Back to California Unemployment

Miguel Hernández

Can I get unemployment if fired for taking lunch and breaks together - California EDD question

So my manager called me into the office last Thursday and let me go. The reason they put on paper was that I'd been combining my lunch period with my two rest breaks to get a longer stretch away from my desk, which honestly I'd been doing for over a year with no complaints from anyone. Then new management came in and apparently that violated some internal policy they never formally told me about. I worked there for about four years, never had a written warning, never had a performance review that said anything negative. This was completely out of left field. I went home and filed for unemployment through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ the same day because I figured I should get the clock started. UI Online showed my application went through. Now I'm sitting here wondering - does combining breaks count as misconduct in EDD's eyes? Like is this the kind of firing where they just deny you, or do I actually have a decent shot here? I've never filed before and have no idea what to expect from the whole phone interview process or how EDD decides these things. Any experience with something similar?

Fired for the same reason about eight months ago - my employer documented it as a policy violation when I'd been taking stacked breaks for two years without a single write-up. When I filed through California EDD, the pending weeks sat there for three weeks and I couldn't get anyone on the phone to tell me whether the interview was even scheduled. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what finally got me talking to a live EDD agent - the video on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. What the agent told me was that my interview was already scheduled for the following Tuesday and the date and time were listed on the DE 4800 notice EDD had mailed, and also showing on my UI Online homepage. I hadn't looked in that spot on the homepage. The agent said I just needed to keep my phone free at that time because the interviewer phones at the time on the DE 4800. That was the detail I was missing.

0 coins

Going back into UI Online right now to look at the homepage for that DE 4800 date - I had no idea that screen showed interview timing. Thank you for pointing me to that specific spot.

0 coins

The DE 4800 notice itself also has the questions EDD is likely to ask, which is worth reading before the interview so you're not caught off guard about what to say regarding the policy and your history with it.

0 coins

Had the same experience where the homepage had the interview time and I'd completely missed it. Check there first before anything else.

0 coins

Four years with no discipline and then fired for a break policy they never formally communicated - that's actually a pretty solid position going into the EDD interview. The burden question here works like this in plain terms: if you were fired, EDD makes your employer show there was actual misconduct. EDD's own language is basically that your employer has to prove misconduct happened. Stacking breaks when nobody ever told you in writing that it was against the rules is a very different thing from, say, stealing or ignoring a direct written warning. I'd put together everything that shows no prior discipline: any performance reviews, old emails that show no one complained, even a note about how long the practice went on. The interviewer will ask both you and your former employer what happened, and your side of the story - especially the part about no warnings - matters a lot.

0 coins

Pulling together everything I have from my four years there right now. I do have my last two annual reviews saved in email and neither mentions anything about breaks.

0 coins

The 'no prior written warning' detail is probably your strongest point. EDD has denied people for misconduct when there were multiple documented warnings before the termination. No documentation at all cuts the other way.

0 coins

Agree with this - misconduct in EDD's world isn't just 'we didn't like what the employee did.' It's supposed to be a deliberate disregard of a known rule. If you genuinely didn't know the rule existed, that matters.

0 coins

Worth noting that your employer will get a Notice of Unemployment Insurance Claim Filed (DE 1101CZ) in the mail and has 10 days from the date on it to respond to EDD. What they write in that response is part of what shapes the interview questions.

0 coins

DE 1101CZ from my own termination last year showed my former employer submitted a response claiming I violated a 'clearly communicated attendance policy' - the problem was they had never put it in writing. When I finally got a live EDD agent on the phone through Claimyr, the agent pulled up my file and told me the interview was still open and I needed to keep certifying every two weeks on UI Online or Tele-Cert in the meantime. The agent confirmed pending weeks only get paid out after EDD decides eligibility AND I've certified, so stopping certifications would have cost me those weeks. That piece was critical for me because I had almost stopped certifying while waiting.

0 coins

Keeping certifications going during the whole wait - noted. I did not know that stopping would cost you those weeks even if you eventually got approved.

0 coins

Certifying every two weeks while your claim is in adjudication is something a lot of people get wrong. If you don't certify, EDD can't pay those weeks retroactively even after they decide in your favor.

0 coins

The employer claiming a policy was 'clearly communicated' when nothing was in writing is exactly the kind of contradiction that can go your way at the interview. The interviewer hears both sides.

0 coins

Reading about your situation - four years, no write-ups, and a policy they never formally gave you in writing - I'd check your calendar right now and make sure you haven't missed the interview notice. If you do miss the scheduled interview, phone EDD that same day at 1-800-300-5616. Missing it and NOT phoning the same day means EDD makes the eligibility call with just your employer's version of events, and that's not a situation you want.

0 coins

Already have a note to check the UI Online homepage every day and I've got EDD's number saved. Definitely not planning to miss it.

0 coins

The 'phone EDD the same day' rule if you miss the interview is one that trips people up. Even a few hours late calling in can make the difference between getting it rescheduled and EDD just deciding without you.

0 coins

Also note that if you need to change the interview time for a legitimate reason, you have to contact EDD at least one day before it's scheduled and there has to be an open time slot available to move it to. It's not guaranteed they can shift it.

0 coins

My experience going through a termination claim two years ago - the waiting period is worth understanding before your first certification. Every California UI claim has a one-week unpaid waiting period that you serve on the first eligible week. It doesn't reduce the total amount the claim can eventually pay, it just means that first week is unpaid. Your first certification after EDD processes your application usually covers the waiting week and one paid week together.

0 coins

So the first certification basically covers two weeks but only one of them pays out - good to know so I'm not confused when I see that first payment.

0 coins

Exactly right on the waiting week. A lot of people think something went wrong with their claim when the first payment is less than expected, but the waiting week is working as designed.

0 coins

DE 429Z is the notice EDD mails you that shows your weekly benefit amount - that's separate from any eligibility decision. It just tells you the weekly amount the claim calculates to, between $40 and $450 depending on your earnings history.

0 coins

The break-stacking issue is one of those gray areas where EDD really does look at all the circumstances. I know someone whose termination for a similar policy issue got approved for benefits because the employer couldn't produce a signed acknowledgment that the employee ever received the policy. A verbal 'everyone knows the rules' doesn't hold up the same way a signed document would. The interviewer's job is to figure out whether this was genuine misconduct or whether it was ambiguous enough that benefits should flow.

0 coins

No signed acknowledgment of any break policy in anything I ever signed at that company. I went through my onboarding documents last night and found nothing.

0 coins

Keeping those onboarding documents is a smart move. If you have them available during the interview, you can say directly that nothing in your paperwork covered the specific break policy they cited.

0 coins

The employer might still push back hard even without documentation - just be prepared for the interviewer to ask follow-up questions about whether managers ever verbally told you the stacking was a problem before the termination.

0 coins

Combined meal and rest period situation from earlier this year - my employer also terminated me over it, and my adjudication dragged out because my employer filed a late response to EDD after the DE 1101CZ. Getting through to EDD by phone to understand why my weeks stayed pending was the main problem. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent who looked at my account and said the employer's late response had triggered an additional review step. The agent told me the pending weeks in my Claim History would stay that way until EDD finished that review and I certified for those weeks. I kept certifying on Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 every two weeks the whole time.

0 coins

Late employer response triggering additional review is something I hadn't even thought about. Good to know the pending status in Claim History can have multiple causes beyond just the interview itself.

0 coins

The Tele-Cert line at 1-866-333-4606 (option 2) is worth saving separately from the main EDD number. Some people don't realize there's a dedicated line for certifying that works 24 hours.

0 coins

EDD's payment information also updates daily at that same 1-866-333-4606 line, so you can check on your payment status there even if you certified through UI Online.

0 coins

EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site at edd.ca.gov lets you estimate your weekly benefit amount before the DE 429Z arrives. Worth checking so you have a rough idea what to expect. The calculation is based on the highest-paid quarter in your base period - for most people that's the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before the claim week. If your wages in that window don't qualify, EDD automatically looks at the alternate base period instead, which is the last four completed quarters.

0 coins

Running the calculator now - my wages were pretty consistent across the last couple years so this should give me a decent estimate.

0 coins

The alternate base period thing is worth knowing even if you probably won't need it. EDD applies it on its own if the standard period doesn't get you to a valid claim, so you don't have to ask for it.

0 coins

Maximum weekly benefit is $450 and the minimum is $40, so the calculator estimate will land somewhere in that range based on your highest quarter earnings.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is another thing that can quietly stop payments if you miss it - most claimants have to register on caljobs.ca.gov and post a resume within 21 days of the date on the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405). EDD mails that notice after your application is processed. If you don't register in time, payments can get held up. EDD tells you if you're one of the people who doesn't need to register, but most people do.

0 coins

Registering on CalJOBS as soon as I get the DE 8405 - didn't realize that was a separate step from just filing the claim.

0 coins

The 21-day window on that runs from the date printed on the DE 8405, not from when you receive it in the mail, so open it immediately when it arrives and register that same day if possible.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is probably the most underestimated step in the whole process. Claims that are otherwise clean get held up purely because someone thought it was optional.

0 coins

While everything is pending, you also need to be genuinely able to work, available for work, and looking for work every week you certify. Those three things are what California UI requires for each week you claim. I keep notes on where I've applied but EDD's pages don't tell you a specific number of applications you need each week - the certify questions ask whether you looked, so being actually out there applying is what matters.

0 coins

Already updating my resume and starting to apply places. Good point that the certification questions will ask about this directly.

0 coins

The work search requirement applies during adjudication too, not just after you're approved. Keep applying during the whole waiting period.

0 coins

If EDD eventually decides you don't qualify and you disagree, keep certifying through the appeal period. You can only be paid for weeks you certified - going silent during an appeal means those weeks can't be paid even if you win.

0 coins

The claim that you hadn't received formal notice of the policy is going to be tested at the interview. The interviewer will ask both you and the former employer for specifics - dates, conversations, any documentation. Your answer to 'were you ever told this was against the rules before the termination' should be clear and consistent with whatever actually happened. Don't speculate or expand beyond what you actually know.

0 coins

Keeping my answer to that question factual and specific to what actually happened - new management arrived in March, nothing was communicated to staff about policy changes, then terminated in June.

0 coins

Exact dates and sequence of events are helpful in the interview. 'New management arrived, no policy communication followed, then termination' is a clear timeline that the interviewer can follow.

0 coins

If your employer says in the interview that there was an employee handbook or posted policy, have your honest answer ready about whether you received or saw it, since that documentation question is often central.

0 coins

Something that caught me off guard on my first claim years ago - if EDD decides against you, the Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) comes with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) right in the same envelope. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing. Miss that window and you need to explain why, and a late appeal is much harder. So if the determination goes the wrong way, don't sit on it.

0 coins

Keeping track of the mailing date on any notice EDD sends, not just the date I receive it. The 30-day clock from mailing date is a detail I would have gotten wrong.

0 coins

The appeal goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board (CUIAB) after EDD reviews it. An administrative law judge holds the hearing and testimony is under oath, so it's a real process, not just paperwork.

0 coins

Keep certifying through the appeal too - already said above but worth repeating because it's the step people skip when they're frustrated with the whole process and EDD can only pay certified weeks.

0 coins

Overpayment fear was something that stressed me out when I was in adjudication - I want to be clear because I see people get confused about this. Collecting benefits during the interview and decision period is normal and expected. If EDD later decides you don't qualify for some weeks, they'd send an overpayment notice, but that is different from fraud. Collecting while EDD is making up its mind, while certifying honestly, is exactly what the system is designed for.

0 coins

Good to hear collecting during the decision period is the normal path and not something that creates automatic problems. That was a background worry I had.

0 coins

The distinction between non-fraud overpayment and fraud matters a lot. Honest certification during adjudication is the right thing to do - it's a person misrepresenting wages or continuing to claim after returning to full-time work that creates the fraud category.

0 coins

If there ever is an overpayment notice that you disagree with, the same 30-day window and appeal process applies, same form DE 1000M.

0 coins

Unemployment benefits are federal taxable income even though California doesn't tax them at the state level. EDD mails a Form 1099G each January, and it's also available in UI Online under Payments then Form 1099G. At each certification you get the option to have 10 percent withheld for federal taxes, which is worth considering if you don't want a surprise at tax time.

0 coins

Setting federal withholding on my certifications from the start - better to manage it now than deal with a large tax bill in January.

0 coins

Nobody pays into unemployment as an employee, by the way - that's the employer's cost. The CASDI line on a paycheck is for State Disability Insurance and Paid Family Leave, not UI. Sometimes people think their EDD claim is 'their' money they put in. It's insurance funded by employers.

0 coins

Correcting a misconception that shows up sometimes - the fact that benefits are taxable federally is correct, and the 10 percent withholding option at certification is the main way to handle it without doing estimated quarterly payments.

0 coins

Appeals after a denial go to an administrative law judge at the CUIAB - the hearing is real and testimony is under oath. Anyone can represent you: yourself, a union rep if applicable, or an attorney. EDD sends a Notice of Hearing by mail at least 10 days before the date. The good news is you're not at this stage yet and many termination claims like yours resolve at the initial interview without needing an appeal at all.

0 coins

Hoping to resolve at the interview stage, but good to know the full path if it doesn't go that way.

0 coins

Preparing your side of the story the same way whether or not you think an appeal is likely is good practice. Clear documentation and a consistent factual account serve you at the interview and would serve you again at an appeal hearing.

0 coins

The Notice of Hearing arrives at least 10 days before the hearing, so you do have time to prepare once you know the date. It's not sprung on you last minute.

0 coins

Direct deposit or the Money Network prepaid debit card are the two options for receiving payments - EDD's card is through Money Network, not any bank. If you haven't set a payment method preference, you'll get the card by default. You can update it in myEDD if you'd prefer direct deposit to a bank account. Payment information updates daily in UI Online and also on the Tele-Cert line.

0 coins

Switching to direct deposit through myEDD now so payments go straight to my account when they start coming through.

0 coins

Worth doing before your first payment rather than after - changing payment method after the first disbursement can delay the transition by a cycle or two.

0 coins

UI Online payment status is worth checking daily during adjudication since the status updates there before you'd get anything in the mail about it.

0 coins

Lots of helpful detail in this thread - for anyone who gets confused about what 'adjudication' means since it comes up here: it's just the period when EDD is deciding whether you're eligible. Pending weeks in Claim History mean EDD is working through that decision. It doesn't mean you've been denied. It's normal for a termination claim, especially one with a policy dispute, to sit in adjudication for a few weeks while both sides respond.

0 coins

That definition actually helps. I kept reading 'adjudication' and treating it like it meant something had already gone wrong.

0 coins

A lot of first-time claimants mix up adjudication and appeal too - adjudication is EDD's internal decision process, appeal is what you do after a denial if you disagree. Very different stages.

0 coins

Pending status in Claim History can also mean identity verification is still in process, not just the eligibility question. If you haven't completed ID.me verification yet, that can be the reason for pending weeks on its own.

0 coins

ID.me verification - if you applied through UI Online your identity verification should have been part of the online application process. If EDD couldn't verify right away you would have gotten a Request for Identity Verification (DE 1326C) in the mail. Check whether you've received that and if so it needs to be handled through ID.me before anything else moves.

0 coins

Completed ID.me during the initial application so that should be handled, but I'll double-check my mail for a DE 1326C just to be sure.

0 coins

Even if you completed ID.me initially, occasionally EDD sends the DE 1326C anyway if something in the verification didn't fully process. Worth confirming it's marked complete on your end.

0 coins

The DE 1326C situation is one where phoning EDD directly is often the fastest resolution, since ID.me status and EDD's internal records don't always sync immediately and an agent can see what EDD's side shows.

0 coins

Reached the end of this whole thread - the core answer to your original question is: fired for taking lunch and breaks together, with no prior written warnings and no documented communication of the policy, is NOT automatically disqualifying. EDD requires the employer to demonstrate misconduct, and 'we had an unwritten rule they didn't follow' is a weaker case than a documented written policy with signed acknowledgment. Your job is to tell your side clearly at the interview, certify every two weeks, and keep your work search active. The outcome isn't guaranteed either way, but your facts are genuinely in your favor.

0 coins

Summarizing where I am: interview date checked on UI Online homepage, CalJOBS registration in progress, certifications set up, federal withholding selected, four years of clean reviews ready. Feeling a lot better about the situation than I did when I filed.

0 coins

Claimyr at claimyr.com is worth having ready if your pending weeks pile up and you can't get through on 1-800-300-5616 during the wait - stacked break termination claims can sit in adjudication longer than straightforward layoffs and you may need to talk to an agent about what's holding a specific week.

0 coins

EDD's live chat through the Help button in UI Online also works Monday to Friday 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. if phoning isn't an option at a given time - another contact path alongside the main phone line.

0 coins

Good luck at the interview - keep your answers factual, specific, and grounded in what actually happened rather than what you think EDD wants to hear. Consistent accounts hold up better.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure