Back to California Paid Family Leave

MoonlightSonata

Received full wages from employer and PFL bonding payment — what to do

So I'm kind of panicking here. Took bonding leave starting three weeks ago for our new daughter and filed the PFL claim in SDI Online. My employer ended up paying me my full regular wages the whole time, and then EDD also issued a PFL payment for the same weeks. So now I've got both. I didn't do anything wrong on purpose, I just didn't realize my job was going to keep paying me in full while the PFL was also going. What do I do with this? Do I report it to EDD? Is this automatically an overpayment? Really worried about getting hit with something bad here, anyway.

Report it to EDD right away. What you're describing — full wages from your employer covering the same days EDD paid PFL — is exactly how an overpayment happens. Log into SDI Online through myEDD, pick your claim, and use Request Claim Update to let EDD know. The sooner you tell them, the better it looks on your end.

0 coins

So I go through Request Claim Update in SDI Online? I wasn't sure if I needed to call or if the online message would actually work for something like this.

0 coins

The online message works fine. Write clearly what happened: your employer paid full wages for the same days, list the weeks, and say you want to report it. EDD will sort out what you owe.

0 coins

Agree with reporting it fast. Waiting only makes it worse.

0 coins

Wages plus PFL on the same days is an overpayment. EDD will want back whatever PFL covered that your wages already replaced. Report it now, don't sit on it.

0 coins

Does reporting it yourself help at all, or does EDD just send the notice regardless? I'm not sure if it changes anything to be proactive.

0 coins

Being upfront helps. EDD still sends a notice, but voluntarily reporting it early is better than them catching it later.

0 coins

Came here to say the same thing. Proactive beats reactive with EDD every time.

0 coins

Receipt number for my bonding claim got lost somehow after I filed, couldn't see it anywhere in SDI Online and needed it to track things down. Tried calling PFL's line for three mornings straight and got the busy signal every single time, never made it past the recording. Finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. She pulled up the claim, confirmed the receipt number, and also told me my proof of relationship document had been received and was matched to the claim already. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

What did you need to have ready when the agent picked up? Like account info, ID, that kind of thing?

0 coins

Had my Social Security number, the claim's approximate start date, and my myEDD login info on hand. Agent found everything quickly once she had those.

0 coins

been at that line since 7am four days running. hasnt gone through once.

0 coins

Worth clarifying something here: your employer paying you and EDD also paying PFL for the same days isn't automatically illegal or a penalty situation. It's an overpayment and EDD will issue a notice telling you the amount. You can appeal within 30 days if you think the number is wrong, using the Appeal Form DE 1000A. The main thing is not to ignore it.

0 coins

That actually helps a lot. I was imagining some worst-case fraud scenario. So they just send a notice and I deal with it from there?

0 coins

Exactly. The notice lays out what they calculated. If you disagree, appeal within those 30 days. If you agree, you pay it back.

0 coins

Is there any way to get the overpayment waived, or do you always have to repay it? I'm asking because I might be in a similar situation with my own bonding leave.

0 coins

EDD can issue a waiver in some cases but there's no guarantee. EDD's site has overpayment info. Best thing is to read the notice carefully when it comes and go from there.

0 coins

Don't wait for EDD to find it themselves. Report it, deal with the notice, pay it back. That's the whole play here.

0 coins

Yeah that's what I'm going to do. Just wasn't sure if I'd somehow made it worse by not catching it right away.

0 coins

You caught it now. That's what counts. Send the message in SDI Online today.

0 coins

Honestly this happened to a client of mine, sort of. Her company kept paying her and she got PFL too. She reported it and EDD sent the overpayment notice, she paid it back and that was it. No drama after that. The reporting piece was the whole thing.

0 coins

Good to hear it got resolved cleanly. That's what I'm hoping for.

0 coins

She said it felt way scarier than it turned out to be. Just do the right thing and it moves along.

0 coins

Same situation here, resolved fine after I reported it.

0 coins

December 3rd is when my PFL payment posted for the first two weeks, and my employer's payroll for those same two weeks was full pay. I know exactly how you feel. I reported it through SDI Online and EDD's overpayment notice came about two weeks later with the amount they wanted back.

0 coins

Two weeks for the notice to arrive, that's helpful to know roughly. Do they give you time to pay, or is it due immediately?

0 coins

The notice I got gave a timeframe for responding or paying. Read yours carefully when it shows up, it should lay out your options.

0 coins

The notice will also include the Appeal Form DE 1000A and instructions. 30 days to appeal if the numbers don't look right.

0 coins

just report it today dont overthink it, edd finds this stuff eventually anyway and its way worse if they find it first

0 coins

Yeah I'm doing it today. Already have SDI Online open.

0 coins

good luck dude

0 coins

Looked into my own Notice of Computation after my bonding claim got going, the weekly benefit amount on it looked lower than I expected based on my wages. Ended up calling EDD because the PFL phone line and I were not getting along. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent who actually walked me through which quarter of my base period they used for the calculation. The number on the DE 429DF turned out to be right, just a quarter I hadn't expected them to pull from.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and I'm not sure the base period they used is correct either. I want to ask EDD about which quarter they pulled before I assume there's an error. Going to try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have the DE 429DF in front of you and your pay stubs from the base period if you can find them. The agent can tell you which quarter was used and what wages they have on file.

0 coins

Mine also looked off at first. Turned out EDD was right and my own math was off.

0 coins

So the Notice of Computation isn't the same as an approval? I thought getting it meant the claim was approved.

0 coins

It just shows the potential weekly benefit amount. Eligibility confirmation is separate. The notice doesn't mean you're approved, it means EDD has your wage info and calculated a number.

0 coins

Wages AND PFL at the same time, yes EDD will catch that! Report it right away and you'll be fine. The overpayment process is annoying but it's not scary once you're in it.

0 coins

Sent the Request Claim Update message this morning. Feels better having done it.

0 coins

Good move! Now you just wait for the notice and handle it from there.

0 coins

EDD has seen this before. Report it, get the notice, respond to the notice. That's the whole arc of this situation.

0 coins

Does EDD ever reduce the overpayment amount or is it always the full PFL amount that overlapped?

0 coins

The notice shows what they calculated. If you think it's wrong, appeal it. If it's right, pay it.

0 coins

Mine was the full PFL amount for the overlapping weeks. No reduction. Just paid it back.

0 coins

Sick leave and vacation can be combined with PFL in some situations, but that's your employer's own policy. Full regular wages covering the same days as PFL is the overpayment situation. EDD doesn't pay PFL for days you're already being made whole by wages.

0 coins

So is there any situation where I could keep both? Like if my employer paid me a partial wage top-up instead of full pay?

0 coins

If wages plus PFL don't exceed your normal wages, that's a different story. But full wages plus full PFL on the same days is too much. Ask EDD how your specific numbers work if the overlap isn't total.

0 coins

The rule is that wages excluding overtime plus PFL can't go above what you normally earn. EDD's the one who calculates it, so when in doubt, report and let them tell you the number.

0 coins

Two payments into my bonding claim and I had no idea which weeks EDD had actually paid for and when the next one was coming. Spent a week trying the PFL line and kept getting cut off. Ended up using Claimyr and the agent told me exactly which two-week period the payment covered and confirmed when the next one was scheduled. Really cleared up the confusion because SDI Online wasn't making it obvious to me which week was which.

0 coins

The two-week period thing tripped me up too on my bonding claim. Used Claimyr as well after getting nowhere with the line, and once the agent confirmed my proof of relationship had been matched to the claim I stopped stressing about the timing. Felt better just knowing EDD actually had what they needed.

0 coins

been trying that line for four days. glad to hear it can eventually work.

0 coins

Wait, I thought PFL had a waiting week before you start getting paid? Does an overpayment still happen if you're in that first waiting week? I'm confused about how the first week works.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period at all. No unpaid first week. You may be thinking of Disability Insurance, which does have a seven-day waiting period. PFL starts paying from the first day of leave if you're eligible.

0 coins

Oh! I had those confused. So the overpayment issue covers every day from day one, not just after a waiting week.

0 coins

Correct. If wages covered day one and PFL paid day one too, that's an overpayment from day one.

0 coins

yeah pfl is different from sdi on that, no waiting week at all

0 coins

You're doing the right thing by asking about this instead of hoping it disappears. The people who get into real trouble are the ones who ignore these situations.

0 coins

Definitely not ignoring it. Already sent the message through SDI Online this morning. Feel a lot less panicked after reading through here.

0 coins

That's the move. Now you just wait for EDD's response and deal with the notice when it comes.

0 coins

Something to keep in mind about the PFL eight weeks: bonding, care, and military assist all share that same eight-week pool in a 12-month period. So if any other leave comes up in the next year, the weeks you've already used for bonding come off that total.

0 coins

I had no idea they shared the same eight weeks. So if something happened with a family member I couldn't get eight more weeks on top of my bonding leave?

0 coins

Correct. It's one combined limit. Use five weeks for bonding, you have three left for a care claim in the same 12 months, not eight fresh ones.

0 coins

I definitely assumed they were separate. That's a big deal to know upfront.

0 coins

The fact that you caught this now matters. Some people go months before they even realize there's an overlap and by then the amount is bigger and there are more notices. Three weeks in is very manageable.

0 coins

Three weeks worth of PFL is the overlap I'm dealing with. So hopefully the amount isn't too wild.

0 coins

Should be straightforward then. Report it, let EDD calculate, done.

0 coins

EDD will figure out the amount whether you report it or not. Reporting it yourself just means you're not surprised when the notice lands.

0 coins

Exactly. They have your employer's wage records. It's not like it stays hidden.

0 coins

Yep. EDD gets quarterly wage data. They'll see it.

0 coins

For the appeal option: if you get the overpayment notice and the amount doesn't match the weeks you believe overlapped, go through it line by line. The DE 1000A is the form and you have 30 days from the notice date. It's worth checking the math before just paying whatever they say.

0 coins

30 days goes fast. I'd put a calendar reminder the day the notice arrives.

0 coins

Good point. I'll note that when it comes in.

0 coins

And make sure you're appealing within 30 days of the notice date, not 30 days from when you receive it in the mail. Read the notice for the exact date.

0 coins

reporting it today is the right call. edd doesnt forget about these things

0 coins

Already done. Message sent this morning in SDI Online.

0 coins

good. now you just wait it out.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure