Disqualified excessive earnings when certifying self employment income - what do I do now?
So I've been doing some freelance graphic design on the side while collecting UI, and I reported everything honestly every time I certified - every project payment, every invoice that came in. Last week I got a Notice of Determination saying I was disqualified for excessive earnings in several of the weeks I already certified. I genuinely don't understand how this happened. I thought the whole point of reporting your earnings was so EDD could calculate the offset and just pay you less, not disqualify you entirely. My weekly benefit amount is $310 and some of these weeks I made maybe $180 or $200 from a client. That should still leave me with something, right? Now I look back at my Claim History and those weeks all show Pending or nothing at all. I've been trying to reach EDD for days with no luck. Has anyone dealt with a disqualification from self employment income during certification? Did you appeal it? What actually happened?
63 comments

Charlotte White
Freelance income knocked me sideways too - I had a week where a client paid me for three separate invoices at once and my payment dropped to zero that week. Ended up having to actually talk to an EDD agent about it, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through on the phone. They hold the line for you so you end up on the phone with a live agent without sitting on hold for hours yourself. There's a video on reaching a live person at EDD if you want to see what I mean: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent I got pulled up my account and explained that EDD looks at gross earnings for the week the work was done, not when the payment hits your bank - so three invoice payments landing the same week looked like I earned all of it that week. That was the whole problem. She said I needed to go back and figure out which week each project was actually performed and report it to that week. It didn't fix things instantly but at least I knew what I was dealing with.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorThe timing of when the payment hits vs when the work was done - that might actually be exactly what happened to me. I get paid net-30 so money from a project in one month lands in my account the next. I was reporting it when I received it, not when I did the work. Is that what you corrected?
0 coins
Admin_Masters
EDD asking about when the work was done rather than when you got paid is something I wish I'd known from the start. Had the same exact confusion with freelance translation work.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Yeah that was it exactly. The agent was pretty clear - report wages in the week the work was performed, full stop. If you got paid weeks later it doesn't matter, it still goes to the week you did the job.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
DE 429Z on my claim showed $285 as my weekly benefit amount, and even then EDD dinged me for a week where I made $340 from a one-day photography gig. I'd been using Claimyr to get through to EDD agents on a few of my pending issues - that week I spoke to someone who walked me through the math. The first $25 or 25 percent of gross earnings in a week (whichever is bigger) doesn't count against you, and whatever's left over gets subtracted from your weekly benefit amount. So on a $340 earnings week the 25 percent exemption is $85, leaving $255 to subtract from my $285 benefit - that's only $30 paid out but I still got something. The issue people run into is when the leftover after the exemption exceeds the weekly benefit amount, which makes the payment zero for that week. Zero isn't the same as a disqualification though, so I'm curious what your notice actually says.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorMy notice says disqualified, not just zero payment. That's what's freaking me out. If it was just zero I'd understand but the word disqualified feels way more serious.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
Disqualified on the notice usually means EDD found you weren't eligible that week under whatever criteria they applied, not necessarily that your whole claim is dead. The appeal rights on that same notice are what matter right now.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
The math breakdown on the earnings exemption is really useful context. The first $25 or 25% whichever is greater - I never knew about the 25% side of that until I ran into a high-earnings week myself.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
$340 in one week from a client and EDD sent me a determination that felt like the sky was falling. The Notice of Determination you got came with an Appeal Form DE 1000M stapled to it or on a separate page - 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice is your window to appeal in writing. If you let that pass, you lose the right to contest it. File the appeal even if you're still trying to figure out what happened, because you can explain everything at the hearing afterward.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Author30 days from the mailing date - not from when I received it or when I read it, right? Mine is dated about 10 days ago so I still have time but I want to make sure I'm counting from the right date.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
Mailing date on the notice is the clock that starts. You appeal with the DE 1000M or just a letter to the address on the notice. Keep a copy of whatever you send.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
Filing the appeal before figuring everything out is exactly the right instinct. The hearing is where you present your side, so getting it in the mail now buys you time to gather everything.
0 coins
Chris King
This is the part that tripped me up - I waited while I tried to understand my determination and missed the 30 days. Had to file a late appeal with a reason for missing it, which added another layer of stress.
0 coins
Rachel Clark
Something in your original post about reporting every payment honestly - that matters for how EDD views this. A disqualification from excessive earnings for self employment is different from a fraud finding. You reported everything, so EDD has a record of your transparency. When you appeal, that history of honest reporting on each certification should work in your favor. Gather your freelance invoices, your project timesheets if you have them, and any bank records that show when payments actually deposited versus when the work was done.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorI do have invoices with project dates on them and my bank statements showing later deposit dates. That gap between work done and payment received is actually documented pretty clearly in my records.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
Invoices with dates are gold for this kind of appeal. An administrative law judge at the CUIAB hearing is going to want to see the timeline of when work was performed versus when payment came in.
0 coins
Mia Alvarez
Report Wages in UI Online is the tool that's supposed to let you work out your earnings before certifying - but here's what a lot of freelancers don't realize: it only helps before you submit a certification. If you've already certified a week and reported an amount, that week is locked. The only way to fix a week already submitted is to contact EDD directly - either through a message in your UI Online account or by phone. You can't go back and edit a past certification through Report Wages or anywhere else in the system.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorI definitely already certified all those weeks. So the fix path is through EDD directly or through the appeal, not something I can click my way through in UI Online. That tracks with what I'm seeing - no edit option anywhere.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
UI Online being read-only for past certifications has caught so many people. At least messaging through the UI Online account creates a paper trail of when you flagged the issue to EDD.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
Adjudication and appeal get mixed up constantly in these threads. What you're describing - getting a Notice of Determination saying you're disqualified - is already past the adjudication stage. EDD investigated and issued a decision. The appeal is the next step, which goes to a hearing before an administrative law judge. It's a separate process from whatever review EDD did internally. Knowing which stage you're at helps you use the right words when you contact anyone about this.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorI've been saying adjudication when I meant the decision had already come. So I'm at the appeal stage now. The determination is already issued, 30 days on the clock, appeal form is what I need to file.
0 coins
Sophia Long
Self employment income and the week it's earned versus when it's paid - that exact ambiguity is probably what triggered the adjudication in the first place. EDD flags it, reviews it, then issues the determination. Appeal is definitely where you are now.
0 coins
Angelica Smith
Certifying with self employment income every two weeks and trying to match project work to the right week is genuinely complicated. The way EDD defines the week - Sunday through Saturday - means you have to track which days within each week you performed the work, not just when a client paid you. For ongoing projects that run across multiple weeks, you'd prorate or allocate the earnings to each week the work was actually done. Most freelancers don't realize that level of detail is expected.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorOngoing projects split across the EDD week boundary - I hadn't thought about that. I had a logo project that took about three weeks and I reported the whole payment in the week I got the check. That might be one of the disputed weeks.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
The Sunday through Saturday EDD week thing is confusing even when you're paying attention. I had a project that started Thursday and my next certification period started the following Sunday, and I still wasn't sure which week to put the first few hours in.
0 coins
Rachel Clark
For the appeal, documenting the specific days you worked on each project within each week is what the judge will want. Time logs, emails to clients, anything that pins the work to specific calendar dates.
0 coins
Charlotte Jones
Excessive earnings notices on self employment income have a particular wrinkle that full-time W2 workers don't face - gross self employment income isn't the same as what you actually take home after expenses. EDD looks at gross though, not net profit. So if you billed $500 for a job and spent $150 on software licenses and equipment for it, EDD still counts the full $500 for that week's earnings. That gap can push people into excessive earnings territory even when their actual take-home was modest.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorEDD counting gross before business expenses... that's a rough rule for freelancers. My margins on some projects aren't great once I account for software subscriptions and equipment.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
The gross vs net thing is real and I've seen people get blindsided by it. No one tells you upfront when you start certifying that your business costs don't offset what EDD considers your earnings for that week.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
Makes sense that EDD uses gross from an administration standpoint but it's genuinely punishing for people whose freelance work has real costs attached to it. The earnings exemption formula doesn't help as much when gross is high and net is much lower.
0 coins
Harper Thompson
Keep certifying every two weeks through your whole appeal. If the administrative law judge rules in your favor, EDD can only pay the weeks you actually certified - weeks you skipped because of the disqualification can't be paid back. Your appeal is about whether the disqualification was correct; certifying is a separate obligation that keeps those weeks in play.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorKeep certifying even while appealing - I would have stopped because I assumed the disqualification meant I couldn't. Really glad I know this now before I miss any certification periods.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
Stopping certifications during an appeal is one of the most common and painful mistakes people make. The judge can reverse the disqualification but can't go back and create certifications for weeks that were never submitted.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
At the hearing itself, an administrative law judge hears testimony under oath. You can represent yourself or bring someone with you - a union rep, an attorney, whoever you want. The notice of your hearing date comes in the mail, at least 10 days before it's scheduled. You'll want to organize your evidence by week: invoice date, work performed dates, payment receipt date, and what you certified for that week. Showing the timeline clearly is what makes the case.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorOrganizing by week sounds like the right approach. I have maybe six or seven disputed weeks so a simple table with dates and amounts might be cleaner than a wall of text in the appeal letter.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
A table by week is a good call. Judges see a lot of paper. Anything you can do to make your timeline easy to follow helps.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
Something that might help before the hearing: Send a message through your UI Online account explaining the gross payment timing issue - that you reported income in the week you received payment rather than the week the work was performed. Even if EDD doesn't reverse the determination before your hearing, that message is part of your claim record and shows you identified the issue and reached out proactively. The appeal is the main vehicle but having that communication on file doesn't hurt.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorSending that message now while I gather my invoices for the appeal sounds like a reasonable parallel track. At minimum it timestamps when I understood the issue.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
Messages through UI Online also help you remember exactly what you said and when, which matters if the conversation comes up at the hearing. Screenshots of sent messages are worth keeping too.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
Misconduct and excessive earnings are two completely different things, and I've seen people in this situation confuse them. Misconduct is a reason for being fired - EDD uses it in that specific context, the employer has to show it. Excessive earnings is just about whether your income in a given week reduced your benefit to zero or triggered a determination. No one is accusing you of misconduct. The disqualification here is about the earnings calculation, which is something you can address with documentation at an appeal.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorGood to know those are entirely separate categories. I was starting to feel like I'd done something wrong beyond just miscalculating which week to report income in.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
The distinction matters a lot emotionally too. Excessive earnings is a math and reporting question, not a character question. The appeal is about the calculation, not about whether you were honest.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
My first certification after I went freelance I reported my payments for two projects on the same week just because that happened to be when both clients paid me. EDD processed it, my payment showed as zero that week, but no determination came. Second time something similar happened, a determination showed up. I never understood why one triggered it and the other didn't. If anyone has figured out what causes EDD to send a determination versus just issuing a zero payment, I'm still curious.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
Zero payment weeks and determinations are different outputs depending on how EDD processes the certification. When the math alone causes the zero (earnings minus exemption wipes out the benefit), it may just show as zero. When EDD needs to make an eligibility decision - like questioning whether you were actually available for work or whether the income was properly categorized - that's when a determination letter gets issued. At least that's how I understand it; the specifics would depend on what EDD flagged.
0 coins
Angelica Smith
The inconsistency is real and maddening. I think it has to do with how EDD's system flags certain income patterns, but I've never gotten a clear explanation either.
0 coins
Chris King
CalJOBS registration is still required for most claimants even when you're doing freelance work and certifying self employment income. The Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) gives you 21 days from that date to register and post a resume at caljobs.ca.gov. If that slips while you're dealing with the disqualification appeal, it creates a separate issue on top of the earnings dispute. Worth checking your CalJOBS status while everything else is happening.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorCalJOBS I did handle right away when I got the DE 8405, so at least that's one thing I don't have to worry about while dealing with the appeal.
0 coins
Harper Thompson
Good that CalJOBS is handled. It's one of those things that creates a whole separate headache when it lapses, especially on top of an active appeal.
0 coins
Sophia Long
Net-30 payment terms as a freelancer combined with UI certification schedules is a collision that EDD's system isn't really built for. Got into a similar tangle last spring when three separate clients all paid within the same two-week certification window. Ended up getting a live EDD agent on the phone through Claimyr - the agent found two of my weeks flagged and said I needed to contact EDD in writing about correcting the week I'd assigned the income to, then also file the appeal on the determination I'd already received. The appeal and the correction were separate steps, she was clear about that.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorAppeal AND a written correction to EDD as two separate steps running at the same time - that's exactly the kind of detail I needed. I was thinking the appeal would cover everything but it sounds like they're parallel processes.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
Parallel tracks make sense because the appeal contests the determination while the correction addresses the underlying reporting. One is about the decision, one is about the data.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
The 30-day appeal window running from the mailing date and the ongoing certification obligation running on its own schedule at the same time is a lot to track. Some people set a calendar alert for the appeal deadline date as soon as they get the notice. The hearing itself happens after you file - you get a Notice of Hearing in the mail at least 10 days before it's scheduled, and testimony is under oath. Bring every document you have on the disputed weeks.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorCalendar alert for the appeal deadline is set now. And I'll start pulling together my invoice dates, project timesheets, and bank deposit records for the hearing packet.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
Bringing more documentation than you think you need is always better than arriving without something the judge asks about. Even email chains with clients showing project dates could help.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
For the appeal letter itself, keep it factual and focused on the earnings timing issue. Write out each disputed week, what you reported, what your invoices show for work performed in that week, and when payment actually came. Courts and judges respond to organized timelines, not emotional arguments about how the system is unfair. The DE 1000M form is simple but you can attach a letter with the week-by-week breakdown.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorWeek by week with dates is my plan. I have maybe seven disputed weeks so the attachment will be longer than the form itself, but organized.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
Attach the invoices themselves as exhibits, labeled clearly with which week they correspond to. Having the actual documents as backup to the written timeline is stronger than just the letter alone.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
While everything with the appeal is in motion, checking in on UI Online daily to watch your Claim History is worth doing. Sometimes EDD updates claim status or processes certifications without any separate notification. If a week that was showing as disqualified changes status, you want to know about it rather than finding out weeks later.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorDaily check on UI Online while the appeal is active - good habit. I'd been avoiding it because seeing those weeks was stressful but I need to stay on top of any changes.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
UI Online updates at least daily and sometimes more than once. The Claim History screen is the most useful place to watch for changes during an appeal.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
After the hearing, the administrative law judge mails a written decision. If you disagree with that decision you can do a second-level appeal to the CUIAB, which is the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. Most people are surprised there are two levels. First level is the ALJ hearing, second level goes to the board itself. Keep all your documents until everything is fully resolved, however long that takes.
0 coins
Anthony Young
AuthorTwo levels of appeal is news to me. I was thinking the ALJ hearing was the final word. Good to know there's a second option if the first doesn't go well.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
The board-level appeal after the ALJ decision is there but rarely needed. Most cases resolve at the first hearing. That said, knowing it exists is useful if the ALJ's decision doesn't feel right.
0 coins