Back to California Unemployment

Freya Andersen

Claim disqualified after verification and Bank of America card still locked - California EDD mess

Two weeks ago I finally finished the ID.me verification EDD kept asking for, uploaded my photo ID, got the confirmation that it went through. Felt like the nightmare was over. Then I get a Notice of Determination in the mail saying I'm disqualified - no real explanation beyond something vague about eligibility - and my debit card is still locked so I can't even access the small amount that was on there from my first partial payment. I was laid off from a warehouse job in late September after the company lost a contract, completely no fault of mine, so I genuinely do not understand what triggered a disqualification after they already had my identity confirmed. UI Online just shows Pending on every single week going back to when I filed. I tried calling 1-800-300-5616 three separate times this week and got disconnected twice and put on hold for over two hours the third time before giving up. Has anyone dealt with both a disqualification AND a locked card situation at the same time? I need to figure out which problem to tackle first because I can't pay rent next week.

Which notice came first - the ID.me confirmation or the disqualification letter? That detail actually matters a lot for figuring out what's going on with your claim.

0 coins

ID.me said verified about four days before the Notice of Determination arrived, so EDD definitely had the identity piece done when they sent that letter.

0 coins

The timing actually makes sense in a weird way - EDD can have an identity issue AND a separate eligibility issue open at the same time. Clearing one doesn't automatically clear the other.

0 coins

The card situation might be separate from the disqualification entirely. EDD switched payment cards to Money Network a while back - if the card you have is still the old one, it might just be inactive rather than locked because of the claim issue. Worth checking which card it actually is.

0 coins

Oh wow, I didn't even know they changed card providers. I'll look at the card again tonight. It came in a plain envelope and I assumed it was the current EDD card.

0 coins

Had the exact same confusion last spring. My card was the old one and I didn't realize it. Once I updated my payment method in myEDD the new Money Network card came pretty fast. The claim issue was totally unrelated.

0 coins

This is a really important point that gets missed. The card problem and the disqualification are almost certainly two separate things to solve separately.

0 coins

The DE 429Z showing pending on every week after a disqualification notice meant I had to actually speak to someone at EDD - the online stuff couldn't tell me anything useful. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with a live EDD agent after I'd given up on the hold line. There's a video showing how reaching a live person at EDD works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. When I finally got through, the agent pulled up my account and told me the disqualification was flagged because of a mismatch between what I reported as my separation reason and what my employer submitted. She said to look at the Notice of Determination carefully for the specific section code and to appeal within 30 days of the mailing date using the DE 1000M form or a written letter sent to the address on the notice.

0 coins

The 30 days from the mailing date - is that calendar days or business days? I want to make sure I don't miss it.

0 coins

Calendar days, 30 of them from the date printed on the notice itself, not from when you got it in the mail. So count from the letter's date, not the envelope's postmark.

0 coins

That employer mismatch thing happened to my claim too. The warehouse I worked for said I quit when I was actually told my position was eliminated. Night and day difference in how EDD sees it.

0 coins

Went through a disqualification after my layoff last year that turned out to be a data entry error on the employer side. Appealed it and won. The appeal process through California EDD honestly isn't as scary as it sounds - you send the DE 1000M or just a letter explaining your side to the address on the notice, and EDD reviews it before it even goes to a hearing. Keep certifying every two weeks while you wait too, because if the appeal goes in your favor they can only pay back the weeks you actually certified.

0 coins

Should I keep certifying even now that it shows disqualified? I stopped because I figured there was no point.

0 coins

Yes, keep certifying. Appeals can take time and EDD can only pay back weeks you certified. Missing weeks means missing payments even if you win.

0 coins

This is correct - certify every two weeks through the appeal no matter what the status shows. Lost that lesson the hard way on my own claim.

0 coins

NOBODY explains this clearly but the disqualification notice has a specific code or reason on it and that is literally the most important thing to read first. Mine said something like 'left work voluntarily without good cause' even though I was laid off. That exact language tells you what your employer told EDD and what you're actually fighting.

0 coins

Found it - mine says 'question regarding reason for separation.' That's vague, right? Does that mean they're still investigating or that they already decided?

0 coins

That phrasing usually means EDD held an eligibility interview or is waiting to, not necessarily a final decision. Did you get a DE 4800 notice about a phone interview at any point?

0 coins

No DE 4800 ever came. At least nothing I remember seeing. Could it have gone to spam if they email those?

0 coins

EDD sends the interview notice by mail, not email. The DE 4800 has the date and time and EDD phones at that time. If you missed it without knowing, calling EDD to explain is important because otherwise they decide with just the employer's version.

0 coins

My EDD claim got flagged for the same kind of separation question after my employer contested it. What I learned was that the Notice of Determination and an appeal are two different things from a phone interview. I'd been thinking the interview WAS the appeal, which is wrong - the interview is earlier in the process, before EDD even makes its decision. The appeal is after they've decided and sent you the notice.

0 coins

Genuinely did not know that distinction until reading this. I thought my phone interview was me appealing the hold on my account.

0 coins

Super common mix-up. The interview is EDD gathering facts to make a decision. The appeal is what you do if you disagree with the decision they already made.

0 coins

To add: if you haven't had the interview yet and your claim shows disqualified, it's possible the interview happened without you knowing and EDD decided on the employer's information alone. That's exactly why calling EDD matters here.

0 coins

Has anyone actually gotten through to EDD by phone this month? Every time I call 1-800-300-5616 it feels like I'm dialing into a void. Either busy signal, hold forever, or disconnected.

0 coins

My disqualification notice from a job I was let go from in October had me in the same loop with the phones. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent after days of failed attempts. The agent looked at my account and saw that my employer had filed a response saying I was terminated for cause, which I completely disagreed with - she told me to appeal with the DE 1000M and include any documentation I had of the actual reason. Filed the appeal two days later.

0 coins

Good to know. I need to get my actual claim status because UI Online just says Pending and that tells me nothing.

0 coins

The live chat through the Help button in UI Online is another option, but only 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. Monday through Friday. Sometimes faster than the phone depending on the day.

0 coins

About the card situation - if it turns out to be the Money Network card and it's locked, calling the number on the back of the card itself is usually faster than going through EDD. The card company handles the lock separately from EDD's claim side.

0 coins

That makes total sense. I was planning to call EDD about everything but the card lock might be a whole separate call to a whole separate number.

0 coins

Exactly. Two different problems, two different phone calls. EDD can't unlock the card and the card company can't fix a disqualification.

0 coins

Spent a whole afternoon on hold with EDD asking about my card when the answer was just on the back of the card the whole time. Very frustrating lesson.

0 coins

Had a situation where my identity verification through ID.me went through fine but there was still a separate flag on my claim for a question about my wages in the base period. The two issues looked connected from my end but EDD was actually working on them independently. The point being - even with ID.me resolved, there can be an open eligibility question that runs on its own track.

0 coins

That's what it sounds like happened to me. EDD cleared identity but still had the separation question open.

0 coins

Yep this is exactly how it works. Identity verification is just confirming who you are - it doesn't answer questions about why you left your job or whether your wages qualify.

0 coins

The appeal form being called DE 1000M trips people up because there's also a DE 1000 for a totally different thing. The 1000M specifically is the UI appeal form and it comes attached to the Notice of Determination. Mail it to the exact address on your notice, not just any EDD address, because appeals go to a specific office.

0 coins

Missed this detail on my first appeal attempt and mailed it to a general EDD address. Had to refile and it ate up almost two weeks of my 30-day window.

0 coins

That's really stressful. The address on the notice is important because that's the office that actually handles the appeal routing to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board.

0 coins

Wrote this down. Using the exact address on the notice, not a general EDD address.

0 coins

Something that helped me when my claim got disqualified was writing out a clear timeline before appealing: date hired, date I was told the position was ending, last day worked, what my manager said to me, any emails or texts. Even informal documentation is better than nothing for an administrative law judge hearing.

0 coins

Does the appeal automatically go to a judge or does EDD look at it first?

0 coins

EDD reviews it first. If they don't reverse the decision on their own, it goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board and you get a Notice of Hearing before an administrative law judge. At the hearing you testify under oath and can bring someone to represent you if you want.

0 coins

Just to add - the hearing notice comes by mail at least 10 days before the hearing date. Keep your address current with EDD so you don't miss it.

0 coins

My cousin tried to certify during her appeal and was told it was pointless - is that actually true? Because I've seen people here saying to keep certifying.

0 coins

Certifying during an appeal is definitely the right move. EDD can only pay back the weeks you actually certified if the appeal goes your way. Weeks you skip are gone even if you win.

0 coins

Got it, will pass that along. She's been not certifying for three weeks already which is not great.

0 coins

She should contact EDD about those skipped weeks and explain the situation. It may be possible to certify retroactively depending on the circumstance, but that's a conversation she needs to have with EDD directly.

0 coins

Separation reason disputes are genuinely one of the more painful parts of the California EDD process - mine dragged on for almost two months. Had weeks and weeks showing Pending with no explanation in UI Online. Eventually used Claimyr to get an agent on the line; she confirmed the employer had filed a response saying I resigned voluntarily when I had documentation that my hours were cut to basically nothing and I had no choice. The agent said to include that documentation with my DE 1000M appeal and to note the specific dates the hours changed.

0 coins

Hours being cut down and then leaving - does EDD count that as a quit or a layoff?

0 coins

EDD decides after looking at both sides. The agent told me my specific situation would be evaluated in the appeal process, not that I was automatically covered. The interview and appeal are where you tell your side.

0 coins

Constructive discharge situations like that are genuinely complicated and EDD really does look at the specifics. The documentation of when hours changed matters a lot.

0 coins

For the wage base stuff - just to make sure you have good wages going in, the base period they look at is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you filed. So your most recent quarter probably isn't even in the mix yet. If those four quarters don't have enough wages there's an alternate base period that uses the last four completed quarters, but EDD only uses that one automatically if the standard one doesn't get you to a valid claim.

0 coins

Does this matter if the disqualification is about separation reason rather than wages?

0 coins

No, those are separate issues. Wages determine if a claim is valid, separation reason determines if you're eligible. Someone can have plenty of wages and still get disqualified for how they left.

0 coins

Good distinction to make clear. Two different eligibility questions that EDD evaluates separately.

0 coins

Wait, one thing I'm unclear on - someone above said the employer has to prove misconduct to deny a claim if someone was fired. But does that mean if EDD says you quit, the burden flips and YOU have to prove it was a good reason?

0 coins

EDD's own language on this is basically: if you quit, you have to show there was a good reason. If you were fired, the employer has to show there was misconduct. Those are the two different tracks and yes, it matters a lot which category your situation falls in.

0 coins

OK so for the original poster who was laid off - that's neither quit nor fired for misconduct, right? A layoff should be cleaner than either of those?

0 coins

A layoff is out of work through no fault of your own, which is what unemployment is designed for. The issue might be that the employer told EDD something different from 'layoff,' which is why the separation reason question exists on the claim.

0 coins

My layoff paperwork said 'position elimination' but my former employer filed with EDD saying my performance was the issue. Night and day. I ended up needing to speak to a live EDD agent about it - used Claimyr to get through when the hold line wasn't working. The agent confirmed the employer's response was flagged and that my claim was pending the interview. I didn't even know an interview had been scheduled because I'd moved and the DE 4800 went to my old address.

0 coins

The address issue - if EDD mailed the DE 4800 to a wrong address, is that a legitimate reason to explain a missed interview?

0 coins

The agent told me to contact EDD as soon as possible explaining why I missed it and to have the correct address updated. Missing the interview without reaching out to EDD the same day means they go ahead and decide with what they have.

0 coins

Updating your address in myEDD matters a lot for exactly this reason. EDD mails all the important stuff - the DE 4800, the Notice of Determination, the appeal notice - and if they go to a wrong address you can be in a really bad spot.

0 coins

Just want to flag something about the 30-day appeal window that burned me once. The clock starts on the mailing date printed on the notice itself, not the day you received it. If the letter sat in a mailbox for a few days or took longer to arrive, those days still count. Open the notice the moment it comes and note the date at the top.

0 coins

Mine arrived four days after the date on the letter according to what I remember of when I first saw it in the mail. So I've used up at least four of my 30 days already.

0 coins

File the appeal as soon as possible then. Don't wait until you feel fully ready - you can add more information later but missing the deadline is very hard to come back from.

0 coins

A late appeal is possible but you have to give a reason for missing the deadline and EDD has to accept that reason. Much easier to file on time even if the appeal letter is simple.

0 coins

What do you actually write in an appeal letter if you use a letter instead of the DE 1000M form? Like is there a specific format?

0 coins

The DE 1000M is basically a simple form with your name, claim info and a spot to say you disagree - it doesn't require a legal argument. If you write a letter instead, include your name, the last four of your Social Security number, your claim ID if you have it, the date of the notice you're appealing, and a clear statement that you disagree and why. Mail it to the address on the notice.

0 coins

Thank you, that's way simpler than I thought. I was imagining it had to be like a formal legal document.

0 coins

Administrative law judge hearings can get more formal later in the process, but the initial appeal letter is really just saying 'I disagree with this decision and here's the basic reason.' The more detailed explanation comes at the hearing.

0 coins

Has anyone dealt with EDD and gotten a disqualification reversed without it going all the way to a hearing? Like does EDD ever just look at an appeal and say 'we made a mistake, here are your payments'?

0 coins

EDD does review appeals before sending them to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. Some get reversed at that stage. But there's no guarantee and EDD doesn't give a timeline for how long that review takes.

0 coins

Mine was reversed before the CUIAB stage. Got a letter saying EDD had reconsidered and I was eligible. Took about five weeks from when I filed the appeal.

0 coins

Five weeks is a long time when you have no income but better than a full hearing. Good to know it can happen.

0 coins

Curious if identity verification through ID.me ever needs to be redone, or once it's confirmed it's confirmed forever? I went through it once and I keep being paranoid a new claim would make me do it again.

0 coins

For a new claim or a reopened claim, EDD may ask you to verify again. It's not always required but it can come up. If you get a DE 1326C in the mail it means EDD needs identity verification for that claim specifically.

0 coins

Good to know what to look for. So the DE 1326C is the specific notice that kicks off the ID.me process?

0 coins

That's the one EDD mails when they can't verify identity automatically. It tells you to go through ID.me and gives instructions.

0 coins

OP - any update on the card situation after checking which company it's from?

0 coins

Looked at it tonight. It's the old card, not Money Network. So that whole problem is completely separate from the disqualification like people said here. Going to call the number on the back of the new Money Network card EDD issued - found it in my myEDD account settings. And filing the appeal letter tomorrow morning before anything else.

0 coins

Filing the appeal and then sorting the card is the right order. The appeal deadline doesn't stop for card problems.

0 coins

When you do the appeal, consider also asking EDD - through a message in UI Online or the live chat from the Help button - about the missed interview, since that might be what triggered the disqualification in the first place. Getting that clarified could help your appeal.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure