Back to California Unemployment

Yuki Kobayashi

Should I file taxes later if I owe on unemployment benefits? California EDD situation

So my DE 429Z came in showing a weekly benefit amount of $310 and I collected for about 18 weeks last year. Just sat down to do my taxes and realized I didn't have federal withholding taken out from any of my certifications. Never clicked that box. Now I'm staring at what looks like a pretty significant federal tax bill and I'm wondering if there's some advantage to waiting to file, like if I push the deadline back with an extension does that help me somehow? Or does the interest and penalty situation get worse the longer I wait? I know California doesn't tax unemployment but the federal side is hitting me hard. Anyone dealt with owing on unemployment income specifically?

Overpayment notice for $1,840 landed in my mailbox about six weeks into my claim, and I needed to talk to someone at EDD fast to understand whether that amount was going to affect my tax situation on top of everything else. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to a live EDD agent after the hold times on 1-800-300-5616 were killing me. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed that the $1,840 was flagged as non-fraud, which meant no penalty, just repayment. She also told me that since I was paying it back, I should check with a tax professional about how the repayment figures into my federal return for the year I repaid it, since EDD handles the 1099G side but doesn't give tax filing advice. That part was outside what she could tell me, but at least I knew exactly where my claim stood. Here's the video Claimyr posted on reaching a live person at EDD by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10

0 coins

$1,840 non-fraud overpayment is stressful enough without also having the tax question hanging over it. Glad you got clarity on the claim status at least. Did the agent say anything about timing on repayment affecting the 1099G amount?

0 coins

The 1099G only shows what EDD paid out, so if you repaid some of it in the same calendar year the amount on the form might differ from what you think you owe taxes on. Worth a call to EDD or a tax person to sort that out before filing.

0 coins

Filing an extension buys you time to submit the return paperwork, but it doesn't push back when any taxes you owe are actually due. April 15 is still the payment deadline whether you file in April or October. So if you're trying to avoid or reduce the bill itself, waiting doesn't help and you'll just add interest on whatever you owe from April onward. The move if the money isn't there yet is to file on time anyway and then set up a payment plan with the IRS, which you can do directly through their site. California side you're right, unemployment is exempt from state income tax so that piece is clean.

0 coins

April 15 as the payment deadline even with an extension, that's the part I had wrong in my head. I was thinking the extension moved everything. So I should file and then deal with the payment separately if I can't pay all at once?

0 coins

Exactly. File the return on time to avoid the failure-to-file penalty, which is worse than the failure-to-pay penalty. Then the IRS installment agreement handles the actual payment over time.

0 coins

Confirming this is right. Filed on time with a balance owed last year, set up the installment plan online same day. The interest keeps running but it's manageable compared to both penalties stacking up.

0 coins

Unemployment income going on the federal 1040 as regular taxable income is something a lot of people get surprised by their first time collecting. The 10 percent withholding option during each certification exists specifically to avoid this situation, but EDD doesn't remind you loudly enough that the default is no withholding. For the return itself, your 1099G from EDD shows the total paid and any amount withheld. UI Online has it under Payments then Form 1099G if you need a copy, and EDD mails it by January 31. Add that amount to your other income and your tax bracket does the rest.

0 coins

10 percent withholding doesn't always cover it though depending on the person's bracket. Someone with a spouse still working could end up in a higher bracket where 10 percent was way too low.

0 coins

True, the 10 percent is a floor not a guarantee. For higher earners or dual-income households collecting UI it might not be enough. But zero withholding is almost always worse, which is what a lot of people end up with.

0 coins

I picked 10 percent withholding on my first certification and honestly forgot I'd even done it. Then the 1099G came and the amount already withheld was sitting right there. Still owed some but way less than zero withholding would have meant.

0 coins

My 1099G showed up in UI Online on January 28th and the number was bigger than I expected because it included weeks from two different calendar years worth of certifications. If you collected unemployment across a year boundary, say started in late one year and kept going into the next, each calendar year gets its own 1099G with just what was paid in that year. Make sure you're looking at the right year's form.

0 coins

Mine was all within one calendar year so that shouldn't complicate things, but that's a good thing to flag for people who crossed a year end.

0 coins

This tripped up my roommate last year. Got one 1099G for each year and initially thought EDD had sent duplicates by mistake. They're separate forms for a reason.

0 coins

Something I want to flag about the California side since you mentioned it: unemployment benefits are indeed exempt from California state income tax, so your CA return won't add to the bill. But I'd double-check that you're entering things correctly in whatever tax software you're using, because some programs auto-populate the state return from the federal 1099G entry and you have to manually back it out for California. Had to do that myself and it took me a minute to find where the subtraction was.

0 coins

Using tax software and hadn't thought about that specific step. Going to look for where that California subtraction gets applied, don't want to accidentally pay state tax on it.

0 coins

TurboTax at least handles this automatically but I've heard other software doesn't always. Worth reviewing the California schedule before you submit just to confirm the unemployment income isn't showing as taxable there.

0 coins

The California Schedule CA is where you'd see the adjustment. If the software is doing it right, the unemployment amount should show up as a subtraction on that schedule so it comes out of your CA taxable income.

0 coins

Weeks 14 and 15 of my claim got flagged as pending right as I was also trying to figure out the tax picture for the year. Needed EDD to tell me exactly which weeks had been paid versus pending so I knew what would actually appear on my 1099G. Claimyr got me to an agent who went through each week in my Claim History and told me which ones had paid out in the calendar year versus which were still pending and might pay in the new year. That cleared up the 1099G question because I knew exactly what had been paid by December 31.

0 coins

Pending weeks crossing into a new year affecting the 1099G is something I hadn't thought about. If those pending weeks pay in January they'd go on next year's form, not this year's?

0 coins

That's what the agent confirmed for my situation. The 1099G reflects what actually paid out in the calendar year, so pending weeks that resolve in a new year show on that year's form.

0 coins

This is a really practical point. Had a few weeks that paid in January and they were on the following year's 1099G, not the year I actually certified for them. Confused me until I lined up the payment dates.

0 coins

The IRS payment plan option already mentioned here is solid advice. What I'd add is that if the amount you owe is under a certain threshold and you've filed and paid on time in prior years, the IRS has a first-time penalty abatement option. Doesn't erase interest but can knock out the failure-to-pay penalty. Worth asking about if you've had a clean filing history before this year.

0 coins

First-time penalty abatement is new information for me. Is that something you apply for separately after filing?

0 coins

You request it after you receive a penalty notice, either by phone with the IRS or by writing in. Have to have no penalties in the three years before. It's not automatic but it's worth asking for if you qualify.

0 coins

Got this for a different tax situation a few years back. Called the IRS, asked specifically about first-time abatement, they applied it same call. Saved me a few hundred dollars in penalties.

0 coins

Certification schedule getting thrown off led me to also having to sort out what weeks I'd actually been paid for before I could reconcile my 1099G. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr to get a week-by-week breakdown of what paid and when. The agent walked me through each paid week in my Claim History including the exact payment dates, so I could match them against the 1099G total and confirm it was accurate before filing.

0 coins

Week-by-week breakdown from EDD sounds like exactly what I might need too if the 1099G total looks off from what I calculated.

0 coins

UI Online Claim History does show individual payment amounts and dates too if you want to add them up yourself before calling. But having EDD confirm it verbally is cleaner if there are pending weeks complicating the picture.

0 coins

On the question of filing later specifically: the extension request itself is easy, you just need to submit it by April 15 and the IRS grants it automatically without you having to explain why you need more time. Gives you until mid-October. But as the person earlier said, any money owed still accrues interest from April 15 regardless. The only real use case for an extension when you owe is if you need more time to get documentation together, not to delay the payment itself.

0 coins

April 15 as the automatic extension deadline is a thing people forget. No hardship explanation needed, it's just a form. But the interest clock doesn't pause.

0 coins

So the extension is basically only for paperwork complexity, not for buying payment time. That's clearer now.

0 coins

Repaying an overpayment in a different year than it was paid introduces a wrinkle worth knowing about: if EDD paid you an amount in year one that showed on that year's 1099G, and you repaid it in year two, you may be able to claim a deduction or credit on the year-two return for the repaid amount depending on how large it was. The IRS has specific rules about this called the claim of right doctrine. Not something EDD can advise on but a tax professional can walk through it.

0 coins

$1,840 repayment in my situation, wondering now if that falls under what you're describing for year two. Going to flag this for my tax person.

0 coins

$1,840 likely falls into the smaller bucket where a deduction rather than a credit is used, but the threshold matters and I'd confirm it with someone who knows the current rules. Not something to assume.

0 coins

Had a friend who panicked and just didn't file because they owed on unemployment and didn't have the money. Big mistake. The failure-to-file penalty is 5 percent of the unpaid amount per month up to 25 percent. The failure-to-pay penalty is 0.5 percent per month. Filing with zero payment is infinitely better than not filing at all.

0 coins

5 percent per month for not filing versus 0.5 percent for not paying is a huge difference. That framing makes it really clear why filing matters even without the money.

0 coins

Watched someone I know end up with a tax bill that doubled because they kept not filing for two years on unemployment income. The penalties compounded fast. File first, figure out payment second.

0 coins

Also worth checking: if your total income including unemployment was low enough, you might actually qualify for the Earned Income Tax Credit or other credits that reduce what you owe. Unemployment income itself doesn't count as earned income for EITC purposes but if you had any wages in the same year, those wages do. Run the numbers before assuming the worst on your bill.

0 coins

Had some part-time work in the same year, so wages plus unemployment. Didn't think about EITC potentially offsetting some of this.

0 coins

Unemployment not counting as earned income for EITC is something a lot of people get wrong. The wages piece matters though. If you had wages, those count for EITC eligibility even if the total income including unemployment is higher.

0 coins

The 10 percent federal withholding option during certification, for anyone reading this who's currently on a claim: you can change your withholding election at any point during the claim, not just at the start. If you're a few weeks in and haven't elected withholding yet, you can turn it on now and at least get the remaining weeks covered. Doesn't fix past weeks but stops the problem from growing.

0 coins

Changing withholding mid-claim is something I didn't know was possible. Turned it on week three of my current claim after reading a thread like this one.

0 coins

For anyone starting a claim or partway through one, this is probably the most actionable thing in this thread.

0 coins

The option is in myEDD during each certification. Easy to miss because it's not prominently labeled but it's there every time you certify.

0 coins

Quarterly estimated payments are another option if you're currently on a claim and want to avoid a big bill next tax season. Instead of relying on withholding, you calculate roughly what you'll owe on the UI income and pay the IRS in four installments through the year. More math involved but lets you hold the money longer. Mostly relevant for people who are self-employed or have variable income, but applies to anyone with under-withheld income including unemployment.

0 coins

Quarterly estimates feel complicated but I can see why they'd help for people with no withholding at all. For this year the ship has already sailed but maybe useful going forward.

0 coins

The IRS has a withholding estimator on their site that works well for figuring out if estimates are needed and how much. Useful before you end up in this situation.

0 coins

Something that caught me off guard was that my total income for the year including unemployment pushed me into a slightly higher bracket than I was used to. The UI benefit itself is taxed at whatever marginal rate your total income falls into, not some special lower rate. So if you had wages earlier in the year before the layoff plus the unemployment, they stack together for bracket purposes.

0 coins

The stacking of wages plus UI into one income figure pushing up the bracket is exactly what happened to me I think. Wasn't expecting the bracket to shift.

0 coins

This is a really common surprise. Someone collects UI for half the year after a good-paying job ends and the total annual income is still high enough to be in a bracket where 10 percent withholding wasn't close to enough.

0 coins

My claim certification had a couple of weeks where I reported some part-time wages, and those weeks the UI payment was reduced. What surprised me was that the 1099G still showed the reduced payments for those weeks, not some gross amount. So the 1099G reflects exactly what EDD actually paid out, nothing more. Important for people who had partial weeks of wages during their claim.

0 coins

Partial weeks with wages reducing the payout and the 1099G reflecting only what actually paid is good to know. Mine were all full unemployment weeks so shouldn't be an issue, but useful context.

0 coins

EDD's Report Wages tool in UI Online lets you see how wages in a week would affect that week's payment before you certify. Useful for understanding the math if you have any weeks with partial wages.

0 coins

Had a pending adjudication issue on my claim that took a while to resolve, and I needed EDD to confirm which weeks had officially been approved and paid before I could trust the 1099G total. Claimyr got me to an agent who had my full payment history in front of them. The agent confirmed three specific weeks I was unsure about had paid in December, so they were on that year's 1099G, and two more had paid in January, landing on next year's form. Knowing those exact dates let me file confidently.

0 coins

Adjudication weeks straddling December and January and landing on different 1099Gs is exactly the kind of thing that would throw me off. Good outcome getting those exact dates confirmed.

0 coins

Payment dates in Claim History in UI Online also show this if you go through each week individually, but having an agent confirm it verbally removes any doubt about whether the data is current.

0 coins

To answer the original question directly: no, filing later when you owe doesn't help and can hurt. The benefit of filing on time even with a balance owed is avoiding the larger failure-to-file penalty. The IRS installment plan is the tool for when you can't pay all at once, not an extension. Extension is for paperwork time only.

0 coins

Clearest summary in the thread. File on time, set up a payment plan, don't delay the filing itself. Got it.

0 coins

Exactly. And if the amount owed is genuinely unmanageable, there are also currently-not-collectible status options and offers in compromise through the IRS for extreme hardship situations, but those are longer processes and not typical first moves.

0 coins

Offer in compromise is worth knowing exists but it's a longer process and not guaranteed. For most people owing on unemployment income the installment plan is the realistic path.

0 coins

Last practical note: when you file your federal return, unemployment income from the 1099G goes on Schedule 1, line 7, then flows to the main 1040. If you're using software it handles this automatically when you enter the 1099G. Just make sure you don't accidentally enter it twice if EDD sent you a corrected 1099G at any point, some software will want you to override the original entry.

0 coins

Schedule 1 line 7 noted. And the corrected 1099G point is relevant because EDD did send me a corrected one that matched the original anyway but I'll make sure only one amount gets entered.

0 coins

Corrected 1099G replacing the original is the right way to handle it. Only the corrected form's amount goes on the return. If software has an original and a corrected entry showing, delete the original.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure