Why was my PFL caretaking claim denied after doctor submitted form?
I filed a PFL care claim in SDI Online about six weeks ago to take care of my dad, who's been having serious health problems. His doctor submitted Part D online using my receipt number, which I gave the office myself. I thought everything was done on our end. Then yesterday I got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination in the mail saying I was denied. I don't understand what went wrong. The doctor's form was in, I completed all five sections when I filed, and I never got any warning that something was missing. Has anyone had their care claim denied even after the doctor sent the certification? Do I have any options now or is it just over?
71 comments

Beatrice Marshall
The DE 2500E for my own care claim never arrived after I filed, so I phoned EDD to find out what had been issued. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach someone on the PFL line, since I had tried on my own for two mornings and the line dropped both times before I reached anyone. The agent pulled up my claim and told me no Electronic Benefit Payment Notification had gone out yet because Part C, the care recipient's statement, hadn't been received. That was the gap I hadn't noticed. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM
0 coins
Melina Haruko
The agent confirmed Part C specifically as what was missing, not Part D? I want to understand whether both forms have to arrive before EDD moves forward at all.
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
Yes, Part C specifically. The agent said both are needed, and my claim sat until Part C came in. Part D was already matched.
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
Two mornings sounds like a vacation compared to what I've put in on that line. I've dialed before 8 and gotten the busy tone four days running.
0 coins
Reina Salazar
Looking at the denial notice carefully is the first thing I would do. The Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, the DE 2514, tells you the specific reason EDD denied the claim. It also comes with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. If you disagree with the reason, you have 30 days from the date on that notice to file an appeal, either online or by mail.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorI read the notice again and it says Part C was not received. But I thought Part C was my dad's own statement, not the doctor's form. Did I need to mail that separately?
0 coins
Reina Salazar
Part C is exactly that, the care recipient's statement, and it goes out by mail on the paper form. It never gets uploaded online. If your dad's statement didn't reach EDD, that could absolutely be the reason even if Part D from the doctor was submitted fine.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
Oh no, I did not know Part C was separate from the doctor's part. I assumed filling everything out in SDI Online covered it. This is so important.
0 coins
Demi Lagos
Don't file a new claim. You appeal the denial using the DE 1000A and explain that Part C was mailed but apparently not received. Attach proof if you have it.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorI don't think we ever actually mailed Part C. The doctor's office offered to handle it and I think I assumed that covered everything. So the denial might be correct on that point.
0 coins
Demi Lagos
Then you need to get Part C mailed fast and also check whether you're still inside your 41 days from when leave started. If you are, contacting EDD to sort out whether you can still submit it is the move.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
41 days goes fast. Figure out your start date and count from there before anything else.
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
Part C and Part D get confused a lot. Part D is what the physician fills out certifying the serious health condition. Part C is what the person being cared for fills out themselves, or in some cases their representative. Both mail in on paper, and EDD says not to upload either one because it can slow things down.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorSo the doctor's office submitting Part D online with my receipt number was fine, but Part C still had to be a physical mailed form from my dad?
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
That's how it works. The doctor can submit Part D in SDI Online using your receipt number, which is actually the recommended way. But Part C is a paper mailing, no digital option for it.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
I had no idea Part C even existed when I filed my care claim for my mom. I thought the doctor did all of it. This thread is clarifying a lot for me.
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
Care claims get denied for Part C more often than people realize. The doctor's office submits Part D and the claimant thinks they're done, but Part C gets forgotten entirely.
0 coins
Honorah King
Yep, the whole process puts a lot of responsibility on the claimant to track both forms separately, which isn't obvious at all when you're already stressed caring for someone.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
found this out the hard way too. assumed the doctor handled everything. they didn't.
0 coins
Mary Bates
Appeal within 30 days, that's the window on that denial notice. Do it online or mail the DE 1000A. Even if Part C really wasn't sent, explaining what happened and what you've done since is worth doing, anyway.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorMy dad is well enough to sign the form, so I'm going to get Part C mailed this week and then figure out the appeal timeline.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
Good, do both at the same time if you can. Send the form and start the appeal. That way you're covered on both angles.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
Part C on my own care claim was sent but I wasn't sure if it had been received, so I tried to phone EDD about it. Couldn't get through on my own after several attempts across different mornings. I ended up using Claimyr to reach a live agent on the PFL line. I had also been taking some partial days at work while on leave, and the agent confirmed they had the DE 2580GF logged on my account for the intermittent days I'd reported. That settled a worry I'd been carrying for two weeks.
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
My question for EDD is whether my care claim's 41-day window is still open since I started leave but filed a little late. That's what I'd use Claimyr to ask. What should I have ready before the call?
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
Have your receipt number and your exact leave start date ready. The agent looked those up right away on my call.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorKnowing the DE 2580GF was logged must have been such a relief. I didn't even know that form existed before this thread.
0 coins
Clay blendedgen
If the 41-day deadline has passed, the situation is harder but not necessarily hopeless. EDD can consider late filings in some circumstances. The denial notice and the appeal are still the right path, and explaining the timeline clearly matters.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Does the 41 days run from when leave actually started, or from when the claim was filed in SDI Online?
0 coins
Clay blendedgen
From when leave started. That's the date that starts the clock, not the filing date.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
Filing date and leave start date can be different, good to know that.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
My sister went through almost this exact thing with a care claim for her father-in-law. Part D was in, Part C never made it. EDD denied the claim for the same reason. She appealed, explained what happened, and mailed a completed Part C with the appeal.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorDid her appeal go anywhere after she did that? I'm trying to figure out if it's even worth filing one.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Honestly I don't know the outcome, she never told me how it resolved. But she did say EDD acknowledged receiving the appeal, so at least it wasn't ignored.
0 coins
Honorah King
Even without knowing the result, filing beats not filing. 30 days goes fast.
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
wait so the doctor submitting part d doesnt mean the claim is good? thats wild i assumed the whole thing was on the doctor side
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
Part D is only the physician's certification of the medical condition. Part C is the care recipient's own statement, completely separate form, mailed on paper.
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
ok that makes way more sense now. two forms two different mailers. got it
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
PFL denied after doctor submitted Part D already, that's genuinely confusing because the system doesn't remind you about Part C once you file online. I went through a bonding claim and Part C doesn't apply there, but I remember reading about it and thinking how easy it would be to miss for a care claim.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
The SDI Online flow kind of implies you're done once the doctor's office has the receipt number. It doesn't flag that Part C is a whole separate mailing you have to manage.
0 coins
Kai Santiago
EDD could send one reminder about Part C. They don't. So here we are.
0 coins
Lim Wong
The appeal is the right step. Write down exactly what you did and when, what the doctor submitted and when, and why Part C wasn't mailed. Keep it factual and attach anything you have showing the timeline.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorI do have the email confirmation from when I filed in SDI Online, which shows the date. And I can get a note from the doctor's office about when they submitted Part D. That should help show the timeline.
0 coins
Lim Wong
Those two things together with a completed Part C would be a solid appeal packet.
0 coins
Honorah King
Dated confirmation from the SDI Online filing is exactly the kind of thing that makes an appeal clearer. Good that you have it.
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
The care claim process asks a lot of people who are already exhausted from caring for someone. Two forms going two different places, one by mail, is not obvious from the SDI Online screens.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
been there. its a lot to manage when youre also at the hospital every day.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorThis is exactly it. I was at my dad's appointments, coordinating with his doctor's office, and I honestly just trusted the process more than I should have.
0 coins
Honorah King
To answer the original question directly: a denial after the doctor submits Part D usually comes down to Part C not arriving. The claim needs both. The good news is you have 30 days to appeal and can include the completed Part C with your appeal packet.
0 coins
Dananyl Lear
Is there any way to check whether Part C was received before the denial came, like in SDI Online?
0 coins
Honorah King
SDI Online shows your claim status and payment history, but EDD hasn't published what it shows for individual document receipts. Phoning EDD is the most reliable way to confirm what they have on file.
0 coins
Dananyl Lear
The DE 2514 on my own care claim said denied, and I had no idea where to start. Tried phoning EDD a few times and got nowhere. Used Claimyr to get through to an agent on the PFL line. The agent looked up my claim and read me exactly what the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination said, which matched the letter, and told me the appeal window I had left based on the notice date.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
My care claim's start date was something I needed to confirm before I sent any paperwork, so I tried Claimyr too after reading that the 41-day clock runs from leave start. The agent gave me the exact start date EDD had on file, which let me figure out where I stood on timing. Mailed the appeal the same afternoon.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
How did the agent give the start date, did they just look it up on the claim?
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Exactly that, they pulled it up and read it off. Took about two minutes of the call to get that one piece of information.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Part C and Part D both have to reach EDD within 41 days of the leave start date. That deadline is the claimant's responsibility to track, not the doctor's office. If Part C was never mailed and the 41 days are up, the appeal is the place to explain that and ask how to proceed.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorMy leave started about six weeks ago, so I'm right at or past 41 days. I'll have to include that in the appeal and explain that I didn't realize Part C was separate.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Six weeks is about 42 days. Worth noting in the appeal that the Part D was submitted timely and the gap was specifically Part C due to a misunderstanding about the form's separate mailing requirement.
0 coins
Mary Bates
Reasonable explanation stated clearly in an appeal is better than nothing. File it.
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
Status still said "Part D not received" on my bonding claim for a whole week after the foster agency sent their letter. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask whether the proof of relationship document had been matched to my claim. The agent found it had arrived but hadn't been matched yet, and confirmed the receipt date so I'd have it.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
That line is impossible. I tried eight mornings in a row once, every time it cut off before I got anywhere near a person. How is it that you got through at all?
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
I'd been trying the same way you describe, same result, for days. The Claimyr route put me on with an actual EDD employee. That person was definitely working at EDD, answered questions about my claim directly.
0 coins
Lim Wong
Knowing the document arrived but just hadn't been matched yet is exactly the kind of update that matters. Without that the anxiety is pointless.
0 coins
Kai Santiago
Appealing a care claim denial because a form didn't arrive is fair game. EDD has to consider it. Write a plain explanation, attach the completed Part C, send it in.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorI'll do exactly that. Keeping it simple and factual, not trying to make it more complicated than it is.
0 coins
Kai Santiago
Good. Keep a copy of everything you send.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
For anyone reading this later, the safest move on a care claim is to call the doctor's office as soon as you file, give them your receipt number for Part D, and mail Part C yourself that same week. Don't wait to hear back from EDD before checking that both are on their way.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
I wish I had read this before I filed. I gave the receipt number to the doctor but completely forgot Part C even existed until I was deep into the process.
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
Mailing Part C the same week you file is excellent advice. The 41-day window sounds long but between coordinating care and working it goes quickly.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
hope you get the appeal sorted. care claims are hard enough without paperwork surprises on top.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorThank you. I'm going to file the appeal this week with the Part C attached and just see what happens. At least now I understand what actually went wrong.
0 coins
Honorah King
That's the right move. You're in a better position now than when you posted, knowing exactly what to fix.
0 coins