Can I claim EDD after quitting a temporary job to return to my seasonal position?
Hi everyone, I'm in a bit of a tricky situation with my employment. I work a seasonal job in agriculture that typically runs April through October. I'm currently in the off-season and just got offered a position at a warehouse. The warehouse wants to hire me immediately, but my seasonal farm work starts back up in about 3 months. I have a few questions about how this might affect my unemployment: 1. If I take this warehouse job and then quit in 3 months to return to my higher-paying seasonal job, would that disqualify me from claiming unemployment later? 2. After my seasonal job ends in October 2025, would I still be eligible to file for unemployment even though I voluntarily left the warehouse job earlier in the year? 3. What would EDD consider a "good cause" for quitting the warehouse job? Would returning to my regular seasonal employment count as reasonable? I'm trying to avoid messing up my unemployment eligibility for when I really need it after the harvest season. Any advice from people who've navigated seasonal work situations would be super helpful!
24 comments


Amina Diallo
This is a common situation for seasonal workers. Here's what you need to know: 1. If you quit the warehouse job without "good cause" as defined by EDD, it could potentially impact your ability to collect unemployment after your seasonal job ends. 2. EDD looks at your most recent work separation when determining eligibility. So if your seasonal job ends in October 2025 and that's your most recent employment, they'll base your eligibility on that separation, not the earlier warehouse job. 3. For "good cause" to quit, returning to your regular, higher-paying seasonal work might qualify, especially if you're clear with the warehouse from the beginning about your temporary availability. Document everything and be upfront with both employers.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
•Thank you! That's really helpful. So you think I should tell the warehouse upfront that I can only work until April? Would having that conversation documented somehow help my case with EDD later?
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
BE CAREFUL!!! I did something similar last year and it was a NIGHTMARE with EDD! I quit a temp job to go back to my regular gig and when I applied for benefits after my season ended, I got DENIED because of the job I quit months earlier!!! Had to go through the whole appeal process and wait 6 weeks for an interview. They consider ANY quit in your base period, not just your most recent job!
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
•omg that sounds awful... did u end up getting benefits eventually? or were u just denied completely?
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
•I eventually got approved after the phone interview but it took FOREVER and I had to provide a ton of documentation showing I quit for a legitimate reason. Just warning you it's not as simple as the previous comment made it sound!
0 coins
Javier Cruz
The previous responses have some good points but miss some technical details. What matters is your "base period" - the 12-month period EDD uses to calculate your benefits. When you file a claim after your seasonal job ends in October 2025, your base period will likely include the quarter when you worked at the warehouse. If you quit the warehouse job, EDD will investigate that separation during your claim process. You need what's called "good cause" to quit. Returning to regular, higher-paying employment can potentially qualify as good cause, but it's not guaranteed. Best approach: Be transparent with the warehouse that you can only work until your seasonal job starts. Get this in writing if possible (email confirmation works). When you apply for benefits after the seasonal job ends, clearly explain the circumstances of why you left the warehouse job.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
•Thank you for the detailed explanation. This makes more sense now. So basically, I need to be upfront with the warehouse about my timeline and get something in writing that shows we had an understanding about the temporary nature of my employment there?
0 coins
Javier Cruz
•Exactly. Having documentation that shows both you and the employer understood the temporary nature of the position will significantly strengthen your case. A simple email confirmation would be sufficient. When you eventually file for benefits, be prepared to explain this during your eligibility interview.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
I've been through this exact situation! Took a retail job during my off-season from landscaping. When I told the retail manager I needed to leave for my regular seasonal job, I just made sure to: 1) Give proper 2-week notice 2) Explained in writing it was to return to my primary employment 3) Left on good terms When my landscaping job ended in November and I applied for unemployment, I had to do a phone interview about why I left the retail job earlier that year. I explained everything clearly and got approved without issues. Just be honest and professional about it.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
•This is really reassuring to hear! Did they ask for any specific documentation during your phone interview? I'm worried about how to prove the "good cause" part.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
•They just asked me to explain the situation. I had saved a copy of my resignation letter where I clearly stated I was leaving to return to my primary seasonal employment. I also mentioned that the seasonal job paid significantly better and had more hours. The EDD interviewer seemed to understand that was a reasonable economic decision. Just make sure you document everything!
0 coins
Malik Thomas
If you're struggling to get through to EDD to ask about this specific situation, I'd recommend trying Claimyr. I used them when I was in a similar situation with seasonal work questions and needed to talk to an actual EDD rep. They helped me get through to EDD in about 15 minutes when I'd been trying for days on my own. They have a video demo that shows how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km It was worth it to get clarity directly from EDD about my specific situation. Their website is claimyr.com if you want to check it out.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
•Thank you for this suggestion! I've been wondering if there was a way to just ask EDD directly instead of guessing. I'll check out that video. Did you find that the information EDD gave you was helpful for your situation?
0 coins
Malik Thomas
•Definitely! The EDD rep was able to look at my specific work history and give me personalized advice about my situation. They explained exactly what documentation I'd need and how to handle the eligibility interview when the time came. Much better than trying to piece together info from online forums (no offense to everyone here!).
0 coins
NeonNebula
just tell the warehouse job ur leavin cause of a family emergency or health reasons or somethin. thats considered good cause and edd wont even question it usually.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
•I would strongly advise against providing false information to either your employer or EDD. That could be considered misrepresentation and might lead to penalties or disqualification if discovered. Being honest about your situation is always the better approach.
0 coins
Javier Cruz
One additional thing to consider: If you take the warehouse job, you'll establish a new benefit year with potentially different weekly benefit amounts. Depending on how much the warehouse pays compared to your seasonal job, this could either increase or decrease your potential unemployment benefits after your seasonal job ends. Before making a decision, I'd recommend checking your wage history in your EDD account and using the EDD benefit calculator to see how different scenarios might affect your benefit amount. The higher-paying job will generally result in higher weekly benefits.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
•That's a really good point I hadn't considered! The warehouse job actually pays quite a bit less than my seasonal agricultural work. If I understand correctly, taking the lower-paying job could potentially lower my benefit amount when I need to claim later in the year?
0 coins
Javier Cruz
•Correct. Your weekly benefit amount is based on your highest-earning quarter in the base period. If the warehouse wages are significantly lower than your seasonal job, and they fall in a quarter that would otherwise have had your seasonal (higher) wages, it could potentially lower your benefit calculation. However, having some income is still usually better than no income. And if the warehouse job doesn't displace your highest-earning quarter, it won't negatively impact your benefit amount.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
Whatever you do, KEEP RECORDS OF EVERYTHING!!! Save emails, text messages, even write down dates/times of conversations with the warehouse manager about your situation. When I went through my eligibility interview with EDD, they wanted evidence of EVERYTHING. I wasn't prepared and it made things so much harder. Learn from my mistake!!!
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
•Thanks for emphasizing this! I'll definitely make sure to document everything. Would an email confirmation about the temporary nature of the position be sufficient, or should I try to get something more formal?
0 coins
Amina Diallo
After reading through all the responses, here's a summary of the best approach: 1. Be completely transparent with the warehouse about your timeframe and get it in writing 2. When it's time to leave, provide proper notice and clearly state you're returning to your primary seasonal employment 3. Maintain good standing with both employers 4. When you file for unemployment after your seasonal job ends, be prepared to explain your work history during the benefit year 5. During your eligibility interview, clearly explain the higher wages and established nature of your seasonal employment as the reason for leaving the temporary position This approach gives you the best chance of maintaining eligibility while still earning income during your off-season.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
•Thank you so much for summarizing everything! This community has been incredibly helpful. I feel much more confident about how to handle this situation now. I'll definitely be transparent with the warehouse job and get everything documented properly.
0 coins
Javier Morales
I'm dealing with a similar situation right now! I work in forestry (seasonal May-September) and just got offered a part-time retail job for the winter months. Reading through all these responses has been super educational. One thing I want to add - if you do take the warehouse job, make sure you understand their policies around rehiring. Some places will mark you as "not eligible for rehire" if you quit, even with proper notice. That could limit your options if you need temporary work again next winter. Also, consider asking the warehouse if they have any temporary or seasonal positions available instead of permanent roles. Some employers are more understanding when they know upfront that it's meant to be temporary employment. Good luck with whatever you decide! Seasonal work definitely has its challenges when it comes to navigating the off-season.
0 coins