Back to California Unemployment

Sean O'Donnell

Unemployment after quitting part time job voluntarily and starting new job - California EDD question

Okay so here's my situation and I genuinely cannot find a clear answer anywhere. I was working two jobs - my full time position at a logistics company and a part time retail job on weekends. Got a new full time offer with better pay and hours back in September, which obviously I took. When I did that I quit the part time retail gig because the new job had me working Saturdays and there was simply no way to keep both. So I quit the part time job voluntarily to start the new full time one. Fast forward about three months and the new full time job laid me off. Classic restructuring situation, whole department got cut. So now I'm filing for California EDD unemployment and I'm honestly terrified that the voluntary quit from the retail job is going to come back and haunt me. Like is EDD going to see that I quit a job and just deny the whole thing? My new full time job is definitely the one that counts for my wages but I don't know if the quit from part time triggers some kind of disqualification. Anyone dealt with something like this?

Worried about this same kind of thing last year when I filed. The way the base period wages work is what really matters here - EDD looks at your earnings over a set window and figures out your weekly benefit amount from that. Your full time wages at the logistics company and then the new job are what's going to drive those numbers. The part time retail money probably adds some but isn't the main event.

0 coins

Right but the question isn't really the wage calculation, it's whether the voluntary quit from retail will trigger a disqualification even though I left to take a better job?

0 coins

Yeah the wage piece and the eligibility piece are actually two separate questions EDD looks at. You can have solid wages in your base period and still hit an eligibility issue if there's a quit on the record. Worth knowing both sides of it.

0 coins

Laid off from your new full time position after quitting part time to take it - EDD is going to look at why you left each job. The key thing people get confused about is that the disqualification question attaches to whichever separation is most recent with each employer. Since you were laid off from the full time job, that's your most recent separation and that's the one EDD focuses on for eligibility. You quit the part time job, yes, but you left it to accept new full time work - that's a recognized reason. EDD's own rules say if you quit, you have to show a good reason, and leaving part time work to take a full time job is exactly the kind of thing that tends to satisfy that.

0 coins

So EDD actually looks at the reason for each quit separately? I thought if any quit showed up on the record it was an automatic denial.

0 coins

Not automatic at all. The quit reason matters a lot. 'Quit to accept new full time work' is very different from 'quit because I felt like it.' EDD does a phone interview when there's a question like this and you explain the situation.

0 coins

Used to think the same thing - that any voluntary quit anywhere in your history just kills the claim. That's not how it works. The question is always about why you left and what the circumstances were.

0 coins

DE 1101CZ notice showed up for my former employer to respond to after I filed - my situation was similar, quit a part time seasonal job to take what I thought was a stable full time position, then got laid off four months later. Couldn't get through to EDD by phone for days to ask whether the part time quit was going to be an issue. Tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an EDD agent directly. The video they have on reaching a live person at EDD - https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 - shows what that looks like. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my DE 4800 phone interview was already scheduled for the following Thursday and that the part time separation was one of the questions on it. She said the interview is at the time shown on the DE 4800, so I made sure I was available then and explained that I quit the seasonal job specifically because the full time hours conflicted. That interview went fine.

0 coins

DE 4800 is the phone interview notice? So they'd mail that to me and the time would be listed there and also on UI Online?

0 coins

Yes - the date and time are on the notice itself and also on your UI Online homepage. The agent told me to keep my phone available at that exact time because that's when the interviewer phones in.

0 coins

Glad that worked out. The DE 4800 thing tripped me up too, I didn't realize the interview time was already set until I actually looked at the notice properly.

0 coins

Quit to take a better job is one of those situations where people assume EDD automatically sides with them, but I want to flag something. The question EDD actually asks is whether you had a good reason to quit at the time you quit - and 'good reason' under their rules means something specific. Leaving part time work because new full time work has conflicting hours is a solid reason. But during the phone interview you'll want to be ready to explain the timeline clearly: when you got the full time offer, when you gave notice at the retail job, when the new job started. The clearer your timeline, the smoother the interview goes.

0 coins

That's helpful. So I should basically have my dates ready - offer letter date, last day at retail, first day at the new full time job?

0 coins

Exactly. And if you have anything in writing like an offer letter or a schedule from the new job showing Saturday hours, keep those handy. You may not need them but it doesn't hurt.

0 coins

The timeline thing is real. My interview went sideways briefly because I couldn't remember the exact dates off the top of my head. Interviewer was patient but having it written down in front of you is way easier.

0 coins

Wait, can I ask something kind of related? My situation is a little different - I quit my only job (not for a new one, just quit) and I'm trying to figure out if I even have a shot. Reading this thread made me think maybe not but I'm not sure I understand the rules right.

0 coins

Different situation from the original post. Quitting without another job lined up means you'd need to show EDD a good reason - job conditions, something that made staying unreasonable. It's definitely harder but not impossible. EDD decides after a phone interview.

0 coins

Okay so there's still a process, it's not just an automatic no. That's what I needed to know, thank you.

0 coins

EDD still schedules the interview, hears your side, and makes a decision. The burden of showing a good reason is on you when you quit, but that just means you need to explain your circumstances clearly.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up when I filed: I kept thinking the DE 429Z they mailed was my approval letter. Spent a week thinking I was good to go. That form is actually just the award notice showing what the claim could pay - it doesn't mean EDD decided you're eligible. The actual eligibility decision comes separately after the phone interview and certification.

0 coins

Oh I did not know that distinction. So the DE 429Z just shows the weekly amount but doesn't mean I'm cleared?

0 coins

Right. It tells you the weekly benefit amount based on your wages, not whether EDD has decided the quit issue in your favor. If EDD finds you eligible, the payments just process for the weeks you've certified. If not, you get a Notice of Determination.

0 coins

Made the same mistake. Thought the award notice meant I was approved and then was confused when things were still showing pending in Claim History. They really do mean two different things.

0 coins

How does the base period work when you have wages from two jobs? Like does EDD add both together or just count the main job?

0 coins

EDD adds up wages from all employers in your base period - the standard one is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your claim starts. So yes, your part time retail wages and your full time wages both go into the calculation. The weekly benefit amount comes from your highest-paid quarter across all of that.

0 coins

So having both jobs actually could help the weekly amount since there's more total wages in there?

0 coins

Potentially yes, depending on when you earned what. The quarter where your combined earnings were highest is what EDD uses to set the weekly amount, up to $450 a week.

0 coins

Had a nearly identical setup - two jobs, quit the smaller one to start a bigger one, then got laid off from the bigger one about five months in. EDD did schedule a phone interview because of the quit. Interviewer asked me directly: when did you receive the offer for the full time job, and was the schedule conflict with the part time job the reason you left. Answered both clearly and my claim went through. The pending weeks in Claim History resolved about a week after the interview.

0 coins

That's really reassuring to hear. Did you have to do anything special to prepare or did you just answer the questions they asked?

0 coins

Mostly just answered the questions. I had my dates written down on a piece of paper in front of me which helped. The interview was shorter than I expected, maybe fifteen minutes.

0 coins

Similar experience here. The interviewer was pretty direct, not trying to trip anyone up. Have your facts straight and let them lead the conversation.

0 coins

Is there any chance EDD contacts your old retail employer about the quit? Like would they weigh in on whether your reason was legitimate?

0 coins

EDD does notify employers when a claim is filed. The retail employer could respond. But EDD makes its own decision based on what both sides say - the employer doesn't get to deny your claim, EDD decides.

0 coins

So even if the retail place says 'yeah she just quit with no notice' that doesn't automatically kill it?

0 coins

Correct. EDD hears from both sides and decides. What matters is whether your reason for quitting was good enough under their rules, not whether the employer is annoyed about how you left.

0 coins

Registering in CalJOBS - do you have to do that before or after the phone interview? I got a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work and I'm not sure when that clock starts.

0 coins

The notice itself has a date on it - most claimants have 21 days from that date to register in CalJOBS and post a resume. It runs separately from the phone interview timeline. Missing it can hold up payments so don't let it slide.

0 coins

Okay so I should just go do CalJOBS registration now regardless of where my interview is in the process?

0 coins

Yes, handle it as soon as you get the notice. The CalJOBS registration and the eligibility interview are on separate tracks. Getting the CalJOBS piece done early is one less thing to worry about.

0 coins

My part time job was at a nonprofit and I was told those employers don't pay into unemployment so my wages there wouldn't count. Is that actually true?

0 coins

Used to believe the same thing until I actually looked into it. Nonprofits in California aren't excluded from unemployment coverage just because they're nonprofits. Some 501(c)(3) organizations handle UI taxes differently through what's called the reimbursable method, but that's about how the employer pays EDD, not about whether their workers are covered. Your wages from a nonprofit job count toward your claim just like any other employer's wages.

0 coins

Wait so I've been not reporting those wages on my application because I thought they didn't count? Do I need to fix that?

0 coins

Yes, include all employers from the last 18 months when you apply. If you already filed without them, contact EDD through your UI Online account to correct it. Getting the wage picture right matters for your weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

Two part time jobs on my record when I filed, quit one of them around the same time situation as the original poster here. Phone interview kept getting pushed and I couldn't get anyone at EDD to tell me what was actually holding up my claim. Ended up using Claimyr to get through to an agent - the agent looked at my Claim History and found that my identity verification through ID.me hadn't fully processed, which was a separate hold from the interview. Got that sorted before the interview date so both issues were resolved around the same time.

0 coins

The ID.me thing is interesting - so there could be multiple holds going on at the same time and the interview isn't necessarily the only thing causing pending weeks?

0 coins

Exactly. Looking at Claim History showing Pending doesn't tell you which specific thing is pending. The agent could see which step was actually the holdup, which was more useful than staring at UI Online guessing.

0 coins

This is a good point. Pending could mean the interview, could mean identity, could mean something with an employer response. You can't tell from the screen alone what's actually in the queue.

0 coins

Thought I should mention - someone earlier said the burden 'shifts' to the employer in a firing situation. That's a bit off. The way EDD actually frames it: if you quit, you have to show a good reason; if you fired, the employer has to prove misconduct. Those are two separate standards that apply to two separate situations, they don't shift from one to the other. For this thread's situation - quitting part time to take full time work - the question is whether the reason was good enough, and that's on the person who quit to explain clearly.

0 coins

That framing makes more sense actually. Good reason on the quitter's side, misconduct proof on the employer's side in a firing. Two different tests, not one that moves around.

0 coins

So for someone like me who just quit without another job, I have to explain my reason and show it was good enough. Got it.

0 coins

Has anyone appealed a denial after a quit situation? I got a Notice of Determination last month saying my quit didn't meet the good reason standard and I'm trying to figure out if it's worth filing the Appeal Form.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date on the notice is your window to appeal using the DE 1000M form or a written letter sent to the address on the notice. If you have documentation that supports your reason for quitting - anything that shows the conditions you were dealing with - include it. An administrative law judge hears the case.

0 coins

The notice was mailed three weeks ago so I still have time. I do have texts from my manager that show the work situation was pretty bad.

0 coins

Keep certifying even while the appeal is pending. EDD can only pay back weeks if you certified them. Missing certifications during an appeal is a mistake that can cost you those weeks even if you win.

0 coins

Quick thing about the certification schedule - this is for anyone newer to this. You certify every two weeks in California, not weekly. First certification usually comes about two weeks after EDD processes your application and covers the waiting week plus the first paid week. UI Online is the fastest way to do it.

0 coins

Waited a week for my first certification option to show up and was convinced something was wrong with my account. Normal apparently?

0 coins

Normal. The two-week wait after the application processes is just how the timing works out. If nothing shows up after three or four weeks that's when to reach out to EDD.

0 coins

Missed my first certification window because I didn't understand the schedule and thought I'd get an email reminder. No email came. Lost that two weeks.

0 coins

DE 429Z came in the mail and I was trying to figure out if the weekly amount on it was final or if it could change. My part time wages were higher than usual in one specific quarter because of holiday hours and I wasn't sure if EDD would use that quarter or average things out. Used Claimyr and the agent explained that EDD uses whichever quarter of your base period had the highest wages - the holiday quarter was actually my highest, so that was what set my weekly benefit amount. Appreciated having a straight answer instead of guessing.

0 coins

That's really useful. So if you had one strong quarter the system actually benefits you there, it's not just averaging your wages?

0 coins

Right, the highest quarter is what drives the number. For me that meant the holiday retail quarter counted more than my slower months, which worked in my favor.

0 coins

This is why it matters to have all your wages from all jobs in the application correctly - both part time and full time wages in that highest quarter add together.

0 coins

Something I got wrong when I first filed: I thought severance from my full time layoff would delay when I could start collecting. Spent two weeks after getting laid off not applying because I assumed I had to wait for the severance to run out. Turns out severance paid under a company plan isn't treated as wages for unemployment purposes - you can file right away. Lost two weeks of benefits for no reason.

0 coins

Oh that's a costly mistake to make. So severance doesn't block you from applying?

0 coins

No. File immediately when you're laid off, don't wait for severance to end. The application is what starts your benefit year clock - waiting just costs you weeks off the front end.

0 coins

Still report any severance when you certify though, that's on EDD's list of things to report. EDD decides how it affects any given week. But the application itself, file that right away.

0 coins

Worth knowing about the alternate base period since it came up in another comment. I used to think you could request it to get a higher weekly amount if you had a good recent quarter. That's not how it works. The alternate base period - last four completed quarters instead of the standard first-four-of-five - only kicks in when the standard calculation doesn't produce a valid claim at all. It doesn't replace the standard one just because you'd prefer a bigger number. EDD runs the alternate automatically if the standard doesn't qualify you, you don't need to ask.

0 coins

So if your standard base period already qualifies you, requesting the alternate doesn't do anything?

0 coins

Correct. If you're already valid under the standard base period, the alternate isn't used even if your most recent quarter was your best one. That confused me for a long time.

0 coins

This trips up a lot of people. Had a friend convince himself his recent quarter would bump his weekly amount if he could just get EDD to use it. Doesn't work that way.

0 coins

Layoff from my full time job after I'd quit a part time gig a few months earlier - same basic situation as this thread. Had a pending week that wouldn't move in Claim History for over two weeks after my interview. Tried phoning EDD at 1-800-300-5616 several days running and couldn't get through the queue. Claimyr got me to an agent who could actually see my file. The agent told me the pending week was the waiting week - every new claim has one unpaid week at the start - and that it would just show pending until the following weeks processed alongside it. Nothing was actually wrong, I was just confused about what I was looking at.

0 coins

The waiting week thing is good to know - so one week being permanently pending doesn't mean there's a problem, it's just the unpaid waiting week?

0 coins

Exactly. It doesn't go away as a dollar amount, it just sits there because it's unpaid. The agent explained it shows in Claim History as a week EDD processed but didn't pay because it's the first eligible week.

0 coins

Panicked about that exact same thing for a few days. The waiting week looks like something is wrong when really it's supposed to look that way.

0 coins

Wrapping up the original question here because I think there's been a lot of useful info: quit from part time to take full time work, then laid off from full time. EDD will schedule a phone interview because of the quit. At the interview you explain the timeline and reason. The laid-off separation from the full time job is clean. Your wages from both jobs feed into the base period calculation. Keep certifying while everything is pending, register in CalJOBS if you got that notice, and check your DE 4800 for the interview date and time so you're ready when the interviewer phones.

0 coins

This is exactly the summary I needed. Phone interview covers the quit from part time, laid off from full time is straightforward, and I just need to have my timeline ready and certify on schedule.

0 coins

Also keep certifying through any pending status - that part really can't be said enough. Missing certifications during adjudication is how people lose weeks they were actually entitled to.

0 coins

And if your Claim History shows weeks stuck at pending with no movement after your interview, that's when it makes sense to reach out to EDD directly - message through UI Online or phone the 1-800 number.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure