How to fix unemployment overpayment if I worked out of state - California EDD question
Okay so I'm kind of freaking out and need some help. I got a Notice of Overpayment in the mail last week saying I owe EDD back $2,180 and honestly I don't even fully understand why. Here's the situation: I was collecting unemployment after getting laid off from my warehouse job in Sacramento, but about four months into my claim I picked up some contract work that was technically based out of Nevada - my employer was registered there but I was doing the work remotely from my apartment here in California. I reported wages when I certified but I guess I reported them wrong? Like I wasn't sure if the out-of-state employer wages counted differently or if the timing mattered. Now EDD is saying I was overpaid and I genuinely don't know if this is fixable or if I'm going to owe them $2,180 forever. Did anyone deal with something like this where you had earnings from outside California while collecting? Should I just pay it? Can I appeal or ask for a waiver or something? My claim year doesn't end until February so I'm not even sure if I should still be certifying.
76 comments

Carmen Sanchez
Out-of-work-state contract earnings during a California UI claim - that's exactly the mess I found myself in six months ago. My situation was similar: laid off from a Bay Area tech company, then picked up freelance work for a client registered in Oregon while still collecting. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent, and they walked me through what had actually happened on my account - told me which weeks had been flagged and that the overpayment calculation was tied to how I'd entered the gross amounts, not the net. The video they have about reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see the process. The agent confirmed my overpayment was non-fraud because I had reported something, just not quite the right figures, and told me to watch my mail for the Notice of Determination with appeal options. I ended up requesting a waiver using the DE 1446UI form because the agent said I could ask EDD to consider whether repaying would be an extraordinary hardship.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorThe DE 1446UI is what I need to look into - did you fill it out yourself or did you get help? And did EDD actually grant the waiver or are you still waiting?
0 coins
Andre Dupont
Non-fraud overpayments are the more manageable kind at least. Fraud ones come with a 30 percent penalty on top of whatever you owe, which makes the whole thing way worse.
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
DE 1446UI - writing that down. I have a smaller overpayment from last year that I've been ignoring and this is making me think I should actually deal with it.
0 coins
ThunderBolt7
The where-the-employer-is-registered part doesn't actually change how EDD counts your wages when you're certifying. What EDD cares about is what you earned in that week, whatever the employer's home state is. The question to ask yourself - and EDD if you call - is whether the gross amount you entered each week matched your actual gross earnings for those days. If you underreported, that's one kind of problem. If you just reported wrong weeks - like entering wages in the week you got paid instead of the week you did the work - that's a different calculation issue. EDD wants wages reported in the week they were earned, not when the check or deposit landed.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorPayment timing is probably where I went wrong honestly. My contract payments came in batches and I reported them when I got paid, not spread across the weeks I actually worked. That tracks with what the notice said.
0 coins
Jamal Edwards
Reporting by pay date instead of work week is probably one of the most common reasons people end up with overpayments and they don't even realize it's wrong until the notice shows up.
0 coins
Mei Chen
EDD's Report Wages tool in UI Online lets you enter wages before you certify to see how it affects your payment for that week. Doesn't help you now but worth knowing for anyone reading this who is still mid-claim.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
SAME EXACT SITUATION happened to me two years ago and EDD was absolutely no help when I tried calling the regular line. Spent probably eight or nine hours total on hold over three different days and either got disconnected or just gave up. Eventually my overpayment went into collections with the state because I didn't respond in time and that made everything ten times harder to untangle. PLEASE don't wait on this one. The notice has a deadline on it - 30 days from the mailing date to appeal, and separately you can ask about the waiver but don't sit on either option.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
Author30 days from the mailing date - I need to check that right now because the envelope sat on my counter for a few days before I opened it.
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
The 30-day clock running from the mailing date, not the date you actually open it, is brutal. EDD doesn't give you extra time because the letter sat in your mailbox over a holiday weekend or whatever.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
Eight or nine hours on hold across multiple days is not an exaggeration for people who've never tried calling EDD. The phone situation there is genuinely rough.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Sayed
Before deciding whether to appeal or just request the waiver, it's worth figuring out which one fits your situation. Appeal if you think the overpayment amount itself is wrong - like if EDD's math doesn't match your records. Waiver if you agree the amount is probably right but you couldn't help reporting it the way you did and paying it back would be a real hardship. Some people qualify for both paths at the same time. What's on your Notice of Overpayment - does it say fraud or non-fraud? That changes things.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorMine says non-fraud. I reported wages, just apparently not in the right weeks. So it sounds like I might be a waiver candidate rather than an appeal situation, unless the dollar amount is off.
0 coins
Dylan Hughes
Non-fraud means no penalty tacked on, which is a relief. The 30 percent fraud penalty they add turns a $2,000 overpayment into $2,600 before you've even started.
0 coins
NightOwl42
Both paths at once - didn't know that was even an option. Good to know you don't have to pick one and rule out the other.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
Something people mix up: the appeal and the waiver are completely different requests. An appeal is you saying 'EDD got this wrong, here's why.' The waiver is you saying 'EDD might be right about the amount but I'm asking them not to make me pay it back because it wasn't my fault and I can't afford it.' The waiver form is DE 1446UI, you send it back to EDD, and they look at whether the overpayment happened through no fault of yours and whether repaying it would genuinely create an extraordinary hardship for you.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorThat distinction actually helps a lot. I think I need the waiver more than the appeal because I did mess up the reporting even though I didn't mean to.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
EDD deciding what counts as 'no fault' on a waiver is kind of a black box though. Like there's no clear published standard that tells you exactly what they look for.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
True, it's not spelled out in detail. But the form itself asks for your income and expenses to evaluate hardship, and the fault question is about whether you intentionally misreported. Someone who reported wages in good faith but got the timing wrong has a decent argument on the fault side.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
My overpayment from a few years back involved part-time work I didn't fully understand how to enter on the certification questions. EDD's questions when you certify ask about work and earnings in ways that aren't always crystal clear, especially if your work situation is unusual. When I finally got someone at EDD on the phone they confirmed the overpayment was non-fraud but said I still had to submit the waiver and explain the circumstances in writing. The written explanation part matters - don't just submit the form with blanks, actually write out what happened.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorWritten explanation - noted. I want to explain the out-of-state employer confusion because I genuinely thought the wages might be treated differently.
0 coins
Miguel Herrera
EDD's certification questions are written for pretty standard layoff situations. Anything involving contract work, variable pay schedules or multi-state arrangements gets confusing fast and the questions don't really walk you through it.
0 coins
Zainab Ali
Putting the explanation in writing protects you too. You have a record of what you told them and when.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Keep certifying while all this is being sorted out. A lot of people stop certifying when they get an overpayment notice because they think their claim is frozen or done, but if you're still in your benefit year and still eligible, you need to keep certifying. If you appeal and win, EDD can only pay back the weeks you actually certified for - they won't go back and pay weeks you skipped because you panicked.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorI actually did stop certifying for two weeks when I got the notice because I thought the whole claim was locked. I should restart?
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Restart as soon as you can if you're still in your benefit year and you've been able to work and looking for work during those weeks. Contact EDD about those two skipped weeks - they may still be recoverable depending on the circumstances, but don't let more weeks pile up uncertified.
0 coins
Yara Nassar
Two overpayment letters showed up in my mailbox before I finally got my situation sorted. I had stopped certifying too and ended up losing weeks I should have been paid for. Claimyr helped me get to an actual EDD agent to find out which weeks were still open on my claim - the agent pulled up my account and confirmed my benefit year end date and told me exactly which weeks I could still file for.
0 coins
StarGazer101
The out-of-state employer piece shouldn't change EDD's calculation at all - but I could see how someone would think it might. If the work is performed in California, it's California wages for unemployment purposes on the reporting side. The employer being registered in Nevada or wherever doesn't create a special category. So whatever you earned doing that work, you were supposed to report it the same way you'd report wages from any California employer.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorThat makes sense in hindsight but nothing in the certification questions made that obvious. I genuinely thought 'out of state employer' might mean EDD handles it differently.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
The certification questions EDD asks don't get into employer location at all, which I guess is part of why people assume it might matter. The questions are about work you did and what you earned.
0 coins
StarGazer101
Exactly. The questions on certification are about whether you worked and what you grossed - not where the employer's business is incorporated or headquartered.
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
One thing to understand about how the earnings formula actually works during a claim: if you earn something in a given week, the first $25 or 25 percent of your gross for that week - whichever of those two numbers is bigger - doesn't count against your benefit. Everything above that gets subtracted from your weekly benefit amount. So if your weekly benefit was something like $380 and you earned $200 in a week, you'd keep $25 of that earnings free, and EDD would subtract $175 from your $380, paying you $205. The overpayment happens when EDD paid you a full week or more without knowing about those earnings.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
Author$380 weekly benefit and $200 in earnings - that example actually makes the formula click for me. So EDD is recovering the difference between what I was paid and what I should have been paid under that formula.
0 coins
Mei Chen
That formula is specifically for part-time work weeks. If you worked full time in a week, you wouldn't get any benefit for that week regardless of the formula.
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
Right, full-time weeks are just zero payment for unemployment, the earnings formula doesn't come into play. The formula is for the in-between weeks where you worked but not full time.
0 coins
Paolo Romano
Has anyone had EDD try to collect from a tax refund? I read somewhere they can take state or federal refunds for unpaid overpayments and I'm paranoid about that now for my own situation.
0 coins
ThunderBolt7
EDD does have the ability to collect from future unemployment payments, state tax refunds, and even federal tax refunds if an overpayment goes unresolved. They can also potentially seek a court judgment. That's why responding to the notice quickly is so important - getting into a payment plan or filing for the waiver shows you're engaging with it.
0 coins
Paolo Romano
Payment plan is an option? Or only the waiver?
0 coins
ThunderBolt7
Contact EDD to ask about repayment options. The waiver is a request to have it forgiven under hardship, but if you don't qualify or the waiver is denied, there are ways to arrange repayment rather than having it collected from your refunds. EDD's website and the number on your notice are your best bet for getting specifics on your account.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
Appealing doesn't mean you have to prove EDD wrong about everything. If their math on the overpayment amount is off even a little, that's worth raising. Pull your own records - bank deposits, pay stubs or invoices from the contract work, and what you entered on each certification - and compare it against what EDD says you were paid versus what you should have been paid. If the number on the notice doesn't match what you calculate, appeal it and show your work.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorMy bank records should show what I actually received each week from the contract. That's probably the best starting point for me to figure out if EDD's $2,180 figure is accurate.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Invoice dates vs. deposit dates are going to matter a lot for the week-you-worked-it question. Having both lets you reconstruct the actual timeline.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
Exactly - the invoice date or the date work was performed, not the deposit date, is what matters for which week the wage belongs to.
0 coins
Amina Diop
To appeal the overpayment notice you use the Appeal Form that should have come with the Notice of Overpayment - it's the DE 1000M. If that form wasn't included, you can still appeal in writing with a letter, as long as it clearly identifies you, your claim, and states that you are appealing and why. Mail it to the address on the notice. 30 calendar days from the mailing date on the notice, not from when you got it in the mail. EDD reviews it first, then it goes to the CUIAB - the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board - and an administrative law judge handles the actual hearing.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorDE 1000M - I'm going to look for that in the envelope again, I might have missed it in the stack of papers.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
Administrative law judge hearing sounds intense but it's a lot more informal than it sounds. I had one for a different issue and it was basically a phone call where you explain your side.
0 coins
Amina Diop
Testimony at the hearing is under oath, and you can represent yourself or have someone help you - a union rep, an attorney, or just someone you trust to speak for you. The notice of hearing comes at least 10 days before it's scheduled.
0 coins
Oliver Schmidt
DE 1446UI sitting on my counter for three weeks before I finally did something about it - that was me last spring with an overpayment from a certification period where I honestly don't remember what I entered. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD, and the agent looked at my account and told me which specific weeks the overpayment covered and what amounts had been flagged. That let me actually compare my records to EDD's numbers before I sent the waiver form in with my explanation.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorKnowing exactly which weeks are flagged before you write your explanation seems like a huge advantage. I'm going in a bit blind on that.
0 coins
Jamal Edwards
EDD's Claim History in UI Online sometimes shows pending weeks but it doesn't break down the overpayment calculation week by week. Having an agent pull that up would be much more useful.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
Something nobody's mentioned yet: if the overpayment gets resolved - whether through waiver, repayment, or appeal - and you're still within your benefit year, your remaining claim balance doesn't just disappear. EDD tracks the maximum benefit amount you're entitled to for the year, and an overpayment situation doesn't necessarily eat into that if the waiver is granted or the appeal succeeds.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorI hadn't even thought about what happens to my remaining balance. I have maybe 10-11 weeks left in the benefit year potentially.
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
Maximum benefit amount is 26 times the weekly amount or half the total base period wages, whichever is smaller. The overpayment hits those weeks you already received, not future potential weeks.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
Right, the overpayment is about weeks already paid. Future weeks are separate as long as you stay eligible and keep certifying.
0 coins
Dylan Hughes
The certification question that trips everyone up for contract or freelance work is the one about whether you worked and what you earned - it asks for gross earnings, not net. If you were entering what actually hit your bank account after any self-employment expenses or taxes, that could explain part of the discrepancy EDD found. Gross is the full invoice amount or the full payment before anything else.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorGross vs. net - I honestly might have been entering net. I need to go back and check what I reported versus what my invoices actually said.
0 coins
Miguel Herrera
So many people enter net because that's what feels like 'what you made.' The question says gross but it's not intuitive if you're used to thinking in take-home terms.
0 coins
Zainab Ali
For whoever's still in the middle of their claim while this plays out: being able to work, available for work, and looking for work are still required every week you certify, overpayment situation or not. The overpayment doesn't put your claim on pause for eligibility requirements. You still need to be doing work search activities and you can't certify yes to availability if you're not actually available.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorStill job searching even during the contract work period because the contract was supposed to be short-term. So I should be fine on that front at least.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
CalJOBS registration is also still a thing even if you have an open issue with EDD - the 21-day window from your DE 8405 notice still applies and not doing it can stop payments separately from whatever the overpayment situation is.
0 coins
NightOwl42
EDD's online live chat actually helped me once with a question about an overpayment notice. It's through the Help button in UI Online and runs Monday to Friday 9 to 2. Can't do everything through it but they were able to tell me what the notice was about without me having to sit on hold.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
Author9 to 2 on weekdays - that's a tighter window than I thought. I'll try that before I commit to a long phone call.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
Live chat being only available inside UI Online means you have to already be logged in and your account has to be accessible. If there's some kind of lock or identity issue on your account you're stuck with the phone.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
One more thing on the waiver - EDD considers both whether the overpayment was your fault and whether paying it back would be a real hardship. Those are two separate things they're weighing. Even if you kind of were at fault for the reporting error, the hardship piece might still work in your favor depending on your income situation now.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorCurrently not working full time so hardship could genuinely be an argument. Good to know they look at both pieces independently.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Sayed
The DE 1446UI form asks for your monthly income and expenses in detail. Having that documentation organized before you fill it out makes the form go faster and your case clearer.
0 coins
Yara Nassar
Benefit year end date was what I confirmed when I called EDD - worth asking that specifically when you do get through, so you know exactly how long you have to work with on the remaining claim.
0 coins
Jamal Edwards
Ask EDD through UI Online - there's an online message option in your account - is worth trying in parallel with whatever else you're doing. It won't necessarily move as fast as a phone call but you get a written record of what you asked and what they said, which is useful if anything ends up at an appeal hearing.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorWritten record is a good point. I've been thinking phone call only but having something in writing seems smart given this might go to a hearing.
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
UI Online messages can take a while to get a response but the fact that you sent them and what date you sent them is documented. Useful for showing you were trying to resolve things in good faith.
0 coins
Dylan Hughes
Both - message through UI Online to create a paper trail and phone to get real-time answers. They serve different purposes.
0 coins
Mei Chen
Just to close the loop on the out-of-state employer question since the original post raised it: California EDD cares about where the work was performed and what you were paid, not where the employer is based. If you did the work sitting in your California apartment, it's California wages for reporting purposes. The employer's state of registration is irrelevant to how you fill out your certification.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
AuthorFully clear on that now. I wish I had known before I started the contract because I think some of my confusion came from assuming the out-of-state piece made it more complicated.
0 coins
Paolo Romano
This actually applies to remote workers generally, not just people on UI claims. Where your employer is based doesn't determine which state's rules apply to your wages if you're physically working in California.
0 coins
Mei Chen
For unemployment specifically, what matters for California EDD is that you have California wages in your base period from work performed here. The employer's business address is separate from that.
0 coins