Back to California Paid Family Leave

Carlos Mendoza

Should I mail part A of PFL form if I already applied online

So I filed my PFL bonding claim through SDI Online about five days ago for my new daughter. Got the confirmation and saved the receipt number. But now I'm second-guessing myself because I still have the paper DE 2501F sitting here and I'm wondering if I'm supposed to also mail in Part A of it, like maybe the online filing only does part of the claim? I honestly don't know if online means everything is done or if EDD still needs the paper form too. Really hoping someone can tell me if I need to send anything in or just wait.

DE 2500E showing up in my SDI Online was what finally gave me peace of mind after my bonding claim. Had been checking every single day wondering if my first payment info would ever appear. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone at EDD on the phone because I couldn't figure out if the payment notification had even been sent out yet. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the DE 2500E had been issued two days prior, so I just needed to wait for it to arrive. Video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave if you need it: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Anyway to your actual question: filing in SDI Online is the whole thing. You don't mail Part A on top of it. Sending the paper form after you already filed online can mess things up, EDD could treat it as a duplicate. Just wait on your claim.

0 coins

Wait what is Claimyr exactly, I've been trying to figure out how people actually get through to a live person there. Spent three mornings this week and got the same recording every time, anyway.

0 coins

You dial in and it stays on the line with EDD while you do other things, and your phone rings once someone there picks up. That's the whole idea. What would you even ask them about your claim?

0 coins

Honestly I'd want to ask why my claim still says pending twelve days after I filed. That feels like a lot and I keep refreshing SDI Online like it'll magically change, anyway.

0 coins

Filing the paper DE 2501F after already completing everything in SDI Online would be submitting the same claim twice. EDD is very clear that you should not do that. When you finished in SDI Online and saw the confirmation screen with your receipt number, that was your complete filing. No additional paperwork is needed for a bonding claim if you filed online.

0 coins

That confirmation page with the receipt number, that really is it then? I kept thinking there had to be something else I was missing.

0 coins

The receipt number on that confirmation is exactly what you hold onto. Keep it somewhere you can find it. That is how EDD and the doctor's office, if relevant, link anything back to your claim.

0 coins

Okay so for a bonding claim there's no doctor involved at all right? It's just me uploading the birth certificate?

0 coins

For bonding, yes, no doctor's certification is needed. You provide a proof of relationship document, the birth certificate works for that. The care claims are the ones with the physician's certification.

0 coins

you dont mail anything if you did it online thats the whole point of doing it online lol. the paper form is just for people who cant use a computer or whatever. dont send both

0 coins

Okay that makes sense when you put it that way. I think I just panicked because the paper form was still sitting on my counter.

0 coins

yeah just recycle it, youre good

0 coins

The EDD guidance says explicitly not to submit both. When you file in SDI Online you complete the full claim electronically, and the DE 2501F is the paper alternative for people who prefer mail. The two paths exist separately. Using both for the same claim creates a duplicate situation that EDD has to sort out, and that sorting out can delay everything.

0 coins

Does EDD actually catch duplicates automatically or does someone have to manually review them? I always wondered how that works on their end.

0 coins

Their internal process isn't something I can speak to, but the effect claimants report is a delay. What we know for certain is EDD says don't do it, so the safest move is just not to.

0 coins

Fair enough, good to know the official position is that clear at least.

0 coins

I made this exact mistake years ago, thought the online filing was just like a preliminary step. Mailed the form too. Took forever to get sorted. Don't do what I did.

0 coins

How long did it actually take to fix it?

0 coins

Longer than it should have. Phone line was useless. Took about three weeks total before my claim moved anywhere. Would have been fine if I'd just left it alone after the online part.

0 coins

Two days a week back at the warehouse since my kid turned four months, and the second intermittent payment never landed. Spent a week trying to get EDD on the phone about the DE 2580GF before I tried Claimyr. Got an agent in one shot. She confirmed they had received the Continued Claim Certification and told me which weeks were showing as eligible on their end, so I at least knew the form wasn't lost. For what it's worth on your situation: online filing covers it completely, mailing Part A on top would just cause problems.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself for a question about when my leave officially started and whether I'd hit the 41-day window. Agent pulled up the claim start date, confirmed the filing was inside the deadline. No drama.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about which date they use as the start, the first day of leave or the date you filed?

0 coins

First day of leave. That's the date that counts for the 41 days, not when you actually submitted.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused about something, does "bonding" always just mean the birth certificate or are there other documents that work? My husband filed for bonding but we're not on the birth certificate yet because of a paperwork delay at the hospital.

0 coins

A Declaration of Paternity, the CS-909, is another option EDD accepts for bonding. If the birth certificate isn't available yet that form can serve as the proof of relationship.

0 coins

Oh I had no idea that form existed. Where does he get it, is it something the hospital gives out?

0 coins

Hospitals do typically have them, yes. If not, the local child support office would be another place to ask.

0 coins

Thank you, I'm going to tell him to ask at the records office when he goes back to pick up the certificate anyway.

0 coins

Online is complete. Paper is for folks who don't use the internet. Pick one, not both. You picked online, you're done filing.

0 coins

Yep, got it. Thank you for saying it plainly.

0 coins

Don't overcomplicate it. Just wait and watch SDI Online for the status to move.

0 coins

My claim sat on pending for like eleven days and I was losing my mind refreshing the page, but it did eventually move. EDD says deciding can take up to 14 days so I think that's just kind of normal, as annoying as it is.

0 coins

Eleven days is kind of a lot but it's good to know it resolved. Mine is at five days right now so maybe I just need to chill.

0 coins

Honestly yeah just give it the full two weeks before you stress too hard. If it's still pending past that, send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online.

0 coins

Didn't know I could send that through SDI Online, I thought phone was the only way. That helps a lot.

0 coins

Filing online covers the full claim. No second form needed. Sending paper after the online submission creates duplicate work and can delay the whole thing.

0 coins

Short and clear, that's what I needed to hear too. Same question was on my mind.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period either, which is one of the things I didn't realize when I first filed! No seven-day wait like disability has. Once the claim clears you get paid from day one of leave.

0 coins

That's actually a really useful thing to flag because I had a coworker convinced there was a waiting week for PFL too. Good to know it's only the disability side that has that.

0 coins

Yes the seven unpaid days thing is specific to Disability Insurance, not PFL. PFL starts right from day one of your leave period!

0 coins

For documentation purposes on a bonding claim: the receipt number from SDI Online is your record of filing. The birth certificate or other proof of relationship is uploaded through SDI Online, not mailed. The claim status can be checked in SDI Online. Nothing about a standard bonding claim requires the postal service unless you filed on paper to begin with.

0 coins

Is the upload for the birth certificate done right away when you file, or is it a separate step later?

0 coins

You can upload documents through SDI Online after filing. The important thing is EDD needs the proof of relationship to process the bonding claim, so sooner is better than later.

0 coins

Okay my husband said he already uploaded it the same day, so hopefully that's fine.

0 coins

Got a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination on my care claim last spring that I didn't understand at all. The notice said I wasn't eligible and I had no idea what I'd done wrong. Tried calling EDD for two weeks straight, never made it past the recording. Used Claimyr to reach someone and the agent explained I had until 30 days from the notice date to file an appeal using the DE 1000A. She confirmed what date the notice was issued so I knew exactly how much time I had left. If you're still figuring out the basics of your bonding claim, don't mail that DE 2501F, filing online already completed the whole thing.

0 coins

The timing on that honestly sounds like marketing for whatever this Claimyr thing is. Getting a live EDD agent in a reasonable time frame doesn't match anything I've experienced with that phone line.

0 coins

thought the same thing when i first saw it. tried it anyway because i couldnt get through any other way. agent picked up and told me which payment method was on file for my claim, turns out i hadnt finished setting up direct deposit so payment was sitting there waiting. not marketing, just worked.

0 coins

Hm. Alright, that's specific enough to be believable. I might give it a try for my own situation.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation came on my claim before I'd even heard anyone mention it. Wasn't sure what it meant or if it meant I was approved.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation shows the potential weekly benefit amount based on your wages. It is not an approval. It just tells you what the payment could be if EDD finds you eligible.

0 coins

So I should wait for a separate notice or for payments to actually start before assuming I'm approved?

0 coins

Exactly right. The Notice of Computation is just about the amount. Actual eligibility gets confirmed through payments beginning or through a separate determination notice.

0 coins

Birth certificate copy sat in the uploaded documents section of SDI Online for nine days with no movement on the claim. Spent three mornings redialing before I tried Claimyr to reach a PFL agent. She looked at the claim and said the proof of relationship document had been received and matched to the bonding claim, the hold was just the standard review window. At least I knew the document wasn't stuck somewhere unread. And to actually answer the thread, you do not mail Part A after filing online, one or the other, never both.

0 coins

When you spoke with the agent, did they say anything about how they verified the document had been matched versus just received?

0 coins

She just said it was showing as received and matched on her end. Didn't get into the how, just confirmed it was there.

0 coins

been trying that phone line since monday. four attempts, same recording each time. starting to think there's genuinely no way through on a normal morning.

0 coins

There's also a question buried in this thread worth pulling out: even if you wanted to do both, there's nowhere on the paper DE 2501F to submit only Part A separately. The form doesn't split that way for a bonding claim. You either file the whole paper form or you file online. Mailing a partial paper form after an online filing doesn't even make procedural sense.

0 coins

That's actually the clearest explanation I've seen. I think I misread the form and thought Part A was like a cover sheet or something.

0 coins

A lot of people look at the sections on the paper form and think each one is a separate mailing. It's not. The whole form goes together if you use paper. Since you used SDI Online, that form is irrelevant to your claim at this point.

0 coins

Genuinely relieved. I was about to drop it in a mailbox.

0 coins

EDD's phone situation is what pushes people into these spirals of doubt where they can't get a simple answer confirmed and start doing things like mailing forms they already filed online. The system basically manufactures this kind of confusion by being impossible to reach.

0 coins

That's not wrong. Spent most of a week trying to get someone on the line about my intermittent claim and by the end I would have done anything just to hear a human voice confirm the forms were received.

0 coins

Exactly. And then people post questions like this one which are totally reasonable questions that should take two seconds to answer over the phone.

0 coins

For anyone who filed a bonding claim as a dad like me, the proof of relationship document thing tripped me up too. I uploaded the hospital-issued birth certificate but it hadn't been officially registered yet, just the one they give you at discharge. EDD accepted it though.

0 coins

This is really helpful to know because my husband had the same thing, discharge paperwork but not the official certificate yet.

0 coins

In our case it went through fine. The official registered one came weeks later but EDD didn't ask for a second upload or anything, anyway.

0 coins

Just want to confirm I had the same question and filing online was definitely the complete thing. Claim processed, payment came, never mailed anything.

0 coins

How long did yours take from filing to first payment?

0 coins

About twelve days total from filing to the first payment showing up.

0 coins

The eight weeks of PFL can also be broken up if you don't take them all at once, which I didn't realize until someone mentioned it here on another thread. You just have to use them within twelve months of the birth.

0 coins

Worth noting the eight weeks is a combined total across bonding, care and military assist claims within any twelve-month period. Not eight weeks per type of claim. Someone told me once I'd get a fresh eight for a care claim and that turned out to be wrong.

0 coins

Oh wow I didn't know that, I would have assumed the same wrong thing. So if you used five weeks bonding you'd only have three left if you needed to file a care claim that same year?

0 coins

That's how it works. One pool of eight weeks for the year, shared across claim types.

0 coins

Mailed the paper form once thinking it was required even after going online. Learned from it. You are not required. Online is the full filing.

0 coins

What happened when they got both?

0 coins

Delay. Had to call in and sort it out. Not worth it.

0 coins

If you're still uncertain after everything in this thread, you can always send a Request Claim Update in SDI Online. Opens a written question to EDD and they respond there. No phone needed.

0 coins

I did end up doing this this morning actually. Asked EDD directly whether my online filing was complete or if I needed to send anything. Got a response that said the claim was filed and I just needed to wait for the review. That settled it for me.

0 coins

That's the best outcome honestly. Straight from EDD in writing, that's as confirmed as it gets.

0 coins

Yeah I feel a lot better now. Going to stop checking every hour and just let it sit.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure