Back to California Unemployment

Paige Cantoni

I reopened my claim by mistake on UI Online - what should I do?

Okay so I completely panicked just now. My job ended about six weeks ago and I had an existing claim with weeks still left on it from earlier this year. I went into UI Online to certify and somehow ended up reopening my claim instead of just certifying for my regular weeks. I didn't realize what I'd done until it was already submitted. The dates on the new claim look different from what I had before and I'm scared I just wiped out the remaining weeks on my original claim or messed something up with my weekly benefit amount. Has anyone accidentally done this? Is there a way to fix it or undo it? I don't even know what to call this when I phone EDD to explain it.

About four weeks into my own situation I did something similar - went in to certify and hit the wrong option, ending up with a reopen screen I didn't mean to submit. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live person at EDD on the phone without spending all day redialing; they handle the hold so you end up talking to an actual agent. The video on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent I got pulled up my claim and told me the reopen hadn't replaced anything yet - the original benefit year was still open and the remaining balance was intact. She said I needed to send a message through my UI Online account right away explaining the reopen was submitted in error so it could be flagged before any duplicate processing happened. I sent that message the same day and my certifications for the original claim went through fine the following week.

0 coins

Thank you - sending a message through UI Online today. Did the agent say anything about whether the weekly benefit amount would stay the same or could it change because of the accidental reopen?

0 coins

EDD can't just swap your weekly amount mid-claim from an accidental reopen - the original claim stays active with the same amount unless the benefit year actually ended first. Good that you're messaging them today.

0 coins

That makes me feel better. I'll message them now and hopefully they can note it before anything gets processed differently.

0 coins

Before the reopen submission went through I always thought EDD had a confirmation screen that would warn you - turns out it doesn't, or at least it didn't flag anything obvious for me either when I changed something by accident last spring. What you need to know is that a reopen on an active benefit year doesn't automatically cancel the balance you built up. The claim still has the same expiration date it was always going to have, and your weekly benefit amount comes from the base period that was already set when the original claim was filed. A second reopen inside the same benefit year doesn't recalculate any of that. What you do need to do is contact EDD right away - message through UI Online, or the phone at 1-800-300-5616 (8 a.m. to 5 p.m. weekdays) - and tell them exactly what happened so the error is on record.

0 coins

Mine definitely did not give me a warning. I was clicking through pretty fast and the next thing I knew there was a confirmation number. So the base period from my original claim still applies - it doesn't pull new quarters?

0 coins

Correct. The base period for your existing claim was locked in when you first filed it. A reopen inside the same benefit year uses that same base period and that same weekly amount. Only a brand-new claim filed after your benefit year ends would look at different quarters.

0 coins

Same experience here - my benefit year ran from March to March and when I reopened mid-year the weekly amount didn't change at all, same DE 429Z figure the whole time.

0 coins

Had a minor heart attack doing something similar last October. Went into UI Online to report wages and somehow ended up on a reopen screen. What helped me most was using the live chat from the Help button inside UI Online - it's available Monday through Friday 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. Got someone who could look at my account in real time and confirmed the reopen was just sitting there unprocessed. They marked it as erroneous right in the chat. Might be faster than waiting on the phone if you're in that window.

0 coins

Good to know about the chat hours. I'll try that first since it's still morning. Did they resolve it fully in the chat or did they tell you to follow up another way?

0 coins

They resolved it fully in that chat session - they put a note on my account and told me to keep certifying for my existing weeks as normal. I didn't hear anything else about it.

0 coins

The live chat is genuinely underused. Most people don't even know it exists because you have to be logged in to see the Help button. Beats being on hold for two hours.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is brutal though. I tried calling 1-800-300-5616 three separate mornings last month about an adjudication question - disconnected every single time before I even got a menu option. So I fully understand why people look for other ways in.

0 coins

Disconnected before the menu is so common and so maddening. EDD's call volume is just not manageable for most people calling in the morning.

0 coins

By the third day I started calling at 8 a.m. on the dot. That worked a little better but I still got disconnected once. Early as possible seems to help.

0 coins

I was going to try the chat window first but good to hear the 8 a.m. strategy if the chat doesn't work.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up early on - I confused reopening a claim with refiling a brand-new claim and I told someone the wrong thing on here once. They're not the same. Reopening is for when you're still inside your benefit year and you go back to work and then stop again - you use the same claim, same weekly amount, same balance. Filing a new claim is only after the benefit year ends. If you accidentally hit reopen inside an active benefit year, the original claim doesn't disappear; EDD just needs to know the submission was an error.

0 coins

I made the same confusion - I thought anytime you filed anything it was a new claim. Took me way too long to figure out the benefit year runs 52 weeks from the original filing date no matter what.

0 coins

Exactly. And the balance doesn't reset either. You can only collect up to 26 times your weekly amount total across the whole benefit year, and reopening in the middle doesn't give you more weeks on top of that.

0 coins

The 26 weeks maximum tripped me up too. I thought going back to work for a month and then stopping again somehow gave me fresh weeks. Nope - still counting against the same total.

0 coins

Just make sure you don't stop certifying for your original weeks while this is getting sorted out. I made the mistake of pausing my certifications while waiting for EDD to fix something on my account and ended up with weeks they couldn't pay retroactively because I hadn't certified them. Keep certifying every two weeks like normal - even if the account looks strange - and let EDD fix the error on their end.

0 coins

Really good point - I would have assumed I should wait until it was resolved. So I should keep certifying on my regular schedule?

0 coins

Absolutely keep certifying. EDD can only pay weeks that have been certified. If you pause and EDD takes two weeks to fix this, those are uncertified weeks and you lose them.

0 coins

Seconding this hard. During my appeal last year I got told to keep certifying the whole time and I'm glad I did - when it resolved they had weeks to pay me because I'd kept up with it.

0 coins

Last week I had an overpayment flag pop up on my account from some weeks I thought were fully resolved, and my UI Online just showed Pending across all my recent weeks with no explanation. Spent most of a morning trying to call before I used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent. The agent pulled up my account and walked me through exactly which weeks had the flag and what documentation EDD was waiting on - said I needed to send a secure message through UI Online attaching the pay stubs for those specific weeks. Sent them that afternoon and two of the three weeks moved off Pending by the end of the week.

0 coins

Pending weeks with no explanation are the worst because UI Online just leaves you staring at it with no idea what's holding things up. At least the agent could tell you exactly what was needed.

0 coins

That was the most useful part - knowing the specific weeks and the specific documents. Without that I would have just been guessing what to send.

0 coins

My pending weeks resolved faster once I sent the right documents too. EDD actually does move quickly when they have what they need; the problem is knowing what that is.

0 coins

My reopen-by-accident situation last spring also made me paranoid that it would mess up my CalJOBS registration. It didn't - CalJOBS is separate from the reopen process. If you registered in CalJOBS and posted your resume within the 21 days from the date on your Notice of Requirement to Register (the DE 8405), that registration carries forward. Accidentally reopening inside the same benefit year doesn't wipe your CalJOBS status or reset that 21-day clock.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about CalJOBS being affected - glad to hear it stays intact. I did register and post my resume within that window so at least that's one less thing to worry about.

0 coins

Good. Keep that resume updated on CalJOBS though - EDD doesn't specify a frequency but keeping it current is a good habit while you're on a claim.

0 coins

I let mine go stale for a couple months and nothing happened to my claim but I definitely felt better updating it once I realized I hadn't touched it.

0 coins

The alternate base period came up in conversation when I called EDD once and I totally misunderstood the agent - I thought reopening my claim would trigger them using my newest quarter's wages instead of my old base period, which I thought might raise my weekly amount. Someone here set me straight: the alternate base period only even gets looked at when the standard base period doesn't have enough wages to make a claim valid in the first place. It doesn't get used to bump up an amount on a claim that's already valid, and a reopen inside the same year doesn't change which period they look at anyway.

0 coins

You're right that it doesn't apply to a valid existing claim. The alternate base period is automatic and EDD would have already used it if the standard one didn't qualify you when you first filed. It's not something you request mid-claim.

0 coins

I wish I'd understood that before I got my hopes up. My newest quarter was my highest-paid one and it wasn't going to help me either way.

0 coins

Same trap I almost fell into - thinking more recent wages would automatically mean more money. The base period doesn't update during the claim, full stop.

0 coins

Is there any risk that the accidental reopen gets treated as the start of a new waiting week? I ask because when I reopened my claim legitimately last fall - after going back to work for two months and then getting laid off again - I did not have to serve another waiting week. The agent I talked to said the waiting week is a one-time thing per claim at the start, not something that resets every time you reopen.

0 coins

That's exactly what I was worried about - another waiting week. Good to know it's just the one at the beginning of the whole claim.

0 coins

Correct. The waiting week is served once, on the first eligible week when you first filed. A reopen inside the same benefit year doesn't bring a new one. The balance and the timeline of your claim just continue.

0 coins

Glad I asked when I did - I was about to certify like normal after my reopen and panic if the first week came back unpaid, thinking I had to do the waiting week again.

0 coins

For what it's worth, calling at 8 a.m. sharp on a Tuesday or Wednesday seems to get through faster than Monday mornings which are absolutely packed. I've had luck with Wednesdays specifically. No guarantees but it's the pattern I've noticed over a few months of dealing with EDD on a tricky adjudication question.

0 coins

Wednesday is my lucky day too on the EDD phone line. Monday is always the worst - probably everyone calling about the weekend's certifications or whatever went wrong Friday.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you get disconnected before reaching the menu, phone EDD the same day and try again rather than waiting - if you let it go to the next morning you're in the Monday-pile situation even on a different day.

0 coins

My Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award - the DE 429Z - came about two weeks after I first filed and it listed my weekly benefit amount. When I reopened legitimately later in the year I checked that same document and confirmed the amount hadn't changed. That's how you can tell whether something went sideways with your weekly amount - pull up that DE 429Z and see if the number matches what your certifications are showing.

0 coins

I still have my DE 429Z - I'll check the amount on there against what UI Online is showing me. Good concrete way to verify nothing changed.

0 coins

If those numbers don't match after EDD fixes the error, that's when you'd want to contact them again - but in my experience they matched fine.

0 coins

The DE 429Z is good to keep saved somewhere. I lost mine for a while and had to call just to confirm my weekly amount, which felt silly in hindsight.

0 coins

My adjudication dragged on for almost five weeks because I had a question about why I'd left my previous job, and during that whole time my UI Online showed every week as Pending. I kept certifying the whole time and when adjudication cleared, EDD processed all the pending weeks at once. The point being: even if your account looks frozen or strange right now because of the accidental reopen, keep certifying. EDD works through the backlog of certified weeks once whatever's holding things up gets resolved.

0 coins

Five weeks of Pending sounds absolutely terrible. Did they communicate anything during that time or did you just have to wait and keep certifying?

0 coins

Almost no communication - I checked UI Online constantly and there was nothing new until one morning everything flipped and payments posted. Phoning EDD during that period didn't give me much more information than the screen did.

0 coins

That's the most frustrating part - certifying into what feels like a void and not knowing if it's working. Good to know the payments came through for all those weeks at the end though.

0 coins

Sent a message through UI Online last week about an identity verification delay and it took about four business days to get a response. So if you message them today about the accidental reopen, don't expect same-day confirmation - it might be a few days. The live chat during 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. weekdays would probably get you a faster answer if you can catch it in that window.

0 coins

Four days is longer than I'd hoped but good to have realistic expectations. I'll try the live chat first and if I miss that window I'll send the message as backup.

0 coins

Good plan to do both. The message in writing also creates a record that you flagged the error on a specific date, which could matter if EDD later questions the timing.

0 coins

The written record is underrated. I always send a follow-up message after a chat or call anyway just to have something in the system with a date stamp.

0 coins

My severance pay situation had me calling EDD in circles because I didn't know whether to report it and when. After a lot of failed attempts at the phone line I ended up using Claimyr to actually get through to an agent. She confirmed my severance was something to report when certifying - listed under the week it was paid - and that EDD would determine how it affected my payment for that week. She also confirmed my benefit year end date so I could see how many weeks I had left on the original claim.

0 coins

Knowing your benefit year end date is so useful. I didn't look mine up until I was almost at the end and panicked thinking I had more time than I did.

0 coins

The agent read it right off my account. I should have known it from my DE 429Z but I'd misplaced that paperwork by then, so having the agent confirm it in real time was helpful.

0 coins

One thing that caught me off guard: when I went back to work for a few weeks and then got laid off again, I thought I could just start certifying again automatically. EDD actually requires you to reopen the claim through UI Online first - there's a specific flow for it. You don't just pick up certifying as if nothing happened. I didn't do that reopen step and my certifications just bounced back as not accepted. Had to call and sort it out before anything would go through.

0 coins

I made the exact same mistake - I thought certifying would just resume. Didn't realize there was a reopen step I had to do first.

0 coins

And the reopen in UI Online is the fastest way to do it, not by phone. Once I did it correctly the certifications went right through.

0 coins

This is probably why some people accidentally hit the reopen screen when they're not expecting it - the flow isn't as clearly labeled as it could be.

0 coins

Vacation pay tripped me up during one of my certifications. I thought since it came from my old employer as part of a final check, I didn't need to report it. Turns out EDD's list includes vacation pay as something to report for the week it covers, same as wages. I ended up with a pending week because I hadn't reported it when certifying. Had to send a message to EDD to correct the certification, which I didn't even know you could do - you can't fix a past certification through UI Online directly, you have to contact EDD to make the correction.

0 coins

The list of things to report when certifying is longer than most people realize. Vacation pay, holiday pay, severance, tips - I had no idea tips needed to be reported until I read the guide carefully.

0 coins

And it's based on when the work was done, not when you got paid - which matters a lot for severance paid out over time or for a final paycheck that covers hours from the previous week.

0 coins

I didn't know you could message EDD to correct a past certification. That's useful to know in case I end up needing to fix something from the accidental reopen weeks.

0 coins

My claim had an odd twist where I went back to part-time work for about six weeks and I wasn't sure if the earnings formula I'd heard about was right. Someone on another forum told me I could earn up to half my weekly benefit amount with no reduction, which sounded too good to be true. The real rule is the first $25 or 25 percent of gross weekly earnings (whichever is bigger) doesn't count, and the rest comes off the weekly payment. So if you have a $380 weekly benefit and earn $150 gross, the first $37.50 (25 percent) is ignored and $112.50 reduces the benefit - you'd get $267.50 that week. Knowing the actual math helped me decide whether it was worth taking the part-time work.

0 coins

The 'half your benefit' myth is everywhere online. I almost turned down some part-time hours because I thought I'd lose everything over a certain threshold.

0 coins

Full-time work is different - that ends eligibility for that week regardless of earnings. The formula is only for part-time.

0 coins

Good catch. Full-time hours for the week means zero benefits for that week, whatever the hourly rate was. EDD doesn't split it.

0 coins

Tried to appeal something once and realized I'd missed the 30-day window on the Notice of Determination - the mailing date, not the date I actually received it. I'd assumed the clock started when I opened the envelope. Lost that appeal window because of the gap between when it was mailed and when I finally got around to reading it. Not directly related to the original question but if anything comes out of EDD as a result of this accidental reopen situation, read every notice the same day it comes and check the date printed on it.

0 coins

The mailing date vs. received date thing is a really common mistake. I keep a folder of every piece of EDD mail now specifically so I know when things were dated.

0 coins

I do the same now. The 30 days runs from the date printed on the notice, not when it showed up in my mailbox, and not when I decided to read it.

0 coins

Is there any way to do a late appeal if you have a good reason for missing the deadline?

0 coins

EDD says you can submit a late appeal with a reason for why you missed the window. Whether they accept it is up to them and I don't know what the standard is - I didn't try after I realized I'd missed mine.

0 coins

Quick update: I used the live chat this morning from the Help button in UI Online and got connected to someone who could see my account. She confirmed the reopen was flagged as an error on my account and that my original claim balance and weekly benefit amount are unchanged. She also told me to keep certifying on my normal schedule and said there would be no additional waiting week. So it's fully resolved on their end. If anyone else does this by accident, message them or use the chat - the faster you catch it the easier it is for them to fix.

0 coins

Really glad the chat worked out quickly. Good that you caught it the same day.

0 coins

The same-day fix is probably why it was so clean. If this had sat for a week unaddressed it might have been more complicated.

0 coins

Thanks for updating - good to know the chat can handle this kind of account correction in real time, not just answer general questions.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure