Back to California Unemployment

Ryan Vasquez

Employer claims misconduct to deny unemployment, what can I do about it with California EDD?

Got my Notice of Determination last week and EDD sided with my former employer who told them I was fired for misconduct. The thing is, what they're calling misconduct was showing up 10 minutes late twice in my last month after two years of spotless attendance. I never received a written warning, no PIP, nothing documented. EDD denied my claim based entirely on what the company told them in their response. I worked in logistics for a mid-size warehouse operation and I genuinely don't know if I have any recourse here. My weekly benefit amount was set at $310 on the DE 429Z so I know the money's there if I can get the denial reversed. Has anyone fought back against a misconduct determination and actually won? I have 30 days from the mailing date on the notice to appeal and I'm already 8 days in. What am I even supposed to do?

The mailing date on your Notice of Determination is the clock that matters, so at 8 days in you still have room. You want to ask yourself what documentation proves that those two late arrivals were isolated and not part of a pattern EDD would call willful disregard of your employer's rules, because that's the core of what they'll weigh at the hearing. The appeal goes in writing using the Appeal Form DE 1000M that came with your notice, or even just a plain letter sent to the address printed on the notice. Once EDD reviews it they forward it to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, and an administrative law judge holds the actual hearing. Gather anything that shows your attendance record over those two years, any texts or emails where a supervisor acknowledged your work, whatever you have. The judge hears from you under oath and you can represent yourself.

0 coins

My DE 1000M was in the envelope with the denial, I still have it. When you say gather attendance records, does that mean I need to contact HR at my old job to request them? I'm not sure they'll hand those over willingly.

0 coins

HR isn't your only route. Check your own pay stubs, any shift confirmation emails, scheduling app screenshots, or time clock records you saved personally. If the company used an app to track hours you might still have access. Focus on anything that shows those two lates were the exception over a long clean run.

0 coins

Two lates in two years with no written warning is a really weak misconduct case honestly. EDD's standard is about whether you deliberately violated the employer's rules, not whether you made a mistake once or twice.

0 coins

Twelve days into my own appeal right now for almost the same situation, so I'm watching this thread. My former employer said I violated a conduct policy but never gave me a copy of the policy. The question I wish I had asked myself sooner is whether EDD ever actually saw proof that you were told what the rule was before you supposedly broke it, because a rule you didn't know about is a lot harder to call willful misconduct.

0 coins

Mine never gave me the policy in writing either. I signed an offer letter when I was hired but it didn't spell out attendance rules beyond 'arrive on time.' No handbook was ever given to me physically.

0 coins

This is a really common fact pattern. The absence of a written policy or a warning the employee actually received tends to come out clearly at the hearing, and judges pay attention to it.

0 coins

my old roommate went through an appeal over a conduct firing and said the judge asked the employer rep like 15 questions about whether they'd documented anything. the employer basically had nothing and he won

0 coins

Termination letter from my employer said 'policy violation' with zero specifics, and UI Online showed my claim sitting in adjudication for weeks before the denial came through. Getting to an actual EDD agent to find out what the employer had submitted felt impossible until I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com). Their video on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. I asked the agent what documentation the employer filed with EDD and what specifically triggered the misconduct finding, and she told me the employer had submitted a termination report that cited 'repeated tardiness' but EDD's file showed only two reported incidents. That detail mattered a lot when I wrote my appeal because I could address exactly what was in EDD's file rather than guessing.

0 coins

Only two incidents in the file and they still found misconduct? That's exactly my situation. Did filing the appeal put the denial on hold at all, like do you keep certifying while it's being reviewed?

0 coins

Keep certifying every two weeks through the whole appeal process. The only way EDD can pay those weeks retroactively if you win is if you certified for them. Don't stop even if it feels pointless.

0 coins

Knowing what documentation the employer actually submitted before you write your appeal seems like a smart move, I might try doing that before I send mine in.

0 coins

The burden question is something a lot of people get tangled up on. What EDD's own language says is that your employer has to prove misconduct if you were fired, not just claim it. So the question you should be ready to answer at your hearing is what evidence they actually brought versus what they just said. Two years of clean performance versus two late arrivals is a factual record and facts matter to the judge.

0 coins

So the employer is the one who has to bring proof, not me proving I didn't commit misconduct?

0 coins

Exactly that. EDD's framework puts it on the employer to show misconduct when you were fired. You're not trying to prove a negative. You're responding to whatever they present, which based on what you've described sounds thin.

0 coins

i thought the employee had to prove they weren't guilty. glad someone clarified this because i had it completely backwards before my own interview last month

0 coins

Scheduled for a hearing before my own CUIAB case wraps up and something that helped me was understanding what 'misconduct' actually isn't. Missing a shift once due to traffic, forgetting to clock out, being slow on a task, minor stuff like that isn't what the law is after. The question for the judge is whether you deliberately disregarded your employer's interests in a way that showed you just didn't care about keeping the job. Two lates in 24 months doesn't sound like that to me at all.

0 coins

That framing actually helps a lot. I wasn't careless about my job, I had one rough stretch for a personal reason and then it was done. I never did it again.

0 coins

the 'deliberate disregard' framing is the key thing. i've seen people lose appeals because they couldn't explain why a single thing they did wasn't intentional. having a reason for the specific incidents goes a long way

0 coins

Bring anything that shows what was going on during that period if it's relevant and not embarrassing to share. Judges aren't looking to punish people for being human, they're looking at whether there was genuine willful conduct.

0 coins

Appeal paperwork just went into the mail yesterday on my own denial and I'll say the hardest part was writing the statement clearly without it turning into an emotional rant. What helped me was treating it like a timeline, just the facts in order, what I was told, what I did, what I wasn't told, and what documentation exists or doesn't. Keep the feelings for after you win.

0 coins

The emotional rant risk is real, I've rewritten the section about my employer four times already trying to stay factual.

0 coins

Read it out loud and ask yourself whether a stranger reading it cold would understand the sequence of events. If you're assuming they know context they don't have, add it. If you're editorializing about how unfair it was, cut it.

0 coins

Timeline format is genuinely the move. Bullet points with dates if you can. Date hired, dates of the two incidents, date terminated, what you were told each time, what you weren't given.

0 coins

Wrote to EDD through UI Online messaging to ask what specifically the employer submitted before I filed my appeal. Got a response about a week later that confirmed the submission was a one-page termination notice with no attached documentation. That told me the employer was going to have a hard time proving anything at the hearing beyond their own word.

0 coins

I didn't know you could message EDD through UI Online to ask about what the employer submitted. I'll try that today.

0 coins

Use the message option in your account, spell out clearly that you're asking about documentation submitted by the employer in connection with your termination and the misconduct finding. Be specific about which claim and which week the denial covers.

0 coins

Good tip. Phone also works for this kind of specific question if the UI Online message takes too long.

0 coins

Misconduct finding on my claim got reversed at the hearing stage and the main thing was showing up prepared. I had printed copies of everything. My attendance records, screenshots of scheduling confirmations, a written summary of my two-year tenure, and a one-page explanation of the specific incidents with dates. The administrative law judge asked me direct questions and I answered them calmly. The employer rep on the phone was not prepared at all.

0 coins

How did the hearing itself work logistically? Was it in person or by phone?

0 coins

Mine was by phone. The Notice of Hearing that came by mail told me the date and time and gave me a number to call in. The judge introduced everyone on the line and then went through the questions methodically.

0 coins

Phone hearings seem to be standard for most cases now. The judge runs it, you testify under oath, the employer gets to present their side too but you get to respond to what they say.

0 coins

The notice comes at least 10 days before the hearing date. Keep an eye on your mail after you file the appeal because that's how you find out when it's scheduled.

0 coins

My DE 429Z had a weekly benefit amount listed and I wanted to confirm that the number was right before my appeal resolved, since I hadn't worked for the full base period in my industry. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD and talked to an agent who pulled up my claim and confirmed which quarters of wages EDD had on file and which ones made up the base period calculation. That reassurance that my wages were counted right was one less thing to stress about while the appeal was moving.

0 coins

Mine was at $310 a week and I honestly hadn't thought to verify whether the base period quarters they used were the right ones. That's a separate thing I should check.

0 coins

The DE 429Z lists the weekly benefit amount based on your highest earning quarter in the base period. If those wages look off compared to what you actually earned, that's worth questioning through EDD before the benefit year runs out.

0 coins

Something a lot of people miss when they're preparing for a misconduct hearing is that you're allowed to bring a representative. Not a lawyer if you can't afford one, it can literally be a union official if you're in a union, or just someone who can help you stay organized and calm during the call. You testify under oath but that doesn't mean you have to go in alone.

0 coins

I'm not in a union but I do have a friend who went through something similar and knows the process. Would they be allowed to be on the call with me?

0 coins

Anyone you choose can represent you at the hearing. They can speak on your behalf or just be there for support. The judge's focus is on the facts of the separation.

0 coins

having someone else there also helps because they can track what's being said and remind you of things you planned to mention if you blank during testimony

0 coins

Fourteen days of my claim stuck on pending after the misconduct denial went in and I was losing my mind not knowing if the appeal was even received. Getting to EDD by phone on my own was a wall of busy signals. Eventually talked to an agent through Claimyr and she confirmed the appeal had been received and logged the date it came in, so the 30-day clock was met. She also told me what week my next certification was due so I didn't miss it while everything was in limbo.

0 coins

Can you keep certifying normally while the appeal is pending? Or does the system freeze those weeks?

0 coins

You certify on your regular schedule no matter what. The pending weeks stay pending through the appeal but EDD can release payment on the weeks you certified if the judge rules in your favor. Missing certifications means no payment even on a win.

0 coins

Confirming the appeal was actually received with a date stamp seems like the kind of thing worth knowing early rather than finding out later that mail got lost.

0 coins

Paperwork on my misconduct appeal got complicated because my employer submitted a second statement after the initial denial, adding new reasons they hadn't mentioned originally. Asked an agent about it through Claimyr and found out that additional employer submissions before the hearing are part of the record and I'd have a chance to respond to them at the hearing itself, so it wasn't the emergency I thought it was. The agent said the CUIAB judge controls what's admitted and both sides get to speak to the evidence.

0 coins

The idea that they could add new reasons during the appeal hadn't occurred to me. Good to know the judge manages that.

0 coins

New evidence from either side before the hearing is normal. The key is that you get to respond. If something shows up that you weren't expecting, you can ask the judge for time to address it.

0 coins

my situation was i got fired for 'insubordination' which my boss defined as disagreeing with him in a team meeting once. filed my appeal and EDD reversed it without even going to the CUIAB hearing. sometimes they review the appeal first and decide internally before the judge gets involved

0 coins

Wait so there's a step where EDD reviews the appeal before it goes to the judge? I didn't know that.

0 coins

EDD takes a first look at the appeal when it comes in. If they determine on their own review that the initial decision should be changed, they can reverse it at that stage. If not, it moves to the CUIAB and the administrative law judge.

0 coins

it took about 3 weeks before i got the letter saying EDD had reversed the decision themselves. not everyone gets that lucky but it does happen

0 coins

Two things nobody mentioned yet that tripped me up during my appeal hearing. First, the judge may ask you about every job separation in your base period, not just the most recent firing. Second, if you've certified for weeks after the denial, make sure you certified consistently and correctly, because your credibility at the hearing matters.

0 coins

I've only had one employer in the last 18 months so other separations shouldn't come up. But the certification accuracy point is a good one, I want to make sure everything I reported was correct.

0 coins

If anything on past certifications might look inconsistent, like a week where you did part-time work you reported, have that documentation ready too. Judges sometimes look at the full picture of your certifications.

0 coins

Certifying accurately is just non-negotiable. Report every dollar of wages in the week you earned it, not when you get paid. If you did any part-time hours during any pending week that's already in the system, make sure it's reflected right.

0 coins

my employer also claimed misconduct when i was terminated last year and their whole case at the hearing was based on an employee handbook that wasn't even signed by me. the judge asked them to verify i had received and signed the handbook, they couldn't, and that was basically the end of their argument

0 coins

I signed my offer letter but nothing that said I'd received an employee handbook. If they try to cite handbook policies at my hearing I'll raise exactly that.

0 coins

ask right at the start of the hearing if they intend to reference any written policies, and then ask when and how those were provided to you specifically. the burden isn't just that the policy existed, it's that you knew about it

0 coins

This is a really useful specific thing to flag. Employers love to wave a handbook around but if they can't show the employee had it, the judge takes that into account.

0 coins

Spent about two weeks thinking an appeal was the same thing as a second phone interview with EDD and kept waiting for them to call me to discuss the denial. Finally read the notice again and realized the appeal is a formal hearing before a judge, not a chat with an EDD rep, and I'd already burned 12 of my 30 days. Filed the DE 1000M that same afternoon.

0 coins

I almost made the same mistake. When I first got the denial I thought I'd have a conversation with someone at EDD to explain my side. The formal hearing before a judge caught me off guard too.

0 coins

The phone interview that may have happened before the denial and the CUIAB appeal hearing after it are two totally different things. The interview is EDD gathering facts. The hearing is a judge reviewing the determination with both sides under oath.

0 coins

the DE 4800 notice and the DE 1080CZ denial notice are two different forms covering two completely different steps. i had them mixed up in my head for the first week

0 coins

Filed my own misconduct appeal three weeks ago and my biggest regret so far is not writing down everything I remembered about my termination meeting the same day it happened. By the time I got around to writing my appeal statement, some details had faded. If you're still fresh on the events, write everything down now even if you're not ready to file yet.

0 coins

I actually texted a friend the night I was fired so I have a timestamp and a bunch of what I said in the moment. That could be useful as my own record.

0 coins

Time-stamped messages to someone else right after the fact carry weight. It shows the account of events is contemporaneous and not reconstructed later.

0 coins

same idea with voicemails or emails from that period. anything that proves what you knew or said at the time, before you had any reason to shape the story, is worth saving

0 coins

Not sure if anyone's mentioned CalJOBS but while your appeal is pending you generally still need to keep your registration and resume active on there if EDD required it when you first filed. Missing the CalJOBS requirement doesn't pause because of an appeal.

0 coins

I did register on CalJOBS when I first applied and uploaded a resume. I should check whether it's still showing as active.

0 coins

Log into caljobs.ca.gov and check that your resume is still marked as active and searchable. The DE 8405 notice EDD sent after you first filed tells you the specific deadline they gave you to register, usually 21 days from that date.

0 coins

Work search requirements stay in effect through the appeal period too. Keep doing your work search activities for every week you're certifying, same as before the denial came down.

0 coins

DE 1000M just needs to clearly state that you disagree with the determination and why. It doesn't have to be a legal brief. Courts, well judges, have seen everything. Write plainly, say what happened, and say why the evidence doesn't support a finding that you willfully violated a known policy. Mail it to the address on the denial notice and keep a copy.

0 coins

I've been overthinking the language and trying to make it sound formal. Plain and clear is better?

0 coins

Plain and clear every time. The judge wants to understand the facts. Legalese from someone who isn't a lawyer often just muddies things. Say what happened, in order, with dates where you have them.

0 coins

Sign it, date it, and if you can send it certified mail keep the receipt. Having proof of the mailing date matters if there's ever a question about whether you met the 30-day deadline.

0 coins

UI Online doesn't give you much during the appeal stage beyond your weeks still showing as pending, which is frustrating. Checking your Claim History daily won't speed anything up, but do watch your physical mailbox closely because the Notice of Hearing and any decisions from the CUIAB come by mail, not through UI Online.

0 coins

I've been refreshing UI Online every morning hoping something changes. Good to know the actual movement happens through the mail.

0 coins

Physical mail is how the whole appeal process communicates with you. The Notice of Hearing has to come at least 10 days before the scheduled date, so if you're not watching your mail carefully you can miss it.

0 coins

someone in another thread said their notice came the week before the hearing and they almost didn't have time to prepare. stay on top of that mailbox

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure