Back to California Paid Family Leave

Manny Lark

Should I apply for PFL baby bonding before after employer paid parental leave

So my company gives me six weeks of paid parental leave and I'm trying to figure out the right order here. Baby arrives in January and I want to make sure I don't leave any PFL money on the table. Should I take my employer's paid leave first and then file for PFL bonding after, or file for PFL right away and stack them somehow? Or does it not matter at all? I keep going back and forth and nobody at work seems to know either. The 12-month window is stressing me out a little.

Filing timing is something I got completely wrong when my youngest was born, so let me share what I learned. The 12 months runs from the birth date, so as long as you file your PFL bonding claim and use your eight weeks within that window, you have flexibility on when you start. EDD's rule is you can't file earlier than the first day of your family leave, and no later than 41 days after that leave begins. So if you take your employer's six weeks first and then start your PFL leave, file within 41 days of the day your PFL leave actually begins, not the birth date.

0 coins

So the 41 days counts from when I start PFL leave, not when the baby is born? That's the part I was confused about. As long as I start PFL before the 12 months is up I'm fine?

0 coins

Exactly right. The birth just starts the 12-month clock for using the weeks. The 41-day filing deadline is tied to your leave start date, whichever day that turns out to be.

0 coins

Does that mean you could technically take employer leave, then come back to work for a little while, then take PFL? Or does it have to be back to back?

0 coins

Lots of people in my circle have done employer leave first, then PFL after. Worked out fine. The main thing is making sure you actually file before that 41-day clock on your PFL start date runs out. Easy to lose track when you've got a newborn.

0 coins

Yeah the newborn chaos is exactly why I want to figure this out in advance.

0 coins

Smart move planning ahead. File on SDI Online through myEDD when you're ready to start your PFL portion and save that receipt number.

0 coins

DE 2500E status was sitting there in SDI Online for two days with no explanation of what it meant or when payment would actually come through. EDD's site says most payments go out within two weeks of a completed claim but I couldn't tell if mine was complete. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after three mornings of the line cutting off on me. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the DE 2500E had been issued and told me the first payment date. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's Paid Family Leave line: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. For the original question, the agent also mentioned that PFL and employer-paid parental leave can't pay the same days simultaneously, so the sequencing matters for that reason specifically.

0 coins

Can you say what Claimyr actually does? I've never heard of it.

0 coins

It waits on the EDD phone line in your place, and when a live person picks up your phone rings. That's it. For anyone wondering what I'd bring up on my own call, I'd want to ask about the proof of relationship for my bonding claim since I uploaded the birth certificate but SDI Online just says pending.

0 coins

The DE 2500E thing is so stressful, I remember staring at mine like it was written in another language. Good to know you got a real answer.

0 coins

EDD and employer leave on the same days, that actually makes sense they wouldn't both pay. Never thought about it that way.

0 coins

PFL doesn't stack on top of your employer's paid leave for the same days. Can't collect both for the same day. Take one, then the other. That's how I did it, employer leave first, then filed PFL after.

0 coins

Got it. So no overlap on the same days. That settles the main question for me I think.

0 coins

Right. Six weeks company pay, then start PFL, file within 41 days of that start. Done.

0 coins

What if the employer leave overlaps with the first week of PFL by accident, like if dates get crossed up? Does EDD find out?

0 coins

Wages from your job, not overtime, plus PFL can't add up to more than your normal wages. So even if an employer allows some overlap arrangement, there's a cap. Worth asking HR exactly how your company's policy interacts with PFL before you plan the dates.

0 coins

HR here just kept saying to check with EDD and EDD says to check with HR. Classic.

0 coins

Ask HR specifically whether their parental leave is considered wages or a separate benefit. That changes the calculation.

0 coins

I had the same runaround. EDD finally explained mine over the phone after I got through to someone, took forever to reach a person though.

0 coins

Three weeks trying to reach EDD's PFL line and I finally got through on a Tuesday. By that point I had filed on SDI Online and my claim was already moving. The hold situation is brutal.

0 coins

tuesdays seem better but still not good. i gave up after the third disconnection two weeks ago.

0 coins

Yeah it's not exactly reliable. File online if you can, that way you at least have the receipt number and the claim is in while you figure out the phone.

0 coins

Intermittent days reporting was the part that tripped me up after going back part-time. I had used Claimyr after three days of mornings that ended the same way, that recording saying to try again, and the EDD agent told me the DE 2580GF had been sent out and was waiting for me to return it, which I hadn't even opened yet. Would have lost payments if I hadn't made that call.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for me too on a different question. Agent confirmed my claim start date was recorded right and that I was still inside the 41 days when I filed. Had been worried I'd waited too long after my employer leave ended.

0 coins

What did you ask about the 41 days exactly? Like what specifically were you worried EDD had wrong?

0 coins

Just wanted to confirm the date they had on file as my PFL leave start, since it's tied to that 41-day window, not to the birth. Agent read it right back to me, matched what I had written down.

0 coins

OK so the start date they record is based on when you actually begin PFL leave, not the birth. That's consistent with what others said above. Good to hear an agent confirmed it.

0 coins

my company gave me eight weeks paid then i did pfl after and it worked fine, just filed when my company leave ended and i was home the extra weeks on pfl. wasnt complicated at all

0 coins

Eight weeks company leave is generous. So you just had a gap between the two? No drama?

0 coins

zero drama. filed in sdi online, got my receipt number, notice of computation came in the mail like a week later. pretty smooth

0 coins

Worth clarifying something I assumed wrong for a while: PFL is eight weeks total across bonding, care claims and military assist within any 12-month period, not eight weeks per category. So if you used some weeks on a care claim in the last year, check how many bonding weeks you actually have left before planning around a full eight.

0 coins

Wait so it's one pool of eight weeks not eight per type? I did not know that. I thought you got eight for bonding and eight separate ones for a care claim.

0 coins

It is one pool, eight weeks total in any 12-month period shared across all claim types. So yes, planning matters if you've had any recent PFL use.

0 coins

Haven't had any PFL claims before so I should have the full eight available. But good to flag for anyone who has.

0 coins

my employer paid leave ran six weeks and i didn't file pfl until the monday it ended, was worried i'd waited too long. checked the 41-day rule and i was fine lol. cut it closer than i needed to.

0 coins

Honestly that's probably where I'll end up too, filing right as the employer leave wraps up.

0 coins

just set a reminder on your phone for like day 35 after your pfl start date. don't let that 41 days sneak past.

0 coins

I keep reading that there's a seven-day waiting period before PFL kicks in. Is that real? Because if I lose the first week of benefits after my company leave ends that changes my math.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period at all. Payments start from the first day of your PFL leave, no unpaid days at the front. You may be thinking of Disability Insurance, which is different and does have an unpaid period at the start.

0 coins

Oh wow, I definitely had those two mixed up. That's a relief, changes things a lot for my planning.

0 coins

Really common mix-up. Disability Insurance is for your own medical condition, PFL is for bonding or care. Different programs, different rules.

0 coins

I almost had these mixed up too early on. EDD's site makes it clearer once you're actually in the PFL section.

0 coins

EDD gets whatever notice period they give you in the Notice of Computation. Filed, waited, it arrived. That's the job.

0 coins

Ha. Minimal but accurate.

0 coins

The notice came faster than I expected. About a week.

0 coins

The SDI Online portal actually makes this pretty easy once you're in there! You file for PFL bonding, give your leave start date, and upload your birth certificate as proof of relationship. The receipt number at the end is your confirmation that it's in the system.

0 coins

Is the birth certificate always enough for the proof of relationship, or do some people need more documents?

0 coins

For a birth parent the most common documents are the birth certificate or a Declaration of Paternity, CS-909, depending on the situation. If neither applies, EDD's instructions on the form say what else qualifies.

0 coins

Right, and the SDI Online filing steps tell you exactly which documents work for your situation as you go through it!

0 coins

DE 2514 sitting in my mailbox was not how I wanted to start a Tuesday. That's the notice EDD sends when they find you're not eligible, and it comes with an Appeal Form, DE 1000A. I'd figured the sequencing of my employer leave and my PFL start date would be obvious to them but apparently my claim had a question about it. Used Claimyr after I couldn't get anyone on the line, and the agent walked through what date EDD had recorded as my PFL start and what the DE 2514 was based on. Turned out they had the wrong start date. Filed the appeal and sent in documentation of when my employer leave actually ended.

0 coins

I want to be direct: the whole Claimyr thing reads like marketing to me. How do you actually end up talking to an EDD agent through it and not just someone pretending to be EDD?

0 coins

I thought the same thing honestly, I almost kept scrolling. But I had tried EDD's line every morning for two weeks and nothing, so I tried it. The person I spoke with had access to my claim number, could read back my payment dates, knew the forms by name. That was EDD's agent, not some third party. And they found my payment method hadn't been confirmed yet, which was why payments were stalled.

0 coins

Okay that's more specific than I expected. I might try it for my own situation, I need to ask EDD about my payment method too since I picked direct deposit in SDI Online but nothing has come through yet.

0 coins

The wrong start date situation is exactly what I want to avoid. I'll keep records of when my employer leave ends so there's no ambiguity when I file PFL.

0 coins

File your PFL claim the day your employer leave ends, not before. If you try to file while your employer is still paying you for those same days you're going to create a problem.

0 coins

Day one of PFL leave is day one to file, got it. Not earlier.

0 coins

What he said. Keep the dates clean.

0 coins

The 12-month clock starting at birth is the thing to keep front of mind. I took my company leave, came back, then life got complicated and I ended up not filing PFL until month nine of my baby's first year. Totally fine, just had to use the remaining weeks before the 12 months was up.

0 coins

Month nine! That's cutting it close but good to know you got it in. Did you use all eight weeks before the year hit?

0 coins

I used five weeks before the cutoff. I would have used all eight but ran out of time. So plan your PFL dates with the 12-month window in view, especially if you're taking employer leave first.

0 coins

That's a good cautionary note. If I take six weeks employer leave starting in January I need to make sure all eight PFL weeks are used before January of the year after.

0 coins

sick leave and pfl on the same days, can you do that? or same deal as employer leave

0 coins

Employer sick leave can be used alongside PFL but your wages plus PFL together can't exceed what you normally earn. Ask your HR how they set it up.

0 coins

ok so my employer decides, not edd. good to know

0 coins

I filed PFL the Monday after my company leave ended. Notice of Computation came about eight days later. No issues.

0 coins

Eight days for the Notice of Computation, that's good to know. I'll watch for it.

0 coins

Yeah it just showed up in the mail. Straightforward.

0 coins

Can both parents file separate PFL bonding claims for the same baby? Or does one parent's claim affect what the other gets?

0 coins

Each parent files their own separate PFL bonding claim. Each gets up to eight weeks within their own 12-month window. One parent's claim doesn't reduce what the other gets.

0 coins

Oh that's really good to know, we were worried we were splitting some shared amount. That changes our whole plan.

0 coins

Each parent's claim stands on its own. The proof of relationship document each one files just needs to link that specific parent to the child.

0 coins

Nobody at my job knew the right answer to this question either. HR gave me three different answers across three different people. Had to figure it out myself by actually filing and seeing what happened.

0 coins

This thread has been more helpful than three weeks of asking around at work honestly.

0 coins

EDD's own FAQ page on PFL is actually decent once you find it. But for anything specific to your situation you need to reach a person.

0 coins

Filing and finding out is very much the EDD experience. At least SDI Online is functional most of the time.

0 coins

One thing worth flagging: bonding benefits have to be used within 12 months from birth, so if the baby comes in January and you take six weeks company leave, you need all eight PFL weeks finished before the following January. Six employer weeks plus eight PFL weeks is fourteen weeks total, and that is well inside the 12 months, so you have room. Just don't sit on unused PFL weeks thinking you have unlimited time.

0 coins

Fourteen weeks total and 52 weeks in the year. Yeah I should be fine. I just needed to hear someone lay it out that simply.

0 coins

doing the same math over here with four weeks company leave. should be even easier to fit everything in.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure