Back to California Unemployment

Amara Nnamani

Employer says i quit but they told to leave - unemployment California EDD claim help

Last day at my job was six weeks ago and I applied for unemployment right after. I worked at a small landscaping company for almost four years. What happened was my supervisor called me into the office, said there wasn't enough work coming in and that I should "start looking for other opportunities." Those were his exact words. No formal termination letter, nothing in writing. I said okay and left. Now EDD shows I have a phone interview scheduled because apparently my employer told them I voluntarily quit. I never said I quit. I never signed anything saying I quit. The guy literally told me there wasn't enough work and to go find something else. How is that a quit? I need this money - my weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z came out to $388 and that's what's keeping me afloat right now while I look for work. Has anyone had their employer claim they quit when they were actually told to leave? What do I say in the phone interview to make sure EDD understands what really happened?

Four years at that company and they pull that move - really frustrating. What you're describing sounds like a constructive dismissal situation, meaning they essentially pushed you out without calling it a firing. For the interview, write down everything you can remember about that conversation: the exact words your supervisor used, the date, whether anyone else was present, any context about the company struggling for work. EDD is going to hear two very different stories from you and your employer, so the more specific detail you can give the better. The interviewer will ask you directly why you left and you tell them exactly what you told this thread - your supervisor called you in, said there wasn't enough work, and told you to look for other opportunities. That's not a quit, that's being shown the door.

0 coins

No one else was in the room when my supervisor said it, which is what worries me. It's just my word against his. Would it help if I had a coworker who knew about it?

0 coins

Whether there were witnesses isn't what determines this - EDD listens to both sides in the interview and makes the call based on the whole picture, not just whether someone else was physically there.

0 coins

That makes me feel a little better. The interview is next Tuesday and I've been losing sleep over it.

0 coins

DE 4800 came in my mail last year for almost the same situation, so I know exactly where you are right now. My former manager claimed I resigned voluntarily but what actually happened was he told me my "services were no longer required going forward" and suggested I take some time off. I showed up to the interview without any notes or documentation and stumbled through it. EDD ended up needing to do more investigation and it delayed my payments by almost three weeks. For your interview, write out a timeline. When did work start slowing down, when did your supervisor call you in, what exact words were used, and what did you understand it to mean. The interviewer asked me if I ever submitted a resignation letter or gave formal notice - the answer was no, and that mattered.

0 coins

Did you end up getting approved after all the extra investigation?

0 coins

Payments came through about three and a half weeks after the interview. Got a letter explaining they found I hadn't voluntarily quit. Keep certifying through the whole process even if things look uncertain.

0 coins

Not sure the investigation always takes that long - mine was wrapped up faster, but every case is different I guess.

0 coins

Termination dispute with EDD held up my claim for almost a month after my own phone interview. My old employer filed their response saying I resigned, same as what's happening to you. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live EDD agent on the phone - there's a video showing how reaching a live person at EDD works at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. I asked the agent whether my employer's response had been received and whether the interview was still the deciding step or if there was something else pending. The agent told me the interview was indeed the main event, that both sides' accounts would be reviewed, and that my claim status showed no additional holds beyond the eligibility question. That cleared up a lot of anxiety about whether something else was blocking my payments.

0 coins

Really glad you asked specifically about whether anything else was pending - that's something I wouldn't have thought to ask about.

0 coins

My claim had a similar dispute flag and I had no idea there were additional holds until someone suggested I call in. Good to know you can actually get that information from an agent.

0 coins

Knowing exactly what's on your claim file before the interview sounds like it would help you focus on the right things.

0 coins

The language your employer used matters a lot here. "Start looking for other opportunities" is pretty standard management-speak for "you're done here." What's not standard is an employee choosing to interpret that as a voluntary resignation without asking any follow-up questions like "am I being let go or am I still employed?" In your interview, EDD will likely ask whether you made any attempt to clarify your employment status after that conversation. If you just walked out and filed for unemployment, the interviewer might ask why you thought you were terminated rather than simply being advised to job search. Have an answer ready for that.

0 coins

I did ask him if I was still on the schedule and he said probably not for a while. I should definitely mention that part.

0 coins

That detail about the schedule is actually significant - "probably not for a while" on the work schedule coming from a supervisor is much closer to a layoff than a voluntary quit.

0 coins

Absolutely bring that up. Write it down word for word if you remember it that clearly and say it exactly that way to the interviewer.

0 coins

My cousin went through something almost identical - wait, I can speak to this from my own claim too. Got into a situation where hours were cut and then my manager said I'd probably want to "move on" since things were slow. Filed for unemployment and hit the same wall where my employer contested it. EDD scheduled the interview and the interviewer asked me a series of questions: did I give notice, did I sign anything, did I have a final paycheck with any kind of note on it, did I return any equipment. All of those pointed toward them initiating the separation, not me. What documentation do you have from your last day - final paycheck stub, any texts or emails from around that time?

0 coins

I have a text from my supervisor two days before that last meeting saying work was really slow and asking if I had any other jobs lined up. Would that count as evidence?

0 coins

That text is probably your strongest piece of evidence. Screenshot it and have it ready. It directly contradicts any claim that you initiated the separation.

0 coins

A text asking if you have other jobs lined up before you've said anything about leaving... yeah that's going to be hard for the employer to explain away.

0 coins

Spent three weeks terrified I was going to lose my claim because my employer contested my separation for similar reasons. Here's what I learned about how EDD actually looks at this: they're not just deciding who's telling the truth, they're deciding whether someone who left work did so voluntarily with a reason EDD considers valid, or whether the employer ended the employment. When an employer says there's no work and suggests you look elsewhere, most people would reasonably understand that as the job ending. The burden EDD puts on a fired employee's claim is that the employer has to show misconduct. For a quit, the claimant has to show there was a good reason. What your employer is doing by calling this a quit is trying to put that burden on you, which is why how you frame the story in the interview really matters.

0 coins

Not sure about the burden shifting thing - EDD just listens to both sides and makes a determination, right? They're not like a court where someone has to prove something to a legal standard.

0 coins

You're right that it's not a formal legal proceeding, but EDD does treat quits and firings differently when it comes to what it needs from each side. For a firing, EDD's own language is that the employer has to show misconduct. For a quit, the claimant needs to show there was a good reason for leaving. The practical effect is similar to what I described, even if it's not courtroom procedure.

0 coins

EDD's process is basically: tell us your side, employer tells theirs, we look at all of it and decide. Calling it burden shifting is a bit much but the underlying point about quits vs firings being treated differently is accurate.

0 coins

FOUR YEARS at that company and they just told you to go look for other opportunities with nothing in writing?? This is exactly why employers do it verbally, so there's no paper trail. The nerve of them then telling EDD you quit voluntarily. I went through a situation where my employer gave me conflicting information about my status and EDD had to untangle the whole mess. It took forever. The system is not designed to make this easy.

0 coins

Not having anything in writing is frustrating but it doesn't automatically mean EDD will side with the employer. They handle these he-said-she-said situations all the time.

0 coins

I know, I'm just venting. It still took almost six weeks for my claim to get sorted and that's six weeks of stress.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is something worth confirming you've done if you haven't already. When a claim has an open eligibility issue like a termination dispute, people sometimes forget about the other requirements running in parallel. If you got a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405), you typically need to get registered and have a resume posted in CalJOBS within 21 days. Missing that can cause a separate payment hold on top of whatever the interview is resolving. Worth logging into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and checking if anything about CalJOBS registration is flagged on your claim.

0 coins

I actually did register in CalJOBS right after I applied, so hopefully that's covered. Good reminder though because I didn't know missing it could cause a separate hold.

0 coins

Good that you got that done early. The 21-day clock starts from the date on the DE 8405 and runs regardless of what else is happening on your claim, so getting it out of the way early was the right call.

0 coins

CalJOBS also has job listings and workshops which is worth using while you're waiting for the claim to resolve, unrelated to the EDD requirement but still useful.

0 coins

Waiting week plus the dispute delay meant my bank account was basically empty by the time my first payment showed up. My situation was different - I was let go from a warehouse job and my employer still contested it claiming I abandoned the position. Got on the phone with an EDD agent using Claimyr and learned the specific weeks that were certified and pending, and that the interview was the last step before payments could process. Knowing there wasn't some extra form I'd missed let me focus on preparing for the interview instead of panicking about every possibility.

0 coins

Knowing exactly which weeks are pending and confirmed in the system before the interview sounds like it would calm a lot of the "did I even do this right" anxiety.

0 coins

The not-knowing is honestly the worst part. Certifying every two weeks and having no idea what's actually happening with the money is stressful.

0 coins

Certifying through it was exactly the right move. The agent confirmed my certified weeks were in the queue and payments would process once eligibility was decided.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact dispute about seven months ago and want to add something about the interview format that helped me. The interviewer typically goes through a set of questions in order - they'll ask about your last day, the circumstances of the separation, whether you gave notice, whether you received any documentation. Let them lead. Don't launch into a long explanation at the start because sometimes people ramble and accidentally use language that works against them. When they ask why you left, say exactly what happened: supervisor called you in, said there wasn't enough work, said you should look for other opportunities, and you understood that to mean your position was ending. Short and factual.

0 coins

This is really helpful. I've been rehearsing this long story in my head and you're probably right that shorter and more direct is better.

0 coins

The interviewer will ask follow-up questions if they need more detail - you don't have to get everything out in the first answer.

0 coins

My former employer tried the same thing - told me things were slowing down and I should start thinking about other options, then reported to EDD that I resigned. The interviewer asked me point blank whether I had any emails, texts, or voicemails related to the separation. I had one email from my manager about reduced hours that I sent over after the interview via the message function in my UI Online account. EDD approved the claim. What you said about having a text where your supervisor asked if you had other jobs lined up - make sure you can access and send that if the interviewer asks for documentation.

0 coins

Can you send documents through UI Online even after the interview is already done, or only before?

0 coins

You can send a message with documentation through UI Online after the interview if the interviewer requests something or if you remember something important. The message function stays available.

0 coins

Worth noting that you should only send additional documentation if the interviewer specifically asks for it or if you can reference it during the interview itself.

0 coins

Something tripping people up in these employer-contests-the-claim situations is thinking the interview is the same thing as an appeal hearing. It's not. The interview is EDD gathering information to make their initial decision. An appeal is what you do after you get a Notice of Determination if EDD rules against you - you have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice to file, using the Appeal Form DE 1000M that comes with it. If your interview goes badly and EDD rules against you, don't panic - you still have the appeal option before anything is final.

0 coins

Important distinction. A lot of people read about appeals and start trying to file one before EDD has even made a decision, which doesn't make sense procedurally.

0 coins

Exactly - the interview is step one of EDD deciding. The appeal is what happens if you disagree with what they decided. Two completely different stages.

0 coins

Glad someone clarified this because I genuinely thought the interview and an appeal hearing were related until I read a thread like this.

0 coins

Something I keep seeing in these threads is people not certifying while their claim is in dispute. Please don't stop certifying. If EDD ultimately approves your claim, they can only pay weeks that you certified for. If you stop certifying because you're not sure your claim will work out, you lose those weeks permanently even if everything gets resolved in your favor. Keep certifying every two weeks no matter what else is happening.

0 coins

I've been certifying - didn't want to assume I should stop. Good to know that's the right call.

0 coins

Keep doing exactly that. The worst case is you certified for weeks that don't get paid, which is frustrating but at least you haven't lost weeks that would have been paid.

0 coins

Can't stress this enough. Stopped certifying for three weeks during my own dispute because I wasn't sure if I was still supposed to and lost those weeks. Don't make that mistake.

0 coins

Had a DE 4800 show up in my mailbox when I least expected it, right before a long weekend. The notice gives the date and time for the phone interview and that same time is listed on the UI Online homepage. Keep your phone nearby for the entire block of time they give you on that date - the interviewer calls during that window and if you miss it you need to phone EDD the same day, otherwise they'll make their decision based only on what they already have, which at that point includes your employer's version of events and not yours.

0 coins

The interview is next Tuesday morning. I've already blocked out the whole morning just in case.

0 coins

Smart. Also make sure your voicemail is set up and your phone isn't going to silence unknown numbers - some phones do that automatically.

0 coins

The silencing unknown numbers thing caught me off guard once and I nearly missed something important. Good practical tip.

0 coins

Read through the whole thread and want to flag something about the DE 4800 notice: it lists not just the date and time but also the questions the interviewer is likely to ask. If you haven't looked at it closely, re-read it now. Use those listed questions to prepare your answers in advance. It basically gives you the interview script ahead of time.

0 coins

Mine lists four questions and one of them is specifically about whether I gave any formal notice before leaving. The answer is no, I didn't give notice because I didn't understand I was quitting.

0 coins

That answer is exactly right and frames it correctly - you didn't give notice because from your perspective, the separation was initiated by your supervisor, not by you.

0 coins

The absence of a resignation letter, formal notice, or anything else that would indicate a voluntary quit is going to work strongly in your favor here.

0 coins

Eleven weeks into my claim right now and my situation resolved last month but I remember this exact stage of anxiety. The employer contesting the claim doesn't mean they win - EDD makes the decision independently based on what they hear from both of you. Your employer can say you quit but they can't just decide it, that's EDD's call to make. And employers don't always tell EDD the full story of what they said in those private conversations.

0 coins

That's weirdly reassuring - I keep thinking about it like my employer already won because they disputed it.

0 coins

They filed their version. You get to file yours. EDD has seen this movie before.

0 coins

Adjudication flag on my claim sat there for almost five weeks before I figured out I could actually talk to someone about what was happening. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent about an earnings reporting question on my own claim and while I had them on the phone, got the agent to confirm whether the adjudication was because of an employer dispute or something else entirely. Turned out there was a second issue I hadn't known about related to my identity verification step not being marked complete. Worth asking an agent to run through every open flag when you get them on the line, not just the one you called about.

0 coins

Wait - is identity verification something that could be a separate issue from the termination dispute? I did the ID.me thing but I'm not sure if it shows as complete on my claim.

0 coins

The agent confirmed for me that it showed complete on my file, so it's definitely a question you can ask. If yours isn't marked complete it would be a separate hold from the interview.

0 coins

ID.me verification not showing up on the EDD side even when you completed it on the ID.me side is surprisingly common. Getting confirmation directly from an agent that it's marked complete is worth doing.

0 coins

My situation with EDD last spring involved a similar employer dispute and something that helped me was asking for a supervisor to verify my claim status after the interview had already happened. I know calling is hard, but during mine I asked the interviewer directly at the end whether there was anything else I needed to submit or do. The interviewer said everything they needed was collected and EDD would mail a decision. That confirmation at the end of the interview itself saved me from worrying whether I'd forgotten a step.

0 coins

Asking the interviewer at the end if there's anything else you need to do is a good practice. Most interviewers will tell you what happens next and what to expect.

0 coins

They said to watch for mail and that the determination would go to my address on file. Seemed routine for them.

0 coins

Kept certifying through a nearly identical dispute on my retail job claim and there was one specific week where I had picked up a one-day shift at a temp agency while waiting for EDD to decide. Had to report those wages for that week when I certified. Ended up with a question about whether I'd reported everything correctly and used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the phone before the interview to make sure the wage reporting hadn't created a separate complication. The agent looked at the week in question and said the reported amount was showing correctly and there were no flags beyond the original dispute. That week ended up paying a partial benefit because of the earnings offset, which was fine.

0 coins

I haven't done any work since I left so at least I don't have wages to complicate things, but good to know you can check on that kind of thing before the interview.

0 coins

Keeping it simple is easier for sure. No wages to report means one less variable in the interview.

0 coins

The wage reporting piece trips a lot of people up when they're doing part-time work during a claim. Glad that got sorted out cleanly for you.

0 coins

One more thing worth knowing before Tuesday: if EDD rules against you on the termination dispute, the Notice of Determination comes in the mail with an Appeal Form DE 1000M included. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing. The appeal goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board and an administrative law judge holds a hearing where you can present your side. That's a whole separate process, but it exists if you need it. Hopefully the interview goes well and you don't get there.

0 coins

Worth knowing that keep certifying applies during the appeal too. If your appeal takes months, only the weeks you certified for are eligible to be paid if you ultimately win.

0 coins

I really hope it doesn't come to that but it's good to know the appeal option exists and that there's a 30-day window to do it.

0 coins

The 30-day clock from the mailing date, not the date you receive it - keep that in mind and don't wait if you need to appeal.

0 coins

Came back to this thread to add: when the determination does come, actually read the whole thing even if it's good news. The notice will explain which weeks are covered and confirm your weekly benefit amount. If anything on it is different from what you expected based on the DE 429Z, you can appeal within 30 days of the mailing date even if you technically were approved but the amount is wrong.

0 coins

My first determination had a typo in my wages from one employer and I almost missed it because I saw the approval and stopped reading. Had to get it corrected which added time.

0 coins

Exactly - the determination is a document to actually check, not just file away.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure