< Back to California Unemployment

EDD eligibility after 1-month job termination - will previous employer be charged?

Just got fired after only one month at a dental office. Boss initially said I was doing great, then suddenly claimed patients were complaining but refused to tell me what the complaints were. Made me sign a termination paper stating I was let go because 'it wasn't a good fit.' I was collecting about $425/week on unemployment before this job and kept my claim open. When she found out her name was on some EDD employer list, she seemed really angry about it. I'm completely blindsided - I actually enjoyed the job and might have tried too hard to impress. My main question: Since I only worked there for a month, will she be charged for my unemployment benefits if I reactivate my claim? Also, am I even eligible to continue benefits after being terminated like this? The whole 'not a good fit' thing feels like a way to avoid saying I was fired for cause.

sounds like u qualified since u didnt do anything wrong. pretty sure she will b charged partially based on your time working there. thats why shes mad lol

0 coins

Nia Thompson

•

That would explain why she was so weird about the EDD stuff. I'm just worried because I signed that termination document. I was so shocked I didn't even read it carefully. I hope that doesn't disqualify me.

0 coins

Aisha Hussain

•

Yes, you should still qualify for benefits since you were terminated for "not being a good fit" rather than misconduct. When you reopen your claim, EDD will determine if you earned enough wages during your brief employment to establish a new claim or if you'll continue on your old claim. Regarding your main question: Yes, your employer will likely be charged a portion of your benefits based on your time there, even if it was just a month. California uses a "base period" system where employers pay into unemployment insurance based on wages paid. Since you had a previous claim, your new employer becomes part of your wage history and therefore partially responsible for benefits. Be prepared for a possible eligibility interview about your termination. Make sure you explain everything exactly as it happened. Since no specific performance issues were documented and they classified it as "not a good fit," you have a strong case.

0 coins

Nia Thompson

•

Thank you! This is so helpful. I'll definitely prepare for an eligibility interview. Do you know if I need to do anything special to reopen my existing claim, or do I just certify normally?

0 coins

went thru EXACT same thing last yr!!! boss said i was "not a good fit" after 6 weeks. so stupid!!! when i certified, i just reported my earnings for those weeks i worked and then checked the "no longer working" box and put the date my job ended. had a phone interview but got approved no problem!! the interviewer even said "not a good fit" isnt misconduct. my ex-boss was PISSED abt being charged lolol too bad for her!!!!!

0 coins

Nia Thompson

•

That's reassuring to hear someone had almost the same situation! So you didn't have to do anything special to reopen your claim - just regular certification? I'm going to do that right away.

0 coins

Ethan Brown

•

The termination document you signed could potentially be an issue, but it really depends on what it actually stated. "Not a good fit" typically isn't disqualifying for benefits, but if the document contained any admissions of poor performance or policy violations, that might complicate things. Do you have a copy of what you signed? Regarding employer charges: Yes, she will be partially charged based on the portion of base period wages you earned there. Employers pay UI taxes based on their "experience rating" - basically how many former employees collect benefits. New claims affect this rating, which can increase their tax rate. That's likely why she was upset about being on an "unemployment claim list." When you reopen your claim, be 100% honest about the reason for separation. If they schedule an eligibility interview (which they likely will), stick to the facts without emotion. Since you were there less than 90 days, you were technically still in a probationary period in most jobs, which often works in your favor for UI eligibility.

0 coins

Yuki Yamamoto

•

what about misconduct tho? cant they just say there was misconduct and then ur screwed? happened to my sister and she had to appeal

0 coins

Carmen Ruiz

•

The system is RIGGED against employees!! Of course she's upset about EDD - employers HATE paying into the system!! They'll do ANYTHING to avoid paying their fair share, including making up fake reasons to fire people! I bet she planned this from the start - hire you, then fire you with some vague excuse so she could avoid having to pay benefits. I've seen this SO MANY times in California. Employers know exactly what they're doing! They use "not a good fit" because they know saying you did something wrong would require PROOF. FIGHT for your benefits! Don't let her win!

0 coins

Nia Thompson

•

I don't know if she planned it from the start, but it did feel strange how quickly things changed. One week she's saying I'm doing great, the next she's saying patients are complaining but won't tell me what about. Really frustrating!

0 coins

Try calling EDD to ask these questions. They'll give you the right answers.

0 coins

Carmen Ruiz

•

LOL good luck with that!! Been trying to call EDD for WEEKS and can't get through! They NEVER answer!!

0 coins

Aisha Hussain

•

To answer your specific question about reopening your claim: Log into UI Online, select "Reopen Your Claim" from the main menu (usually appears when you haven't certified for a while), and follow the prompts. You'll need to report your work history since your last certification, including the brief employment and termination reason. When you get to the separation reason section, select "Discharged" and then when asked for details, simply state "Employer said it wasn't a good fit" - keep it factual and brief. Avoid saying anything that could be interpreted as misconduct. After you submit the reopened claim, keep certifying every two weeks as normal. EDD will likely schedule an eligibility phone interview to discuss the job separation before they make a final determination.

0 coins

Nia Thompson

•

Perfect - thank you for the step-by-step! I'll log in today and get this started. Really appreciate all the help.

0 coins

Yuki Yamamoto

•

my cousin got fired after 2 months and still got benefits they just asked more questions and had a phone interview

0 coins

Carmen Ruiz

•

Just make sure you SAVE EVERYTHING - any messages where she said you were doing a good job, the termination paper, EVERYTHING! EDD interviews are all about EVIDENCE. If you have proof she was initially happy with your work, that strengthens your case that there was no misconduct. The burden of proof is on HER to show why you shouldn't get benefits. The system isn't perfect but at least has SOME protections for workers!

0 coins

Nia Thompson

•

Good advice. I don't have text messages, but I do have some emails from the first two weeks where she compliments my work. I'll gather those up now before responding to EDD.

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
7,159 users helped today