Back to California Paid Family Leave

Justin Chang

SDI and PFL eligibility remote worker for out of state employer — do California taxes even apply?

So I've been working remotely for a company headquartered in Texas for about two and a half years. I live in California full time, my apartment is here, everything. When I had my baby last spring I assumed I could file for PFL bonding through California EDD because I live here. But my HR person said the company doesn't withhold California SDI from my check because they're based out of state. I looked at my paystubs and I don't see CASDI anywhere on them. Now I'm panicking because I want to take my bonding weeks and I don't know if I even qualify. Has anyone dealt with this as a remote worker whose employer is out of state? Do I have any options or am I just out of luck?

DE 2514 sitting in my portal was what started this whole mess for me, two weeks after I filed my PFL bonding claim. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is how I finally got someone on the line. The agent pulled up my determination and read it to me: the denial was because EDD had no record of CASDI withheld from my wages, same issue as yours. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent said to appeal within 30 days using the DE 1000A that came with the determination, and to get documentation from my employer showing whether California SDI was or wasn't being withheld.

0 coins

Waiting on hold with EDD has never once worked for me, not a single morning in four months of trying. How did you actually get through to someone, because that line just cuts off.

0 coins

Claimyr sat there so I didn't have to. Ended up with a live person at PFL, which I hadn't managed in all those weeks of trying myself. The agent read exactly what the DE 2514 said and what the appeal window was.

0 coins

Receipt number question actually, did you need that ready when the agent picked up? Because I can never find mine fast enough anyway.

0 coins

The core of your situation is something I stumbled into the wrong way first. I assumed my employer handled California SDI because I live here, but it turned out the withholding follows where the employer is registered, not where the employee sits. The rule EDD goes by is whether CASDI appears on your paystubs. If your Texas employer never enrolled with California's SDI program and never withheld it, you won't have the minimum $300 in base period wages with SDI deducted, which is what qualifies you. You'd want to contact your HR department in writing and ask directly whether they're registered as a California employer for payroll tax purposes.

0 coins

Is there any chance they might be registered even if I don't see CASDI on my stub? Like could it be labeled differently?

0 coins

It should appear as CASDI specifically on a California-compliant paystub. If it's not there under that label, the withholding likely isn't happening. Your HR payroll team can confirm whether the company has a California employer account number.

0 coins

Does that mean the whole time I've been working remote for an out-of-state company I've had zero PFL coverage and didn't know it? That's honestly terrifying.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a joke, I've said it before. But the underlying rule here matters: if your employer isn't registered with California EDD and hasn't been deducting CASDI, you don't have an SDI account to draw from. Some remote workers in this situation have asked their employer to voluntarily register as a California employer. Whether your company will do that is a whole other conversation with HR, but it is an avenue.

0 coins

Voluntary registration, does that fix it going forward only or can they backfill past quarters?

0 coins

Going forward only from what I understand. Past quarters where nothing was withheld don't get fixed retroactively. If they register now your future wages start building toward eligibility.

0 coins

So even if they register today I'd have to wait until I've built up enough base period wages with the CASDI deduction before I'd actually qualify for anything?

0 coins

There's also a self-employed or elective coverage angle worth knowing about, though it doesn't apply to everyone. California SDI has a voluntary plan option called Elective Coverage, specifically for people who don't have an employer withholding CASDI. The catch is you have to apply for it yourself and pay the contributions. It doesn't help you for the leave you want to take right now, but if you're staying in this job it's worth looking into so you're covered the next time something like this comes up.

0 coins

Is Elective Coverage something I apply for through SDI Online or somewhere else?

0 coins

It's through EDD directly, not through SDI Online's claim portal. EDD's site has the Elective Coverage application information, and I'd look it up there rather than trying to describe the steps from memory.

0 coins

Didn't know this existed. Useful.

0 coins

My coworker at the salon had a situation kind of like this, her husband works remote for a company based in another state and they just assumed PFL was covered because they live in California. Turned out no CASDI on the paystub, same thing. She said the first thing to do is get the full story from HR in writing so you have something to bring to EDD if you need to appeal or explain the gap. At least then you know exactly what you're working with.

0 coins

Did she end up filing anything, or was it just a dead end for her?

0 coins

She looked into whether her husband's employer would register in California but they declined. So she went the Elective Coverage route for future protection. No PFL for that leave period though, which was a rough outcome.

0 coins

That's the worst part, you find out too late because nobody tells you this when you get hired remote, lol.

0 coins

Part D not received was all the status screen showed on my mom's care claim, four days after her specialist's office said they'd submitted it. Ended up talking to someone at EDD after using Claimyr, and the agent confirmed EDD had received Part D but it hadn't been matched to my claim yet because the receipt number on the form didn't match what was in the system. Got it corrected that day! Anyway your situation with the CASDI question is tricky but the proof of relationship thing on a care claim is a separate nightmare entirely.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly, I've seen the name a few times but don't understand what it does.

0 coins

You give it your info and it handles staying on the line with EDD while you do other things, then your phone rings when an actual EDD employee picks up. That's pretty much it. For me it was getting that Part D matched so the claim could move forward.

0 coins

Ah, so it handles the hold time for you. I might try that for my own situation, I need to ask EDD whether the proof of relationship I uploaded for my granddaughter's care claim actually came through on their end.

0 coins

the part d matching thing is wild i didnt know the receipt number had to be exact on the form

0 coins

Bottom line on your eligibility question: CASDI has to show on your paystub. No withholding, no PFL. That's how EDD reads it. Get your answer from HR first before doing anything else.

0 coins

Does PFL have a waiting period you also have to get past once you do qualify?

0 coins

No waiting period on PFL. That's the one good thing. First eligible day is a paid day.

0 coins

Wait, I've heard people mention waiting days. Is that specific to disability insurance and not PFL?

0 coins

Disability has an unpaid waiting period, PFL doesn't. Different programs. Easy to mix them up.

0 coins

Reading all this I'm really worried about my own job now. I also work remote for a company based in another state. I've been here two years and never once looked at whether CASDI appears on my paystubs. If it's not there I basically have no PFL coverage at all and I didn't know.

0 coins

Pull up a recent paystub and look at the deductions section. If you see CASDI anywhere, you're probably covered. If you don't see it listed at all, that's your answer and you should follow up with HR.

0 coins

Found a paystub from last month. I see federal tax, state income tax for California, but nothing that says CASDI. How is this possible if I've been in California the whole time?

0 coins

State income tax and SDI are separate line items. Your employer can withhold California income tax without being registered for SDI. The two don't go together automatically.

0 coins

my company is based out of state and when i asked hr about casdi they had no idea what i was talking about, had to explain it twice. ended up they registered in california after i pushed for it but it took three months. dont wait to ask

0 coins

Three months is a long time. Did you lose coverage for those months or did it start from when they registered?

0 coins

started from when they registered, nothing retroactive. lost those months basically but at least im covered now

0 coins

HR departments really do not know this stuff, in my experience they just assume the payroll system handles it and never check.

0 coins

Something worth clarifying here: PFL and job protection are two separate things. PFL through California EDD pays you, it doesn't protect your job. Job protection comes from CFRA or FMLA and has its own rules about employer size and time worked. Even if you get PFL sorted out, check with your employer's HR about whether CFRA applies to your situation, because EDD isn't the one who handles that.

0 coins

So I could potentially receive PFL payments but still not have job protection during that time?

0 coins

Correct. EDD says outright that PFL provides benefit payments but not job protection. The job protection piece is entirely separate and your employer or an employment attorney is the right place to ask about that for your specific situation.

0 coins

This distinction trips up so many people. PFL and CFRA serve different purposes and EDD administers only the payment side.

0 coins

Ask HR for written confirmation of your payroll tax setup in California. Specifically whether your employer has a California EDD employer account number and whether CASDI is being withheld. That document matters a lot if you end up filing or appealing.

0 coins

Should I ask for a specific form or is an email from payroll enough?

0 coins

An email from payroll or HR stating the facts works. Keep it in writing either way.

0 coins

October 14th my PFL bonding payment showed as processing but nothing hit my account by the 20th. After a few mornings of the line dropping before I ever reached anyone, I tried Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the phone. The agent looked up my claim and confirmed the payment had issued on the 15th and walked me through the deposit date. Helped me figure out it was a bank processing lag, not an EDD problem. For the CASDI question though, definitely sort the withholding issue before filing anything.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself for the Notice of Computation question and was glad I did. The agent confirmed my weekly benefit amount matched what the DE 429DF showed on the claim, so at least I knew the number was right.

0 coins

what did you need to have ready when the agent answered for the noc question

0 coins

Social security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the notice itself in front of me. Agent just verified the amount on record matched what I had.

0 coins

Deposit lag happens more than it should. Good to know the agent could actually see the issue date anyway.

0 coins

The EDD benefits calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate of your weekly benefit amount once you do have the CASDI withholding in place and qualify. It uses the same base period wage logic EDD applies: five to eighteen months before your claim date, highest quarter of the base period. Worth bookmarking for when you get there.

0 coins

Is the calculator on the main edd.ca.gov site or somewhere inside myEDD?

0 coins

It's on edd.ca.gov, not behind a login. You don't need an SDI Online account to use it.

0 coins

I used that calculator before my claim and it was pretty close to what my Notice of Computation actually showed, within a few dollars.

0 coins

Weeks remaining on my claim was the question after I went back to part time, because I wasn't sure if the intermittent days I'd already used counted toward the eight-week total. Used Claimyr to reach someone at EDD. The agent confirmed exactly how many of the eight weeks I'd used across the full twelve months and what was left. Worth knowing the eight-week cap is shared across bonding, care and military assist in the same twelve-month window, it's not eight weeks per claim type.

0 coins

Eight weeks per claim type being separate is what I assumed until just now. Something about how the marketing around PFL reads made me think they were independent limits. Can anyone confirm it's actually one shared pool?

0 coins

Thought the same thing last year and filed a care claim after using all eight weeks bonding. EDD sent a determination saying no weeks remained in my twelve-month period. One pool, not separate buckets. I'd looked into Claimyr at that point to ask an agent about how the weeks tallied, and what the agent told me was straightforward: the twelve months starts at the first claim's start date and all claim types draw from the same eight.

0 coins

That changes my whole plan then. I'll probably try Claimyr before I file a second claim, just to confirm how many weeks are actually left before I commit to dates.

0 coins

Does the twelve-month window reset after it ends or does it float based on your most recent claim?

0 coins

The floating twelve-month window question comes up a lot. EDD counts it from the start date of your first claim in that period, not a calendar year. So if bonding started in March, your twelve months runs through February, and all weeks used in that window count toward the eight.

0 coins

Mine started in April so if I use five bonding weeks now, I'd have three weeks left for anything else through March next year?

0 coins

That's the right way to think about it, though EDD's count is what matters. Your Notice of Computation and your claim status in SDI Online are the most reliable places to check the actual numbers.

0 coins

Good to know the window moves, I always thought it was January to December and nothing else.

0 coins

been trying to get through to edd for three weeks on a different question and nothing. mornings, afternoons, all the same. the line just ends.

0 coins

Three weeks is about average for my experience with that line. It's not you, the line is genuinely brutal.

0 coins

at least its not just me i guess, still stuck though

0 coins

HR told me once that the reason remote workers slip through on CASDI is that most payroll systems default to the employer's home state unless someone manually flags the employee as California-based. So unless HR actively sets it up, it just never gets withheld. Total system failure on the employer side.

0 coins

thats exactly what happened to me, payroll system just had me as a texas employee because thats where the company is

0 coins

It underscores why checking your paystub directly matters rather than assuming the employer handled it correctly.

0 coins

For the bonding claim specifically, once you do get the CASDI withholding sorted and you qualify, the proof of relationship document you'll need is a birth certificate or a Declaration of Paternity. File in SDI Online no later than 41 days after your bonding leave starts. The 41-day deadline is real and EDD can deny benefits for days before you filed if you miss it.

0 coins

Since my baby was already born last spring, would the 41 days run from then or from when I actually start taking leave?

0 coins

From when your bonding leave starts, not the birth date necessarily. But bonding benefits have to be used within twelve months of the birth, so depending on when your baby was born you may have a narrower window than you think.

0 coins

That twelve-month window from birth is the part that always catches people off guard.

0 coins

One thing nobody mentioned yet: even if you get PFL sorted, the payments won't cover the same days as unemployment. If you're laid off and filing UI, you can't also collect PFL at the same time. Different programs, can't stack them.

0 coins

Not in that situation right now but good to know. I hadn't thought about what happens if something changes at work during leave.

0 coins

Worth knowing before you need it.

0 coins

The appeal window on a denial is 30 days from the determination notice. If you get a DE 2514 and disagree with it, the DE 1000A appeal form comes with it. File online or by mail within that 30 days. Missing the window makes it harder to challenge.

0 coins

Okay, so if I get a denial I should not wait on the appeal even while I'm still talking to HR about the CASDI situation?

0 coins

File the appeal first to protect your window, then continue working the HR angle. The two can run at the same time and you don't want to lose appeal rights while waiting for HR to respond.

0 coins

That's what I did. Appealed while still gathering documentation from my employer. Kept both moving at once.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure