Back to California Unemployment

Alicia Stern

Should I withhold taxes on unemployment payments from California EDD?

Okay so I'm about two months into collecting unemployment and just realized I never set up any kind of tax withholding on my benefits. My weekly amount is $380 and I've been certifying every two weeks without a second thought about taxes. Now I'm reading stuff online that says I could get hit with a big federal tax bill in April and I'm kind of freaking out. Is that true? Should I withhold taxes on unemployment payments, or is it not as bad as people are making it out to be? I don't remember seeing anything about withholding options when I first filed but maybe I missed it. Would love to hear from people who have dealt with this before — did you set up withholding or just deal with the tax bill at the end of the year?

Wait, does California also tax your unemployment, or just the feds? I always assumed both would take a cut and I've been setting aside 20% of every payment just in case.

0 coins

Actually that 20% is way more than you need to set aside. California doesn't tax unemployment benefits at all — it's only federal. So if you're setting aside 20% you're probably holding onto more than you'll owe.

0 coins

Are you absolutely sure about the California part? I swear I saw something on a form that made it sound like the state takes something too, and I've been worried about it for months.

0 coins

The state exemption is real and it's a pretty significant relief when you're on a tight budget. Federal is the only one you have to plan for.

0 coins

Fourteen weeks of Pending weeks in my Claim History, and I finally needed to actually speak with someone at EDD to figure out what the holdup was with my identity verification. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through — they hold your place in the phone queue so you end up talking to a live EDD agent. There's a video they have on reaching a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what it looks like. The agent pulled up my account and told me the DE 1326C I'd submitted hadn't been marked received on their end, which is why everything stalled. Anyway, while I had the agent I asked about the withholding question too — she confirmed the 10% federal option is available every time you certify and you can switch it on or off each certification period.

0 coins

Mine have been pending for a while too, actually — was there anything specific you had to say to get the agent to actually look into the identity piece, or did they just pull it up automatically?

0 coins

Does that 10% come off each individual payment, or do they calculate it differently for the two-week certification period?

0 coins

Each certification period you're asked whether you want withholding, and 10% is deducted from that payment if you say yes. So if your two-week payment is $760, they'd hold $76.

0 coins

Honestly the federal tax thing bit me hard last year. I had about $9,000 in unemployment payments and didn't withhold a cent. Ended up owing around $1,000 in April and had no money saved up for it. If I'd just clicked yes on the withholding option every time I certified it would have been spread out painlessly.

0 coins

Did you end up getting penalized for underpaying throughout the year, or was it just the lump sum you owed at filing?

0 coins

Just the balance due, no underpayment penalty in my case. But I was pretty close to the edge apparently and my tax person said if I'd earned any extra income at all during the year it could have tipped me into penalty territory.

0 coins

This is actually the scenario that scares me. I did a little freelance work during my claim and I'm not sure how that all adds up at the end.

0 coins

I had it backwards for a long time — I thought since EDD takes the money from an employer fund and not from your paycheck, somehow the IRS wouldn't count it as your income. That's not how it works at all. Unemployment benefits are fully taxable at the federal level, same as wages. The only difference is California doesn't add its own state income tax on top. So whatever you collect in a year, the federal government treats it like any other income when you file. EDD mails a Form 1099G in January showing exactly what you received, and it's also available through UI Online under the Payments section by January 31.

0 coins

Does that mean the 1099G shows the gross amount before any withholding, or only what you actually received after the 10% was taken out?

0 coins

The 1099G will show total benefits paid and any federal taxes withheld as separate figures, so you can see both numbers clearly when you file.

0 coins

I never got a 1099G mailed to me one year and panicked. Eventually found it right there in UI Online like you said — took me forever to find it because I didn't know to look under Payments.

0 coins

Is the 10% the only option, or can you choose a different withholding percentage? I'm in a higher tax bracket because of some income earlier in the year and 10% might not cover what I actually owe.

0 coins

EDD only offers the flat 10% federal withholding option — there's no way to request a custom percentage through them. If 10% won't cover your liability you'd want to make estimated tax payments directly with the IRS on top of whatever EDD withholds.

0 coins

Ugh, so if my situation is complicated I basically have to track it myself anyway. Good to know before I just assumed the withholding covered everything.

0 coins

Same situation here with early-year income. I turned withholding on and also started making quarterly estimated payments to the IRS to cover the gap. It's annoying but it beats a surprise bill in April.

0 coins

I thought you could only set up withholding when you first apply and that you were stuck with whatever you chose. Spent three weeks thinking I'd missed my chance because I didn't check the box at the beginning. Turns out you can change your withholding choice every time you certify — it's not locked in from the start.

0 coins

Did they make it obvious during the certification process, or did you have to look for it?

0 coins

It's one of the questions in the certification flow, right there with the work search and earnings questions. Once I knew to look for it I couldn't believe I'd been glossing over it.

0 coins

I glossed over it too for the first four certifications. Just assumed it didn't apply to me because I had some savings. Big mistake in hindsight.

0 coins

What actually counts as the income amount on my taxes — is it every dollar of unemployment, or is there some kind of exclusion like there was during the pandemic? I keep hearing people say something about the first few thousand being exempt.

0 coins

There's no general exclusion on unemployment benefits right now. The pandemic-era exclusion was temporary and it's been gone for years. Every dollar you receive is counted as federal taxable income.

0 coins

I figured that was probably the case but wanted to confirm before I made the mistake of not planning for it. Thanks for being direct about it.

0 coins

People keep repeating the exclusion thing and it really trips up new claimants. No exclusion in effect for current claims.

0 coins

My neighbor told me EDD automatically withholds the taxes for you and you don't have to do anything. I almost didn't even look into it further, which would have been a costly assumption.

0 coins

EDD doesn't withhold anything automatically — it's entirely your choice each certification period whether to have that 10% federal amount taken out. If you don't actively select it, nothing gets held back.

0 coins

Yeah I found that out pretty quickly when I looked at my actual payment amounts. Would have been a rude awakening in April if I'd just trusted what my neighbor said.

0 coins

So many myths floating around about how EDD works. The 'they just handle it' assumption trips up a lot of people.

0 coins

Does choosing withholding affect how much you receive each payment, or does it somehow adjust the benefit amount itself? Someone at my old job said if you withhold it lowers your 'base amount' which made no sense to me.

0 coins

Your weekly benefit amount is set based on your highest earnings quarter and doesn't change because of withholding. The 10% comes out of each payment, so you receive less in hand, but your underlying benefit amount stays exactly the same. Your former coworker had it confused.

0 coins

That's what I figured but I didn't want to dismiss it entirely in case there was something to it. Good to have it confirmed.

0 coins

Partial weeks were creating a weird pattern on my payments and I couldn't figure out if EDD was calculating my part-time earnings deduction correctly. Called EDD through Claimyr and an agent went through my recent certifications line by line. While she had my account open I asked about the withholding setup — she confirmed the 10% federal option shows up in every certification and said I could look at prior certifications in Claim History to see which ones I'd selected it on. Turned out I'd been inconsistent, saying yes some weeks and no others without realizing it, which explained why my net payments varied so much.

0 coins

How complicated was it to understand the part-time earnings calculation once the agent walked you through it?

0 coins

The inconsistent withholding would have driven me crazy too — good that the agent could actually see the history on each certification.

0 coins

She basically showed me the formula — first $25 or 25% of gross weekly earnings, whichever is more, isn't counted, and the rest gets subtracted from my benefit amount. So my $380 weekly benefit minus the deductible earnings. Made sense once she said it out loud.

0 coins

Is there any benefit to NOT withholding and just saving the money yourself? In theory you could earn a little interest on it throughout the year before you pay in April.

0 coins

Technically yes, but you need actual discipline to not spend it. For most people the peace of mind of having it already handled is worth more than a few dollars of interest.

0 coins

Fair point. I told myself I'd put it in a savings account and then life happened and I definitely did not do that the first time.

0 coins

The math on the interest angle almost never pencils out in a way that meaningfully helps. The behavioral risk of having that money accessible outweighs it for most claimants.

0 coins

I didn't realize the 1099G was also available online and was sitting there waiting by mail until late February every year. The UI Online access through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ makes it available by January 31 which is way more useful when you're trying to file early.

0 coins

Does the online version show up in the same place as your payment history, or is there a separate section for the 1099G?

0 coins

Under the Payments section in UI Online there's a Form 1099G option. It's right there but I'd never noticed it because I always went straight to Claim History.

0 coins

Good to know — I'd rather not wait on the mail if I can pull it up myself. Filing early helps me get any refund back faster.

0 coins

What if I already certified a bunch of times without withholding and now I'm worried I owe too much to handle in one shot — can I somehow retroactively have more withheld from future certifications to make up for it?

0 coins

You can't retroactively apply withholding to past payments, but going forward you can say yes to the 10% option on every remaining certification. And if that 10% still won't cover what you'll owe, making estimated payments directly to the IRS is the other lever you have.

0 coins

Makes sense — I think the combination of turning on withholding now and setting aside a little extra each month should get me close enough that April isn't a disaster.

0 coins

This is basically exactly where I was two months ago. Turned withholding on going forward and put a set amount in savings each week. Manageable once you have a system.

0 coins

I'm still a little fuzzy on something — my benefit year started in March and I had a part-time job for a few months in the middle. Does EDD send one 1099G for the whole benefit year, or separate ones for the different periods when I was actually receiving payments?

0 coins

The 1099G covers the full calendar year — January through December — not your benefit year specifically. So everything you received in that calendar year shows up on one form, whether it was a continuous stretch or on and off with breaks in between.

0 coins

Ohh that makes way more sense. I was imagining having to piece together multiple forms and I was dreading it.

0 coins

Okay here's what I'm still not sure about — I freelanced a little while on unemployment and reported my earnings like I was supposed to when certifying. Those earnings already reduced my weekly payments. When the 1099G comes, does it show just what EDD actually paid me, or the full theoretical benefit amount before the earnings deduction?

0 coins

The 1099G reflects what EDD actually paid you after all deductions — so the reduced amounts that accounted for your reported earnings. You're not being taxed on benefit amounts you never received.

0 coins

That's actually a relief. I was calculating my tax exposure based on the full benefit amount and was getting a scary number.

0 coins

Same worry here last year. The actual 1099G number was meaningfully lower than I'd feared because of the weeks where my earnings cut into the payment.

0 coins

My DE 429Z came in showing a weekly amount that seemed low for what I'd earned, and I wanted to understand how they calculated it before I decided whether to appeal. Got through to EDD through Claimyr and the agent explained which quarter was used as my highest quarter in the standard base period. She could see my account and said the number was correct based on what my employer reported, so I didn't need to appeal. While I was on the phone I confirmed the withholding question too — she said to think of the 10% as a pay-as-you-go option so I didn't face a large bill in April.

0 coins

What would have happened if the number on the DE 429Z was actually wrong — would the agent have been able to fix it on the spot or would you have had to do a written appeal?

0 coins

She said if the wages were wrong I'd need to appeal in writing within 30 days of the mailing date on the DE 429Z, and to gather pay stubs to show the correct earnings. She couldn't change it herself on the call.

0 coins

30 days goes fast — good you called when you did instead of sitting on it.

0 coins

Coming at this from a slightly different angle — I work in accounting and clients on unemployment always ask me this question. The short version is that withholding through EDD is optional, only federal, and 10% flat. Whether that covers your actual liability depends on your total income for the year from all sources, your filing status, deductions, everything. If your only income is unemployment, 10% is usually close to right for most people. If you had significant other income in the year, you might need to supplement with estimated payments.

0 coins

Does it make sense to do a rough calculation partway through the year to see if 10% is on track, or just wait until filing?

0 coins

Absolutely run a rough number midyear. Take everything you've received so far — wages, unemployment, any other income — and estimate the full year, then run it through a tax estimator. That'll tell you pretty quickly if 10% withholding is enough or if you should be making extra estimated payments to the IRS.

0 coins

This is the advice I actually needed. I've been treating the 10% question as all-or-nothing when really it's just one piece of a bigger picture.

0 coins

Just ran into something that confused me — when I certified this week the withholding question wasn't at the spot I expected it to be. I almost thought the option was gone. It showed up at the very end of the certification flow, different from where I remembered it being before. Same question, different position.

0 coins

Is the UI Online layout changing on you or is it possible you're remembering where it was from EDD Tele-Cert, the phone certification option? They ask the same questions but in a slightly different order.

0 coins

Oh that's probably it actually — I switched from phone certification to UI Online a couple weeks ago and I think I'm still mentally mapping the old phone flow onto the online one.

0 coins

The phone version through 1-866-333-4606 is so mechanical that the question order gets drilled into you. Online feels different even though it covers the same ground.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure