How to answer fired for poor performance and insubordination on a California EDD claim
Last month my employer let me go, and the termination paperwork listed two reasons: poor performance and insubordination. I'm now trying to file for unemployment through California EDD and I'm not sure how to handle this on my application and in the phone interview that's apparently coming. Some background: I was a warehouse supervisor for about four years. My performance reviews were always satisfactory or better until a new regional manager came in about eight months ago. After that, the expectations kept shifting - targets that were realistic under the old management became impossible benchmarks, and I pushed back a few times in team meetings about the feasibility. That's the 'insubordination' as far as I can tell. My last written review was borderline, but I never received a final written warning before they let me go. I filed my claim online through myEDD and selected 'discharged/fired' as my separation reason. Now UI Online shows everything pending and I know a phone interview is coming. What I'm really trying to figure out is how EDD actually evaluates these kinds of terminations - does the 'insubordination' label automatically disqualify me? And when the interviewer asks me to explain what happened, how specific should I be? Should I mention the management change and the shifting targets?
81 comments

Nia Watson
DE 4800 came in my mail about ten days after I filed - same situation, fired for performance and what my company called 'failure to follow directives.' Getting that notice in my hands and reading the questions EDD was going to ask me made me realize I needed to actually speak to someone before the interview date, not after. Claimyr (claimyr.com) handled the hold time for me and I ended up on the phone with a live EDD agent. The video they have on reaching a live person at EDD walked me through what to expect: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. I asked the agent specifically about whether 'insubordination' on a termination letter automatically disqualifies someone - she pulled up my file, saw that my interview was already scheduled, and told me EDD looks at both what the employer says and what I say, and that my pending weeks would stay pending until after the interview and my certification cleared. She also confirmed the questions on my DE 4800 were the ones the interviewer would actually cover. So I went into that call much less panicked than I would have been otherwise.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorThat's exactly the kind of info I needed to hear. The DE 4800 hasn't arrived yet - my claim is maybe five days old. Is the interview date actually on the notice when it arrives, or do I have to watch UI Online for it?
0 coins
Alberto Souchard
Both, in my experience - the date and time are on the DE 4800 and they also appear on the UI Online homepage once the interview is scheduled. Keep an eye on both just in case.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
The agent being willing to actually explain the process is what surprises me. Every time I've tried calling EDD myself I get cut off before I even reach the queue.
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
The label on your termination paperwork matters less than you'd think. EDD's standard for a fired worker is whether the employer can show the behavior was misconduct - not just that performance was bad or that you disagreed with a manager. Pushing back in a meeting about unrealistic targets is a very different thing from, say, refusing a direct and reasonable work order. What I'd do first in your position is write out exactly what you said in those meetings, to whom, and what the response was. Have that timeline ready for the interview. The interviewer is going to ask you to walk through the events, and specific dates and details help you sound credible.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorThe 'reasonable work order' distinction is helpful. My pushback was essentially arguing that the new quotas couldn't be met safely given our staff levels. I never refused to do anything outright - I raised the concern and then did the work anyway.
0 coins
Hailey O'Leary
Raising a concern and then complying is very different from walking off the job or telling a supervisor off. Keep that framing clear in your head for the interview.
0 coins
Cedric Chung
Exactly - EDD's own language is that your employer has to prove misconduct. Poor performance alone, especially under changed conditions, is a much harder case for them to make than a clear policy violation.
0 coins
Talia Klein
Does poor performance on its own even qualify as misconduct though? I always thought it did automatically.
0 coins
Maxwell St. Laurent
To the question above about whether poor performance is automatic misconduct - it's not. EDD's threshold is that the employer has to demonstrate the worker did something intentionally or negligently wrong, not just that the results were below target. A warehouse supervisor missing new quotas set by incoming management isn't the same as, say, repeatedly ignoring safety rules after being warned. The interview is where you get to explain the context.
0 coins
Talia Klein
Okay, that actually clears it up. I was thinking misconduct just meant anything they fired you for.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorGood to know the bar is higher than just having bad numbers on a review. My concern was that since they put both reasons in writing, one of them would stick no matter what I said.
0 coins
PaulineW
Two reasons on a letter can actually work in your favor - if the employer's story is inconsistent about why exactly you were let go, EDD notices that.
0 coins
Annabel Kimball
Preparing for the phone interview is the most important thing right now. Pull together anything that shows the goalposts moved: emails from before the new manager versus after, your older performance reviews, any written targets that changed. You don't have to prove you were a perfect employee, you just have to give EDD enough to see that the story is more complicated than 'this person was bad at their job and defiant.' Write a one-page timeline with dates - when the new manager started, when the new targets were introduced, what feedback you gave and in what forum, and when you were terminated.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorThe documentation angle is worth pursuing. I do have emails where the regional manager acknowledges the quota changes were 'ambitious.' That might be useful.
0 coins
Chris Elmeda
' Ambitious is a pretty great word to have in writing from them. Keep that email somewhere accessible before theinterview.
0 coins
Jean Claude
Paperwork you gathered before the call is better than paperwork you're trying to remember during it. Print the relevant emails, have them in front of you when the interviewer phones.
0 coins
Charity Cohan
My firing two years ago listed 'insubordination' and I was approved after the phone interview. What saved me was being calm and specific about what actually happened rather than getting emotional or defensive. The interviewer asked me to describe each incident they raised, and I gave dates and context for each one. EDD approved my claim within a week of the interview finishing.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorHow long was the interview itself? I want to block out enough time and not schedule anything right after.
0 coins
Charity Cohan
Mine ran about 25 minutes. Some people say shorter, some say longer - it depends on how many weeks and incidents are in question. Leave at least an hour free just to be safe.
0 coins
Josef Tearle
Mine was closer to 40 minutes because I had three separate incidents they wanted to go through. Block more time than you think you need.
0 coins
Shelby Bauman
Something worth knowing about the pending status: your weeks are going to sit as Pending in Claim History until EDD makes a decision after the interview. Keep certifying every two weeks even while everything looks frozen. EDD can only release payment for weeks you actually certified - if you stop certifying because nothing is moving, those weeks are just gone.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorI've been certifying - I did my first one about two weeks after filing. The UI Online screen just shows Pending next to every week. Is that normal while adjudication is open?
0 coins
Shelby Bauman
Completely normal. Pending means EDD hasn't decided yet. Once the interview is done and they rule in your favor, those weeks typically process within a few days.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
Keep certifying no matter what - I stopped for two weeks thinking nothing was happening and had to call EDD to explain the gap. It slowed everything down.
0 coins
Salim Nasir
One thing that tripped me up in my own phone interview was confusing the interview with an appeal hearing. They're completely different things. The phone interview is EDD's fact-finding step before any decision is made - it's not adversarial and there's no judge. You're just talking to an EDD employee who is writing up a report. An appeal hearing only happens if you disagree with their decision after the fact. The interviewer isn't there to catch you out, they're there to get your side.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorI was actually thinking of these as similar processes, so this helps. I won't be as guarded as I was planning to be.
0 coins
Hazel Garcia
The interviewer is usually pretty neutral in tone. Answer what they ask, give the context, don't volunteer stuff they didn't ask about. Keep it factual.
0 coins
Laila Fury
Someone I know thought the phone interview was an appeal hearing and prepared an appeal letter instead of just answering questions. It really confused things. These are different steps.
0 coins
Geoff Richards
My hours got cut to almost nothing before my employer finally let me go - the termination letter said 'insubordination' but the actual dispute was about being taken off the main schedule. I tried phoning EDD four days running and kept hitting the same busy signal wall. Claimyr got me to a live agent, and I asked her whether my weeks from before the official termination date counted toward my claim. She checked my file and confirmed EDD was looking at the full base period wages, not just the last paycheck. That detail mattered a lot for what my weekly benefit amount would end up being.
0 coins
Simon White
Hours cut before a termination is a common situation and EDD does look at all those base period wages. Good that the agent confirmed yours were in there.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorBase period wages covering the stretch of reduced hours before firing - that's something I hadn't thought about either. I had a couple of months of lower earnings before my termination.
0 coins
Hugo Kass
For the interview itself: pick up the phone even if the number looks unfamiliar. EDD interviewers sometimes call from numbers that don't look like the main EDD line. The interview is scheduled at a specific time on the DE 4800, so keep your phone on and charged in the half-hour window before that time and for a good while after. If you miss it, phone EDD that same day to explain - waiting even a day or two makes it harder to reschedule.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorGood heads-up on the unfamiliar number. I would have let that go to voicemail.
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
Missing the interview isn't fatal but it does slow everything down significantly. EDD will just decide based on whatever information they already have if you don't call in that day.
0 coins
Nasira Ibanez
EDD told my coworker the same thing - call the same day if you miss it. She missed hers and called back the same afternoon and they were able to reschedule without an issue.
0 coins
Khalil Urso
Your phrasing in the interview matters more than you might think. Instead of 'I refused to meet the targets,' say 'I raised concerns about the feasibility and continued performing my duties.' Both sentences can describe the same event but EDD hears them very differently. You're not spinning anything - you're describing accurately what actually happened, which is that you spoke up and kept working. If you outright refused a reasonable directive and walked away from a task, that's a different answer. But what you've described here sounds more like professional disagreement than defiance.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorThe language distinction is actually really useful. 'Raised a concern' versus 'refused' is exactly the difference I need to draw clearly.
0 coins
Annabel Kimball
Precise, calm language in the interview is what distinguishes people who get approved from people who don't. EDD interviewers are used to hearing both emotional rants and calm factual accounts. Calm wins.
0 coins
Myles Regis
My old manager tried to frame every question I asked as 'insubordination' on my file. EDD still approved me after I explained that I was asking for clarification, not refusing anything.
0 coins
Alberto Souchard
CalJOBS registration is easy to overlook when your claim is pending. If EDD sends you a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405), you've got 21 days from that date to get your profile and resume up on CalJOBS. Miss that window and payments can stop even if the adjudication goes in your favor. Check your mail and UI Online for that notice.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorI haven't gotten that notice yet. Should I go ahead and register in CalJOBS anyway as a precaution?
0 coins
Alberto Souchard
Registering early doesn't hurt anything. Having the account set up before the notice arrives means you're not scrambling later.
0 coins
Maxwell St. Laurent
EDD tells you in the initial claim paperwork whether you need to register or not. If your paperwork said you do, don't wait for a second prompt - go register now.
0 coins
Simon White
Looking at how long adjudication takes when both performance and insubordination are cited: a pending decision after a fired claim can take several weeks from the interview date depending on how much back-and-forth there is with the employer. My own termination was for attendance and a supervisor dispute - weeks pending in Claim History the whole time. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask how long the employer had to respond, and the agent said the employer had been notified and their response window was what was holding up the schedule. Knowing that at least told me it was moving, just slowly.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorThat's a good detail - knowing whether the employer has responded is something I can ask the agent about if I get through.
0 coins
PaulineW
Employer response timing can really drag out the pending status. EDD needs to hear both sides before they make a decision, so if the employer is slow to respond, everyone waits.
0 coins
Brian Downey
Misconduct versus poor performance is the central question EDD is trying to answer, and there's a meaningful legal difference. Poor performance, especially when a worker tried and the conditions changed, generally lands as 'laid off for cause' in EDD's analysis rather than misconduct. Misconduct in EDD's framework means something more like willful or deliberate behavior that harmed the employer - stealing, repeated policy violations after clear warnings, that kind of thing. Raising feasibility concerns in a team meeting and then doing the work is not in that category.
0 coins
Cedric Chung
Well explained. 'Laid off for cause' isn't the same as 'misconduct disqualification' - the first doesn't automatically bar benefits.
0 coins
Talia Klein
Wait so there's a difference between a layoff and a 'laid off for cause'? I thought layoffs always meant benefits.
0 coins
Brian Downey
EDD's main distinction is between misconduct and everything else. If EDD finds misconduct, benefits are denied. If the employer fired you but can't prove intentional misconduct, EDD generally sides with the worker. Performance alone rarely meets that bar.
0 coins
Chris Elmeda
A detail about your Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award (DE 429Z) when it comes: that document shows your weekly benefit amount and total claim value. If anything on it looks wrong - like the wage amount is off or the weekly figure seems too low - you can appeal it in writing within 30 days of the mailing date. That's separate from the adjudication about your termination. Two different processes.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorI hadn't realized those were two separate things. So I could win the adjudication but still need to dispute the benefit amount separately?
0 coins
Chris Elmeda
Exactly - the interview and decision is about whether you're eligible at all. The DE 429Z appeal is about whether the dollar amount is right. Both have their own deadlines.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
My DE 429Z had the wrong wages listed from one of my employers. Appealing it in writing fixed it but it added another two weeks to the process.
0 coins
Hazel Garcia
The employer can and probably will give EDD their own account of why you were terminated. EDD sends them a notice and they have a window to respond with their version of events. So don't assume EDD is only hearing your side. What matters is whether their account holds together when compared to yours. If the employer says 'insubordination' but their own records show that your performance was borderline until the management change, that inconsistency is something EDD weighs.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorI hadn't thought about how EDD would weigh the two accounts against each other. My hope is that the shifting management and the lack of a final written warning before firing will make their story look inconsistent.
0 coins
Hailey O'Leary
The lack of a final written warning is significant. If a company skips steps in their own progressive discipline policy before firing someone, EDD takes that into account.
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
Have the name of your previous managers who gave you good reviews ready. If there are witnesses to the target changes, that's worth mentioning even if EDD can't contact them directly.
0 coins
Laila Fury
Work search requirements kick in from day one of your claim, even while adjudication is pending. EDD doesn't pause the work search obligation while they decide your case. Keep records of where you're applying, even informally, so you can certify accurately when the time comes.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorHow specific does the certification question get about work search? Does it ask for a list of employers or just a yes/no?
0 coins
Laila Fury
The certification asks whether you looked for work, not for a detailed log. EDD doesn't collect the contacts during certification but keeping your own records is a smart habit in case they ever ask you to verify.
0 coins
Jean Claude
EDD can ask for work search documentation in an audit, so having some record - even just dates and company names in a notes app - is a good idea.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
Direct deposit setup on your claim will make payment faster once the decision comes through. In myEDD, you can switch from the Money Network debit card to direct deposit into your bank account. Worth doing while you're waiting so the first approved payment lands where you want it without any lag.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorI haven't set up direct deposit yet. I'll go into myEDD and do that now while I'm thinking about it.
0 coins
Josef Tearle
Payment info updates daily in UI Online under Payments once weeks start processing. The first few days after a decision can feel like nothing is happening and then it shows up all at once.
0 coins
Myles Regis
Make sure your phone number in UI Online is current and correct before the interview date arrives. If the interviewer phones and can't reach you because the number on file is wrong, EDD treats it the same as a missed interview - they'll make a decision on whatever information they have. Update your contact info in myEDD now if there's any chance it's outdated.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorGood call. My number changed about six months ago. I'm going to log into myEDD right now and check that.
0 coins
Hugo Kass
Also check that your mailing address is right for the DE 4800 and any other notices. If a notice goes to a wrong address, the 30-day appeal window still starts from the mailing date EDD has on record.
0 coins
Hazel Garcia
Address and phone number updated in myEDD before you apply, or immediately after if you just filed - those two things prevent so many headaches later.
0 coins
Hailey O'Leary
After the phone interview is done, EDD will mail a Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) if they're denying you. If they approve you, the pending weeks just start processing and you'll see it in Claim History. No separate approval letter comes - you know you're approved when the payments show up. If a DE 1080CZ arrives, you have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal in writing using the Appeal Form (DE 1000M) that comes with it.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorThat's an important clarification - there's no approval letter I need to watch for, just the payments appearing. And a denial comes as the DE 1080CZ with the appeal form already attached.
0 coins
Hailey O'Leary
Exactly. Keep certifying regardless, because if you appeal and win, EDD can only pay weeks you actually certified for. Stopping certification while waiting on a decision is one of the biggest mistakes people make.
0 coins
PaulineW
The appeal timeline of 30 calendar days is not negotiable without a very good reason. Mark the mailing date on the DE 1080CZ in your calendar the moment it arrives.
0 coins
Nasira Ibanez
Something that helped me going into a similar interview: I wrote out my own account the night before as if I were telling a friend the story from start to finish. No legal language, just what happened in order. Then I read it back and cut anything that made me sound defensive or vague. By the morning of the interview I had a clear, calm version of events in my head. The interviewer asked almost exactly the questions I expected because I'd read the DE 4800 so many times.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorThe 'tell a friend' exercise is a good reframe. I've been trying to anticipate legal arguments and that's making my mental version of events too complicated.
0 coins
Charity Cohan
Calm and factual is exactly the right register. The interviewer has heard a lot of emotional accounts. Someone who can describe what happened without going off on the employer tends to come across more credibly.
0 coins
Salim Nasir
Rehearsing with the actual DE 4800 questions is the best prep you can do. The form tells you what they're going to ask, so there's no reason to be caught off guard.
0 coins
Cedric Chung
For anyone reading this later who wasn't sure: EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their website lets you estimate your weekly benefit amount before the DE 429Z arrives. You'll need your earnings from the highest-paid quarter in your base period. The actual amount on the DE 429Z can differ slightly but it gives you a ballpark to work with while your claim is in adjudication.
0 coins
Micah Trail
AuthorI actually did use that calculator before filing. My estimate put me right around the weekly maximum. Hoping the actual DE 429Z lands close to that.
0 coins
Brian Downey
The highest quarter calculation can sometimes surprise people - if one quarter was significantly better than the rest, the benefit amount can come out higher than you'd expect from an average. Run the calculator with each quarter's earnings to see.
0 coins