Can I get unemployment if fired after work injury elbow pain? California EDD question
Okay so here's my situation and I'm honestly stressed about it. I was working as a line cook for about two years and started having pretty severe elbow pain about four months ago. Repetitive strain from the lifting and prep work. I told my manager, tried to push through it, eventually had to tell HR because it was affecting my speed and they kept writing me up for not keeping pace. Long story short, they let me go two weeks ago. The termination letter says 'failure to meet performance standards' but everyone knows it's because my elbow was messed up. I've never filed for unemployment before and I honestly don't know if EDD is going to look at this and say I should have filed workers comp instead, or if they'll count the writeups as misconduct and deny me. I already filed online through myEDD but now I'm sitting here staring at the pending status wondering what's going to happen. Anyone dealt with something like this where there was an injury involved and then a firing?
75 comments

QuantumQuester
DE 4800 showed up in my mailbox about ten days after I filed, which is what triggered me actually getting answers on my claim. Had a similar situation, not a kitchen job but warehouse work, and my wrist kept giving out after a repetitive stress injury. Eventually got let go for 'attendance issues' that were really just me leaving early because of the pain. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent because the hold times were impossible. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the phone interview was already scheduled, the date was also on my UI Online homepage, and that the DE 4800 had the specific questions they'd be asking. She said to explain exactly what the injury was, when I reported it to the employer, and what accommodation if any I requested. The video they have about reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if the phone line is killing you. What the agent told me was that EDD decides from both what I say and what the employer says in their own interview, and that my job was just to tell the full story of the injury and the writeups in order.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorThe DE 4800 is what I should be watching for in my physical mail then? I didn't realize there was going to be a formal scheduled interview, I thought they'd just review my file and decide. This is actually good to know.
0 coins
Andre Moreau
Had the same DE 4800 experience when I filed after a shoulder issue ended my delivery job. The UI Online homepage showed the interview time too, which is what I actually checked since mail sometimes runs slow in my area.
0 coins
Zoe Stavros
Flagging the part about telling the full story in order, because when I had my interview for a termination after back problems, the interviewer moved fast and I stumbled over the timeline. Write out the dates before the interview, start of symptoms, when you told your manager, when HR got involved, when the writeups started.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
Performance writeups after a reported injury get complicated and EDD knows that pattern. The way my layoff worked, I'd told my supervisor three times in writing that the repetitive task was causing me pain, then two months later I was out for 'productivity.' EDD asked me for dates and whether I had documentation. The key thing is EDD decides after both sides give their version on the phone. It's not just your paperwork, it's also what your former employer tells them. Keep anything you have in writing, texts to HR, any email chains, that stuff matters if the employer tells a different story.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorActually have some texts where I told my manager my elbow was hurting and I might need to slow down. Didn't know those would be relevant, I'll hold onto those.
0 coins
Mei Chen
DE 1101CZ is the form EDD sends the employer asking them to respond. They have ten days from the date on it. If they don't respond, that changes what happens on their end, but EDD still makes its own decision from your interview.
0 coins
Liam Sullivan
Saving those texts is smart. Had a situation where my employer said I never reported any health issue. Having the actual written record was the difference in what I could say confidently during the interview.
0 coins
Amara Okafor
One thing people mix up with injury-related firings is that workers comp and unemployment are two separate things. Workers comp is for the medical costs and lost wages from the injury itself. Unemployment is about whether you were wrongfully terminated or let go through no fault of your own. You can potentially pursue both but they work through completely different agencies and processes. EDD doesn't decide your workers comp case and workers comp doesn't block you from filing for unemployment.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorSo filing a workers comp claim about the elbow injury wouldn't hurt my EDD case? I was nervous about that because I didn't know if EDD would say go through workers comp instead.
0 coins
Amara Okafor
EDD's program and workers comp run separately. The question EDD is answering is whether you were fired for misconduct. Workers comp is handled through the Division of Workers' Compensation, totally different. File both if both apply.
0 coins
CosmicCommander
Agreed on this, though I'd add that if you receive any workers comp wage replacement payments, you do report those when you certify. EDD decides how they affect your weekly amount. But the act of filing workers comp doesn't disqualify you from unemployment.
0 coins
Giovanni Colombo
Misconduct under EDD's standard is about the employer proving you did something intentionally wrong, like you knew the rules and broke them anyway. Getting written up for being slower because your elbow hurt doesn't sound like that kind of intentional misconduct. That's why the injury context is so important to lay out clearly in your phone interview. EDD's own language is that the employer has to prove there was misconduct, and slow pace because of a physical injury is a very different thing than showing up late because you didn't care.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Qasimi
Payroll records from my last few months also ended up being relevant in my own termination interview, because they showed my output had declined starting exactly when I first reported the injury. That correlation was part of my story and it matched what I said.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorMakes sense, I was worried 'fired for performance' was automatically going to be treated as misconduct. The distinction between intentional rule breaking and injury-related slowdown is what I need to explain clearly.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Had a friend go through almost the exact same thing, performance pip followed by termination after a wrist injury. EDD asked the employer to show evidence of willful misconduct and they couldn't because it was really just the injury. I don't know details but EDD does actually look at the reason behind the performance, not just the writeup itself.
0 coins
Sofia Ramirez
DE 429Z came in the mail about two weeks after I filed on a similar situation and showed my weekly benefit amount. The amount comes from your highest earning quarter in what they call the base period, the first four of the last five completed quarters before you filed. Line cook wages over two years should give you something to work with. The DE 429Z itself isn't a decision on whether you qualify, it's just what the claim could pay if you do qualify. The actual eligibility decision comes after the phone interview.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorHaven't gotten that form yet, it's only been two weeks since I filed. So I should expect that in the mail soon and the weekly amount on it is the estimate based on my wages?
0 coins
Sofia Ramirez
Exactly, it shows what EDD calculated from your earnings record. If the number looks wrong, like quarters are missing or wages are off, that's something to flag, there's a 30 day window from the mailing date to appeal if something on the DE 429Z is incorrect.
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site can give you a rough estimate before the DE 429Z arrives, just so you have a ballpark. It's not exact but it uses the same base period logic.
0 coins
StarSeeker
Rotator cuff issues ended my job at a fulfillment center after they put me on a productivity improvement plan I physically couldn't meet. Filed with EDD and hit a wall trying to reach anyone by phone to understand what was happening with my claim. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to an agent who confirmed my interview was scheduled and explained that the specific questions on the DE 4800 were about the reason for separation. She said I should be ready to give the date I first reported the injury, the date the PIPs started, and whether I asked for any kind of accommodation. Having that roadmap before the interview helped me prepare.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorThe question about whether I asked for an accommodation is one I haven't thought about specifically. I told them verbally that I was struggling but didn't formally request a modified duty or anything in writing. Is that going to hurt me?
0 coins
StarSeeker
DE 4800 for my claim had a question specifically about whether I requested accommodation and what the response was. I'd mentioned my injury multiple times but never used the word accommodation formally either. The interviewer let me explain the full verbal history and that was what mattered, not whether I used the right word.
0 coins
Ava Martinez
Verbal reports to a manager count. What the interviewer is really trying to understand is whether the employer knew about the limitation. If you told your manager and have texts to prove it, that's your documentation of notice.
0 coins
Miguel Ortiz
CalJOBS registration is also something to handle early. After the first payment comes through, most claimants get a DE 8405 notice requiring them to register on CalJOBS and post a resume within 21 days. It doesn't get mentioned much but missing that deadline can stop payments. EDD's notice tells you if you're exempt. For someone with an ongoing elbow injury, also think about whether you're currently able and available for work, because EDD requires that for every week you certify.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorThe able and available question is one I've been thinking about. The elbow pain is real but it's not like I can't work at all, I'd just need something less physically intense. Would that count as available for work?
0 coins
Miguel Ortiz
Being available for some work while having a physical limitation is something EDD evaluates. The requirement is that you're able and available for work generally, not necessarily any specific job. If you're applying for jobs you can actually do given your condition, that's the direction to go. If the injury makes you completely unable to work at all, that's when Disability Insurance becomes relevant instead.
0 coins
Zainab Omar
Just flagging that if the elbow gets worse and you become completely unable to work for a period, the DI claim would need to be filed separately through SDI Online. You can't collect unemployment and disability for the same days, so it's one at a time depending on your situation week to week.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
The certification timeline trips people up. First certification usually covers the waiting week and the first paid week, so the first payment is typically about two weeks after you certify the first time. The waiting week itself doesn't get paid, it's just the first week you serve. All of that is separate from the eligibility question, which is still being decided through the interview process. So you could certify on time and still see pending status until the interview decision comes through.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorSo I should keep certifying even though my status shows pending and there's been no decision yet?
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Yes, keep certifying every two weeks on schedule. If EDD decides in your favor after the interview, they can pay the pending weeks, but only if you certified them. Stopping certification while waiting on a decision means those weeks can't be paid back.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
Missed this when I was going through my own claim and lost about three weeks of payments because I stopped certifying while waiting on the adjudication decision. Definitely keep certifying regardless of pending status.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Injury context plus termination also sometimes means the work search requirement comes up as a question. While the claim is active you need to be looking for work and keeping some kind of record of where you applied. EDD doesn't specify a certain number of contacts, just that you're genuinely searching. For someone transitioning away from physical kitchen work because of an elbow issue, documenting that you're applying for roles you can actually do is the right approach.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorShould I be applying for kitchen jobs still or would it be okay to be applying for lower-physical-demand jobs? I don't want EDD to say I'm restricting my search too much.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Applying for roles you're physically capable of doing is the honest approach. The requirement is that you're available and looking for work, not that you're applying to roles that would reinjure you. If asked during certification, answer truthfully about your search.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Applied for front of house and office jobs after a knee issue made kitchen work impossible for me, and EDD never flagged my work search. The question at certification is about whether you looked for work, not specifically what kind.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
Weekly benefit amount on my claim came out lower than I expected because my elbow had already been slowing me down in my last quarter, so my earnings in that period were less. Figured I should mention that because the highest quarter is what determines your weekly amount, and if the injury affected your hours or tips in recent months that could show up in the numbers. Got on the phone with an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask about whether the alternate base period would apply to my situation. The agent explained the alternate base period only gets used when the standard base period doesn't produce a valid claim at all, not to increase the weekly amount on a claim that's already valid. That cleared up a lot of confusion I had.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorMy hours did drop in the last couple months because of the elbow, so I'm wondering if that hurt my benefit amount calculation. But it sounds like there's not really a workaround for that unless the standard base period doesn't qualify me at all?
0 coins
Paolo Conti
That's exactly right based on what the agent told me. The alternate base period is EDD's safety net for people who don't have enough wages to qualify under the standard calculation. It's not a tool for raising the amount when the standard one already works.
0 coins
Andre Moreau
EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site shows an estimate based on the base period quarters. Worth running it with the quarters you know to see roughly where you land before the DE 429Z arrives.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
My sister went through something kind of similar, fired after an injury and EDD initially pending for weeks, it was really stressful watching her go through it. For what it's worth she did eventually get approved.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorAppreciate hearing that. The pending status sitting there with no movement is what's really getting to me right now.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
Pending in Claim History just means EDD hasn't issued a decision yet on that week. After the phone interview and their decision, they process the pending weeks that you certified. It's not a denial.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
PERFORMANCE WRITEUPS ARE NOT AUTOMATICALLY MISCONDUCT people need to understand this better!! I see so many people not even bother filing because they assume getting fired for performance is a disqualifier. EDD's standard requires the employer to actually prove you intentionally violated a known policy. Struggling to keep up because your body is breaking down is nothing like that. FILE. Even if you're not sure, file and let EDD make the actual determination after they hear both sides.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorThis was literally my fear, that the termination letter saying 'performance' would just automatically mean denial. Good to know that's not how EDD reads it.
0 coins
Giovanni Colombo
Exactly right. The formal reason on the termination letter is the employer's framing. EDD does its own analysis of what actually happened, and that's what the phone interview is for.
0 coins
Zoe Stavros
Had my claim approved after a termination for 'attendance' that was really medical appointments I couldn't avoid. The letter said attendance, EDD heard the full story and decided it wasn't misconduct. The letter isn't the final word.
0 coins
CosmicCommander
Severance question in case that's on your radar: if your former employer is offering any severance as part of the separation, you still report it when you certify. EDD has a spot to report all wages and certain payments during the weeks you're certifying. Severance paid under a company policy generally doesn't disqualify you from receiving benefits, but it still gets reported and EDD decides how it's handled. If that's part of your situation, ask the EDD agent directly when you have the interview.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorThey didn't offer severance so that's not an issue for me. But good to know that it wouldn't necessarily block benefits if they had.
0 coins
Mei Chen
Report Wages in UI Online is the spot to log earnings or other pay for a given week before certifying. It doesn't fix a week already certified, so if something changes after you've already submitted a certification, you'd contact EDD through a message in UI Online.
0 coins
Zainab Omar
Disability Insurance is worth knowing about separately from the unemployment claim. SDI Online is where DI is filed, completely separate from myEDD for unemployment. If the elbow pain gets to the point where a doctor says you can't work at all, DI covers non-work-related inability to work. The window to file is no earlier than nine days after the disability period starts and no later than forty-nine days in. You can't get unemployment and DI paid for the same days, so it would be one claim active at a time depending on your situation.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorIf the elbow needs surgery and I genuinely can't work for a few weeks, it sounds like I'd pause the EDD unemployment certification and file a DI claim through SDI Online for that period?
0 coins
Zainab Omar
That's the general idea. When you become unable to work, you'd stop certifying for unemployment and file for DI. When you're able to return to work and looking, unemployment would be active again if the benefit year is still open. The two programs don't overlap.
0 coins
Amara Okafor
Worth knowing the DI filing window so you don't miss it if that becomes relevant. Nine to forty-nine days after disability starts. Missing that window is one of the most common mistakes people make with that program.
0 coins
Liam Sullivan
Form 1099G is also just something to keep in mind starting now. EDD mails it in January for any unemployment benefits paid in the prior year. Benefits are federal taxable income. You can opt into ten percent federal withholding at each certification if you don't want a surprise at tax time. California state income tax doesn't apply to unemployment benefits though, only federal.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorHad no idea unemployment was taxable federally. I'll opt in for the withholding when I certify so I'm not scrambling in tax season.
0 coins
Liam Sullivan
The option to withhold comes up during each certification. You can change your choice each time you certify if your situation changes.
0 coins
Ava Martinez
EDD's live chat is also an option that people sleep on. From the Help button inside UI Online, Monday through Friday nine to two. If you have a quick status question and don't want to call, that's sometimes faster. Phone line is 1-800-300-5616, eight to five weekdays. Both go to actual EDD staff.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorDidn't know about the live chat option, I've been dreading the phone hold times. I'll try that first for the simpler questions.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
Chat through the Help button worked for me once to check on a pending week. For anything that actually needs them to look at the claim in depth the phone is more reliable, but for quick questions chat is worth trying.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Ask EDD on their site also lets you send a written message through your account. Good for things that aren't urgent and you want a written record of the response.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Coming at this from the other side, I work in a kitchen environment too and watched a coworker go through the exact same thing, repetitive strain, writeups for speed, eventually let go. What I saw was that the phone interview was really the moment that mattered. The interviewer asked questions in a specific order: when did you first have pain, when did you tell someone, what exactly were you told about your performance, and what happened leading up to the termination. Having those answers organized and calm made a big difference. The pending weeks got paid after the decision came through.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorOkay writing down that exact sequence of questions to prepare for the interview. When pain started, when I reported it, what performance feedback said, what led to the termination. That's a solid framework.
0 coins
Zoe Stavros
Add to that framework any dates you have in writing: when you sent the first text to your manager, when the first writeup was dated, when HR got involved. If the interviewer asks for a date and you have it, that specificity helps.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Qasimi
Claim History in UI Online showed all my certified weeks as Pending for almost three weeks after my interview for a termination following a hand injury at a packaging job. Eventually updated to show payment processed after EDD issued their decision. Through Claimyr I'd gotten through to an EDD agent earlier in that wait who confirmed the weeks were held pending the eligibility determination and that the decision would come by mail as a Notice of Determination if denied, or as payments if approved.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorSo the pending status in Claim History is normal during the period between the interview and the decision? I was reading it as something being wrong with my claim.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Qasimi
Exactly what the agent told me too. Pending just means the eligibility question is still open. Once the decision comes through, those weeks resolve one way or the other.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Notice of Determination is what EDD mails if they deny you. It includes the Appeal Form DE 1000M. If you're approved, you just see payments process. The notice of denial is how you know there's something to appeal, so watch your mail.
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
Appeals, just so you have the full picture: if the decision comes back as a denial, you have thirty calendar days from the mailing date on the Notice of Determination to appeal in writing using the DE 1000M or a letter sent to the address on the notice. A late appeal needs you to explain why it was late. After EDD reviews it, the case goes to the CUIAB, and an administrative law judge holds a hearing. You can represent yourself, bring a union rep, or have an attorney. Keep certifying through the whole process because EDD can only pay back weeks that were certified.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorIf I do end up with a denial, I have thirty days from the mailing date, not thirty days from when I receive it in the mail?
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
From the mailing date on the notice itself, not from when it lands in your mailbox. So open it immediately when it arrives and calculate your deadline from the date printed on the document.
0 coins
CosmicCommander
And keep certifying regardless of a denial or an appeal. Stopping certification while appealing means those weeks can't be recovered even if the appeal goes in your favor.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
Had my claim come through fine after a firing tied to an elbow problem actually. Repetitive strain from data entry of all things, which you wouldn't think would be as bad as kitchen work but after two years it was debilitating. Termination letter said performance, EDD call covered the whole story. Payments started coming through about three weeks after the interview. Hang in there while the process runs its course.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
AuthorReally good to hear a similar situation ended okay. Data entry elbow issues don't surprise me, same repetitive motion pattern. Hope mine goes similarly.
0 coins
Ava Martinez
The three week timeline from interview to first payment is pretty typical when there are no additional issues. If it stretches much longer than that, that's when to reach out to EDD for a status check.
0 coins