EDD approved my claim but employer in different state - worried about appeal timeline
I've been working remotely from California for a company based in Florida for the past 18 months. I lost my job last month and filed for unemployment through California EDD since that's where I live and pay taxes. My claim was approved last week and I've already certified for benefits twice, but I'm really anxious about whether my Florida employer can still appeal this. I've heard horror stories about having to repay benefits if an employer successfully appeals. Does anyone know: (1) What percentage of UI benefits come from the employer vs the state government? (2) Is there a deadline for when my employer has to file an appeal? (3) When can I feel confident that I'm actually going to keep receiving benefits without suddenly owing everything back? I'm checking my UI Online account obsessively every day worried about this!
16 comments
Ahooker-Equator
You absolutely filed correctly in CA since that's where you physically performed the work (even if remotely) and where you live. Your employer has 30 days from when they received the Notice of Determination to file an appeal. As for funding, employers pay both federal and state unemployment taxes that fund the program - it's not split percentage-wise between employer and government since the government administers the program using employer-paid taxes. If your claim was already approved, EDD determined you're eligible, and unless your employer can prove misconduct or that you quit without good cause, their appeal likely won't succeed.
0 coins
Abigail bergen
•Thank you so much for this info! Do you know when exactly the employer gets the Notice of Determination? Is that the same day I got my approval letter or could it be days/weeks later? Just trying to figure out when that 30-day window actually starts and ends.
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
my boss tried to appeal my claim last yr and it took 4ever!!!! they have like 30 days to appeal but even after that theres like this whole hearing process that took almost 3 months for me. the most stressful time ever but i won in the end bc they couldnt prove i did anything wrong
0 coins
Abigail bergen
•Oh wow, that sounds nerve-wracking! Did your benefits continue during those 3 months while they were appealing? Or did they put your payments on hold during that time?
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
I WENT THROUGH THE EXACT SAME THING!!! My employer was in Nevada but I lived in CA. EDD approved me then my employer appealed saying I should have filed in Nevada! Had to go through this whole process where they did a "multi-state investigation" and froze my benefits for SIX WEEKS while they sorted it out. Eventually got it resolved but they made me submit all these extra documents proving I actually lived and worked in CA. The system is BROKEN!!!!
0 coins
Toot-n-Mighty
•That sounds so frustrating! Did you eventually get backpay for those six weeks they froze your benefits?
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
To directly answer your questions: 1) Employers contribute 100% of the UI funding through state and federal unemployment taxes. It's not a percentage split between employer and government - the government just administers the program using employer tax contributions. 2) Employers have 30 calendar days from the mailing date of the Notice of Determination to file an appeal. This notice is typically mailed to them around the same time you receive your Notice of Award. 3) If no appeal is filed within that 30-day window, you can feel more confident. However, be aware there are some circumstances where late appeals are accepted if the employer shows "good cause" for the delay. If you're concerned, you might want to call EDD to confirm whether an appeal has been filed. This is often difficult due to high call volumes, but services like Claimyr (claimyr.com) can help you get through to an EDD representative quickly. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
•I tried Claimyr last month when my payments were stuck in pending and it actually worked! Got through to a tier 2 specialist in about 45 minutes instead of trying for days. They helped me fix my identity verification issue right away. Definitely worth it when you're desperate to talk to someone at EDD.
0 coins
Abigail bergen
Thanks everyone for the helpful responses. I called EDD this morning using that Claimyr service (which did work surprisingly well) and got through to a representative. They confirmed my employer has not filed an appeal yet, but said the 30-day window doesn't end until May 10th. The rep suggested I continue certifying normally but maybe keep some emergency savings just in case there's an unexpected issue. She also mentioned that since I properly filed in California where I live and work remotely, my case is pretty straightforward even if the employer does appeal. That makes me feel a bit better about the situation!
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
•Thats good news! If ur employer doesn't appeal by May 10 ur probably in the clear. My cousin went thru something similar and once that appeal deadline passed he never had any problems with his claim.
0 coins
Toot-n-Mighty
wait am i supposed to file in the state where my companys headquarters are?? i work remotely from home in california but my company is based in texas and now im worried im doing it wrong
0 coins
Ahooker-Equator
•No, you file in the state where you physically perform the work, which for remote workers is where you live. So as a CA resident working remotely, you correctly file with California EDD, regardless of where your company is headquartered. It's about where you physically work from, not where your employer is based.
0 coins
Sofía Rodríguez
My sister had her employer in New York file an appeal when she was living in California, and what a nightmare that turned into! I still remember her calling me crying because they froze her benefits for almost two months while they sorted it out. She had to provide like a million documents proving she was actually working from California. Eventually she won the appeal because she was able to show her internet service bills, rent payments, and other evidence that she was physically working in California. The whole time she was so stressed about potentially having to pay back thousands of dollars.
0 coins
Abigail bergen
•That's exactly what I'm afraid of! Did she end up getting backpay for the weeks they froze her benefits during the appeal process?
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
Just to clarify for everyone in this thread: 1) Remote workers file for unemployment in the state where they physically perform their work (usually where they live) 2) Multi-state workers may have their wages combined through a process called a Combined Wage Claim 3) Employers have 30 days to appeal an EDD determination 4) If an appeal happens, you'll receive a notice for a telephone hearing with an Administrative Law Judge 5) Benefits typically continue during the appeal process but could be subject to repayment if the decision is reversed The system can be confusing, especially with remote work becoming more common, but these are the basic rules EDD follows for interstate employment situations.
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
•this is so helpful!! thx for explaining it so clearly. unemployment is so confusing lol
0 coins