Back to California Unemployment

Hugh Intensity

Overpayment from working while certifying and 1099-G taxes how to correct

Last year I picked up a part-time gig while still on UI and honestly didn't realize I was supposed to report those earnings during my certifications. I thought as long as it was just a few hours here and there it didn't matter. Fast forward to now and EDD sent me an overpayment notice for $1,840 and now my Form 1099-G is showing the full original benefit amount I received, not the corrected lower amount after the overpayment. I'm trying to figure out two things: first, can I get the overpayment waived or do I definitely have to pay it back, and second, is my 1099-G going to be wrong for tax purposes because of this? I've already filed my federal return using the number on the 1099-G and I'm panicking that I either over-reported income or that EDD is going to come after me for taxes on money I technically owe back. Anyone dealt with this kind of mess before?

Went through almost this exact same situation earlier this year. My DE 429Z had showed a weekly amount of $380 and I'd been certifying for about four months before EDD sent me a Notice of Overpayment for weeks I'd partially worked. After months of phone tag that went nowhere I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and actually got through to a live EDD agent. The agent confirmed the overpayment on my account was flagged as non-fraud since I hadn't intentionally hidden anything, and said I could submit the DE 1446UI to request a waiver based on hardship. She also told me the 1099-G reflects what was paid out in that calendar year and doesn't automatically adjust for an overpayment in a later year. She said to contact EDD directly about a corrected 1099-G if I repaid the overpayment in the same tax year the benefits were paid. The video Claimyr has on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see how it looks before trying the phones yourself.

0 coins

Wait, so the 1099-G only gets corrected if I repaid it in the same year? I received the benefits and got the overpayment notice both in the same calendar year, but I haven't actually paid anything back yet. Does the correction only apply if I repay it the same year?

0 coins

The agent specifically said repayment in the same tax year as the benefits were paid is what triggers a corrected 1099-G, so yes your situation would qualify if you pay it back before December 31st. She didn't tell me whether partial repayment changes anything, so that might be worth asking EDD directly.

0 coins

Doesn't the IRS also have guidance on repaid benefits from a prior year? Not sure EDD corrects the 1099-G automatically, there might be a deduction you can take instead.

0 coins

The IRS does have a rule for repaid benefits in a prior year, usually handled on Schedule A or as a credit depending on the amount. But for the same-year correction, contacting EDD is the right first step like the person above said.

0 coins

Missed reporting wages during three different certification periods myself and ended up with a $2,100 overpayment notice. The part that tripped me up was not knowing the earnings go in for the week they were actually earned, not when the check cleared my bank. I thought I was doing it right by reporting payday but EDD wants the week you did the work. The overpayment amount came from that timing mismatch almost entirely, and after I explained it in my waiver letter EDD reduced what I owed. Worth knowing the difference if you're writing your own DE 1446UI.

0 coins

Are you saying EDD actually reduced the overpayment amount based on what you wrote in the waiver letter, or they waived it entirely? And did you have to prove the timing thing with pay stubs?

0 coins

They reduced it, didn't wipe it out. I sent copies of my pay stubs showing pay periods versus work dates and they adjusted the weeks accordingly. Wasn't a full waiver, more like a partial correction because a chunk of it was genuine overpayment from weeks I did earn more than I reported.

0 coins

Saving this detail because I had no idea the reporting is based on when you work not when you get paid. My boss pays us two weeks behind and I've been reporting on payday this whole time.

0 coins

If you've been reporting the wrong weeks, reaching out to EDD through the message option in UI Online sooner rather than later is probably smart. Getting ahead of it looks better than waiting for them to catch it.

0 coins

The waiver form being DE 1446UI is correct but one thing I want to flag is what the waiver actually requires. EDD looks at whether the overpayment was your fault and whether repaying it would be a real hardship. If they decide it was your fault, even without fraud, the waiver usually won't go through. So in the original poster's situation where they just didn't know to report, the fault question is what EDD will focus on, not just the hardship part. Document why you didn't know, like if you never got clear instructions during the application process or the certifying questions were confusing to you.

0 coins

The certifying question does just say something like 'did you work any days' and then asks for earnings. I genuinely didn't understand that a few hours of gig work counted. Would that be enough to argue it wasn't my fault?

0 coins

Honestly that's the kind of thing worth explaining in the waiver. I'm not in a position to say what EDD will decide, but describing your understanding at the time and what you thought the question was asking could support a no-fault argument. Keep it factual and specific.

0 coins

EDD's certifying question is worded badly in my opinion. I've seen multiple people confused about whether gig work counts, whether tips count, whether a one-day job counts. The form really doesn't spell it out clearly.

0 coins

Tips definitely count, all wages for the week earned go in. I learned that the hard way too but luckily caught it before EDD did and messaged through UI Online to correct it.

0 coins

About the 1099-G question specifically: the form shows the gross amount EDD actually paid out during that calendar year. If you got $6,000 in benefits and then were told you owe $1,840 back, the 1099-G will show $6,000 regardless of the overpayment notice, unless you repay within the same calendar year and EDD issues a corrected form. The IRS is aware of this situation and there are provisions for handling repaid unemployment benefits on your federal return, either as an itemized deduction or in some cases a tax credit, depending on the amount. The way most people handle it when repayment happens in a later year is through the federal return, not by waiting for a corrected 1099-G.

0 coins

So if I can't repay it this year, I should probably talk to a tax person about the federal return side of it? I already filed so I'm wondering if I need to amend.

0 coins

Whether to amend depends on the year the repayment actually happens and the amounts involved. A tax professional or the IRS instructions for repaid benefits would give you the clearest answer for your specific numbers. I wouldn't amend preemptively before you've actually repaid anything.

0 coins

Amended returns take forever too, like months. If you don't have to file one right now probably better to wait and sort it out when you actually make the repayment.

0 coins

My cousin works in payroll and told me EDD automatically adjusts your 1099-G whenever there's an overpayment. I don't think that's right though based on what people are saying here?

0 coins

That's not accurate as a general rule. EDD issues a corrected 1099-G only in specific situations, same-year repayment being the main one. It doesn't happen automatically just because an overpayment was flagged on the account.

0 coins

Yeah I figured it sounded too easy. Good to know before I told anyone else that.

0 coins

Penalty question: does EDD add extra fees on top of a non-fraud overpayment? I had a friend tell me there's a 30 percent penalty but that sounded like it was for fraud cases only.

0 coins

Your friend has the right number but the wrong situation. The 30 percent penalty goes on fraud overpayments, meaning cases where EDD found someone intentionally gave false info or held something back on purpose. A non-fraud overpayment still has to be paid back but there's no penalty added on top of the principal amount.

0 coins

That's a relief actually. The original poster's situation sounds like non-fraud so at least it won't balloon with a penalty on top of the $1,840.

0 coins

Still not a fun situation but yeah non-fraud without the penalty is at least manageable to pay back over time, EDD does let you set up payments I believe.

0 coins

EDD catching up on certifications where I didn't report a side job was genuinely one of the most stressful things I've dealt with. The letter came out of nowhere, $980 overpayment for four weeks of delivery work I thought was too small to matter. Filled out the DE 1446UI and explained I hadn't known gig work counted the same as regular wages and that the income I'd had was already spent on rent. They came back and said the waiver was denied because they considered it my responsibility to report all earnings. So just want the original poster to know not every waiver goes through, even when it feels like a genuinely honest mistake.

0 coins

Did they give you a reason in writing when they denied it, and did you try to appeal the denial?

0 coins

They sent a letter with a one-line reason saying I had been informed of my reporting obligations during the application process. I didn't appeal it because I honestly wasn't sure I had a strong enough argument and I was exhausted. In retrospect I probably should have.

0 coins

You can appeal a waiver denial within 30 calendar days of the mailing date on the notice. If the window is still open for you it might be worth at least trying. The appeal goes in writing with the DE 1000M or a letter to the address on the notice.

0 coins

Window closed long ago for me unfortunately. For anyone else reading this though, 30 days goes fast so don't sit on it like I did.

0 coins

The DE 429Z on my claim had a weekly amount of $310 and I had three weeks sitting as Pending in UI Online Claim History for months with no explanation. After trying the phone line at 1-800-300-5616 for two weeks straight and getting cut off every time I tried Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the line. The agent pulled up my account and told me one of those weeks had a wage-reporting flag tied to hours I'd logged through the Report Wages screen. She walked me through what had been recorded and what the certification showed and we figured out the week I'd reported my earnings in the wrong period. That fixed the pending issue once I followed up with EDD to correct the record.

0 coins

How did you correct the record once the agent identified the wrong period? Did they fix it on the call or did you have to send something in?

0 coins

The agent said to contact EDD in writing through UI Online with the specific week and what the correct earnings amount was. The Report Wages screen in UI Online only works before you certify that week, so once it's certified you have to message EDD directly to fix it.

0 coins

Glad that worked out. The Report Wages screen is confusing because it looks like you can go back and edit things but you actually can't once the week is certified. Caught me off guard the first time I tried to fix something.

0 coins

Is there any difference in how EDD handles the overpayment if the original work was self-employment versus a W-2 job? I've been doing both and want to make sure I'm not mixing up the rules.

0 coins

EDD wants all earnings reported for the week they were earned, whether it's W-2 wages, self-employment income, gig work, tips, or anything else. How it affects your weekly benefit amount works the same way: the first $25 or 25 percent of gross earnings for the week, whichever is bigger, isn't counted, and the rest gets subtracted from your benefit. Same formula regardless of the type of work.

0 coins

So I should be reporting gross self-employment earnings, not what actually hits my account after expenses?

0 coins

EDD's certification asks for gross earnings for the week. For specific questions about how self-employment income is treated on your claim, reaching out to EDD directly would give you the clearest answer for your situation since it can get complicated.

0 coins

Self-employment is one of those things where I'd really recommend messaging EDD through UI Online with specifics rather than guessing, because getting it wrong in either direction is a problem.

0 coins

The 1099-G being wrong might also just be a timing thing in how EDD processes these. Curious whether anyone has actually gotten a corrected 1099-G from EDD after repaying an overpayment in the same year and what that process looked like.

0 coins

The agent I spoke to said to contact EDD after the repayment posts to the account and request a corrected form. It doesn't happen automatically, you have to initiate it.

0 coins

Makes sense that it's not automatic. EDD's systems don't always connect the dots on their own, pushing them to issue the correction after repayment is confirmed seems like the right move.

0 coins

Good to know. So basically repay, then contact EDD, then wait for a corrected 1099-G if you're in the same tax year window.

0 coins

Months into certifying without fully understanding the reporting rules here too. Never knew vacation pay had to go in, and I had a week where my old job paid out accrued vacation after my last day. Thought since it was for days I didn't actually work it wouldn't count. Got lucky that EDD processed it without flagging it but after reading all this I'm not sure I reported it right.

0 coins

Vacation pay, holiday pay, and in-lieu-of-notice pay all go into the certification for the week they cover, not when paid out. If you think something was reported in the wrong week or not reported correctly, reaching out to EDD through UI Online to flag it before they flag it themselves is the smarter move.

0 coins

The accrued vacation was paid out as a lump sum on my last paycheck, so I honestly don't know what week it was 'for.' This is exactly the kind of question I need to actually ask EDD.

0 coins

Lump sum vacation payouts are worth asking EDD about specifically because how they're allocated to weeks isn't always obvious, and getting it wrong is how overpayments happen.

0 coins

The frustrating part of all these overpayment situations is that EDD's certifying interface doesn't explain the rules clearly in the moment. You're answering a question about whether you worked and entering earnings and there's nothing that tells you gig work counts, or when to report earnings, or that vacation pay is wages. I went through a whole adjudication process last year because I hadn't understood that in-lieu-of-notice pay from my previous employer was supposed to be reported and it delayed my claim by over a month.

0 coins

Did the adjudication end up affecting whether you got paid for those weeks or did EDD just hold them while they sorted it out?

0 coins

EDD held the weeks as Pending during adjudication and paid them all out after the decision. But the month of waiting when I had no income coming in was brutal. Would have been much less stressful if the system had just flagged that in-lieu-of-notice pay at the time I was certifying.

0 coins

Adjudication gets used loosely in a lot of these conversations to mean any time EDD is reviewing something. The actual adjudication process is more specific, it's when EDD is deciding a question about eligibility. Pending weeks can show up for other reasons like identity verification or a wage-reporting review too.

0 coins

Fair point, I might have been using the term loosely. In my case it was specifically an eligibility question they were deciding, so that was actual adjudication. But yes, Pending covers a lot of situations.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD set up a repayment plan rather than paying the overpayment all at once? $1,840 is not small and I'm wondering if EDD is flexible on that.

0 coins

EDD does have options for setting up payments rather than paying in a lump sum. The notice itself usually has information about how to contact them about it, or you can reach out through UI Online or call to ask about payment arrangements.

0 coins

This is actually really useful to know because I'd been worried about owing the full amount immediately. I'll ask when I contact EDD about the waiver.

0 coins

Just make sure you don't ignore the notice while you're figuring out the waiver. If the waiver is denied and you haven't made any payments or arrangements in the meantime it can complicate things.

0 coins

Repayment plan question made me think of my own situation. EDD had my weekly benefit amount listed as $295 on the DE 429Z but started sending me letters saying I had an outstanding balance from a week three years ago. Tried calling for weeks and couldn't get through. Used Claimyr and got an EDD agent who looked up the account and said the balance was from a certification period where wages had been flagged late by an employer. She told me which specific week it was and what amount was in dispute, and I was able to send in the documentation through UI Online to clear it up.

0 coins

Three years later and EDD was still chasing that? Good to know they can go back that far because I want to make sure I address my situation before it compounds.

0 coins

EDD can go back further than most people expect. Getting it resolved sooner rather than waiting is definitely the right call.

0 coins

Employer-reported wages flagging late is such a common issue and it's not even the claimant's fault when it happens. At least there's a process to clear it up once you can actually talk to someone.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the CalJOBS side during all this: if you're still on an active claim while dealing with an overpayment dispute, make sure you haven't let your CalJOBS registration lapse. EDD can stop payments for not registering in CalJOBS and posting a resume within 21 days of the DE 8405 date, and that's a separate issue from the overpayment itself. Dealing with a payment hold on top of an overpayment dispute is a situation I saw a family member go through and it was messy.

0 coins

My claim is probably going to be closed by now given all the time that's passed. But if someone is still actively certifying during an overpayment dispute this is good to keep in mind.

0 coins

Even with a closed benefit year it's worth knowing for anyone else reading who is still mid-claim. And if you do reopen a claim at some point, the CalJOBS requirement kicks in again from the new DE 8405 date.

0 coins

Does filing the DE 1446UI waiver form pause any collection activity EDD might take while they review it? Or can they still start taking future benefits to offset the overpayment while the waiver is pending?

0 coins

Filing the waiver doesn't automatically pause collection. EDD can still offset future UI, disability or Paid Family Leave benefits against an outstanding overpayment while the waiver is being reviewed. If you have a new claim active it's worth contacting EDD to ask specifically whether collection is paused during waiver review in your situation.

0 coins

That's really important and not obvious from the waiver form itself. I assumed submitting it would put a hold on everything.

0 coins

The offset from future benefits is one of the main collection tools EDD uses, along with tax refund intercepts and state lottery winnings. None of those pause automatically just from filing the waiver.

0 coins

Okay so I should probably move on this waiver quickly rather than waiting to see what happens. Good to know the clock isn't paused automatically.

0 coins

Something that caught me off guard when I got my overpayment notice: the 30 calendar day window to appeal starts from the mailing date on the Notice of Determination, not from when you actually receive it. I lived in an apartment with slow mail delivery and by the time I got the letter and read it carefully I had maybe 12 days left. Would have missed it entirely if I hadn't opened the mail the same day it arrived.

0 coins

Is there any way to know the mailing date before the letter arrives, like through UI Online?

0 coins

Not that I found. The mailing date is only on the letter itself. So opening EDD mail immediately when it arrives is genuinely important, not something you can catch up on later in UI Online.

0 coins

Paperless settings in myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ can help you know when something new has posted, though the actual notice text still comes by mail. At least you'd know to watch for it.

0 coins

Random thing from my own certification mess: I didn't realize you could keep certifying during an appeal and that EDD can only pay those weeks if they were actually certified. Almost stopped certifying while my appeal was pending thinking there was no point. Someone on a thread like this one warned me not to stop and they were right.

0 coins

That's actually a really important point that I hadn't even thought about. So even if the overpayment has me worried about certifying, I shouldn't just stop?

0 coins

If you're still in a benefit year and eligible, yes keep certifying. EDD can't pay back any weeks that weren't certified, so stopping means you lose those weeks permanently even if the appeal goes in your favor.

0 coins

This tripped up a lot of people I know. The instinct when something feels uncertain is to pause everything but with certifications the opposite is true.

0 coins

One thing worth mentioning for the original poster and others here: once you repay an overpayment and want a corrected 1099-G, EDD's contact options include UI Online messages, the phone line at 1-800-300-5616, or the live chat through the Help button in UI Online which runs Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. Pacific. The live chat is underused because people don't know it exists. For something like a corrected 1099-G request it might actually be faster than waiting for a callback that never materializes... I mean, faster than waiting on hold.

0 coins

I didn't know the live chat existed either. I'll try that after I get the repayment sorted. Thanks for the hours.

0 coins

Just make sure you're logged into UI Online first because the Help button only appears once you're in your account. Outside of that you're back to phone or messages.

0 coins

The live chat window being so short, 9 to 2, makes it hard for anyone who works daytime hours. But for someone dealing with an overpayment who might not be working full-time right now, it's probably accessible.

0 coins

Got hit with an overpayment notice myself about six weeks ago for $740 from a week where I had vacation pay from my former employer that I honestly forgot existed. The DE 1446UI was a lot more involved to fill out than I expected. I used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line and asked her specifically what documentation would make the strongest waiver application. She told me the two things EDD weighs most heavily are whether I had been notified of the reporting obligation and whether repayment would create a genuine hardship, and to include bank statements or bills showing my financial situation alongside the form.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of guidance I was hoping to find. Did she say whether I should send everything in together or if the waiver form alone is enough to start the review?

0 coins

She said to include supporting documents with the form, not separately, because separate mailings can get separated from the file and slow the review down.

0 coins

The tip about keeping documents together with the form is worth remembering. EDD's mail processing is not known for being careful about keeping related things together.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure