Back to California Unemployment

GalacticGladiator

Should I appeal notice of determination overpayment and fraud? California EDD situation

Got a Notice of Determination in the mail last week saying EDD found fraud on my claim and I owe back over $4,200. I am honestly in shock. I reported everything when I certified - my part-time hours, the small amount I earned, all of it. Now they're saying I intentionally gave false information and they're hitting me with the 30% penalty on top of the overpayment amount. I never tried to cheat the system. I lost my warehouse job in early 2026, filed right away, and kept certifying honestly every two weeks. At some point I did get some extra hours for about three weeks and I reported those wages. My weekly benefit was $310. I don't understand how they got to fraud from that. The notice came with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) and says I have 30 days from the mailing date to respond. I'm terrified to appeal in case it makes things worse somehow, but I also can't just accept a fraud finding I didn't earn. Has anyone actually gone through fighting one of these? Did the appeal do anything?

Overpayment fraud notices from EDD shook me completely when mine arrived in March. The amount on mine was $3,850 plus the penalty, and I had no idea how they calculated it. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live agent on the phone - basically it handles the hold time so you end up speaking directly with EDD. The video they put out about reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what it's about. The agent pulled up my account and told me which specific weeks EDD flagged, and that the fraud finding was tied to wages I had reported but that EDD's system had matched to a different employer's quarterly report at a higher dollar amount. I got my pay stubs together after that call and filed my appeal on the DE 1000M the same day.

0 coins

The weeks being flagged by a wage-match discrepancy is exactly what happened to a guy on another forum I follow. His employer had filed the quarterly report late and the numbers didn't line up with what he certified. He won his appeal.

0 coins

Knowing which weeks were flagged would help me so much right now. My UI Online Claim History just shows the overpayment balance with no breakdown of which certifications triggered it.

0 coins

The Notice of Determination itself should list the weeks in question somewhere on it - mine had them printed near the bottom with the dollar amounts next to each one.

0 coins

The appeal deadline on the DE 1000M is 30 days from the mailing date printed on the notice, not the day you received it. Missing that date means you'd need to explain why you were late, so counting carefully matters here. Filing the appeal does not make anything worse - EDD reviews it first, then it goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board and an administrative law judge holds a hearing. You get to present your side under oath. The judge's decision comes in writing after the hearing. Keep certifying through all of this if your benefit year is still open, because EDD can only pay back weeks you actually certified for.

0 coins

My benefit year should still be open. I'll keep certifying. I was afraid that appealing would somehow flag my account further but that's good to know it doesn't work that way.

0 coins

Agreed on counting from the mailing date. I almost miscounted mine from the day I actually opened the envelope and would have cut it close.

0 coins

The 30 days from the mailing date thing is real - I called EDD when I had a determination and the first thing they asked was what date was printed at the top of the notice, not when I got it in my hands.

0 coins

Fraud findings specifically require EDD to show you intentionally withheld or misrepresented information - it's a higher bar than just an error. If you reported your wages when you certified and EDD's own records or your employer's reports don't match what you said, that discrepancy alone isn't automatically fraud. The 30% penalty and the false statement disqualification weeks are what gets added when EDD decides it was intentional. An administrative law judge at the CUIAB hearing looks at the actual facts, not just EDD's initial determination. Getting your pay stubs, any bank deposits showing what you actually earned those weeks, and screenshots of what you entered when you certified - all of that becomes your evidence at the hearing.

0 coins

Pay stubs I have. What I don't have is any record of exactly what I entered when I certified - does UI Online keep that history anywhere?

0 coins

UI Online Claim History shows the weeks you certified and what EDD paid or didn't pay, but it doesn't show you the exact dollar amounts you typed in during each certification. Your pay stubs showing the actual gross for those weeks are the evidence that matters.

0 coins

The employer's quarterly wage report to EDD is what usually creates the mismatch. If your employer reported a different amount than what you earned and certified, getting a wage statement or letter from HR explaining the actual hours and pay could help at the hearing.

0 coins

Weeks on my claim got flagged for the same kind of fraud determination after my part-time earnings during the spring didn't match what my employer reported to EDD. After spending two days getting nowhere on hold, I tried Claimyr and ended up talking to an agent who explained exactly which form EDD had used to calculate the alleged overpayment. The agent confirmed the issue was on the employer's end - their payroll company had reported my gross pay including a one-time tool stipend that wasn't wages. I included that explanation in my appeal letter along with the offer letter showing the stipend was separate.

0 coins

A stipend being lumped in with wages by the payroll company - that's infuriating. At least the agent could actually see what EDD had on file for the calculation.

0 coins

Payroll companies messing up the wage reports to EDD is way more common than people realize. Every time I hear about an overpayment that doesn't make sense to the claimant, that's where I'd look first.

0 coins

Before the CUIAB hearing, EDD mails you a Notice of Hearing at least 10 days in advance. At the hearing itself, testimony is under oath. You can represent yourself, have a union rep do it, or bring an attorney. The judge is not EDD's advocate - they're an independent administrative law judge. What you say about why you reported what you reported, backed by the pay stubs and any employer documentation, is exactly the kind of evidence these hearings are designed to hear.

0 coins

The independent judge part is what gave me confidence when I appealed a different kind of determination. The hearing felt more like explaining my situation than defending myself in court.

0 coins

Can you bring printed documents to the hearing or do you have to submit them ahead of time?

0 coins

The Notice of Hearing gives you the specific instructions for that, including whether documents need to be submitted before or if you can bring them on the day. Follow exactly what it says.

0 coins

My aunt went through a CUIAB hearing last year and she said the judge actually walked through each week with her line by line, asking what she earned and what she reported. It was slower than she expected but thorough.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone reading this thread who is dealing with a fraud determination vs. a non-fraud overpayment - the distinction matters a lot for whether you can apply for a waiver. A non-fraud overpayment that wasn't your fault and that would be a real hardship to repay makes you eligible to request the Application for Overpayment Waiver (DE 1446UI). A fraud finding is different - EDD doesn't grant waivers on fraud determinations, plus the 30% penalty stays on top. That's another reason it's worth appealing if you believe the fraud finding is wrong: getting it reduced to a non-fraud overpayment could open the waiver option.

0 coins

This is actually huge. If the appeal gets the fraud finding changed to non-fraud, I could ask for the waiver too. I didn't know that path existed.

0 coins

Had no idea the waiver wasn't available for fraud findings. That changes the whole picture of why appealing matters even if the base overpayment amount stays the same.

0 coins

The DE 1446UI is what I filed after my non-fraud overpayment got confirmed. EDD looked at my income and expenses and I was eventually granted a partial waiver. It's not guaranteed but it exists.

0 coins

Disqualification weeks attached to a fraud finding were the part that scared me most when I got my own notice - my determination said two weeks were being disqualified and that future benefits could be affected. The agent I reached through Claimyr clarified that the disqualification weeks were 2 to 23 and mine were set at two based on what EDD found. That number is set by EDD, not automatically by any formula. The agent said the Notice of Determination would have the specific number, which mine did in the second paragraph.

0 coins

Mine says 5 weeks disqualified on top of everything else. Didn't understand until reading this that the number isn't fixed - it's set by EDD based on what they found.

0 coins

Appealing successfully can change that disqualification count too, right? If the judge finds it wasn't fraud, the whole penalty structure should be reconsidered.

0 coins

Exactly - if the fraud finding itself gets overturned or reduced, the penalty and the disqualification weeks go with it. That's the whole stakes of the appeal.

0 coins

Writing the appeal letter itself doesn't have to be complicated. The DE 1000M has a spot where you explain why you disagree. Keep it factual: state the weeks you're disputing, what you actually earned and reported those weeks, and that you have pay stubs as evidence. Don't editorialize or speculate about why EDD made the finding - just say what actually happened from your side. Mail it to the address on the notice.

0 coins

Should I reference the specific certification dates and dollar amounts in the letter or is it enough to say I reported everything accurately?

0 coins

Referencing the specific weeks and amounts is better - the more specific your letter, the clearer your position when it goes to the judge.

0 coins

Keeping it factual and specific is exactly the advice a union rep gave me before my own hearing. The judge reads a lot of these and vague letters don't help your case.

0 coins

The 30% penalty attached to the fraud finding is a separate thing from the base overpayment - if you win the appeal and the judge agrees it wasn't intentional fraud, the penalty should be removed even if EDD decides some amount was overpaid. That alone could be worth thousands of dollars depending on what they're claiming.

0 coins

$4,200 times 30% is over $1,200 just in penalty. Yeah, that's absolutely worth appealing even if I end up accepting some of the base overpayment.

0 coins

The penalty is what makes it feel so punitive. Getting it reclassified as non-fraud doesn't erase the debt but removes that extra hit on top.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up early on: the appeal doesn't pause EDD's collection activity automatically. EDD can still offset future unemployment, Paid Family Leave or disability benefits, or state tax refunds, while the appeal is going. The appeal is about whether the determination was right, not a hold on what EDD can collect during that time. Worth knowing so it doesn't surprise you later.

0 coins

So I could have future benefits reduced while I'm waiting for the hearing? That's rough. Does it affect my current certification payments right now?

0 coins

Current certifications going through should still process normally. The offset on future payments is usually applied when EDD moves to collect, which often happens after the appeal resolves. But EDD's specific timeline for your account is something the agent or the Notice itself would clarify.

0 coins

The notice should say something about collection steps. Mine had a paragraph near the bottom about EDD's right to collect. Reading through the whole notice carefully is worth the time.

0 coins

At the CUIAB hearing, the administrative law judge may ask you to walk through each flagged week and explain what you did during that period - what hours you worked, what your employer paid you, and what you entered when you certified. Having your pay stubs organized by week rather than just by pay period makes that easier, since EDD's system is week-by-week.

0 coins

My employer paid me biweekly so the pay stubs cover two weeks at a time. I'll need to break down the daily hours to get to what I earned in each individual UI week.

0 coins

Your employer's timecard records or any app they used to track hours could be useful for showing the breakdown by week if the stubs are biweekly.

0 coins

A letter from HR confirming the actual hours worked each week in the period in question is probably the cleanest documentation you could bring.

0 coins

IF you do lose the appeal on the fraud finding, the non-fraud waiver is off the table, but you can still appeal again at the second level to the CUIAB board itself after the administrative law judge's decision. The whole process has multiple steps before it's truly final.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a second level beyond the ALJ hearing. So the first appeal isn't necessarily the last word.

0 coins

There is a second level, though the timeframe and process for that are on the judge's written decision itself. The first hearing is where most people get resolution though.

0 coins

For the certification records question raised earlier in the thread - your employer's payroll records are actually more persuasive evidence than anything you could pull from UI Online, because the whole dispute is about whether what you reported matched what you actually earned. If the two match, the fraud allegation falls apart.

0 coins

Exactly. The fraud finding is about intent - EDD has to show you knew the amount was wrong. If your pay stubs show you reported what you were actually paid, there's no intent to show.

0 coins

My pay stubs and what I reported should match almost exactly. I reported gross pay each time because that's what the certification asked for.

0 coins

Gross pay is what EDD asks you to report - wages for the week they were earned, not what hit your bank account after taxes. If you reported gross every time, that's correct. Where I've seen mismatches that lead to these notices is when someone accidentally reports net pay instead, or when they report when they got paid rather than the week they earned it.

0 coins

I reported gross each time - I remembered reading somewhere that it had to be gross. So at least that part should be right.

0 coins

The earned vs. paid timing thing is a super easy mistake to make if you have a job where payday is two weeks behind the work. Worth double-checking which weeks your employer reported your wages to EDD.

0 coins

Report wages for the week earned is EDD's rule. If your employer's quarterly report assigns your wages to a different quarter than you earned them, that creates a mismatch that isn't your fault at all.

0 coins

Filing the appeal while continuing to certify is the right move here. The DE 1000M goes to the address on the notice. Keep a copy of everything you send. If you use certified mail you'll have proof of the mailing date, which could matter if there's ever a question about whether you filed within 30 days.

0 coins

Certified mail is a good call. I was going to drop it in a regular mailbox but that makes more sense given how much is riding on the deadline.

0 coins

Certified mail with return receipt gives you the postmark and confirmation of delivery. Worth the few extra dollars on something this important.

0 coins

The hearing notice from CUIAB gives you at least 10 days advance notice of the hearing date. If the date doesn't work for you - a work conflict, a medical appointment - there's usually a way to request a continuance. The notice itself explains that process. Missing the hearing without requesting a change is what you want to avoid.

0 coins

Good to know I could request a different date if needed. I'd rather not delay it but it's good to have that option.

0 coins

Requesting a continuance early is better than waiting until the last minute. The earlier you contact them the more likely they can accommodate it.

0 coins

The notice will have a contact number or address for CUIAB scheduling. Use whatever method it lists rather than trying to reach EDD directly about the hearing - they're separate systems.

0 coins

One thing that doesn't get said enough in these threads: the administrative law judge at CUIAB is not trying to protect EDD's initial determination. They're reviewing whether EDD got it right. People go in expecting to be fighting uphill, but it's actually a fresh look by an independent judge. If your evidence is solid, the hearing is designed to let that come out.

0 coins

That reframe helps honestly. I've been dreading it like it's going to be EDD arguing against me in front of someone on their side.

0 coins

The judge genuinely wants to understand what happened. At my hearing the questions were pretty direct and the whole thing moved faster than I expected.

0 coins

Pulling all your documentation together now rather than waiting until closer to the hearing date is worth it. Things like old pay stubs, timecards, the specific weeks listed in the notice, any communication with your employer about pay - gathering it while it's on your mind is easier than scrambling later.

0 coins

Starting to build that file tonight. The notice lists five specific weeks so I'll pull the pay stubs for those and label everything by week.

0 coins

Labeling everything by UI week rather than just pay period was something the CUIAB hearing officer specifically thanked someone in a thread I read for doing. Makes it much easier to follow.

0 coins

Coming back to the waiver question from earlier - even if the appeal goes to the hearing and the judge agrees some amount was genuinely overpaid but that it wasn't fraud, you'd want to file the DE 1446UI as soon as that determination comes through. The hardship standard for the waiver looks at whether repaying would leave you unable to meet basic living expenses. EDD weighs both the fault question and the financial impact together.

0 coins

Filing the DE 1446UI quickly after a favorable ruling on the fraud question is smart because there's a window where you want it in front of EDD before collection moves forward.

0 coins

I'll keep the DE 1446UI form ready. Even partial relief on the base overpayment would help if I can get the fraud finding removed first.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure