Back to California Unemployment

Sydney Torres

Sent two letters one approved and one denied unemployment benefits which is correct

Last Thursday I got home to two envelopes from EDD sitting in my mailbox on the same day. Opened the first one and it said my claim was approved with a weekly benefit amount listed. Opened the second one and it said I was denied and there's a Notice of Determination with an appeal form inside. Both letters are dated the same day. I've been a retail manager for eight years, got laid off in October when the company closed our location, and now I genuinely have no idea which letter is the actual answer. My UI Online account just shows pending weeks and doesn't give me any clear direction. I've tried calling EDD multiple times but can't get through. Has anyone dealt with contradicting letters like this? Which one do I actually go by?

Two of my approved weeks flipped to pending out of nowhere after I had already spent that money budgeting for the month, and I had the same kind of situation where my paperwork seemed to be sending me in two different directions. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get an EDD agent on the line after the hold times were making it impossible to reach anyone. The agent pulled up my account and told me one of my pending weeks had a wage discrepancy that needed to be resolved before they could release it. Here's the video Claimyr put out about reaching a live person at EDD if you're in that spot: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. What helped me most was asking the agent specifically which determination on my account was the active one and what date it was issued, because sometimes two notices go out when EDD revises something mid-process. Worth knowing exactly what the agent sees on their end versus what lands in your mailbox.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of question I need to ask. When you talked to the agent did they tell you which document to actually go by when two different things arrive the same day?

0 coins

Asking the agent which determination is the active one on their system is smart, the mailbox situation can lag behind what's actually in EDD's records.

0 coins

Had a similar timing issue with my own notices. The dates on the envelopes can mislead you because they both go through the same mail batch even if one supersedes the other.

0 coins

Ask EDD which document carries the later determination number, because that's the one that controls your claim, and here's why that matters: when EDD mails a Notice of Determination (the DE 1080CZ, the one with the appeal form inside), that's the official eligibility decision. The other document you got that said approved sounds like it could be the Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award, the DE 429Z, which shows your weekly benefit amount and what the claim could pay out total. Those are two different things. The DE 429Z isn't a decision that you qualify, it just shows the math if you do qualify. If the DE 1080CZ says denied, that's EDD's eligibility decision and you have 30 days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing using the DE 1000M form that came with it.

0 coins

Wait so the first letter I thought was an approval might not actually be saying I'm eligible, it's just showing me numbers? That makes it make a lot more sense why both arrived the same day.

0 coins

DE 429Z versus DE 1080CZ is a distinction that trips up almost everyone. The award notice is not the green light people think it is.

0 coins

Retail closure layoff situation here too from earlier this year. My DE 429Z came in the same week as a denial on a separate eligibility issue from my last week of work. Two letters, two different answers to two different questions essentially.

0 coins

So does the 30-day clock run from the postmark or the date printed on the letter itself? My denial notice has both dates and they're different by two days.

0 coins

The mailing date printed on the face of the DE 1080CZ is what starts your 30-day appeal window, not the postmark and not the date you received it. Count from that printed date. If you're right at the edge of that window, the Appeal Form DE 1000M can be mailed or sent to the address printed on the notice itself, and you want to send it in a way you can prove was received.

0 coins

Sent mine certified mail for exactly that reason. The post office gives you a tracking number and it creates a record that you filed before the deadline.

0 coins

Mine says it was mailed eleven days ago so I still have time but I want to understand what I'm actually appealing before I send anything in.

0 coins

Filing the appeal doesn't stop you from certifying either. Keep certifying every two weeks because if the appeal goes your way, EDD can only pay back the weeks you actually certified for.

0 coins

The two-letters situation usually means EDD processed something in stages. With a retail layoff where the whole location closed, it's pretty unusual for there to be a denial because nobody's employer is claiming misconduct in a mass closure. Ask yourself whether the denial letter mentions a specific issue like availability, job search, or identity, because that tells you what the actual dispute is. The DE 1080CZ will have a reason code or explanation somewhere on the front page. What does the denial reason say?

0 coins

It says something about availability for work and that there was a question about whether I was able and available during certain weeks. I had a minor surgery in November and was off for about two weeks.

0 coins

That explains both letters then. The DE 429Z was EDD setting up your claim financially, and the DE 1080CZ is a separate eligibility question specifically about those weeks when you were recovering. For unemployment you have to be able and available every week you certify, so EDD is questioning whether those particular weeks were valid.

0 coins

For the surgery weeks specifically, if you filed for State Disability Insurance during that time you can't double-collect UI for the same days, but you can get DI for weeks you can't work and UI for weeks before and after.

0 coins

BOTH letters being dated the same day is the part that really breaks people's brains and EDD does this constantly. It happened to me twice on my claim and both times the denial was about something completely separate from the award calculation. They're not canceling each other out, they're answering different questions about your claim at the same time. Your weekly benefit amount math and your eligibility for a specific period are handled separately in their system.

0 coins

Makes total sense now that it's laid out that way. I was treating them like they were contradicting answers to the same question when they were actually about two completely different parts of my claim.

0 coins

Exactly. And the appeal only needs to cover the denied period, not the whole claim. Focus the appeal specifically on those November weeks and what your situation actually was.

0 coins

EDD's system really does separate these out and it creates so much unnecessary panic. I wish the letters came with a plain-language explanation of what each document is actually for.

0 coins

With the surgery availability issue, the question you'd want answered before writing your appeal is whether you were actually told by a doctor you couldn't work at all, or whether you were restricted from certain types of work. That distinction matters because if a doctor cleared you for some kind of work during recovery, your availability argument is a lot stronger than if you were completely off. EDD doesn't require that you can do every job, just that there's some work you're able and available for during those weeks.

0 coins

My doctor cleared me for light duty work after the first week but I didn't go back to my old job because the location was already closed. So I was technically available, just not for heavy lifting or stocking.

0 coins

Then put that in your appeal letter. State clearly that you were able and available for light duty and sedentary work during those weeks, attach anything from your doctor that says so, and explain that you were actively able to accept suitable work offers.

0 coins

DE 1000M has a section for attaching additional documents. Medical clearance letters are exactly the kind of thing to include with the appeal form.

0 coins

To the person saying they were off for two weeks after surgery, something to double check is whether you certified for unemployment during that recovery period or not. If you answered the certifying questions honestly and said you weren't able to work, EDD would have denied those weeks from your certification, which is correct because those would be DI weeks not UI weeks. If you certified and said you were available when you weren't, that's a different issue. What did you actually tell EDD when you certified those weeks?

0 coins

Certified and said I was available because my doctor told me after the first week I could do light duty. So for week two of recovery I genuinely was available for some work, I just wasn't job hunting as aggressively.

0 coins

Then your appeal is on solid ground for at least that second week. Document that you were medically cleared for light duty and that you were still making efforts to find work even during recovery, even if the pace was slower.

0 coins

Keeping any records of applications, emails to employers, or CalJOBS activity from that period would help. Not because there's a mandatory number of contacts you have to prove, but because it shows you were genuinely still looking.

0 coins

Something nobody's addressed yet is whether the surgery weeks were the only ones being questioned or if there's a broader period on that denial. The DE 1080CZ should specify exactly which week or weeks the denial covers. If it's just two weeks out of a much longer claim period, your other weeks may be totally fine and paying out normally while you fight the specific denial.

0 coins

Just checked and the denial covers exactly the two weeks I was recovering. The rest of my claim periods are showing pending in UI Online which I assume is just normal processing.

0 coins

Pending for the other weeks is probably just regular processing lag then, not related to the denial at all. Keep certifying for the ongoing weeks and focus the appeal on those two specific November dates.

0 coins

That's a relief actually, a narrow denial covering a defined period is way more manageable to appeal than a blanket eligibility denial across the whole claim.

0 coins

The pending status on my remaining weeks was sitting there for almost three weeks and I had no idea if it was connected to a denial I'd gotten earlier. November layoff from a warehouse closure and I couldn't tell which part of my claim was the problem. Claimyr got me through to an EDD agent who looked at my account and said the pending weeks were on a standard processing hold completely unrelated to my denial, and that my denial was only about the specific two weeks I'd filed a DI overlap question on. The agent told me to keep certifying and expect the pending weeks to release once their batch processed.

0 coins

Really helpful to hear this, filing an appeal while keeping everything else moving is what I need to do.

0 coins

DI and UI overlap is exactly the kind of thing that causes these split letter situations. EDD processes them through different channels and both land in your mailbox the same week.

0 coins

November was busy on my end too, former restaurant supervisor, got cut when two locations consolidated. My pending weeks weren't clearing and I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr after I couldn't get anyone on the phone the regular way. The agent told me my DE 429Z had already been issued and my benefit year was active, the pending weeks just needed my identity verification step to clear first. After that resolved the payments came through for every certified week I had stacked up.

0 coins

Identity verification is a whole other layer I hadn't thought about. Mine was done through ID.me when I first filed so hopefully that's not causing additional holds.

0 coins

If you completed ID.me when you applied you should be clear on that front. The agent can confirm in about thirty seconds whether your identity step shows as complete on their end.

0 coins

ID.me verification is attached to your myEDD account so you can usually see the status reflected there, but calling to confirm never hurts especially when other holds are already in play.

0 coins

What nobody tells you upfront about filing unemployment is that your claim actually starts on the Sunday of the week you apply. So if there were any weeks between your layoff and when you actually filed where you were waiting to see what happened, those weeks before the filing date aren't claimable. With a November surgery and an October layoff, the timing of when you actually submitted the application matters for what they'll consider as claimable weeks.

0 coins

Applied the same week I was laid off so that part should be fine. Filed online through myEDD the day my manager confirmed the closure.

0 coins

Good, applying right away is the right move. Some people wait thinking they need to find another job first and they lose weeks they could have been collecting.

0 coins

Even the first week is the unpaid waiting period, so week one of a claim is served but not paid. That can confuse people into thinking they're missing a week when it's just how every new claim starts.

0 coins

Appeals sometimes get people anxious because they think it's like a court fight but it really starts simple. Write down in plain language what happened: I was laid off in October, had minor surgery, my doctor cleared me for light duty after one week, and I remained available for suitable work throughout. Attach the doctor's note or clearance letter. Mail it to the address on the denial notice using the DE 1000M. That's really the first step. The administrative law judge hearing at CUIAB only happens if EDD doesn't resolve it after reviewing your written appeal.

0 coins

So EDD reviews it first before it ever goes to a judge? I didn't realize there were two stages to this.

0 coins

EDD does an initial review first, then if it still stands the Office of Appeals and a judge get involved. For a lot of appeals the initial review stage resolves things, especially when new documentation is added.

0 coins

The notice of hearing comes by mail at least ten days before the actual hearing date if it goes that far, so you won't be blindsided. And you can represent yourself or bring someone, like a union rep or an attorney.

0 coins

For anyone reading this in a similar spot where surgery weeks are getting questioned, filing for DI during the period you actually couldn't work is the right move instead of UI. The two programs cover different situations: UI covers being out of work and looking, DI covers being unable to work due to illness or injury. If the surgery weeks were ones where you couldn't work at all, those should have been DI weeks. If you were cleared for light duty and were available, they can be UI weeks. EDD's own language says you can't receive both for the same days.

0 coins

Didn't know DI was even something I could file for during this. I just kept certifying for unemployment through the whole period.

0 coins

If you were medically cleared for light duty by week two, certifying UI for that week is probably fine given you were available. But if week one was when you genuinely couldn't work at all, that's a week where DI would have been the more accurate claim. Something to ask EDD about directly.

0 coins

Filing DI during the week you can't work and then switching back to UI once cleared is how it's supposed to work. Most people don't know that until something like this comes up.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is another thing worth confirming is complete, because if you haven't posted a resume there yet that can hold up payments separate from any eligibility issue. After a layoff, EDD typically sends a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (the DE 8405) and you've got 21 days from that date to get registered and post your resume on caljobs.ca.gov. If that slipped through the cracks with everything happening it's worth checking.

0 coins

Got that notice in the mail and registered the same week. Resume is posted. Didn't want anything extra holding things up.

0 coins

Then you're good on that front. Some people miss it in the pile of EDD mail they get in the first few weeks and then wonder why payments stall.

0 coins

The CalJOBS step being missed is way more common than people expect, especially when multiple EDD envelopes are arriving and people are overwhelmed reading all of them at once.

0 coins

About the two-letter confusion in general, it comes up because EDD's financial processing and their eligibility adjudication are literally separate departments running on different tracks. The award calculation went through on the financial side and generated the DE 429Z before the eligibility review flagged your November weeks. By the time the DE 1080CZ was printed they went out in the same batch. It's a systems coordination issue that EDD has had for years and it creates enormous confusion for claimants who reasonably assume two answers to one question have to be one or the other.

0 coins

Knowing it's a systems thing and not something I did wrong is honestly a relief. Felt like I was being punished for opening my mail in the wrong order.

0 coins

The system really is built in a way that makes no logical sense from the recipient's perspective. Two envelopes, same date, opposite answers, no explanation included for why both exist simultaneously.

0 coins

EDD's FAQ page even acknowledges this happens but most people don't know to look for that explanation when they're staring at two contradictory letters on the kitchen table.

0 coins

Assuming the appeal goes through and those November weeks get approved, make sure you're still certifying every two weeks in the meantime. The appeal process can take a while and you don't want to have a gap in certifications for weeks that eventually do get paid. If you stop certifying and win the appeal later, EDD can only go back and pay the weeks that were certified even if the appeal covers the full period.

0 coins

Already certified for the most recent two-week period just a few days ago. Planning to keep that going no matter what happens with the appeal.

0 coins

Keep that rhythm going. The appeal and the ongoing certifications run on parallel tracks and one doesn't pause the other.

0 coins

One more layer to the November surgery situation: if you had any vacation pay, holiday pay or in-lieu-of-notice pay that your employer paid out during the closure, all of that gets reported when certifying for the weeks you earned it even if you received it later. Lump sum payouts from a shuttered company sometimes land in people's accounts after the layoff and it's easy to forget to report them. If that happened and those weeks weren't reported correctly, that could also be contributing to what EDD is questioning.

0 coins

Got a final paycheck that included unused vacation payout the same week they closed. Reported it on my certification for that specific week. Is that how it's supposed to be done?

0 coins

Reported for the week it was earned is exactly right. The rule is to report wages in the week the work was performed or the entitlement occurred, not when the check cleared.

0 coins

Vacation payout on a closure layoff is one of the more confusing reporting situations because the timing of a final check doesn't always match when you'd normally say you 'earned' that vacation. Reporting it the week of the layoff is the approach most people take and it's consistent with how EDD describes earnings timing.

0 coins

With everything sorted out in the replies above, the action list from where you stand is pretty concrete: appeal the DE 1080CZ in writing using the DE 1000M before the 30-day clock runs, include your doctor's light-duty clearance as documentation, keep certifying every two weeks, and confirm your ID.me and CalJOBS registration are both showing complete. That covers every angle this thread identified.

0 coins

Written it all down. Going to draft the appeal letter tonight and send it certified mail tomorrow morning. Light duty clearance from my doctor is already in my files.

0 coins

Document everything you send and note the date mailed. If EDD has questions later, having a paper trail of what you submitted and when matters.

0 coins

Appeal in, certifications continuing, documentation attached. At that point it's really just a waiting game and EDD sends the next notice to your mailbox when a determination is made.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure