to certify, get the prompt again. Did the agent say anything about whether the weeks before the freeze ever get paid out even if the appeal takes months?

0 coins

What she told me was specific to my account, so I can't say it'll match yours exactly - but on my claim the pre-freeze weeks were separate from the disqualification period and they did eventually process once the adjudication closed. Keep certifying for whatever weeks the system lets you touch.

0 coins

The appeal part is what I keep second-guessing. 30 days from the mailing date on the notice, right? Not 30 days from when you actually open it?

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date printed on the DE 1080CZ itself, not the day you read it. That's why checking the date the minute the envelope arrives matters a lot.

0 coins

Fraud suspension and a 'file new claim' prompt are actually two separate problems that can look identical on UI Online, which is what makes this so confusing. The prompt showing up during certification usually means EDD has flagged your existing claim and essentially locked the certification path - it's not literally asking you to abandon your old claim and start over, even though it reads that way. What you want to ask EDD is whether your current claim has been suspended or disqualified, because the answer determines whether you appeal the existing claim or whether something went wrong with identity verification that just needs to be cleared up. If EDD issued a false statement disqualification, it comes on a Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) and you get 30 days from the mailing date to appeal using the DE 1000M form that comes with it. Keep certifying for every week the system will accept while the appeal is open - the CUIAB can only award back pay on weeks you actually certified for.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

So the 'file new claim' button is essentially a dead end I shouldn't click? My account never gave me a DE 1080CZ yet, it's been six weeks of Pending and silence.

0 coins

Six weeks with no notice and only Pending weeks is a different situation than a confirmed disqualification. EDD may still be in the middle of adjudication, or identity verification might be holding things up. Contact EDD through Ask EDD in your UI Online account and ask specifically whether your claim has been suspended for a fraud investigation or whether there's an identity issue still open - those two things get resolved differently and you don't want to mix them up.

0 coins

Same Pending limbo for me right now, week five. I keep thinking maybe I should just file the new claim like the button says but everyone I talk to says don't do it.

0 coins

Filing a new claim while your existing one is suspended doesn't erase the suspension issue - EDD will still have the original flag on file and the new claim will likely hit the same wall. The underlying question has to get resolved first.

0 coins

Went through almost exactly this in the spring. The fraud suspension on my account turned out to be tied to a former employer who reported my separation date differently than I did. EDD scheduled a phone interview (I got the DE 4800 notice in the mail with the date and time on it and also saw it on my UI Online homepage), the interviewer phoned at the time listed, I explained my side, and about three weeks later the Pending weeks either paid or came back as a denial I could appeal. The key thing nobody told me upfront: the certification path doesn't re-open automatically after the interview - I had to call EDD to confirm the hold was lifted before I could get back in.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

Did the DE 4800 show up before or after your Claim History started showing Pending? Mine went Pending first and I still haven't seen any interview notice.

0 coins

Pending showed first by about a week and a half on my claim. The DE 4800 came in a separate envelope, easy to miss if you're not watching the mailbox every day.

0 coins

My employer reported a totally different last day of work than what I put and EDD flagged it as a discrepancy, not fraud. Still got the phone interview and had to explain everything under oath. Employer ended up not responding and EDD went with what I said.

0 coins

Employer not responding is actually significant - EDD's own process says the employer loses the ability to appeal if they don't respond within 10 days of the DE 1101CZ. That worked in my favor too.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD is going to voluntarily explain the difference between a fraud flag and a standard adjudication hold unless you ask them directly by name. I had three different calls where the rep just said 'your claim is under review' without telling me which of the two it was. The question that finally got me an actual answer was: 'Is there a false statement disqualification open on this claim or is it in adjudication for a separation issue?' Those are two different tracks with two different resolution paths and they won't volunteer which one you're in.

0 coins

Three calls and nobody told you which track you were on?? I would have lost my mind. EDD's hold times alone are enough to break a person.

0 coins

Completely lost it, yes. Fourth call I had the question written on paper in front of me and read it off the page so I wouldn't get flustered and accept a vague answer again.

0 coins

Preparing the exact question in writing before you call is genuinely what works. The reps aren't trying to be unhelpful most of the time, they just move to the next thing unless you hold the conversation where you need it.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up early on: I kept calling the phone interview an 'appeal hearing' and the reps kept having to correct me. The interview (DE 4800) is EDD gathering information from you and your employer before making a decision. The appeal hearing is what happens after EDD issues a decision you disagree with and you file the DE 1000M - a totally different step, in front of an administrative law judge at the CUIAB. Getting those two mixed up means you might wait for a 'hearing' that's never coming when what you actually got was an interview notice.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

I've definitely been using those two terms interchangeably, so thank you for that. If I haven't gotten a DE 4800 at all yet, does that mean EDD hasn't started adjudication or just that the interview isn't the route they're taking for my specific issue?

0 coins

Not all holds involve an interview - identity verification issues, for example, get resolved through ID.me rather than a phone interview. If your Pending weeks are related to ID verification rather than a separation question, you wouldn't get a DE 4800 at all. That's another reason to contact EDD and ask what type of hold is on your account specifically.

0 coins

Spent two months thinking I was waiting for an appeal hearing when what I'd actually received was just the interview notice. By the time I figured out the difference the 30-day appeal window on the actual determination had almost closed.

0 coins

30 days goes fast when you're confused about what step you're even on. Reading the form number on whatever arrives in the mail before anything else is worth making a habit of - DE 4800 is an interview, DE 1080CZ is a determination you can appeal.

0 coins

My fraud disqualification came with a 30 percent penalty tacked on, which I didn't understand at first. If EDD decides it's a 'false statement' situation - meaning they concluded you intentionally gave wrong information - they add that penalty on top of whatever they're claiming you were overpaid, and you can also get a false statement disqualification of anywhere between 2 and 23 weeks where you're not eligible even if you file again. If it turns out to be non-fraud, there's no penalty, but you still have to pay back the overpayment. The difference between those two findings matters enormously for what your account looks like going forward.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

The 2-to-23-week disqualification range is terrifying. Is there a way to know which end of that range you'd be looking at before the determination comes out?

0 coins

EDD doesn't publish how they set that number for individual cases, so you won't know until the DE 1080CZ arrives. What you can do is prepare documentation that supports your side of the story so that if you appeal, you're walking in with evidence.

0 coins

The overpayment waiver option is worth asking about too if yours ends up non-fraud. There's a form for it - the DE 1446UI - and EDD considers whether paying it back would cause serious hardship. No guarantee, but it exists.

0 coins

DE 1446UI waiver only works for non-fraud overpayments though. If EDD classified yours as fraud, the waiver path isn't available and you're looking at the full amount plus the penalty.

0 coins

That 'file new claim' prompt kept showing up on my account for weeks and I finally learned it was because my existing claim's benefit year had been suspended mid-stream. When a fraud investigation is open, EDD can freeze the whole benefit year in place - so the system shows the prompt because it technically can't advance your existing claim while the freeze is active. Filing a new claim into that situation just creates a second mess on top of the first. What eventually cleared mine was the adjudication closing and EDD processing a Notice of Determination, then I could either accept the outcome or file the DE 1000M. I used Claimyr to reach an agent and ask whether there was anything left open on my identity verification because I wasn't sure if that was part of the hold - the agent confirmed my ID was clear and that the only open issue was the separation question from my former employer, which helped me stop chasing the wrong problem.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

So the prompt being there doesn't mean EDD actually wants me to start a new claim, it's essentially just the system not knowing what else to show when the existing claim is frozen. That reframing helps a lot.

0 coins

Exactly - it reads like an instruction but it's more like the system hitting a wall and defaulting to the new claim screen. Wait for the determination, respond to whatever EDD sends you.

0 coins

Had the same frozen benefit year situation. Asked EDD through the message system in UI Online what the prompt meant and they just replied with a form letter. Actually reaching someone by phone was the only way to get a straight answer about what was holding things up.

0 coins

Question for people who got past this: once the fraud suspension was resolved and your ability to certify came back, could you certify for the weeks that piled up during the freeze all at once, or did EDD limit how many back weeks you could do?

0 coins

Back certifications are limited - you can't go back indefinitely and certify for every frozen week once the hold lifts. Contact EDD when the hold resolves and ask specifically which weeks are still open for certification, because some may have closed out depending on how long the process took.

0 coins

That's what I was afraid of. So the advice to keep certifying for whatever the system will accept during the freeze matters even more than I realized.

0 coins

EDD Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 sometimes let me certify for weeks that UI Online was blocking during my hold, worth trying if the online path loops on you.

0 coins

DE 429Z came in the mail about two weeks after I filed, showed my weekly benefit amount correctly, and then the fraud flag hit a week later and everything stopped. Spent three weeks trying to get through on the EDD line before I tried Claimyr - got an agent who looked at my claim and found that my ID.me verification had been flagged for a secondary review even though the system showed it as complete on my end. The agent told me to watch for a DE 1326C in the mail and that once I responded to it the identity hold would release. That letter showed up four days later and I took care of it right away.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

DE 1326C - I didn't know that form existed. If that's sitting in a pile of mail I haven't opened, is there a deadline on responding to it?

0 coins

The form itself will have instructions and a deadline printed on it - mine said to respond within a specific number of days. Opening everything EDD sends the day it arrives is not optional when your claim is frozen.

0 coins

My ID.me said verified on my end too but the EDD side still showed something unresolved. The disconnect between what ID.me shows you and what EDD actually received is real and confusing.

0 coins

Appeal process timeline from my experience: mailed the DE 1000M the same day I got the DE 1080CZ, wrote 'postmark by' on the envelope and took a photo of it. About two weeks later I got a Notice of Hearing in the mail confirming an administrative law judge had been assigned - the notice came at least 10 days before the actual hearing date, which is what EDD's own rules say. Hearing was by phone, I testified under oath, presented my documentation, and the judge's written decision came by mail about three weeks after. The whole thing took roughly two months from appeal to decision.

0 coins

Two months is actually faster than what I've heard from other people. Did you have a union rep or attorney, or did you go in yourself?

0 coins

Went in myself. EDD says you can represent yourself, have a union official, or bring an attorney - I had my pay stubs and my own notes from every week I worked, and that was enough for my situation.

0 coins

Photographing the envelope before mailing is exactly the kind of thing that seems like overkill until you need to prove you filed on time. Doing that from now on with anything I send EDD.

0 coins

Overpayment waiver (DE 1446UI) is the piece of this most people don't know about until it's too late. If EDD finds a non-fraud overpayment - meaning the money you got that you weren't supposed to, but it wasn't because you lied - you can ask EDD to waive collecting it back if repaying would cause serious financial hardship. You fill out the DE 1446UI and EDD weighs it. It's not guaranteed and it doesn't apply to fraud cases, but if your situation ends up being classified non-fraud, it's worth asking about rather than assuming you have to come up with the full amount immediately.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

If EDD hasn't issued a determination yet, is it too early to request the DE 1446UI or do I wait and see what the determination says first?

0 coins

Wait for the determination - the waiver is for a confirmed non-fraud overpayment. If you request it before EDD has even classified the situation, you're getting ahead of a process that hasn't reached that point yet.

0 coins

Worth noting that appealing the overpayment and requesting a waiver are different actions. You can appeal the finding itself (saying EDD got it wrong) while also requesting a waiver as a backup (saying even if EDD is right, paying it back would cause hardship). They're not mutually exclusive.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is one more thing that can quietly cause problems during a fraud suspension that people forget about. EDD sends a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) and you have 21 days from the date on that notice to register on CalJOBS and post a resume. If your account was flagged and you got that notice but ignored everything EDD was sending because you were focused on the fraud issue, you might have a CalJOBS violation sitting on top of the fraud hold by now. Worth checking.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

I did register on CalJOBS early on - is there anything I need to do there repeatedly while the freeze is in place, or just the initial registration?

0 coins

The initial registration and resume post is what EDD requires to meet the DE 8405 deadline. The work search requirement continues every week you certify as able and available, but the CalJOBS registration itself is a one-time step. If you already did it, that part's covered.

0 coins

I didn't get a DE 8405 until after my claim was already in adjudication and I genuinely didn't know the 21-day clock had started. Got flagged for that separately from the main fraud question. Two separate holds at the same time was a mess.

0 coins

EDD's phone lines during a fraud suspension situation are one of the most maddening things I've encountered in any government system. The automated menu has no option that maps cleanly to 'my account is frozen and I don't know why' so you end up pressing whatever seems closest and hoping the rep who picks up has the authority to actually look into a suspended claim. I've gotten reps who said they couldn't see anything beyond what UI Online shows me, which is useless.

0 coins

1-800-300-5616 hits differently depending entirely on who answers. Same question, same frozen account, two completely different levels of information from two different reps on two different days.

0 coins

Calling at 8 a.m. on the dot when lines open Monday has consistently gotten me a more experienced-sounding rep than calling midday. No idea if that's real or just luck.

0 coins

Ask EDD through UI Online messages is worth using in parallel with calls - you create a written record of what you asked and when, which matters if you ever need to show EDD you were responsive and trying to resolve the issue.

0 coins

Certifying through EDD Tele-Cert (1-866-333-4606, option 2 with your PIN) got me through weeks that UI Online was refusing to process because of the freeze on my account. Not every week worked that way, but some did. My Claim History in UI Online updated the next day to show those weeks as certified even though I couldn't do it through the website directly. Might be worth trying before concluding you're completely locked out.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

I haven't tried Tele-Cert at all because I assumed if online was blocked everything was blocked. Going to try this tonight for the weeks UI Online won't take.

0 coins

Try it and note which weeks the system accepts. The ones it refuses might be the specifically frozen weeks tied to the investigation, which is itself useful information about what EDD has actually put a hold on.

0 coins

Tele-Cert accepted two weeks for me that UI Online was blocking during my hold. Those weeks got processed once the investigation closed. The ones Tele-Cert also refused were the ones directly tied to the flagged period.

0 coins

Payment info updates on 1-866-333-4606 around the clock too, so I call that line just to check whether anything changed on weeks I certified, without having to wait until 8 a.m. to call the main line.

0 coins

Documentation habit that helped me enormously during my fraud suspension: a simple note in my phone for every EDD interaction - date, time, what I asked, what rep said. When the determination came out different from what two different reps had suggested verbally, I had a record of the calls that helped me build my appeal argument. It's also just calming to feel like you're doing something concrete while everything is frozen.

0 coins

Screenshots of UI Online too - Claim History, the Pending weeks, timestamps. I didn't do that early on and later wished I had a record of exactly what the screen showed on specific dates.

0 coins

Exact same thing. The screen on day one of your fraud hold might look different than the screen three weeks later, and that progression can matter if you end up in front of an administrative law judge.

0 coins

Administrative law judges respond well to organized claimants, in my experience. Showing up with dated screenshots and a log of calls is not excessive - it's the kind of preparation that keeps a hearing from going sideways.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone reading this who is early in the process: your benefits are federal taxable income, but California doesn't tax them at the state level. If EDD eventually pays you a lump sum of back weeks after a fraud investigation closes, the whole amount hits your federal return for that calendar year. That surprised me and I hadn't set aside anything for it. You can elect 10 percent federal withholding at each certification, which I'd recommend once your account unfreezes if the back pay is significant.

0 coins

Form 1099G will reflect the full amount paid in the calendar year, available in UI Online under Payments then Form 1099G by January 31 for the previous year. If a big backlog of weeks pays out in December, it all shows up on that one 1099G.

0 coins

December timing was exactly what happened to me. Lump sum in mid-December, full federal tax hit for a year where I'd only worked nine months. Would have made very different withholding choices if I'd understood that in advance.

0 coins

ID.me verification flagged my account even though I had verified successfully - EDD's side apparently didn't receive the confirmation the way it should have. After weeks of Pending and no movement, I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr about whether my identity hold was actually cleared or still open on their end. The agent confirmed EDD had received the ID.me verification but that a secondary manual review had been queued and hadn't been completed yet. Knowing the actual status meant I could stop second-guessing whether I needed to go through ID.me again and just wait for the manual review to close.

0 coins

Zane Gray

Author

Secondary manual review existing as a separate step after ID.me shows verified is exactly the kind of thing EDD doesn't tell you about upfront. So the solution was just to wait it out once you knew that's where you were?

0 coins

Yes - once I knew the specific step it was stuck on, there was nothing for me to do but wait. That's actually useful information even though it's frustrating, because I stopped doing things that weren't going to help.

0 coins

ID.me showing verified on your end and EDD's system showing a hold at the same time is incredibly common and incredibly confusing. The UI Online Pending status doesn't tell you which step is actually open.

0 coins

Real question about the CalFresh side of this while a claim is frozen: can you still apply for CalFresh using the suspended EDD claim as proof of unemployment income, or does the account freeze affect what counts as proof? Asking because I've been in Pending for seven weeks and need to figure out food assistance while this drags on.

0 coins

CalFresh eligibility is based on your actual financial situation right now, and unemployment benefits are listed as a type of income you can report when you apply. Whether a pending or suspended claim qualifies as proof of income is the county CalFresh office's call, not EDD's. Applying at BenefitsCal or calling 1-877-847-3663 and explaining exactly what your EDD situation is will get you the county's answer directly.

0 coins

Applying at BenefitsCal and explaining the suspended status is what I'll do then. Didn't know if the freeze on my EDD account somehow made the claim not count as reportable income.

0 coins

CalFresh and EDD are separate systems - EDD's freeze doesn't reach into the county's CalFresh determination. The county just needs to know what income you're receiving or expecting; explain the pending status and let them assess it.

0 coins

Week nine on my end, still Pending, no DE 1080CZ, no DE 4800, no DE 1326C, nothing in the mail except the original DE 429Z and a CalJOBS notice I already handled. UI Online just shows the new claim prompt every time I try to certify. At what point is the lack of any determination notice itself a problem I can escalate?

0 coins

Nine weeks with no determination and no interview notice is a long time. Send a message through Ask EDD in your UI Online account asking specifically what the hold type is and when a determination is expected. Create a written record that you asked. If you still get no meaningful response, 1-800-300-5616 at 8 a.m. and ask the same specific question the person above mentioned - fraud investigation or separation adjudication, which one is open.

0 coins

Drafted the Ask EDD message three times and deleted it because I wasn't sure how to phrase it without sounding like I'm admitting to something. Sending it today with the specific question about which type of hold.

0 coins

Phrasing it as a question about the hold type, not an explanation of your innocence, is exactly right. 'What type of hold is currently on claim number X and what is the next step in the process?' - neutral, specific, unemotional. EDD agents respond better to that than to anything that sounds defensive.

0 coins

Sending the Ask EDD message creates a timestamp showing you reached out. If your situation ever goes to an appeal or a hearing, that record of you proactively asking EDD about the hold at week nine is useful context.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure