Back to California Unemployment

AstroAdventurer

Unemployment disqualified for incarceration how to appeal and how long for hearing in California EDD?

Got a Notice of Determination in the mail last week saying my claim was denied because of a period of incarceration in my past. I've been out for about four months now and went through all the right steps to get back on my feet - registered in CalJOBS, applied to jobs every week, did everything EDD asked. My weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z showed $310 and I was counting on that while I look for steady work. The denial letter came with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) and I genuinely don't know what I'm doing here. Has anyone actually appealed a disqualification like this? How long does it take to get a hearing scheduled? Do I keep certifying while I wait? I'm trying not to spiral but this caught me completely off-side and the EDD phone line just rings forever or disconnects me.

30 days is the number that matters here - it's on the mailing date of that Notice of Determination, not the day you got it. I had a disqualification issue on my own claim and ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) - the way it works, Claimyr holds your place waiting on hold so you end up on the phone with a live EDD agent without sitting there yourself. There's a short video on how to reach a live person at EDD that way: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent I spoke to looked at my file and told me which weeks were still pending and what was flagged, so I knew exactly what to put in my appeal letter. Keep certifying every two weeks no matter what - if the appeal goes your way, EDD can only pay back the weeks you actually certified for.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date - got it. The notice is dated last Tuesday so I still have time. Did the agent give you any sense of how long you'd be waiting for a hearing once your appeal was submitted?

0 coins

Agree about certifying through the whole appeal. Lost a chunk of back weeks on my own appeal years ago because I stopped thinking the whole thing was paused. Don't make that mistake.

0 coins

The appeal goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board after EDD takes a first look at it. An administrative law judge runs the actual hearing - you get a Notice of Hearing in the mail at least 10 days before the date. How long between filing and that notice showing up varies a lot depending on caseload.

0 coins

Filing that DE 1000M or even a plain signed letter to the address on the notice both work - either way gets your appeal in. When my claim hit a snag over availability questions, the DE 4800 phone interview got rescheduled twice and I couldn't reach anyone to sort out what was happening. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent who confirmed the interview had actually been completed and told me the decision was pending. That was the information I needed to know I wasn't just being ignored. For an incarceration disqualification specifically, you'll want to lay out in writing the exact dates you were out and available for work, because EDD's decision will have been based on whatever dates they had on file.

0 coins

Makes sense. The dates are actually where I think the error is - the period they flagged overlaps with weeks I was already released and actively job hunting. So that's what I need to spell out in the appeal letter.

0 coins

Dates are everything in these cases. If you have any documentation of your release - paperwork from that period, pay stubs from any work you picked up, anything timestamped showing you were out and available - attach copies to the appeal.

0 coins

Also worth knowing the hearing is under oath but you can represent yourself, have a union rep, or bring an attorney. You don't have to show up alone if the case feels complicated.

0 coins

DE 1000M is the form but honestly a letter works just as well, as long as it's signed and mailed to the address on the denial notice. Write down clearly what you disagree with and why. The judge at the hearing reads the whole record, so the clearer your letter, the better your foundation going in.

0 coins

That's helpful - I was overthinking the form. I'll write out a plain explanation of what the dates actually were and why the disqualification period is wrong.

0 coins

One thing to include: explicitly say you were able and available for work during the weeks in question. That's one of the things EDD checks off for eligibility each week, so naming it directly doesn't hurt.

0 coins

Agree with the available-for-work point. EDD has to see that you met the weekly requirements during those specific weeks, not just that the incarceration dates were different from what they had on file.

0 coins

Heard a few people say you should wait to hear back from EDD before certifying after an appeal and that is not right. Keep certifying every two weeks through the whole appeal process - EDD can only release payment for weeks that are certified. If the administrative law judge rules in your favor, uncertified weeks are gone.

0 coins

Already had one person tell me to pause. Really glad this came up. I'll keep certifying.

0 coins

This needs to be said more often. People assume certifying while disqualified is pointless but it's the only way to get back pay if the appeal wins.

0 coins

Exactly right. The certification is separate from the eligibility decision. Keep them going in parallel.

0 coins

The hearing itself is less intimidating than it sounds. An administrative law judge runs it, you give your side under oath, and there's no prosecutor from EDD arguing against you at the table. The Notice of Hearing comes at least 10 days before, so you'll have time to get your documents together once you know the date.

0 coins

Good to know EDD isn't literally opposing me in the room. I pictured it more adversarial than that.

0 coins

Bring whatever you have that shows your release date and your availability during those weeks. Even a copy of your CalJOBS registration with the timestamp helps show you were doing what you were supposed to do.

0 coins

The judge reads the file before the hearing, so the written appeal you send in now becomes part of what they already know going in. A clear, factual letter actually does a lot of work before you even show up.

0 coins

The 30-day clock on the DE 1080CZ - that's the Notice of Determination - is from the mailing date printed on the notice, not the day it landed in your mailbox. Important difference if there was any delay getting to you. After the 30 days you can still appeal but you'd need to explain why you missed the window, so sending it now is the move.

0 coins

Just double-checked - the mailing date is the 14th so I have until next month. Filing this week to be safe.

0 coins

Smart move not to cut it close. Even if you're confident about the date, postmarks can get messy.

0 coins

My cousin told me I shouldn't appeal because it would look bad on future claims and I really don't think that's how it works?

0 coins

Not accurate at all. Appealing a determination is a standard part of the process EDD itself provides for - the DE 1000M is literally included with the denial notice. Exercising your right to appeal doesn't flag your account or affect future claims.

0 coins

Your cousin is thinking of fraud findings maybe, where there are actual consequences. A standard appeal of a disqualification has no negative effect on future claims. File it.

0 coins

Thank you both - really glad I asked before I talked myself out of it.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is one of those things that can get tangled up with timing for people returning from incarceration. You mentioned you registered - just double-check your resume is posted on there too. EDD's requirement is usually to post a resume within 21 days of the date on that DE 8405 notice. If the resume isn't up, that's a separate issue that can hold payments independent of the appeal.

0 coins

Resume is posted, done that weeks ago. Appreciate the check though - didn't realize there was a 21-day window.

0 coins

Good that you confirmed. CalJOBS issues and disqualification appeals are handled separately so sorting both sides at once is the right call.

0 coins

Something that helped me when my claim had an adjudication flag I didn't understand: the weeks listed in UI Online under Claim History as Pending told me the specific weeks in question before I'd gotten any paperwork. When my hours got cut and EDD put a hold on two weeks, I ended up speaking with an agent through Claimyr - the agent pulled up my file and confirmed which weeks were held and why. For your situation, knowing exactly which weeks are flagged versus just pending helps you write a tighter appeal letter that addresses the right weeks specifically.

0 coins

UI Online shows four weeks marked Pending going back to when I first filed. So those are the weeks I need to address in the appeal. That's actually a useful frame.

0 coins

Four weeks is worth fighting for. Specifying each week and why you were available during each one will make the appeal letter much more concrete than just saying the dates are wrong in general.

0 coins

The written decision from the administrative law judge gets mailed to you after the hearing. If you disagree with that too, there's a second level of appeal to the CUIAB itself. The process has more than one stage so even if the first hearing doesn't go fully your way, it's not necessarily the end.

0 coins

Had no idea there was a second level. That actually helps - I was treating the hearing as the last shot.

0 coins

The CUIAB second level is a real option but most people who have a solid factual case about dates and availability don't end up needing it. Document your release date clearly and you're in decent shape at the first level.

0 coins

The phone interview thing - just want to make sure you understand what it is in this context. When EDD looked at eligibility and found the incarceration issue, they may have already scheduled an interview via DE 4800. If that happened and you missed it, EDD could have made its decision on whatever information it had without your side. Not saying that's what happened but if there was a DE 4800 notice you didn't see, mention that in the appeal.

0 coins

I did get the DE 4800 and I did the interview. The interviewer took my information down. The denial still came. So they had my side and still decided against me, which is why I need the appeal.

0 coins

That actually makes your appeal stronger in a way - you can point to the interview and show what information you gave them, and argue the determination didn't reflect it accurately.

0 coins

If you have the DE 4800 or any notes from the day of the interview, keep those. The appeal record includes whatever EDD had at the time of the determination, so being able to reference what you told the interviewer is useful.

0 coins

People sometimes ask whether a disqualification means the whole claim is gone. The benefit year doesn't disappear because of a disqualification finding. If the appeal succeeds, the weeks you certified during that period can be paid. The claim doesn't restart from scratch.

0 coins

Really needed to hear that. I thought the whole $310 weekly amount was just gone.

0 coins

The DE 429Z showing your weekly benefit amount stays the same through an appeal as long as the benefit year is still open. The disqualification affects specific weeks, not the total claim.

0 coins

And the maximum benefit amount - 26 times the weekly amount or half your base period wages, whichever is less - doesn't get eaten up by weeks that were disqualified and then successfully appealed. Those weeks just get processed.

0 coins

For the appeal letter itself: lead with the specific dates EDD cited in the denial, then immediately follow with the actual release date and what you were doing during those weeks - applying to jobs, doing CalJOBS, available and able to work. Keep it factual and sequential. Judges respond to clear timelines.

0 coins

Timeline format makes a lot of sense. I was going to write it more like an explanation but laying it out date by date will be cleaner.

0 coins

Factual and calm reads better than emotional in these letters. You can note that the determination was distressing but the meat of it should just be dates, documentation references, and what you were doing week by week.

0 coins

Something worth mentioning: anyone can represent you at the CUIAB hearing - yourself, a union rep if applicable, or an attorney. Legal aid organizations sometimes help people with EDD appeals at no cost. Might be worth looking into before the hearing date if the case feels complicated.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about legal aid. If the case hinges on factual dates I'll probably handle it myself but good to know there's an option.

0 coins

Legal aid is easier to find than most people expect for these situations. Worth a call even just to get a quick read on how strong the case looks before the hearing.

0 coins

Also remember the Notice of Hearing gives at least 10 days' notice before the actual hearing date, so you don't have to decide about representation immediately when you file the appeal.

0 coins

Saw a lot of people assume above that the hearing always takes a long time to schedule - actually depends heavily on how many appeals are in queue at that CUIAB office. Some people get heard in a few weeks, some wait longer. No way to predict it, but keeping certifying the whole time means nothing is lost if it takes a while.

0 coins

Certifying continuously regardless of timing - message received. I'll set a reminder every two weeks.

0 coins

EDD Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 on option 2 is an alternative if UI Online is ever giving you trouble on a certification day. Same result.

0 coins

The base period wages question is separate from the disqualification appeal but just making sure: if EDD's denial is about incarceration timing, the DE 429Z showing your $310 weekly amount is based on wages in your highest quarter of your base period - that calculation doesn't change with the appeal. What you're fighting for is the right to actually receive those weeks.

0 coins

Yes, the $310 figure seems right to me based on what I earned. It's purely the eligibility period they got wrong, not the wage calculation.

0 coins

That's a cleaner appeal then - single issue, factual dispute about dates. Those tend to be more straightforward than appeals where both the wage calculation and the eligibility reason are contested.

0 coins

Appeal Form DE 1000M or a plain signed letter both work, but whichever you send, keep a copy and send it with some way to confirm delivery - certified mail or at least photograph the envelope before you drop it. The mailing date matters and you want proof you filed inside the 30 days.

0 coins

Certified mail it is. I'll keep copies of everything.

0 coins

Also note down the date you drop it at the post office. If anything gets disputed about timing later, that record is yours.

0 coins

Address on the denial notice is the right address - don't just send it to a general EDD office. The notice will have the specific Appeals address printed on it.

0 coins

After the hearing the judge mails a written decision. If EDD issued the disqualification because their records showed incarceration overlapping with claim weeks, and you show documentation that the actual release date was before those weeks, the judge has clear grounds to reverse it. These aren't judgment calls the way a misconduct case is - they're factual questions about what dates are correct.

0 coins

That framing helps. This isn't a matter of interpretation, just a matter of which dates are right. I have documentation to support mine.

0 coins

Factual date disputes with supporting documentation are among the more winnable appeals. Keep your paperwork organized and lead with it.

0 coins

Payments tab in UI Online updates daily. Once the appeal is filed and the CUIAB process is moving, you'll be able to see any status changes there. Claim History showing Pending weeks will stay that way until a decision is made, but at least the certifications are logging.

0 coins

I've been checking UI Online daily. Good to know the Payments tab is the one to watch.

0 coins

Also 1-866-333-4606 gives payment information 24 hours a day if you want a quick check without logging in.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure