Back to California Unemployment

Raul Neal

Notice of determination invalid claim section 1277 new claim after benefit year ended - what does this mean for California EDD?

Got a Notice of Determination in the mail yesterday and I'm completely confused. The letter says my claim is invalid under section 1277, something about filing a new claim after my benefit year ended. For context - my previous claim ran out earlier this year, I went back to work for a few months at a warehouse job, got laid off again in September, then filed a brand new claim. I figured since I had new wages from those months back at work, I'd be fine. But now EDD is saying the claim is invalid? The notice has an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) attached and says I have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal. I don't even understand what I did wrong. I reported everything honestly when I applied - all my employers, my wages, the dates. Is this a denial of benefits entirely or just a problem with how the claim is set up? Has anyone dealt with a section 1277 invalid claim determination from California EDD before? I really need this income, the warehouse job didn't pay much and I didn't save a ton between claims.

Section 1277 came up on my claim too, back when my benefit year ended in the spring and I tried filing again after picking up some temp work. The UI Online homepage showed my new application sitting there with no payment activity and no explanation, just weeks showing as pending. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent - there's a video about reaching a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what that looks like before you try it. The agent pulled up my file and told me my new wages hadn't been entered into EDD's system yet from my employer, so the alternate base period couldn't generate a valid claim either. She said to wait for EDD to request the wage information from my employer and that the determination might be revised once those wages posted. Worth knowing your base period situation before you appeal, because the fix might not need an appeal at all.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

Did they actually revise it without you having to appeal? I'm only at 18 days since the mailing date and getting nervous about the 30-day window closing on me.

0 coins

Mine did get revised, but it took a couple more weeks after the agent said the wages were being verified. I sent in the appeal anyway as a precaution, mentioning I was waiting on wage records. Keeping both options open seemed smart.

0 coins

How long does EDD usually take to update wages from an employer? My situation is similar and I have no idea if my former employer even reported anything yet.

0 coins

Wait, is section 1277 specifically about not having enough wages in the base period, or is it something different? I always thought an invalid claim just meant not enough earnings, but that DE 1080CZ wording about 'new claim after benefit year ended' sounds like a timing issue, not a wage issue.

0 coins

Is the distinction actually that clean though? From what I understand, the two things can overlap - if your benefit year just ended and you file immediately but your most recent wages fall outside the standard base period, you might not have enough to qualify even if you worked a decent amount.

0 coins

The base period question is the key one to ask EDD directly - specifically, which quarters they're looking at for your claim. The standard one looks at the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you filed, so if you worked those months but the quarter isn't closed yet, those wages might not count. EDD automatically checks the alternate base period too if the standard one doesn't generate a valid claim, using the last four completed quarters instead. The threshold is either $1,300 in one quarter of the base period, or $900 in your highest quarter with total wages of at least 1.25 times that amount. Neither the standard nor alternate base period worked for someone I know, and that's what triggered their section 1277 determination.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

So if the warehouse job wages are in a quarter that's not fully closed yet, they just... don't count at all for my claim? That seems brutal. My highest quarter at the warehouse job was probably around $3,800 so it should clear the threshold if EDD can actually see it.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be dumb - does filing the appeal automatically extend the 30 days or do you have to submit it before the deadline no matter what? I got a DE 1080CZ for a different reason last month and I'm still figuring out the paperwork.

0 coins

The 30 calendar days run from the mailing date on the notice itself, and there's no extension for submitting it - you send it in before that date or you lose the automatic right. If you do miss it, you can still appeal but you'd need to explain in writing why you missed the window. Send it to the address on the notice, using the DE 1000M or just a letter stating you disagree and want to appeal.

0 coins

Does that mean postmarked by day 30 or received by EDD by day 30? I always get paranoid about mailing stuff to government agencies.

0 coins

Mailing it via certified mail on or before day 30 is the safest approach so you have a postmark and delivery confirmation. The address is on the DE 1080CZ itself.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

I'm going to drop mine off this week either way. Not taking any chances on that deadline.

0 coins

Honestly this whole base period calculation thing is one of the most confusing parts of the California EDD system. I didn't understand any of it when I filed my first claim and nobody explains it upfront. You just get a letter that says invalid and you're supposed to somehow know what base period means and which quarters apply to you.

0 coins

Agree it's not explained well at all. EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site at edd.ca.gov does let you plug in wages and quarters before you even file so you can estimate whether a claim will be valid. Would have been helpful to know that existed before getting a denial letter.

0 coins

I didn't know the calculator existed either. I just filed and hoped for the best. Found this forum after getting my own determination letter two years ago.

0 coins

The calculator is useful but it still requires you to know which quarters to put in, which assumes you understand the base period to begin with. Kind of circular.

0 coins

Has anyone actually won an appeal on a section 1277 determination, or is appealing kind of pointless if the wages genuinely weren't there? I want to understand whether the appeal is worth the effort before I go through the whole process.

0 coins

Appeals on invalid claim determinations can succeed, but mostly in specific circumstances - like when EDD used the wrong base period, when employer wage records weren't accurately reported to EDD, or when there's a wage dispute. If the wages legitimately aren't there in any base period, an appeal won't create them. What you'd argue in an appeal is that EDD miscalculated, not that the rules are unfair.

0 coins

That makes sense. So the first step is really just verifying EDD actually has correct wage information before deciding if appealing even makes sense.

0 coins

Exactly - and you can request your own wage statement from EDD to see what wages they actually have on file for you. If it doesn't match your pay stubs, that's the core of your appeal argument.

0 coins

My cousin went through something kind of similar and was told the alternate base period would save her claim, but then it still came back invalid. Is there a situation where even the alternate base period doesn't fix it?

0 coins

Completely possible, yes. The alternate base period shifts the window to the last four completed quarters instead of the standard four, but if someone had a long gap in employment before filing or their recent wages fell in an unclosed quarter for both periods, neither calculation produces a valid claim. The threshold still has to be met under whichever base period EDD uses.

0 coins

Is there any other option after that? Like a third base period or something?

0 coins

No third option - standard and alternate are what California has. If neither generates a valid claim, the section 1277 determination stands unless there's a wage error to correct. That's worth verifying before giving up though.

0 coins

How do you actually see what wages EDD has on file for you? Is that somewhere in UI Online or do you have to call or write in?

0 coins

Calling EDD directly is the most reliable way to hear exactly which wages they have recorded - the agent can read the quarters off your file. UI Online shows your payment history and claim status but I've never seen a wage detail screen in there.

0 coins

So there's no way to see it online without calling? That feels like information they should just show you.

0 coins

You can also send a message through your UI Online account to ask about wages on file. It's slower than calling but it creates a written record of what EDD says.

0 coins

Section 1277 gets thrown around but does anyone know if there's a difference between section 1277 and just being disqualified? My notice says invalid, not disqualified, but my neighbor said it's the same thing.

0 coins

Not the same thing - worth clarifying that for your neighbor. An invalid claim under section 1277 means the claim itself can't be established because the wage threshold wasn't met. A disqualification means the claim could be established but you're not eligible for some period because of something like quitting without good cause or misconduct. Two different legal situations with different remedies.

0 coins

Oh that actually matters a lot. I'll tell them. So an invalid claim is more about the math not adding up, not about anything you did wrong.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

This is really helpful actually. I was sort of treating it like a disqualification and beating myself up about what I did wrong when maybe it's purely a wage calculation issue.

0 coins

Did EDD tell you at any point during the application that your claim might not be valid, or did the section 1277 notice just show up out of nowhere?

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

Total surprise. UI Online just showed pending weeks with no explanation, then the letter arrived. No warning during the application itself, no message in my account. I didn't even know what section 1277 was until I started googling and found threads like this one.

0 coins

That's the frustrating part. Even a message in UI Online saying 'your wage records are under review' would help people understand what's coming instead of just getting blindsided by a determination letter.

0 coins

EDD's communication is honestly one of the biggest pain points. The system sends a determination and then you're left figuring out the reason from the code on the letter.

0 coins

What does the actual appeal hearing look like if you get to that stage? I always imagined it was some intimidating courtroom thing.

0 coins

The hearing is conducted by an administrative law judge from the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board - the Office of Appeals handles it. It's not in a courtroom. You get a Notice of Hearing by mail at least 10 days before it happens. Testimony is under oath, and you can represent yourself or bring someone with you, like a union rep or an attorney. The judge hears both sides and mails a written decision afterward.

0 coins

Is it usually done by phone or in person?

0 coins

The format can vary - hearings have been conducted both ways. The Notice of Hearing will tell you how yours is set up. For invalid claim appeals, you're typically presenting wage evidence so having your pay stubs organized is important either way.

0 coins

OK that's less scary than I pictured. Might actually go through with it now.

0 coins

If you appeal and the judge sides with you, how does EDD process the back pay for the weeks you certified during the appeal period? Do you need to do anything special to get those paid out?

0 coins

Certifying every two weeks during the appeal is the essential step - EDD can only pay the weeks you've certified for. If you stop certifying while waiting on the appeal and win, those uncertified weeks may not be payable. Keep certifying through the whole process even if everything shows as pending.

0 coins

Does certifying while your claim is under appeal affect the appeal itself in any way?

0 coins

No, certifying is separate from the appeal. It just preserves your weeks so there's something to pay if the appeal succeeds.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

I've been continuing to certify even though everything says pending. Good to know that's the right move.

0 coins

My benefit year ended in July and I had a gap before filing a new claim in October after getting laid off from a restaurant. UI Online showed all pending weeks and no payment activity. Used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line who checked my file and found that my employer had reported wages for only one of the three months I worked - the agent said once the other two months' wages came through from the employer, EDD would re-evaluate the claim. I went ahead and filed an appeal on the DE 1000M anyway, noting the missing wages, and my pending weeks moved to paid about three weeks later.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

Three weeks from filing the appeal to payment - that's actually not as long as I feared. Did you have to do anything else or did it just resolve on its own once the wages showed up?

0 coins

Just kept certifying and waited. The appeal might have prompted EDD to look at the file again, or the wages showed up on their own - hard to say which did it. Either way, acting on both fronts at once seemed to work.

0 coins

The employer not reporting all the wages is something I hadn't thought about as a possible cause. That would explain a section 1277 that feels wrong to the person who filed.

0 coins

Does submitting the DE 1000M appeal automatically trigger EDD to review the wage records again, or is it reviewed by the appeals board without EDD looking at it first?

0 coins

EDD reviews the appeal first before it goes anywhere near the appeals board. If EDD decides to change its determination based on the appeal, it can do that without sending the case to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board at all. Only if EDD doesn't change the determination does it transfer to the Office of Appeals for a hearing in front of an administrative law judge.

0 coins

So appealing might actually get a faster resolution if EDD just fixes it themselves without a hearing.

0 coins

Exactly. That internal review step is worth factoring in - a lot of appeals get resolved at that stage without ever reaching a hearing.

0 coins

What do you actually write in the appeal if your argument is that your wages weren't all recorded? Do you need to include pay stubs or just describe the problem?

0 coins

Including copies of your pay stubs covering the disputed quarters makes your argument concrete. Write clearly that you believe the wages used to evaluate your claim are incomplete, identify which employer and time period you think is missing, and state that you disagree with the section 1277 determination. The more specific you are, the better.

0 coins

Does the DE 1000M have enough space to explain all that, or should you attach a separate letter?

0 coins

Attaching a written explanation with your pay stubs to the DE 1000M is completely fine. The form has limited space so a brief letter attached to it works well.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

I'm drafting mine now and planning to attach copies of my last four pay stubs plus a brief letter. This thread has honestly clarified a lot about what I should actually write.

0 coins

Can you file a brand new claim with different base period quarters while the section 1277 appeal is still pending, or would that mess up the appeal?

0 coins

Filing a new claim while one is under appeal could complicate things, and EDD's rules around benefit years and base periods mean a new filing might just produce the same result if the wage situation hasn't changed. The appeal is usually the cleaner path - ask EDD directly about your specific dates before filing anything new.

0 coins

Makes sense to not start a second process before the first one is resolved. I'll stay on the appeal track.

0 coins

EDD can answer that question directly for your specific situation. The dates involved matter a lot and their answer might be different from one person to the next.

0 coins

November wages from a retail job I had weren't showing up when my claim came back invalid. EDD's phone lines were impossible for about two weeks - I'd call right at 8 a.m. and get disconnected before reaching anyone. Ended up getting through to an agent using Claimyr after getting nowhere on my own. The agent confirmed my employer had filed the wage report late, and that EDD was processing the correction - she told me to watch Claim History in UI Online over the next week and to send a message through my account if the status didn't change.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

Late employer wage reports seem to come up a lot in this thread. Is there any way to check on your end whether your employer actually filed, or does that information only exist on EDD's side?

0 coins

From what I can tell it's really on EDD's side - they receive the wage data from employers and you can't see the raw report yourself. That's why getting an agent to actually look at your file is so much more useful than staring at UI Online waiting for something to change.

0 coins

Two weeks of calling right at 8 a.m. and getting disconnected is legitimately exhausting. That part of the system is so broken.

0 coins

For the 30-day appeal window specifically - does the clock start on the date the notice was mailed or the date you received it? My mail is sometimes slow.

0 coins

The mailing date printed on the DE 1080CZ is what starts the clock, not when you received it. If your mail ran late and you're worried about being close to the edge, file immediately and explain in the appeal letter that you received the notice later than the mailing date. EDD and the appeals board do consider late appeals when there's a reasonable explanation.

0 coins

So if the mailing date says October 15 and I got it October 22, I'd have until November 14 regardless of when it arrived.

0 coins

Exactly. Count 30 calendar days from the date printed on the notice. No weekends or holidays change that number.

0 coins

Somebody above said EDD reviews the appeal before it goes to the appeals board. How does EDD notify you which way they went with that review?

0 coins

EDD mails a new Notice of Determination if they decide to revise the original determination after reviewing your appeal. If they don't change it, the file transfers to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board and you'll eventually get a Notice of Hearing for the administrative law judge hearing.

0 coins

So you might get another letter either granting or maintaining the denial, and if it's maintained that's when the CUIAB process kicks in.

0 coins

Right. Keep your mailing address current with EDD because those notices go to your address on file, and missing the hearing notice would be a problem.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

Updated my address in myEDD last week just to make sure. This whole process has made me check everything twice.

0 coins

Does a section 1277 invalid claim affect your eligibility to file again in the future, or is it kind of a one-time situation based on specific timing?

0 coins

The determination is specific to the claim you filed - it's about whether that particular claim, based on that benefit year and those base period quarters, meets the wage threshold. It doesn't create a permanent disqualification. If your circumstances change and new wages accrue in future quarters, you can file again when eligible.

0 coins

That's a relief to hear. I worried a section 1277 would somehow flag your account for future claims.

0 coins

Worth knowing your benefit year end date too, because a new claim can't be filed until that year closes even if you're trying to fix this one through an appeal.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD revise a section 1277 determination without an appeal - like just because wages eventually posted from the employer?

0 coins

That's what happened on my claim, based on what the agent told me. The determination was revised without the appeal being decided - the appeal might have prompted them to look again, or the wages just showed up. The two processes seemed to run parallel and the wage correction drove the outcome.

0 coins

Similar on mine - hard to isolate whether it was the appeal or the wages posting that actually triggered the revision. Filing both and waiting seemed to be the practical answer.

0 coins

Raul Neal

Author

Okay, hearing that more than once from different people - I'm going to file the DE 1000M this week and also try to verify through EDD what wages they have on record. Covering both angles seems like the smart move. Thanks everyone, this thread answered questions I couldn't find clear answers to anywhere else.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure