Second claim: are you unemployed as direct result of disaster how to answer on California EDD
Okay so I filed my original California EDD unemployment claim back in January after my company did a round of layoffs. Got through the whole process, served the waiting week, was certifying fine. Then the wildfires came through in February and my area was directly impacted — the building my employer operated out of was destroyed, so the remaining employees (I had been recalled temporarily) got cut again. Now I'm reopening my claim and there's this question on the second claim that asks if I am unemployed as a direct result of a disaster. I genuinely don't know how to answer it. My layoff in January had nothing to do with the fire, but the second time losing work absolutely did — the whole business location burned. Does saying yes to that question change how my claim is processed? Does it route me somewhere different? I don't want to answer wrong and mess up my adjudication or cause a delay I can't afford right now. I'm already worried because the first time around I had pending weeks for almost three weeks before anything moved. I really can't go through that again without income. Has anyone actually encountered this question on a reopened California EDD claim and figured out the right way to handle it?
73 comments

Amina Toure
Had that exact question show up when I reopened after a flood situation two years ago. The way I understood it, if the specific job loss you're claiming for right now was caused by the declared disaster — meaning the actual event wiped out your workplace or your employer couldn't operate because of it — then yes is the honest answer. If you got laid off for unrelated business reasons and the disaster was just coincidental timing, that would be no. Since the building literally burned, your second separation sounds like a direct result to me. Answer based on the actual reason for the job loss you're reopening for.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThat framing helps a lot. The January layoff was a cost-cutting thing, totally unrelated to any disaster. The February loss of work happened specifically because the fire destroyed the facility. So those really are two separate situations with different causes, and I should answer based on the February situation when reopening.
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
Agreed with separating the two events. EDD looks at each period of unemployment on its own terms. The question is about why you're unemployed right now when you file or reopen, not about any prior claim history.
0 coins
CosmicCommander
Worth noting that if the disaster is federally declared, there may also be federal disaster unemployment assistance available through a separate channel. That's different from the standard UI claim, so it's worth checking edd.ca.gov to see what programs are listed for your area.
0 coins
Natasha Volkova
The disaster question tripped me up too when I had to reopen. I initially thought it was asking about anything that had happened in my general area during the claim period, so I said yes even though my job loss was just a regular layoff and had nothing to do with any disaster declaration. EDD flagged it and I had to go through extra adjudication explaining the actual reason for separation. Answer it literally — did THIS unemployment happen because of the disaster, not just did a disaster happen around the same time.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThat's exactly the kind of mistake I was afraid of making in reverse — answering yes when the situation is actually more complicated. Mine really is a direct result for the second period, so I think yes is accurate, but good to know that a mismatch triggers adjudication.
0 coins
Javier Torres
Same type of mix-up almost got me. The question is specific to causation. Your workplace ceasing to exist because the building burned is about as direct as it gets.
0 coins
Emma Davis
Wildfire-related closure wiped out my employer in March and I had to reopen my claim too. Getting through to anyone at EDD to ask about that disaster question before answering it was nearly impossible — I tried the phone line three days in a row and kept hitting the high-volume message. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live agent on the line. There's a video they have on reaching a live person at EDD by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent I spoke with looked at my claim and confirmed that since my employer's physical location was destroyed in the declared disaster and that's the documented reason my work ended, answering yes was correct. She also said to make sure my employer's name and the last date worked at the fire-affected location matched what I'd put in the reopening, because a mismatch there is what usually sends those claims into extra review.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThe employer name and last-date-worked matching point is really useful, thank you. I want to make sure the reopening reflects the February separation from the recalled position, not the January layoff dates.
0 coins
Malik Johnson
Glad you got through. That mismatch detail about employer info is something I hadn't heard before — makes sense that if the name or date doesn't line up with what the employer reported, it'd kick into adjudication.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Had the same struggle getting EDD on the phone after my area was affected. Might try that route so I can confirm my own situation before I answer and submit.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Before I understood how the base period worked I assumed answering yes to the disaster question would automatically pull in some extra federal money or extend my claim. That's not really how it works. Your weekly benefit amount still comes from your highest-paid quarter in your base period, capped at $450 a week, and the standard 26-week maximum still applies to a regular UI claim. What the disaster designation might do is affect eligibility pathways if you didn't qualify under standard criteria, but your base claim math doesn't change just because disaster was involved.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorSo my weekly amount from the DE 429Z when I first filed — that stays the same when I reopen? Or does reopening recalculate based on new wages?
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Reopening the existing claim within the same benefit year doesn't reset the base period or recalculate your weekly amount. The benefit year runs 52 weeks from when you originally filed; your weekly benefit amount stays what the DE 429Z showed. If the benefit year ended and you're filing a brand new claim, that's when new wages get counted.
0 coins
NebulaNomad
Correct on the benefit year. Worth double checking your DE 429Z to see your maximum benefit amount remaining too, since you used some weeks on the first run.
0 coins
Freya Thomsen
Something I want to flag for anyone reopening after a disaster-related closure: the CalJOBS registration requirement doesn't go away just because a disaster was involved. Unless EDD specifically tells you that you're exempt, you still need to have your resume posted in CalJOBS. The notice about that (the DE 8405) is what you look at to know if it applies to you and what your deadline is. Missing the CalJOBS step has held up plenty of claims I've heard about in this forum.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorI did complete CalJOBS registration during the first claim period, so I think I'm already in the system. Does reopening trigger a new deadline for that, or is the registration still valid?
0 coins
Freya Thomsen
If you already registered and have an active profile, you generally don't need to re-register. The key is that your resume is still posted and your profile is current. EDD's requirement is about having it up, not about re-doing it every time.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
Confirming — once you're in CalJOBS with a resume posted you don't start over just because you reopened. I went through this after a gap and my existing registration carried over fine.
0 coins
Chloe Martin
Good to know. I was about to redo the whole CalJOBS thing thinking reopening reset the clock.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
All the people saying 'just answer yes because the building burned' are probably right but I'd also think about whether your specific area was under a federal disaster declaration at the time. The question on the claim form has more weight if there's an official declaration tied to it. Without that, it still might be accurate to say yes based on causation, but the declaration is what formally links your situation to disaster unemployment programs. Check edd.ca.gov for which disasters have been declared and whether your county is included.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThe area was under a declared disaster, yes. The fires in February affected several counties and there were both state and federal declarations made. So that part checks out for my situation.
0 coins
Amina Toure
The declared disaster piece does matter — it's not just about whether something bad happened in the area, it's about the official designation. Good addition to the thread.
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
Went through reopening a claim after a disaster situation and got confused about certifying. I thought since it was disaster-related I had to wait for some special approval before I could certify again. Spent almost two weeks not certifying. That was wrong and nobody told me until I finally got through to EDD. Keep certifying every two weeks through UI Online or EDD Tele-Cert even while your reopened claim is processing. If you stop certifying you create gaps that EDD can't go back and pay, even if they determine you were eligible for those weeks.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThat's a scary scenario. I'll make sure to keep certifying consistently once I reopen. I hadn't thought about the possibility that stopping certification would create unpayable gaps.
0 coins
Javier Torres
The certification gap thing catches people constantly. The rule about not being able to pay back weeks you didn't certify applies regardless of the reason for the delay — disaster-related reopening or anything else.
0 coins
Natasha Volkova
Piling on to emphasize this: Pending weeks in your Claim History are different from uncertified weeks. Pending means EDD is still processing your eligibility. Not certifying means the week literally doesn't exist in the system to be paid. Keep certifying no matter what.
0 coins
StarSeeker
The question about being unemployed as a direct result of disaster showed up differently on my claim than I expected. I had assumed it would only appear on a brand new claim, not on a reopening. When it appeared on the reopening I initially skipped past it thinking it was a glitch from the original application. It's not — when you're reopening and the reason for the new unemployment period is disaster-related, EDD includes it because it's relevant to that specific separation. Answer it as it applies to the reason you're unemployed right now.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorI actually wondered if the question appearing on a reopening was some kind of system carryover from the original filing. Good to hear it's intentional and that I should treat it as applying to the current separation.
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
EDD's reopening process asks about your most recent separation, so the disaster question on a reopening is about why you stopped working most recently, not about the original claim.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
An employer mismatch issue nearly tanked my reopened claim. The name I used for the second employer (they operated under a different DBA during the brief recall) didn't match what EDD had on file, and my weeks went into adjudication for over a month. While I was trying to sort it out I used Claimyr to get through to EDD and an agent confirmed the DBA issue was what had flagged the claim. They were able to note the account with the correct legal business name so the adjudication could move forward. If you were recalled under any entity name that differs from your original employer's filing, make sure that lines up before you submit the reopening.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThe business I was recalled to was the same legal entity as my original employer, just operating out of a temporary location before the fire. So the name should match, but I'll double-check the exact legal name against what EDD has in my claim history just in case.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
DBA versus legal name issues are more common than people realize, especially when a business is in recovery or transition mode like right after a disaster. Solid advice to verify before submitting.
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
Adjudication because of a name mismatch is incredibly frustrating because from the outside you have no idea what triggered it. The more you can confirm matches up front the better.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
Waiting week question for people reopening: some people assume they have to serve another unpaid waiting week every time they reopen a claim. That's a belief I had too. The waiting week is served once per benefit year, not once per separation within the year. If you served it on the original claim this benefit year, you don't serve it again on the reopening. Only your first eligible week at the start of the benefit year is unpaid.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThat's genuinely relieving. I definitely served the waiting week in January during the original claim, so when I reopen I should start getting paid weeks from the first week I'm eligible, not have to sit through another unpaid week.
0 coins
Chloe Martin
I served my waiting week two years ago and thought every new claim had one. Turns out that was for a different benefit year so it was correct — but within the same year you're right, it's just the once.
0 coins
NebulaNomad
Confirming this — one waiting week per benefit year. The confusion usually comes from people who filed claims in separate benefit years and experienced it both times and assumed it was always the case.
0 coins
Malik Johnson
I had an argument with someone at an AJCC workshop who insisted the waiting week applied every time you reopened. They were wrong. One per benefit year per the actual EDD rules.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Adjudication after the disaster question answer had me stuck for weeks on my own reopened claim. The issue ended up being that EDD wanted documentation of the employer's closure tied to the disaster, not just my word for it. I eventually got a live EDD agent through Claimyr to explain exactly what documentation they needed. The agent said a notice from the employer confirming the closure due to the fire, or a government record of the structure being condemned or destroyed, was what the adjudicator was waiting for. Once my employer emailed me a written statement confirming the closure reason, I submitted it through UI Online messaging and the adjudication cleared.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThis is really practical — so if adjudication opens after I answer yes to the disaster question, I should proactively gather something from my employer documenting that the closure was fire-related, rather than waiting for EDD to request it?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Exactly what I'd recommend. Having it ready shortened my adjudication significantly once I actually knew what was needed. Getting that info directly from an EDD agent was the only way I found out what was specifically holding it up.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Requesting documentation from the employer for the disaster link is something I wouldn't have thought to do on my own. The UI Online message system is what you used to submit it, not fax or mail?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Used the UI Online message system to send the employer's statement. The agent confirmed that was an acceptable way to submit supporting documentation for the open issue.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
People filing reopened claims after disasters sometimes believe the work search requirement gets suspended automatically. That's not how it works. Unless EDD specifically exempts you — and they will tell you if they do — you're still required to be able to work, available for work, and looking for work every week you certify. CalJOBS registration and an active resume also still apply unless EDD tells you otherwise. Don't assume a disaster situation automatically pauses those requirements.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorI hadn't assumed it was suspended but I also hadn't confirmed it wasn't. I'll keep treating the work search requirement as fully active since EDD hasn't told me anything different.
0 coins
StarSeeker
The work search requirement tripped a lot of people up after the fire in my area. Everyone assumed disaster status meant the rules changed. EDD didn't send out mass communications saying requirements were paused, so if you assumed they were and didn't look for work, that creates a problem for your certifications.
0 coins
CosmicCommander
If EDD does exempt you it'll say so clearly in a notice or on your UI Online account. Absent any such notice, treat every requirement as active.
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
Direct deposit setup took me by surprise on a reopening. I assumed my payment method from the original claim would just carry over — my Money Network card was already set up. It did carry over, but I'd read somewhere that some people's payment preferences reset. Worth logging into myEDD after you reopen to confirm your payment method is still set to what you want, before your first payment would go out.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorGood call. I'll check my payment settings in myEDD after I submit the reopening to make sure the Money Network card is still the default.
0 coins
Javier Torres
Mine carried over without any issue on a reopening. But it takes about 24 hours after certifying online before payment info updates in UI Online, so don't panic if it doesn't show immediately after you certify the first time.
0 coins
Chloe Martin
Filing the reopening through UI Online is definitely faster than trying to do it any other way. I tried to reopen by phone once because I had a complicated situation and wanted to explain it, and I was on hold for so long I eventually just gave up and did it online. The online reopening captures the same information and you can explain the circumstances in the text fields. Save yourself the time — start with myEDD online.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorI was actually planning to call first to ask about the disaster question before filing, but given how hard it is to get through, maybe I'll answer based on what I've learned in this thread and file online, then follow up by phone or message if I have questions after.
0 coins
Chloe Martin
Honestly that approach makes sense. The thread has covered the key point well — answer it based on whether the fire is the actual reason for this specific job loss. You can always send a message through UI Online if something comes up after.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
The UI Online message system is underrated for follow-up questions. Slower than phone but it creates a written record of what you asked and what EDD responded, which can be useful if something goes sideways later.
0 coins
NebulaNomad
The Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award, the DE 429Z, from the original claim is still the document that shows your weekly benefit amount for this benefit year. When I reopened after a disaster-related closure I kept looking for a new award letter and got confused when none came. There's no new award letter on a reopening within the same benefit year — your existing weekly amount and remaining maximum benefit amount carry through. Check the DE 429Z from January and your Claim History to know how many weeks of benefits you have left.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorSo I should subtract the weeks I already received during the January claim from the maximum on the DE 429Z to figure out how many weeks I have remaining for this reopening?
0 coins
NebulaNomad
Exactly. The Claim History in UI Online shows what's been paid, and your maximum benefit amount on the DE 429Z minus what's been paid tells you what's left in the benefit year.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
The UI Online Payments section also shows running totals. Cross-referencing that with your DE 429Z maximum is the clearest way to see your remaining balance.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Adjudication because of the disaster question answer doesn't mean you did anything wrong. EDD often needs to verify the connection between the disaster and your specific job loss, especially if the declared disaster covers a wide area and there are many claims. It's a verification step, not an accusation. If your weeks go pending after you answer yes, that's probably why, and gathering your employer's documentation proactively — the way someone earlier in the thread described — is exactly the right move.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThat perspective helps. I've been anxious that answering yes would automatically create a problem. Good to reframe it as EDD doing due diligence on the connection rather than doubting my honesty.
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
Adjudication is just EDD checking eligibility — it applies to all kinds of situations, not just disaster claims. Pending weeks are nerve-wracking but they don't mean denial.
0 coins
Natasha Volkova
The worst thing to do when weeks go pending is stop certifying. Keep certifying, keep checking Claim History, and if the pending status doesn't move in a few weeks, that's when you want to reach out to EDD directly.
0 coins
Malik Johnson
Had a friend go through a similar reopening question situation and they answered no because they thought the disaster had to be a hurricane or earthquake — something they personally picture as a major natural disaster. Wildfire absolutely qualifies. Any federally or state declared disaster that resulted in your job loss is what the question is capturing. Don't second-guess whether your specific disaster type counts.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorI had a small version of that doubt — wondering if fires counted the same way floods or earthquakes would. Good confirmation that the type of disaster doesn't matter as long as it's declared and caused the job loss.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
The declaration is the key, not the type of disaster. EDD's question is about causation and official designation, not about whether the disaster fits some mental image of what a 'real' disaster looks like.
0 coins
Javier Torres
If EDD sends you a DE 4800 notice scheduling a phone interview because of the disaster question on your reopening, don't confuse that interview with an appeal. I mixed those two up early on and it caused me a lot of unnecessary stress. The phone interview is EDD gathering more information from you to make an eligibility decision — it's part of the adjudication process. An appeal is a separate formal process you'd initiate after receiving a Notice of Determination if you disagreed with EDD's decision. The interview date and time will be on the DE 4800 and also on your UI Online homepage. Keep your phone nearby at that specific time — the interviewer calls at that time.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThank you for clarifying that distinction. If I get a DE 4800 it means EDD wants more information, not that they've already decided against me. That's a much less scary way to think about it.
0 coins
StarSeeker
The interview versus appeal confusion is so common. The interview is early in the process and cooperative — EDD asking you questions. The appeal comes after a denial, initiated by you. Very different things.
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
And missing the phone interview is bad news — if you're not available at the time on the DE 4800 you're supposed to phone EDD the same day to let them know. Otherwise EDD decides from whatever information they already have, which may not be enough to approve the claim.
0 coins
CosmicCommander
Overpayment concern I had on my own reopening: I was worried that if I answered the disaster question incorrectly it could lead to an overpayment notice later if EDD decided I wasn't actually eligible under that designation. The technical answer is yes — if EDD later decides the disaster designation doesn't apply to your situation and you received benefits under it, they could issue an overpayment notice. That's why accuracy matters. Answer the question based on what's genuinely true about your situation, not based on what might get you paid faster.
0 coins
Paolo Ricci
AuthorThat's a real consequence I hadn't fully thought through. The good news is that in my case the answer really is yes based on the actual facts — the fire destroyed the facility and ended my work. I'm not stretching the truth to get a faster outcome.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Answering honestly always protects you better than trying to game the question. An overpayment for fraud has penalties attached. A misunderstanding that leads to a non-fraud overpayment still has to be repaid. Neither is a situation worth creating by being imprecise.
0 coins