Back to California Unemployment

LunarLegend

Should I reopen my unemployment claim when reopen button appears on UI Online?

Last week my job ended again after I'd been back at the company for a few months following a layoff earlier this year. I still have weeks left in my benefit year from the original claim, and when I logged into UI Online at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ this morning I noticed a reopen button showing up on my account. My question is whether I should actually use that reopen button or if starting fresh with a brand new application makes more sense. I genuinely don't know which route gives me better numbers - like does reopening lock me into the weekly benefit amount from my original claim? My situation changed a bit since the first layoff because I picked up wages at a couple of different rates over the past months. Would a new application look at those more recent earnings? I'm kind of going in circles trying to figure this out and would appreciate hearing from anyone who's been in this exact situation before.

DE 429Z on my original claim showed $312 a week, and after my second layoff I had the same reopen vs new application question sitting in front of me. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent after I'd been getting nowhere on my own - the video explaining how to reach a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and walked me through what the numbers would look like: my standard base period for a new claim would have included the higher-wage quarters from my second stint at the company, but the existing claim's weekly amount was locked at $312 and couldn't be revised upward. She told me the reopen button is for people whose situation basically hasn't changed wage-wise, and that if I had a valid new claim that would pay more, filing fresh was the way to go. I ended up filing a new application the same day.

0 coins

$312 vs whatever a new claim might have come out to - that's exactly the kind of comparison I'm trying to figure out for my own situation. Did the agent mention anything about how long the transition takes if you go the new application route?

0 coins

EDD's calculator on their site can at least give you a ballpark before you decide. Plug in your quarterly wages and you'll see roughly what a new claim would pay vs your current amount.

0 coins

The agent said to expect the same processing window as any new application, roughly three weeks before first payment. The reopen is faster since there's no fresh review, so the tradeoff is speed vs potentially a higher weekly amount.

0 coins

21 days after the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work - that's the CalJOBS deadline that caught me off guard when I reopened mine earlier this year. People forget that reopening a claim doesn't reset that clock the same way a new claim does; you may get a fresh DE 8405 or you may not, and either way you need to have that CalJOBS profile and resume up before EDD flags you. When I reopened I assumed I was fine since I'd already registered from the first round, but my resume was months old and barely reflected my recent work. Worth updating before you even click that button.

0 coins

Had no idea CalJOBS could be an issue on a reopen - I figured since I registered the first time I was in the clear. Going to log in and refresh my resume today just in case.

0 coins

Same assumption I made and it caused a week of payments to hold pending while EDD sorted it out. Definitely update the resume as soon as you reopen, don't wait for a notice.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration carries over between claims but EDD can still require you to update your profile. The DE 8405 will tell you if there's anything new required on your end.

0 coins

The base period math is what most people overlook in this decision. A new claim uses the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters - so if your highest-earning quarter from this second job stretch falls within that window, a new claim could net you more per week. But if your recent wages were lower, the original claim's weekly amount might actually be better. The alternate base period only kicks in automatically when the standard one doesn't produce a valid claim at all, so don't count on it to rescue a lower-wage scenario. Basically run the numbers on the EDD Unemployment Benefit Calculator before you do anything.

0 coins

Thought the alternate base period was something you could just request whenever you wanted a higher amount. Turns out EDD runs it automatically and only if the standard one doesn't qualify you - not as a strategy to get a bigger check.

0 coins

Exactly right. A lot of people assume they can cherry-pick whichever base period gives the best number, but EDD only uses the alternate when the standard doesn't produce a valid claim. It's not a tool for bumping up an already-valid claim.

0 coins

Does that mean if I reopened instead of filing new, I'm stuck with whatever the DE 429Z said originally? No way to get the alternate base period recalculated?

0 coins

Reopening keeps you on the existing claim with the same weekly amount. A new application is the only way to get a fresh calculation. If your recent quarters were stronger, filing new almost always makes more sense.

0 coins

Reopen button showed up for me after a contract ended and I panicked and clicked it before thinking it through. My original weekly amount was $278 and I'd been earning quite a bit more during the contract period. If I'd filed a new application I would have been looking at a much higher weekly amount based on those contract wages. The reopen is genuinely the right move ONLY if your earnings haven't changed much or if you're close to the end of your benefit year and just need to collect the remaining weeks.

0 coins

How close to the end of your benefit year were you when that happened? I'm maybe seven or eight months into mine so I should still have some runway left.

0 coins

About nine months in when the contract ended. With only three months left in the year I figured the reopen made sense to just get the remaining weeks paid out. If I'd had six or more months left I definitely would have filed fresh to capture those contract wages.

0 coins

This is a really useful framework. Close to the benefit year end - reopen. Lots of time left and higher recent wages - file new. Bookmarks this in my head.

0 coins

Something nobody mentions enough: if your benefit year has already ended, the reopen button won't even show up and you have to file a new application regardless. So if you're seeing the button at all, you're still within your 52-week benefit year and you have an actual choice to make. The button disappearing is usually the first sign people get that the year has rolled over.

0 coins

Assumed the button disappearing meant my account was glitched or EDD had closed my claim for some reason. Turns out it just meant the year ended and I had to refile. Logged in one morning and it was just gone.

0 coins

Yep, that's exactly what happened to mine too. No notice, no email - the button was there one day and not the next. Had to start over with a full new application.

0 coins

Good to know. Mine is still showing so I'm definitely still within the year. Gives me a bit of breathing room to figure out the right move before I do anything.

0 coins

One thing worth knowing about the payment method - when you reopen an existing claim your Money Network card from the original claim should still work, assuming it hasn't expired. If you file a new application EDD might issue a new card or link to your existing direct deposit depending on what you had set up. Worth checking your payment preference in myEDD before the first payment processes so you're not hunting for a card you threw out months ago.

0 coins

Threw out my card thinking I was done with EDD. Had to request a new one and it took a couple weeks to arrive. Definitely check that before reopening or filing anything.

0 coins

The card expiration tripped me up too. Mine had expired during the gap between claims and I didn't realize until I tried to use it. Had to update payment info to direct deposit in myEDD while I waited for the replacement.

0 coins

Waiting week is something that confuses people here - every new claim has an unpaid waiting period for the first eligible week. When you reopen an existing claim you've already served that waiting week from round one, so payments can start sooner on a reopen. If you file a completely new application, that first week is unpaid again. Depending on how urgently you need the money, that one-week difference might matter.

0 coins

Had assumed the waiting week was just for first-time filers and after that you never had to deal with it again regardless of what you did. That's wrong - it restarts with every new application.

0 coins

Right, it's tied to each new claim, not to your lifetime history with EDD. Reopen avoids it; new application brings it back.

0 coins

DE 1101I is the form if you end up going the new application route and can't file online for some reason. And for the actual phone call to EDD if you have specific questions about your situation, Claimyr worked for me when my original claim had an adjudication hold - I ended up talking to an agent who confirmed which weeks were still pending. claimyr.com if you need it.

0 coins

Useful to know about the waiting week - I hadn't factored that in at all. If the weekly amount would be significantly higher on a new claim, one unpaid week is probably worth it, but it's not nothing.

0 coins

Adjudication came up for me on a reopen that I hadn't expected. My first claim went through without any issues but when I reopened after a second layoff from a different employer, EDD scheduled a phone interview because there was now a question about the separation from that second job. The reopen button being there doesn't mean the claim automatically picks back up without review - if the circumstances changed, like a different employer or a different reason for leaving, EDD may still investigate.

0 coins

That's genuinely concerning because I left this second job under slightly different circumstances than the first layoff. Not sure if that triggers an interview or not.

0 coins

If the separation reason is straightforward - another layoff, no dispute from the employer - it usually doesn't. If there's any ambiguity EDD will schedule a phone interview and send a DE 4800 with the date and time. Just keep an eye on UI Online and your mail.

0 coins

The DE 4800 also shows up on the UI Online homepage with the scheduled time, so you're not just waiting for mail. Check both.

0 coins

Certifying question after a reopen that I called EDD about - weeks before the reopen date were already locked out for me and I couldn't go back and certify them even though I technically had been unemployed during that time. The agent told me the gaps between claims where you weren't certifying are just gone, you can only certify going forward from the week you reopen. Filed the reopen on a Wednesday and my first certifiable week started from the Sunday of that same week. Used Claimyr to get through since the hold times were brutal and I needed to know before I made the reopen decision - the agent confirmed the gap weeks couldn't be claimed retroactively.

0 coins

So any weeks between when my job ended and when I actually click reopen are just lost? That's a bit painful if I've been sitting on this for a week already.

0 coins

Exactly. The claim week starts from the Sunday before you reopen, not from when your job ended. The sooner you act the fewer gap weeks you lose.

0 coins

This is why EDD says to apply - or reopen - as soon as you're out of work. Even a few days of delay means you can't go back and certify those days later.

0 coins

New application vs reopen also affects how long your benefits last. If your existing claim has 14 weeks left before the year ends, reopening gives you at most those 14 weeks. A new application starts a fresh 52-week benefit year with up to 26 weeks available. If you've already used most of your current year, filing new might give you significantly more total weeks of potential coverage.

0 coins

Didn't realize the benefit year itself resets with a new application. Thought the 26-week maximum was cumulative across all claims no matter what.

0 coins

Each new claim starts fresh. 26 weeks maximum on the new claim, independent of how many you collected on the previous one. The only limit is you can't file a new California claim until the current benefit year ends - so if you're still inside the year, you either reopen or wait it out.

0 coins

Can you file a new application before the year ends if you decide not to reopen? Like just ignore the reopen button and submit a fresh application anyway?

0 coins

That's worth confirming directly with EDD because overlapping claim years get complicated. The standard answer is you can't start a new benefit year until the current one ends, but your specific dates and wages are something an agent could clarify faster than guessing here.

0 coins

My hours got cut rather than fully eliminated and I ended up reopening to claim partial UI for a while before eventually going back full time. The reopen worked fine for that situation - I was certifying and reporting the partial wages each two-week period. The earnings formula still applied where the first $25 or 25% of weekly gross - whichever is bigger - didn't count against my weekly amount, and the rest got subtracted. Partial UI on a reopen is totally doable.

0 coins

Hours being cut rather than a full layoff is a different situation than mine but good to know the reopen handles that too. I'm fully out of work so I won't have wages to report but useful context.

0 coins

Yeah for full layoffs it's simpler - no wage reporting, just certify every two weeks confirming you were available and looking for work.

0 coins

Just to add - report wages in the week they were earned, not when the paycheck hits your account. That tripped me up early on and I had to contact EDD to fix a certification.

0 coins

DE 1080CZ - that's the Notice of Determination that lands if EDD decides something went wrong with your eligibility after a reopen. Worth knowing what it looks like and understanding you have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal using the DE 1000M form attached to it. I got one when my previous employer disputed the reason for my separation after I reopened, and not knowing I had a deadline almost cost me the appeal.

0 coins

30 days felt like forever until it wasn't. I missed an appeal deadline because I assumed I had more time and the notice sat in a pile of mail. Open EDD mail the day it arrives.

0 coins

The deadline runs from the mailing date on the notice itself, not from when you open it. So even if you find a two-week-old notice at the bottom of a stack, you've already burned half your window.

0 coins

Can you appeal late? I missed a deadline once and wasn't sure if that was just the end of it.

0 coins

A late appeal is possible but you need a reason for missing the deadline. EDD and then the CUIAB weigh whether the reason is good enough. No guarantee it gets accepted, so hitting the 30-day mark is really important.

0 coins

NOBODY tells you that your work search requirements start immediately when you reopen - like from the first week you certify after reopening, EDD expects you to have been looking for work. I know EDD's pages don't give a specific number of contacts to hit each week, but you need to actually be searching and have some kind of record of where you applied. I keep a simple spreadsheet because if EDD ever asks I want to have something concrete.

0 coins

Keeping a record of applications is a good habit regardless - I track the company, the role, the date I applied, and whether I heard back. Easy to put together and gives you something if EDD ever follows up.

0 coins

And don't forget availability matters too - for every week you certify you're saying you were able and available for work. If something came up that week that made you unavailable, that could affect your eligibility for it.

0 coins

Phone line at 1-800-300-5616 is 8 to 5 Monday through Friday if you want to talk through the decision before clicking anything. Live chat is also available through the Help button in UI Online, but only 9 to 2 on weekdays. For a decision like reopen vs new application where the numbers actually matter for your specific base period, talking to someone who can see your claim is way more useful than guessing from general info online.

0 coins

Have been meaning to call but keep getting discouraged. Going to try the chat route tomorrow since the hours are a bit more manageable for me.

0 coins

Chat works well for simpler questions. For something like base period calculations they may need to pull your wage data which is easier over the phone where they can walk you through it in real time.

0 coins

Former employer filed a dispute on my separation when I reopened and it delayed everything for weeks. EDD sent the DE 4800 for a phone interview to hear both sides - the interviewer called at the exact time listed on the notice, and I made sure to be near my phone the whole morning. The notice from that round came out in my favor but the wait while adjudication was open was rough. If your second separation had any messiness with the employer, factor in a potential delay.

0 coins

How did you know the interviewer was going to call at that specific time? Did the DE 4800 give a time window or an exact time?

0 coins

Exact time was on the DE 4800 and also on the UI Online homepage under the claim info. No time window, just the specific time. I stayed near my phone for about an hour around it just in case but the call came basically on the dot.

0 coins

If you miss that call, phone EDD the same day. The longer you wait the more likely they process the case without your input, which often means a denial.

0 coins

Form 1099G at the end of the year will reflect whatever you collected across both the original claim and the reopen, all in one place. The whole amount is federal taxable income, though California doesn't tax it at the state level. If you decide to withhold the 10% federal at each certification, you can elect that when you certify. Worth deciding that upfront rather than getting hit with a tax bill in the spring.

0 coins

Had no idea unemployment was taxable at the federal level. Thought it was just income replacement and treated the same as being on a leave of absence. Good to know before I make any elections.

0 coins

Federal tax definitely applies. California doesn't add its own tax on top, so at least there's that. The 10% withholding option is there each time you certify if you want to stay ahead of it.

0 coins

The 1099G is in UI Online under Payments then Form 1099G by January 31 if you need it for filing. Easier than waiting for the mailed version.

0 coins

Balance remaining on the claim is something you can check in UI Online - it shows your maximum benefit amount minus what's already been paid. That number tells you exactly how many weeks of your original amount are left before the year ends. Knowing that balance helped me figure out whether reopening or filing new made more sense for my own situation. Got on the phone with an EDD agent through Claimyr to double-check the balance and confirm which weeks were still certifiable - the agent went through each open week with me one by one.

0 coins

Didn't know the balance was visible in UI Online like that. Logging in now to find it - that number will make the decision a lot clearer.

0 coins

It's right in Claim History alongside the weekly amount. If the remaining balance divided by your weekly amount is fewer weeks than you'd get on a new claim, filing fresh is probably worth the extra processing time.

0 coins

Direct deposit setup question that came up for me - after a long gap without collecting, my bank account on file had changed. Payments started processing but I didn't get anything for a few days until I realized the old account was still set as my deposit destination. Update your payment info in myEDD before you reopen or file anything, not after the first payment is already on its way somewhere.

0 coins

Had the same thing happen with the Money Network card - expired during the gap. Payment posted to it but I couldn't access the funds until a new card arrived. Definitely check whichever payment method you have on file.

0 coins

The UI Online payment status updates daily, so once you notice something is off you can usually catch it before too many payments pile up in the wrong place. But better to fix it before the first one goes out.

0 coins

Social Security is not reported and doesn't get deducted from your UI - found that out when I was trying to figure out what income my retired parent would need to report if they ever needed to file. Regular wages, pensions, severance, part-time pay - all of that gets reported. But Social Security is specifically excluded from what affects your weekly UI amount.

0 coins

Worth clarifying - severance is on the list of things to report when you certify, but EDD has said in its own guidance that standard severance under a company plan isn't treated as wages for UI purposes. So you report it and EDD decides how it applies - you won't necessarily lose benefits because of it.

0 coins

Good clarification. I reported mine and EDD processed the payment without any reduction, but I know the official line is to report and let them determine it.

0 coins

Pensions are a little different - EDD may reduce your weekly amount based on pension income from a past employer. Not a dollar-for-dollar reduction but EDD decides the amount. Something to flag when certifying rather than leaving off.

0 coins

Ask EDD through UI Online is worth using for written questions where you want a paper trail. If you ask EDD in writing whether a new application or a reopen makes more sense given your base period wages, their response is documented. Sometimes useful when things get complicated later and you need to show you asked and got guidance.

0 coins

Hadn't thought of using Ask EDD for something like this - I assumed it was just for disputes or formal issues. Good to know you can use it for general guidance questions too.

0 coins

Any question you'd normally call about can go through Ask EDD. Response time is slower than the phone or live chat, but for a non-urgent decision question like this one it's a reasonable channel.

0 coins

The message you send through UI Online also shows up in your account history, so you can go back and see exactly what you asked and what they said. Helpful for keeping track of guidance you received.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure