Unemployment denied for excessive earnings after refiling with low weekly wages — what can I do?
So I got laid off from my warehouse job back in the spring and filed right away. My hours had already been cut for about six weeks before they let me go, so my earnings in the most recent quarter were pretty low compared to what I used to make. EDD processed everything and sent me the DE 429Z, which showed a weekly benefit amount of $112. I thought okay, not great but something is something. Fast forward to now — I reopened my claim after a short contract gig ended, and all of a sudden EDD is denying me for "excessive earnings." I genuinely don't understand how $112 a week gets flagged as excessive anything. I haven't earned more than that in any week since reopening. Everything I certified was honest, I reported my contract earnings, and I even had two weeks where I made zero dollars. Is this something in how EDD calculated my base period? Did the system pull in wages from the wrong quarter? I know my highest earning quarter was like 18 months ago when I was working full time, and I keep wondering if refiling somehow reset or broke the calculation. Has anyone dealt with this specific situation where the weekly amount looks too low for your actual work history and then you get denied for earnings that shouldn't be a problem?
65 comments

Avery Saint
Denied for excessive earnings on a $112 weekly benefit amount — that one hit me differently because I had almost the same thing happen last year. My claim showed a weekly benefit of $134 and I got the same denial after reopening. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent because the phone line was impossible on my own. The agent pulled up my claim and explained that the system had been comparing my reported wages against the weekly benefit amount from the original claim, and there was a mismatch in which weeks were being flagged. They said two of my certified weeks had wages that exceeded the formula — not my full-time wages, just contract income I'd reported — and the system auto-denied based on that. The agent walked me through what the formula actually does: your weekly benefit amount minus the first $25 or 25 percent of gross earnings (whichever is bigger), and if the remainder hits zero the system calls it excessive for that week. So even modest contract earnings can wipe out a low weekly benefit amount entirely. They told me to look at each denied week individually rather than the whole claim. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you're trying to get through. After the call I went back and checked each week — two weeks I'd earned over $134 so I actually got nothing those weeks, which is correct, but EDD had flagged three other weeks incorrectly and I eventually got those paid after submitting a message through UI Online explaining the discrepancy.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorThe formula you described — weekly benefit minus the larger of $25 or 25% — that's the piece I completely missed. At $112 a week, 25% of even $100 in earnings already chews through most of my benefit. So two or three weeks of light contract work could genuinely zero out the payment without being what I'd call excessive earnings. That reframes the denial for me. Did you have to appeal formally or was the UI Online message enough to get those weeks corrected?
0 coins
Taylor Chen
Paycheck from that same kind of contract work tripped me up too. The week I earned $160 on a $134 benefit I didn't expect to get anything, but the week I earned $80 I thought I'd still get something. The formula worked out to $80 times 25% equals $20, so you use the $25 since it's larger, subtract from $134 and I got $109 that week. The math actually worked but EDD had coded one of my weeks wrong and it took a UI Online message to fix it.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
DE 1080CZ in the mailbox always looks worse than it is at first glance, but the "excessive earnings" language on that notice is specifically about individual weeks, not your overall claim. The denial doesn't erase the whole claim — it's a week-by-week decision. Each week you certified, EDD ran your reported earnings through the formula: take whatever you earned gross for that week, give you a pass on the larger of $25 or 25% of that amount, then subtract the rest from your weekly benefit amount. If that subtraction leaves zero or less, that week pays nothing and gets marked as excessive earnings. On a $112 weekly benefit, the math gets tight fast. If you earned $95 gross in a week, 25% of that is $23.75, so you use $25 since it's bigger, subtract $70 from your $112 and you'd get $42. But if you earned $150, 25% is $37.50, subtract $112.50 from $112 and you're at zero — that week is denied. The fix is to look at every individual week on your Claim History in UI Online and match each one to what you reported earning. The weeks that shouldn't be zero are worth contacting EDD about through the message system.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorGoing through each week in Claim History right now and writing down what I reported for each. Two weeks I definitely earned over the threshold so those denials make sense. But there are three weeks showing denied where I either earned nothing or under $50, so something is off on those. I'm going to send a message through UI Online with the specific weeks and amounts.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
The Claim History screen is honestly the most useful thing for this. Each week shows up individually so you can spot exactly which ones are marked wrong instead of trying to figure out the whole claim at once.
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
I had no idea the formula was based on gross earnings for the week they were earned, not when you got paid. My contract usually paid two weeks late and I was reporting on the wrong weeks for months. That's a whole separate mess but worth flagging here because it can make the excessive earnings denial appear on weeks where it shouldn't.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
WAIT because I think there might be a bigger issue here. When you "reopened" the claim after the contract ended — are you sure the system actually reopened the original claim and didn't file a new one? Because if it filed new, it would recalculate your base period using different quarters and your weekly benefit amount could have changed. If the new weekly amount is lower than what you thought, the excessive earnings threshold changes with it. The DE 429Z you got at the start might not be the right number for the reopened claim period.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorThat's genuinely concerning and I hadn't thought of it. I reopened through UI Online and I assumed the $112 weekly benefit amount carried over. But maybe I should check whether a new DE 429Z was mailed after the reopen. I don't remember getting a new one.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Reopening a claim during the same benefit year keeps the same weekly benefit amount and the same base period — a new DE 429Z doesn't get issued just because you reopened. A truly new claim (after the benefit year ends) would recalculate everything. So if the benefit year is still open, the $112 should be the same number EDD is working from.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
Good correction, appreciate that. I was thinking of a situation where someone's benefit year had actually ended and they filed fresh without realizing it. If the year is still open, what the person above said is right.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
My cousin went through something that sounds similar and she just had to appeal — but I want to be careful here because I may be misremembering how she did it. I think she sent a letter?
0 coins
Keith Davidson
An appeal goes in writing within 30 calendar days of the mailing date on the Notice of Determination. The Appeal Form (DE 1000M) is what most people use, or you can write a letter — either one mailed to the address on the notice. For a week-by-week excessive earnings denial where the numbers just don't add up, contacting EDD through UI Online first sometimes gets it corrected without a formal appeal, but if that doesn't work or the 30 days are getting close, filing the appeal protects the right to a hearing.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
Yeah she mailed the DE 1000M. It took a while but she did eventually get a hearing scheduled and an administrative law judge looked at her earnings records. She came out okay. Keep an eye on that 30-day window is the main thing.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
Something that burned me on my own claim — I was reporting earnings for the week I GOT PAID and not the week I actually did the work. Contract gigs especially because sometimes the payment comes in a week or two after the work. EDD wants the week you earned it, not the week the money hit your account. If you did that too, some of those excessive earning weeks might actually be misreported weeks rather than a calculation error.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorI think I may have done this for at least two weeks. The contract I was on paid net-30 and I was reporting when the check cleared. So those weeks might show earnings that I didn't actually earn in that week. How do I correct past certifications? Can I do that in UI Online?
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
Report Wages in UI Online is for before you certify — it won't fix a week you already submitted. For past weeks reported wrong, you need to contact EDD directly. A message through UI Online explaining the specific weeks and what the corrected earnings should be is the way to start.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
Net-30 contract work is such a nightmare for this. I had three months of overlapping payment timing issues and sorting it out took multiple messages and one phone call. The agent I talked to said to just list the actual work dates in the message, not the payment dates, and EDD can compare it to whatever the employer reported.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
$112 a week is below what I'd expect from even a part-time warehouse job over a full year. Without knowing exactly what the base period quarters look like for your claim it's hard to say, but it sounds like EDD might have used only the low-hours quarters when you were already cut back. The standard base period goes back further than most people think — the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your claim started. So your full-time wages from 18 months ago might be right in that window, which should push the weekly benefit higher. Did the DE 429Z show which quarters and wages EDD used?
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorThe DE 429Z does list the quarters — I'm looking at it now. It shows my highest quarter at around $6,200 and the total base period wages at about $14,800. But you're right that my full-time quarters should have been higher than that. The two quarters before the base period started I was earning close to $12,000 each. Those are outside the window completely.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
If the standard base period quarters don't qualify you for enough wages, EDD is supposed to automatically check the alternate base period — the last four completed calendar quarters — which would pull in those more recent high-earning periods. But the alternate base period only applies if the standard base period doesn't produce a valid claim at all. Since your claim was valid (you got the DE 429Z and payments started), EDD likely determined the standard base period gave you enough wages and stopped there, even though it means a lower weekly benefit amount. That's unfortunately how it works, not a mistake.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
My highest earning quarter was also outside the standard base period on my first claim and I spent two weeks thinking EDD had made an error. The alternate base period explanation was the one thing I actually understood when an EDD rep walked me through it. It doesn't switch to give you a better weekly amount — it's just a fallback if the standard window leaves you without a valid claim at all.
0 coins
Lily Young
idk if this helps but i got denied once for "excessive earnings" on a week i literally reported zero dollars earned. turned out i had vacation payout from my old employer that they had reported to EDD even though i didn't enter anything for that week. so sometimes the employer side reports stuff you didn't even know about and it creates a mismatch
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorThis is actually worth checking. My former employer paid out unused PTO when they laid me off. I did report that in my first certifications but I'm not 100% sure I reported it on the right week. If they also reported it on their end for a different week there could be a mismatch.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Vacation pay, PTO payout, and in-lieu-of-notice pay all go on EDD's list of things to report when certifying. The right week for vacation payout is the week it was paid — but honestly for any mismatch between what you reported and what an employer submitted, a message to EDD through UI Online with the documentation is the fastest path to sorting it out.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
Weeks of back-and-forth with UI Online messages and no movement — that was my situation before I finally got someone on the phone. My claim had been flagged for excessive earnings on three weeks where I'd earned under $80 each. The months on my DE 1080CZ were from a certification period that overlapped with a pay period reporting issue. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr after my own call attempts went nowhere, and the agent found that one of my employer's quarterly wage reports had a typo that attached extra wages to the wrong quarter on my claim. The agent flagged it internally and told me to expect a corrected Notice of Determination by mail within a few weeks. Got it about three weeks later and two of the three denied weeks were reversed.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorEmployer quarterly wage reports with errors is something I genuinely hadn't considered. If my old warehouse employer filed something wrong on their end, I'd have no way to see that in UI Online. The only way to find that out would be talking to an agent who can actually look at both sides of the record.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
Former job's payroll department made an error on my wages too and I didn't find out until an EDD agent mentioned it during a different call. It's more common than people think, especially with smaller employers who handle their own payroll.
0 coins
Lily Young
yeah the employer-side data is completely invisible from the claimant side. UI Online shows what you certified but not what the employer submitted. an agent is literally the only way to see that discrepancy.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
30 days goes faster than you think when you're dealing with a denial notice. If you're still figuring out whether to appeal or try to resolve through UI Online messages, you can do both at the same time — file the appeal to protect the deadline and also send the message explaining the error. The appeal doesn't close off the message route.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorFiling the DE 1000M appeal while also working the message route makes sense. I didn't know I could run both simultaneously. I'm going to get that appeal in the mail this week even if I think the message might fix it faster.
0 coins
Justin Chang
Appeal first, sort it out second, that's genuinely the safer order. Missing the 30 days means you need to give a reason for being late and that's another thing to explain on top of the original issue.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
The excessive earnings denial on a low weekly benefit amount is one of those situations that's technically correct by EDD's formula but feels completely unfair if your work history should have produced a higher weekly benefit in the first place. The two things — the denial and the base period calculation — are separate problems that need separate fixes. The denial: appeal within 30 days if any weeks were flagged incorrectly, and use UI Online messages to show the math doesn't work. The base period: if you believe wages were left out or misattributed, that's a question for EDD to look at, but keep in mind the alternate base period only helps if the standard one doesn't produce a valid claim at all.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorSeparating the two issues is exactly the clarification I needed. I was trying to solve them together and getting confused. The denied weeks are one thing — I can go week by week and show the math. The question of whether the base period captured the right wages is a separate inquiry that may or may not lead anywhere given how the alternate base period rule works.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Two-track approach is the right call. I did the same thing on my claim — appealed the denial while also asking EDD separately about the wage records. The appeal resolved faster actually because the ALJ looked at each week's math directly.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Does anyone know if you keep certifying while an appeal is in progress? I've seen conflicting info and I'm about to file my own appeal on a different issue.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Keep certifying every two weeks through the appeal — this is important. EDD can only pay back weeks that were actually certified. If you stop certifying while waiting for the appeal decision, any weeks you skip can't be paid even if you win.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Thank you, I was worried stopping would look like I'd given up on the claim or something. Continuing to certify it is.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
My appeal took about two months from filing to the ALJ hearing and I certified every single two-week period through all of it. When I won, all those certified weeks got paid in one deposit.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Just a word on the UI Online message route — it works but can be slow. I sent a message about an excessive earnings week in mid-October and didn't hear back for almost three weeks. Meanwhile my 30-day appeal deadline was ticking. File the appeal regardless of whether you also message EDD.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorThree weeks for a message response is not what I was hoping to hear but it's good to know going in. Appeal filed this week, message sent today, and now I wait.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
The waiting is rough. Mine did eventually get resolved through the message, but the appeal as backup gave me peace of mind I didn't regret having.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
My weekly benefit amount on my current claim is $178 and I still managed to have three weeks denied for excessive earnings during the stretch I was doing gig work. The gig platform I used paid out weekly and I had a couple of high-earning weeks around the holidays that wiped out my benefit for those weeks, which I actually understood. What I didn't understand was why a week where I earned $60 got flagged. Turned out I had reported that $60 in the wrong certification period — it got stacked with the following week's earnings in the system and pushed that combined total over the threshold.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorCertification period mismatch is exactly the kind of thing that's nearly impossible to catch from your side without seeing how EDD coded it. Did you figure it out from the UI Online Claim History or did you have to contact EDD?
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
Claim History showed me the week was denied but didn't explain why. I had to contact EDD through UI Online messages to get the actual reason. The agent responding to the message told me about the stacking issue and corrected it. Took about 2.5 weeks to hear back but it did get fixed.
0 coins
Lauren Wood
The base period question the OP raised is worth looking at separately from the denial. My claim had a similar situation — I'd been cut to part-time for a full quarter before being laid off, and my weekly benefit amount came out to $156, which was significantly lower than what my full-time earnings would have produced. After getting a denial on two weeks for excessive earnings during some light freelance work, I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent because I wanted to understand whether my base period was calculated correctly. The agent pulled up my earnings record and confirmed the standard base period was used, that it was valid, and that there was no error — my wages in that period just reflected the reduced hours. What actually helped was the agent noticing that one of the two denied weeks had a data entry issue on the employer's quarterly report, and they flagged it. That week eventually got paid. The other week I had genuinely earned over the threshold and the denial was correct.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorEmployer quarterly report data entry issue coming up twice in this thread now — mine and the reply above. I'm increasingly thinking that's what happened on at least one of my denied weeks. The agent being able to see the employer's filed wages side by side with my certifications is information I genuinely can't get any other way.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
Employer-side data errors are frustrating because you can do everything right on your certifications and still end up with a denial that looks like your mistake. Finding out it was the employer's quarterly filing is at least some relief, even if the fix still takes time.
0 coins
Justin Chang
Heads up on the alternate base period for anyone reading this later: it doesn't get triggered by having a low weekly benefit amount. It only kicks in if the standard base period wages aren't enough to give you a valid claim at all. If you got a DE 429Z and started receiving payments, your claim was valid under the standard base period and the alternate base period won't apply — even if your weekly benefit amount feels low because your recent high-earning quarters fell outside the standard window.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
This is the thing that confused me for weeks. I kept thinking EDD could switch to the alternate base period to give me a higher weekly benefit amount, and an agent eventually told me flat out that wasn't how it worked. The alternate base period is a qualifying tool, not a wage-maximizing tool.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
Exactly right. Someone said something earlier in the thread implying the alternate base period might raise a weekly benefit for a valid claim — just want to clarify that's not how it works. Standard base period, valid claim, $112 weekly benefit — that's the number, and the alternate base period doesn't come into it.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
Between the appeal, the UI Online messages, and trying to get EDD on the phone, the whole process feels like three full-time jobs on top of actually looking for work. Keeping up CalJOBS registration and work search records while also untangling a denial is a lot.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorCalJOBS is the thing I'm most paranoid about right now. I registered within the first couple weeks after my original claim but I want to make sure the reopened claim doesn't require me to re-register or update something. I haven't touched it since the original filing.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
The notice EDD sends when CalJOBS registration is required is the DE 8405. If you registered after getting that notice originally, you should be covered — reopening the same claim during the benefit year doesn't trigger a new registration requirement. But if you have any doubt, logging in to CalJOBS and confirming your resume is still posted is never a bad idea.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
My situation with CalJOBS turned into its own problem when my password had expired and I couldn't get back in for almost a week. EDD eventually confirmed my registration was still on file but it was a stressful week of uncertainty.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
Something I want to flag for anyone getting a denial on excessive earnings: make sure you understand what "full-time work" means in this context. I mistakenly thought my part-time gig work was fine because I was under 40 hours, but EDD's formula isn't about hours — it's about dollar amounts relative to your weekly benefit. You can work 10 hours and still have a week where the earnings wipe out your payment entirely if your weekly benefit is low enough.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorThat reframing matters. I was thinking in terms of hours too — "I only worked 15 hours that week so I'm fine." The formula is entirely dollar-based. Even at minimum wage, 15 hours can easily exceed the threshold on a $112 benefit.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
The hours framing trips up a lot of people. I've seen people say they were working part-time so they assumed they'd still get a reduced benefit check, then be surprised when it was zero because dollar-wise their earnings exceeded the weekly benefit amount.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
My claim history on a different issue: I appealed an excessive earnings denial and the ALJ at the hearing went through each certified week one by one with me. The process felt intimidating going in — testimony is under oath, but you can represent yourself and the ALJ I dealt with was pretty direct about just wanting to understand what I earned each week and when. I had my pay stubs organized by week and that made the whole hearing much simpler.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorOrganizing pay stubs by week rather than by pay period is something I need to do now. My contract paid every two weeks so each pay stub covers a full certification period but I need to break it down into individual weeks for the appeal.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
If your contract payroll detailed hours by day, that makes it easier to split across weeks. I had to go back to my timesheets to figure out which day of the week the work actually happened and sort the earnings accordingly.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Administrative law judge hearings feel scary from the outside but week-by-week earnings math is about as concrete as it gets. No ambiguity about whether you quit or were fired or whether something was misconduct — it's just numbers. That's actually in your favor if the math shows the denial was wrong.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
EDD's excessive earnings denial has an almost automatic quality to it when the formula hits zero — the system flags it without anyone actually reviewing whether the underlying data makes sense. That's why getting an agent on the phone matters so much for these cases. Agents can see the employer-submitted wage records, identify mismatches, and flag data issues that UI Online messages alone sometimes miss or take weeks to address.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
AuthorThe pattern in this thread is pretty clear: UI Online messages work but are slow, and an actual agent can see things the message system can't surface as quickly. I'm going to pursue the phone option more aggressively alongside the appeal.
0 coins
Avery Saint
Phone access is the real bottleneck on a lot of these claims. The hold times on 1-800-300-5616 are rough, especially mid-week. Early morning right at 8 a.m. on a Monday or the live chat from the Help button in UI Online between 9 a.m. and 2 p.m. are worth trying if you haven't yet.
0 coins